No Electoral College Essay, Research Paper
In with the Popular Vote, out with the Electoral College
The recent Presidential election between Al Gore and George W. Bush has sparked a controversial flame among American citizens. Should we keep the Electoral College, or is it time to get rid of it and go by the Nation s Popular Vote? The Electoral College worked when it was first created, but problems have been coming up and deciding the President would be more efficient, and less problem-laden if Americans awarded the Presidency to the winner of the popular vote. America, as a county, has grown and evolved, and our voting systems should follow suit.
The Electoral College didn t just spring up all of a sudden. Many versions were tried and rejected. The first design appointed two senators from each state. In order to avoid voting for their favorite son the senators had to choose two candidates that did not represent their home state. The candidate with most votes became President, and the runner-up became Vice President. This design only lasted for four elections. The second design differed only slightly. Instead of casting two votes for president, electors cast one for President, and one for Vice President. The leaders in each of the categories were elected.
The Electoral College today is different in more ways than one. Not only are our Senators chosen to represent their respective state, but voters also appoint other electors according to each state s population. The larger the population, the more electoral votes a state receives. In previous designs citizens were not welcome to vote because there was no way to get enough information on a candidate, therefore citizens would end up voting for their state s candidates, rather than the issues. Today citizens vote and the appointed electors, the two senators and the appropriate number of representatives, cast the state s electoral votes according to the majority, which is decided by the popular vote. Although Maine and Nebraska divide their electoral votes up differently from the rest of the United States. In both states each one of the electors are divided among each congressional districts. The representing elector in his district casts his vote according to the district s majority, and the overall winner of the state is awarded two extra votes. Electors meet one month after public election to cast their electoral vote. In order to win the election a candidate must have 270 of the 538 electoral votes.
The popular vote is the total number of votes that a Presidential Candidate gets from every voting American citizen. The popular vote also encourages the electors of the Electoral College on how to cast their vote for the President, even though the elector does not have to vote according to the state s majority. The popular vote does not decide the election, the 538 members of the Electoral College decide.
Many people agree that the Electoral College is outdated and that a new voting system is needed. George C. Edwards, director of Presidential Studies at Texas A&M, supports the idea of an election based on popular vote. In the article, School of Hard Knocks Edwards is quoted saying, There s no justification for the Electoral College (52). He backs this up by mentioning how much time is spent enforcing the one person, one vote principle. The With the Electoral College voters are not equally represented. Richard Dunham explains why the voters are not fairly represented by giving an example:
California has 54 electoral votes, and the 22 smallest states combined have well over 54 electoral votes, but the population isn t as large as
California s.
This means every one person s vote in the smaller populated states are more important than another person s vote in a much larger populated state. An Alaskan voter has a louder voice in the decision of who the electoral vote will go to, than a Californian has with their votes.
Hillary Clinton wants to eliminate the Electoral College, and according to a recent poll, over 50% of the respondents agreed in doing away with the Electoral College. In past elections there has been cases of a president winning the Electoral Vote but not the popular vote. According to the chart in the article School of hard knocks there has been more than one occasion when the electoral vote has overruled the popular vote. In 1876 Rutherford Hayes beat James Tilden by one electoral vote, but Tilden had over 200,000 more votes supporting him. In a less dramatic lead William Henry Harrison bested Grover Cleveland by 65 electoral votes, but lost the popular vote by 90,596 votes.
Besides not representing voters fairly, the electoral college is also unfair to the third party candidates running for president. Candidates like Ralph Nader have no chance of
winning an election because the popular vote for each state, excluding Maine and Nebraska, is a winner take all situation. Even if Nader had gotten a lot of the votes, it wouldn t make a difference because there would be no way that he would get more than Al Gore or George W. Bush for the electoral vote. With a popular vote election system third-party candidates would be better represented and have more of a chance of winning the election.
Electing a president by popular vote alone does have a few setbacks. If the presidency was elected by popular vote, the chances of candidates spending any time in sparsely populated states like Wyoming and Alaska would be very slim. Most of the campaigning would be focused on the more populated states like New York and California. The Electoral College was partially created to help keep the less populated states on the campaign trail. Senior analyst from CNN, Jeff Greenfield supports the Electoral College by pointing out the drawbacks of a popular vote based election. If it were decided by popular vote candidates would lay the United States out into categories, consisting of ages, and different interests. The candidates would then work on gaining votes from the more populated regions by redoing their campaign speech into what they believe the people of that geographical category want to hear (66).
Deciding the presidency by popular vote alone could stir up trouble if the polls are close. Jeff Greenfield also points out that America could face a national recount if the election was considerably close (66). A national recount could be more time consuming than the Electoral College ever was, especially if the recount was recommended to be redone by hand. Recounting in Dade County, Florida seems like a hassle, but the thought of recounting and entire countries vote is mind boggling.
Smoothing out the lumps caused by voting for the next President by popular vote wouldn t be as time consuming or difficult as fixing the problems with the Electoral College. There could be a law requiring candidates to visit all of the states, instead of focusing only on considerably populated areas. By requiring this, candidates would be spreading out across the country more than they are now with no regulations from the Electoral College. To avoid large recounts done by hand, a standardized national ballot should be put into action along with a standard vote tabulator. The Electoral College has been around for over 200 years, and it still has problems which have not been fixed. Certain problems have tried to be worked out with little or no success.
Historian Arthur Schlesinger came up with his own solution to ensure the winner of the popular vote also wins the Electoral College vote. Award a bonus of 102 electoral votes, two for each state and the District of Columbia to the popular vote winner (65). By awarding the candidate who wins the popular vote an extra 102 votes the citizens vote for president would make a difference. If this plan were put into action more Americans would vote because the popular vote winner would undoubtedly become the next President of the United States.
Most Americans want a voting system that they feel is the citizens electing the next President, not a committee of 538 House members. One of the reasons that we had an Electoral College was because there was no way to hold a national election, and the government didn t want citizens voting for their favorite sons. We now have ways of holding national elections, making another the argument for the Electoral College become obsolete. Changing the voting system by making the popular vote dominant against the Electoral College, Americans will have less to complain about because it will be a true case of majority rules.
Dunham, Richard S. Why the Electoral College Lives on. Business Week 20 Nov. 2000: 41.
Greenfield, Jeff. The Hidden Beauty of the System. Time 20 Nov. 2000: 66.
Schlesinger, Arthur. It s a Mess, But We ve Been Through it Before Time 20 Nov. 2000: 64.
Wildavsky, Ben. School of Hard Knocks. The Electoral College: An anachronism or protector of small states? U.S. News & World Report 20 Nov. 2000: 52
Другие работы по теме:
Cover Letter Proctology Essay Research Paper Dear
Cover Letter: Proctology Essay, Research Paper Dear Mr. I am writing you this letter to ask you to write me a letter of recommendation for a college. I will be applying to many and would be honored to have a letter from you
The Affects Of The Electoral College On
The Significance And Legitimacy Of American Voting Essay, Research Paper In the 1996 United States presidential election, only 49 percent of the voting age population cast a ballot (Federal Election Committee). Only 56 percent of whites voted, followed by 50 percent of African American, and only 27 percent of Hispanics (Federal Election Committee).
Electoral College Must Stand Essay Research Paper
The Founding Fathers wrote the Electoral College into the United States Constitution as insurance against popular passion electing the chief executive into office. They believed there needed to be a buffer between the people and election of the president. Also a concern of the forefathers was they did not want the states with a larger population to completely overshadow the states with a smaller populace.
Electoral College Persuassive Essay Essay Research Paper
~Electoral College~ In the United States we are all guaranteed one vote per person. Everyone has an equal voice in electing the people that serve in the government. Every four years during the month of November citizens of America go to the polls to vote for a president and vice-president of the United States.
Electoral College Reform Essay Research Paper In
Electoral College Reform Essay, Research Paper In order to increase the ease of creating and establishing a federal government with a central figure of office, the framers of the Constitution created the Electoral College. The College was formed to ease the process of electing a president every four years.
The Electoral College And The Influence Of
California Essay, Research Paper Peter Robinson Examine the operation of the Electoral College in Presidential elections and consider the view that a candidate who cannot win California cannot win the Presidency. In what ways has the balance of power in the Electoral College shifted in recent years?
The Electoral College How Effective Is It
? Essay, Research Paper The Electoral College: How Effective Is It? Our founding fathers wanted to devise a plan to elect the executive branch of the government without it being affected by partisan politics. In the beginning, they instituted and stated in Article 2, Section 1, of the Constitution, the method of selecting electors is delegated to the separate state legislatures, and the voting procedure to be followed by the electors is carefully defined (Encarta, History).
Vote Essay Research Paper Why should Americans
Vote Essay, Research Paper Why should Americans exercise their right to vote? Why should we vote? Is it really worth our time? The answer is YES . People say that one vote won t change the outcome, but take a look at Florida! Right now, the election of our president is in the people of Florida s hands. [Your] one vote is very important.
Ellectoral College Essay Research Paper The Electoral
Ellectoral College Essay, Research Paper The Electoral College has been used to elect the President since the beginnings of the United States. In the two hundred some odd years of history, there have been instances when the college did not work. There have been many ideas that have floated around about fixing the problem with the electorate.
Electoral College 2 Essay Research Paper Electoral
Electoral College 2 Essay, Research Paper Electoral College: It s time for reform It s not fair. It s not fair to the candidates running for office, not fair to the campaign volunteers and especially not fair to the American people. Although the Electoral College System was originally considered to be a brilliant innovation that cleverly solved a cluster of 18th-century problems, as we approach the 21st century, we confront different problems and our constitutional system of presidential selection does not look so brilliant.
College Algebra I Essay Research Paper Quetion
College Algebra I Essay, Research Paper Quetion: y= -3x , y + 3x=2 Answer: substitute y= -3x in for the “y” in y + 3x=2 y + 3x=2 -3x + 3x=2 ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Us Democracy Essay Research Paper Ant V
Us Democracy Essay, Research Paper Ant? V. Williams Political Science 1101 February 1, 2001 It’s Not Right, Get Rid of It In theory, the United States became a democracy when we signed the Declaration of Independence in 1776. This theory is not true. The textbook defines a democracy as a system of government in which ultimate political authority is vested in the people, of course you know that this is just not so.
Electoral College Is Wrong Essay Research Paper
The Electoral College is the name given to a group of electors who are nominated by political activists and party members within the states. The electoral college really isn’t necessary and should be abolished. There are numerous reasons why this is so. With the Electoral College in affect third parties don’t have a chance to become the president, which isn’t fair.
Why Do People Go To College Essay
, Research Paper Why do people go to college? One main reason is to increase their chances of getting a job. Most employers will hire a person with a college degree. Some believe that if a person goes through all the trouble of going to college, this might mean he will work harder and better. Anoth er main reason is the salary.
Electoral College Is No Longer A Functional
System Essay, Research Paper The electoral college has been our method of electing presiden’s sinc eth constitution was formed. With increasing popoulations and the addition of third parties, it can be
Electoral College 2 Essay Research Paper The
Electoral College 2 Essay, Research Paper The Undisputable Necessity for the Electoral College Criticism as to the relevancy of the Electoral College system used in our presidential elections has been around since the implementation of the system into our constitution. This criticism, however, is without true reason and common sense added into these assumptions.
Electoral College System Essay Research Paper After
Electoral College System Essay, Research Paper After the last presidential election, which is still underway apparently, there is much controversy over what should happen to the Electoral College system. There are people who say that the Electoral College is good but should be modified to meet the needs of the modern world.
Electoral College Should Be Here To Stay
Essay, Research Paper Title: The Electoral College Should Be Here to Stay General Purpose: To persuade Specific Purpose: To persuade individuals that the Electoral College is not at fault for the
Electoral College Essay Research Paper ELECTORAL COLLEGEElectoral
Electoral College Essay, Research Paper ELECTORAL COLLEGE Electoral College, the constitutional system for the ELECTION of the PRESIDENT and VICE PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES. It is the collective name for a group of electors, nominated by political parties within the states and popularly elected, who meet to vote for those two offices.
History Of Electoral College Essay Research Paper
HISTORY OF THE ELECTORAL COLLEGE The Electoral College is the name for the electors who nominally choose the president and vice president of the United States. Each of the states receives a certain number of electors, which is determined by the total number of senators and representatives it sends to the U.S.
College Athletics Essay Research Paper The commercial
College Athletics Essay, Research Paper The commercial gains in college athletics have become excessive over the past decade. Major college institutions now have merchandising contracts, television contracts, and the success of the team lures more students to the institutions. These gains are not detrimental unless they are used illegally by the institution.
University Transfer Statement Essay Research Paper Transfer
University Transfer Statement Essay, Research Paper Transfer Statement I believe that the University will offer me a variety of new experiences that I am looking to get out of college life. I don?t believe that I am currently getting out of college all that I should be. I am looking to find a school that is different from where I am, but that will also provide a reputable program.
College Vs High School Essay Research Paper
From my college experience, I hope to gain many things. Obviously college is a time that students can truly become individuals. When I attend college I will have the opportunity to
Paul Ryan Essay Research Paper Dear Paul
Paul Ryan Essay, Research Paper Dear Paul Ryan: Do we really need the Electoral College? I?m writing to you saying that we really don?t need it. I am looking forward in voting in my future years for further elections, but is the Electoral College really needed? I believe that the way that our country votes is wrong.
Binge Drinking Essay Research Paper Personal EssayBinge
Binge Drinking Essay, Research Paper Personal Essay Binge Drinking on College Campuses Binge drinking is running rampant on many college campuses and with an ever-growing number of high school students starting to binge drink, it would appear that there is no end in sight. In a study that was conducted by The Harvard School of Public Health, Binge drinking is defined, as having five or more drinks in a row.
The US Presidential Election Essay Research Paper
The United States has recently elected a new president. The two frontrunners for the presidency were George Bush and Al Gore. It was a close race all way up to Election Day. There was some controversy over the ballads, which prolonged the election. In some states their had to be a recount to see who would win that states electoral votes.
Debat3 Essay Research Paper The 2000 Presidential
Debat3 Essay, Research Paper The 2000 Presidential election between Vice-President Al Gore and Texas Governor George W. Bush was and still is a close campaign. This race has still not ended due to the closeness in the state of Florida primarily and the state of Oregon. Florida which contains 25 electoral college votes was and still is to close to call, which means that the race is close as of last time that I had checked the race was only separated by about 1800 votes.
Do Geeks Need To Go To College
Essay, Research Paper ?Do Geeks need to go to College?? In the essay ?Do Geeks need to go to college? by Lisa Schmeiser is about the question if people lose the skill of wanting to learn if they skip college. I feel that a lot of high-tech jobs easily relate to a good majority of the general majors provided by universities.
Ap Classes Essay Research Paper Your 200
Ap Classes Essay, Research Paper Your 200 word typed essay explaining why you wish to be enrolled in an A.P course(s). I wish to be enrolled in AP courses to better prepared to manage the workload of college. AP courses will prepare me for the type of classes I will take in college. They will give a feel of the college environment.
Fun Essay Research Paper Why not just
Fun Essay, Research Paper Why not just pay college athletes? College athletics is a money making scheme for both the college administration and the athletes that are involved. There are agents