For Dna Testing? Essay, Research Paper
Police forces consider DNA testing to be the biggest break through of the century in solving crime. They have lobbied for legislation to give them the right to take samples from violent suspects and store them in a central Data Bank. In 1995, the Government had drafted a bill that would permit police to take blood, hair, or saliva samples from uncooperative suspects of violent crimes. The Justice Minister then had announced plans to introduce another statute that would favor a data bank of DNA samples.
Many safe guards were sset up to avoid the abuse of collecting DNA from suspects. Police must have reasonable grounds and obtain a warrant from a provincial judetge before any samples are taken. Also, a trained person must obtain the sample; all samples must be used for a specific offence. If the accused is acquitted then the sample must be destroyed
DNA evidence should not be collected from suspects as a matter of routine unless the information is relevant to a specific crime in question. For example, it would appropriate to obtain a DNA sample from a suspect where DNA evidence is left at the scene of a crime and the suspect’s DNA in needed to prove the suspect’s involvement.
DNA evidence should not be colvcslected from suspects as a matter of routine. To do so will cause unnecessary privacy intrusion; in the vast majority of criminal cases DNA evidence will contribute nothing to the investigation. Thus, it would not be appropriate for Parliament to give blanket authority to collect DNA samples from all persons suspected of indictable offences. DNA should also not be collected from a suspect if investigators have no DNA evidence with which to compare the suspect’s sample. Nor would a DNA sample be necessary if the suspect admitted guilt.
The analysis of the samples should be used only to confirm or negate match between the sample taken from the crime scene fgand the sample taken from the suspect. That is, it should sdfremain as an identifgication tool only. There should be no further analysis of the DNA to suggest psychological characteristics that would make the suspect more likely to have cdfommitted the crime. This rule should apply also to samples taken from convicted dfdoffenders for a data vor dagta bank.
The pros for having suspects forced to provide samples for DNA testing are few. One is that if DNA is left at the scene of a crime, then if they can get a sample from a suspect and compare, it is a much faster process. DNA will determine the guilt of innocents of the suspect. 88 percent of Canadians support the use of DNA evidence in court.
In 1995, DNA law argued that forcing criminals to provide samples for DNA evidence infringes upon the Charter of Rights & Freedoms. The individual’s right to protection from unreasonable search and seizure is violated when the suspect is forced to provide samples against his or her own will. The suspect has the right to Due Process. Scientists can never say with absolute certainty that the samples are from the same DNA. They can only determine a statement of probability. Critics feel that mored work needs to be done to improve reliabilityes of the testing. They fear that the positive scientific evidence of gDNA tests may persuade juries and they may fail to consider other evidence that points to innocents of the accused.
The bottom line is thrat no doubt DNA is a very powerful tool, but what about the proposals to test arrestees? Arrest does not equal guilt and an individual should not suffer the consequences of guilt until after he or she has been convicted. To equate arrest with guilt and to empower officers, rather than judges and juries, with the power to force persons to provide the province with the evidence that harbors many of their most intimate secrets and those of their blood relatives. Indeed, programs to collect DNA from arrestees are likelyr to result idn unnecessary arrests solely for the purporse of justifying a DNA test. What do you think should suspects be forhced to provide samples for DNA testing?
In my opinion, I think that suspects should provide samples for DNA testing if any was found on the crime scene. But they should not be forced. If the suspect knows he is innocent, then he should have no problem with the sample, because he should have nothing to hide.
Другие работы по теме:
Macbeth 10 Essay Research Paper MACBETHCHOICE 2
Macbeth 10 Essay, Research Paper MACBETH CHOICE 2 – Compare the changes in Macbeth and Lady Macbeth as a result of the murder of King Duncan. How are they before the murder, and what happens to each of them
In The Name Of The Father Essay
, Research Paper In the Name of the father Too what extent, if any, do repugnant acts of terrorism justify restrictions on civil liberties as counter measures to terrorism?
Narcotics Investigator Essay Research Paper Narcotics are
Narcotics Investigator Essay, Research Paper Narcotics are all compounds that produce insensibility to external stimuli through depression of the central nervous system. Most narcotics today are extracted from opium poppy. Narcotics investigators investigate, and arrest criminal suspects who are involved with the use, sale, and distribution of illegal drugs.
Kosovo Essay Research Paper War crime suspects
Kosovo Essay, Research Paper War crime suspects hunted after jailbreak MITROVICA, Kosovo — Hundreds of NATO-led peacekeepers and U.N. police are searching for a group of Serb prisoners, many charged with war crimes, who escaped from a jail in the northern Kosovo city of Mitrovica.
College Essay Essay Research Paper The history
College Essay Essay, Research Paper The history of DNA use for forensic cases already spans more than a decade. The first cases into which DNA evidence was brought in were in England. The first case of using DNA-related evidence in Arizona courts was the 1988 murder of Jennifer Wilson by Richard Bible near Flagstaff.
Police Brutality Essay Research Paper There continue
Police Brutality Essay, Research Paper There continue to be frequent disturbing reports of unjustified police shootings, with officers firing on unarmed suspects fleeing non-violent crime scenes, during traffic stops,
The Importance Of Laertes And Fortinbras Essay
, Research Paper In the Shakespearean play, Hamlet, Laertes and Fortinbras have important roles although they are minor characters. Fortinbras and Laertes importance arise because they are parallel characters to Hamlet, and they provide pivotal points on which to compare the actions and emotions of Hamlet throughout the play.
Medical Advancement Essay Research Paper
“This could be revolutionary in terms of environmental health,” Richard Jackson, director of the National Center for Environmental Health, told reporters. “For the first time, we’ve profiled what is in people.”
Miranda Essay Research Paper Miranda vs the
Miranda Essay, Research Paper Miranda vs. the State of Arizona Such cases as Gideon v. Wainwright (1963) and Miranda v. Arizona (1966) considered the rights of defendants in criminal cases and initiated a continuing debate on the rights of the individual in relation to the necessary powers of the government.
Dna Essay Research Paper DNA evidence is
Dna Essay, Research Paper DNA evidence is extremely helpful in criminal trials not only because it can determine the guilt of a suspect, but also because it can keep innocent people from going to jail. The suspect must leave a sample of their DNA at the crime scene in order for testing to occur, but DNA can be found in the form of many things such as semen, blood, hair, saliva, or skin scrapings.
Malcolm X Essay Research Paper THE AUTOBIOGRAPHY
Malcolm X Essay, Research Paper THE AUTOBIOGRAPHY OF MALCOLM X Malcolm Little was born on May 19, 1925 in Omaha, Nebraska. At the time of his birth, Malcolm’s father was a Baptist Minister. His mom was a writer of Marcus Garvey. Before he was born, his father had 3 children with his previous marriage and 3 before him with his mom.
Mitochondria S Effect On Aging And Disease
Essay, Research Paper Mitochondria are the powerhouse of the cell. Their sole responsibility is to provide energy for the cell. They do this by synthesizing a molecule known as ATP, which the cell uses as energy. Mitochondria are different from the rest of the cell organelles because they contain their own DNA outside the nucleus.
TwoCareer Family Versus OneCareer Family Essay Research
Paper It seems as though, some people feel a two-career family is necessary for today?s society. Today, the cost-of-living has soared to an enormous height. Ideas of living in a gigantic home with brand-new cars tend to flourish the minds of parents. Meaning, both parents must work, not only for a place to live and an automobile to drive, but also for enough funds to raise a family.
Criminal Justice Essay Research Paper The two
Criminal Justice Essay, Research Paper The two vehicle stops were made for different reasons. The first vehicle, the white Toyota Camry, was stopped because it fit the description of a vehicle that
Adrienne Richs Rape Essay Research Paper Have
Adrienne Rich?s ?Rape? Essay, Research Paper Have you ever been in a situation where you had something horrible happen in your life that you needed to do something about, but in order to do something
Neptune Essay Research Paper Andrea RhodesP1 11501NEPTUNEI
Neptune Essay, Research Paper Andrea Rhodes P.1 11/5/01 NEPTUNE I have been selected as one of five people to go on a mission to Neptune; we are to attempt to gather rock samples from two moons, Triton and the very irregular shaped moon Proteus. We also must gather samples from, the rings of Neptune and we need to gather readings on the three major storms on Neptune (the small dark spot, the great dark spot and scooter.
Iron In Drinking Water Essay Research Paper
Purpose: The purpose of this lab was to gain the quantitative measure of the color difference between Transmitance and absorbance in 8 different samples of water containing varying amounts of iron in a range between 5-100ppm, so that we know which samples where exceptable for drinking.
Child Care Essay Research Paper Caring for
Child Care Essay, Research Paper Caring for a pet is like caring for a child. I feel this is because you do almost the same things that you do when caring for a child, that you would do when caring for a pet. The similarities are you provide food and shelter, you provide them with entertainment, and you take them to a doctor or vettrnarin when they are sick.
Soil Sampling Essay Research Paper INSTRUCTIONS FOR
Soil Sampling Essay, Research Paper INSTRUCTIONS FOR TAKING A SOIL SAMPLE These instructions are for taking a soil sample from a yard, pasture, or any other piece of land. The purpose of a soil sample is to determine the pH of the soil. These instructions give a simple step by step procedure that anyone can do.
Field Trip To The Hospital Essay Research
Paper Field trip to the Hospital Raquel Mendoza On our visit to the Hospital in November, we were able to see the Pathology Department. There are a couple of process that are done in order to get a diagnosis. First the
Contamination Of Road Salt Essay Research Paper
IL 3; Experiment 1 October 31, 1996 The Study of Akali Metal Contamination in Road Side Soil Abstract Six soil samples were taken from a roadside that was expected to exhibit characteristic of road salt contamination. This contamination is characterized by the presence of magnesium, calcium and sodium.
Compare And Contrast On Frost Essay Research
Paper Compare and Contrast on RobertFrost Provide, Provide and PeterMeinke Advice to My Son Robert Frost s Provide, Provide and Peter Meinke s Advice To My Son , these two poems deserve to be compared. Frost s Poem Provide, Provide uses language that is in a fairly straightforward and literal way and states the theme in the final lines.
Biochemistry Lab Essay Research Paper I Introduction
Biochemistry Lab Essay, Research Paper I. Introduction In this experiment, lipids from ground nutmeg are extracted using a combination of solvents and identify the lipids through chromatography. The purpose of using solvent combinations is to elute the lipids based on their polarity to binding of the silica gel.
Persia Essay Research Paper Influence of Islamic
Persia Essay, Research Paper Influence of Islamic Art The art of Europe, or ‘Western art’ is of a totally different type and style as what is known as ‘Islamic art’. It is difficult to have samples of both together in one place, observe the patterns of one and the narrative form of the other and say, “Islamic art influenced the art of Italy”.
Creative Writing Exercise Essay Research Paper 1
Creative Writing Exercise Essay, Research Paper 1. How does one commit a successful murder? To commit a successful murder you first must have a motive. Then after you have established a motive you must create a plan of attack. You need to come up with a way in which you are going to go about committing this crime.
The Double Helix Essay Research Paper After
The Double Helix Essay, Research Paper After reading The Double Helix by James B. Watson, I have learned that the double helix structure of DNA is the source of the genetic code that determines the traits passed along from one living generation to the next. In deciding which of the critical elements in the process of discovering the structure of DNA was most surprising would be how X-rays might be diffracted by a helical molecule.