Angola Crisis Essay, Research Paper
In past centuries, Angola was among the areas most-devastated by the slave trade. In recent decades, it has been afflicted with wars. However, in both eras, much of the violence was driven by powerful external forces. This is because Angola, with an abundance of oil and other resources, could develop into a very prosperous country if led and controlled by the right power. In 1975 Angola was released from colonialism by Portugal. This pivotal event in history sparked the beginning of a massive conflict between many of the key players in world power. These key players included the United States, Cuba, China, and the Soviet Union.
After reading three separate accounts of the crisis in Angola (U.S. Senate hearings led by Secretary of State Henry Kissinger, a personal memoir by 1975 Assistant Secretary of State Nathaniel Davis, and a biography entitled In Search of Enemies: A CIA Story by John Stockwell), I have come to several conclusions. Although these three men all held important positions in the U.S. government, multiple contradictions exist in their chronologies of events. Of the discrepancies I found, all of them put Stockwell in opposition with Kissinger and Davis. I believe this is due to his position in the Central Intelligence Agency, where the greater availability of information was his advantage. Moreover, since all three accounts agree that the U.S. involvement was essentially a covert operation led by the CIA, I feel the account written by Stockwell was the most valid of the three.
When looking at the differences in chronologies, it is necessary to start from the beginning of the conflict. The first difference I found dealt with CIA involvement in Angola. Stockwell, ?an experienced, senior CIA case officer? (Stockwell, 31), marked early July 1974 as the start of CIA support.
In July 1974 the CIA began funding Roberto without 40 committee
approval, small amounts at first, but enough for word to get around
that the CIA was dealing itself into the race…During the fall of 1974
the CIA continued to fund Roberto, still without 40 committee
approval… (Stockwell, 67).
However, Davis describes that covert support did not begin until much later.
Shortly thereafter (his appointment on March 11, 1975), William
G. Hyland, the director of the State Department?s Bureau of
Intelligence and Research, told me that a $300,000 program of
covert support for the veteran Angolan liberation fighter, Holden
Roberto, had been approved that past January by the Forty
Committee… (Davis, 110).
Kissinger also noted this $300,000, which was given to Holden Roberto, was the first U.S. aid to Angola.
…We did not feel that our national interest was sufficiently
involved in the struggle within Angola…therefore, we only
made a grant of $300,000 which, at most, will get bicycles,
office equipment, and aid political efforts of the FNLA… (Angola, 26).
This contradiction is most-likely due to the differences in position between the three men. Stockwell was an important CIA official and had access to more classified information at an earlier time.
The second inconsistency I found dealt with the U.S. military support in Angola. Stockwell insisted throughout his book that the U.S. was spending millions of dollars on arms for the conflict.
…8 million, released on July 27, was allocated primarily for
the shipload of arms and for the procurement of airplanes
to haul material from Kinshasa into Angola…On August 20,
an additional 10.7 million was authorized for more arms,
aircraft, mercenaries, and maintenance of the liberation
forces, (Stockwell, 206).
Stockwell also reported that by December 1975 the CIA was still lying to Congress about arms and advisors in Angola. At this time, Kissinger was not reporting anything remotely close to a U.S. arms build-up. In fact, he suggested that a military-type involvement was out of the question.
Angola is an African problem and should be left to
Africans to solve; foreign military involvement only
escalates and prolongs the warfare there… (Angola, 10).
In comparison, Davis spoke of a similar American view on foreign military involvement in a memo he submitted to the State Department representative of the Forty Committee.
…Covert intervention (military) would not serve larger
U.S. interests…an attempted intervention could not be
kept secret…a covert intervention would have to be so
circumscribed as to fall between stools in any case-while
the other side could escalate at will, (Davis, 113).
Again, due to the availability of classified CIA information, Stockwell knew of massive U.S. military support while Kissinger and Davis were unaware and noted it to be an irrational decision.
The last contradiction I noted dealt with the concept of mercenaries. Stockwell mentioned that the CIA advisors could not meet the needs of the FNLA/UNITA. They needed to find allies who could advise the two groups on military issues to use against the MPLA. ?Mercenaries seemed to be the answer,? (Stockwell, 182). They needed to be Europeans with military skill and experience in Africa. But as long as they were not Americans the Forty Committee approved. In November 1975 the CIA began to recruit mercenaries from France. They began with only a dozen, but the numbers soon grew. In December the CIA began to recruit 300 Portuguese mercenaries. They were simply known as ?military advisors.?
Stockwell claimed the mercenaries played a large role, and their involvement was later viewed as a necessity. However, neither Kissinger nor Davis focus on the mercenary effort or emphasize their importance in the Angola crisis.
Throughout the entire period of 1974-1976 it seems that the CIA had been working covertly in Angola. In the spring of 1974 the CIA began to fund Roberto without Forty Committee approval. Almost a year later they began to supply arms for the conflict via the Kinshasa airport. These arms deliveries continued while the CIA lied to Congress. In September of 1975 they began to feed biased information to the United States press, as well as discouraging a discussion between MPLA and UNITA over a peaceful solution to the conflict. After the recruiting of hundreds of mercenaries to be used for military advising, the CIA continued to lie to Congress. John Stockwell was receiving all of this information secretly. For this reason, I feel his account of the crisis in Angola is the most valid of the three.
I feel that Nathaniel Davis, while holding an important position, was not receiving the respect he deserved. After Davis submitted a memo arguing against further intervention the President decided to go the other way, so Davis chose to resign. His former position of an American Ambassador to Chile could also have affected the impact of his opinions in Angola.
In terms of Henry Kissinger, I believe that his knowledge of covert activity was underestimated. However, his immense focus on the Soviet Union throughout his entire account precluded such information.
With any event of such historical significance you are going to have many different opinions about the order of its events, especially when the event concerns a number of world powers. In this case, all three accounts supplied factual information. However, the explanations of Davis and Kissinger did not account for classified information. Stockwell was at an advantageous position to view the Angola crisis unencumbered. He was a member of the CIA and knew the interworkings of its plan, and for this reason I see his account as the most substantial.
321
Другие работы по теме:
The Namib Desert Essay Research Paper 51396Period
The Namib Desert Essay, Research Paper 5/13/96 Period 6 The Namib Desert The Namib Desert is a parched and rippled desert, an endless expanse. It stretches along the wouthwest coast of Africa from Angola in the north, through Namibia, into South Africa. The name Namib means ?emptiness.? About 1,700 km (1,060 mi long and 100 km (60 mi) wide, the desert is bordered on the west by the Atlantic Ocean.
Cuban Missile Crisis Essay Research Paper Ever
Cuban Missile Crisis Essay, Research Paper Ever since the Soviet Union defeated the United States in the Cold War by launching ?Sputnik? into orbit first, they thought that they had the ?upper-hand?. Soviet intelligence therefore thought they had superior intercontinental missiles. They would soon find out that they were evenly matched by the United States.
Take My Beating Essay Research Paper it
Take My Beating Essay, Research Paper it’s my fault grabs my ears as i open the door rushing through the air my mothers belt landing smack hard across his legs
Angola Essay Research Paper I feel that
Angola Essay, Research Paper I feel that Angola prison system is a very effective correction system. The video demonstrated how the system has different setups to keep the prisoners working to keep them out of trouble. Although Angola is a rough maximum-security system, it seems to have great control over the inmates.
The ClintonLewinsky Scandal Essay Research Paper Lately
The Clinton-Lewinsky Scandal Essay, Research Paper Lately, the top story in the news day after day, months after months have been about William Jefferson Clinton, also known as Bill. Who could blame them, there is nothing better than a story out of the ordinary, especially one with presidential status. For the past months he has been the most talked about figure, being the essential topic for news, talk shows, late night comedy and even going as far as the big screen.
Angola Essay Research Paper Geography Angola is
Angola Essay, Research Paper Geography Angola is located in southern Africa, boarding the South Atlantic Ocean and is between Namibia and Democratic republic of the Congo. The area is 1,246,700sq km. For size comparative Angola is less than twice the size of Texas. For the geographic coordinates they are 12 30 s 18 30 E.
Surviving The Last Plantation Essay Research Paper
Self-preservation, natures first great law,All the creatures, but man, doth awe.-Andrew MarvelleLove, family, and small thrills are but three things to live for. Sometimes they are the only things to live for. Sometimes they are what drive us to survive. For some of the inmates at Angola State Prison, there is little to live for and they still survive.
Finding Our Past Essay Research Paper Reading
Finding Our Past Essay, Research Paper Reading Ruth In Finding Our Past, Rebecca Alpert suggests that Ruth married Boaz for financial stability in her lesbian relationship. This is an indication of society back when the book of Ruth was written, since women were dependent on men for financial support. In today?s society, lesbian couples are still not entirely accepted, but two women in a relationship would be able to support themselves financially.
Mexican Economy Essay Research Paper For the
Mexican Economy Essay, Research Paper For the fourth time in the past 20 years, the Mexican economy is in financial distress, largely because of bad monetary policies pursued by Mexican officials. The United States has responded in all four instances by lending money to the Mexican government as a short-term palliative.
Psychotherapy Vs Crisis Intervention Essay Research Paper
Psychotherapy, also known as crisis counseling, is an organized conceptual framework, which uses multiple psychological theories to assist an individual towards problem resolution. This type of therapy / counseling may be appropriate after crisis intervention since the goal of psychotherapy is problem resolution and the goal of crisis intervention is problem management.
Dont Forget Essay Research Paper It is
Dont Forget Essay, Research Paper It is not a thing of the past, rather a clear vivid image I remember, I remember as if it had happened yesterday. We were called to go fight, Go to Europe and liberate.
College Athletics Essay Research Paper The commercial
College Athletics Essay, Research Paper The commercial gains in college athletics have become excessive over the past decade. Major college institutions now have merchandising contracts, television contracts, and the success of the team lures more students to the institutions. These gains are not detrimental unless they are used illegally by the institution.
TS Eliot Essay Research Paper T S
T.S. Eliot Essay, Research Paper T. S. Eliot – Tradition and the Individual Talent Poets of the present not only have an advantage, but are much smarter than those of the past because they’re still alive.
Poem She Sat Essay Research Paper She
Poem: She Sat Essay, Research Paper She sat… helpless in her room praying to whatever god there may be to let her call to him. could god ignore such a painful cry?
Global Crisis Essay Research Paper In times
Global Crisis Essay, Research Paper In times of global crisis, is it reasonable to expect that nation-states will put aside rivalries and join together to deal with the crisis?
Defintition Of History Essay Research Paper The
Defintition Of History Essay, Research Paper The statement ? History is nothing more than a collection of the static facts of the past; people who say history changes are terribly misguided? is incorrect. History is more than just static facts when ideas and concepts involved in history are understood and applied in life.
Secrets Of Life Essay Research Paper There
Secrets Of Life Essay, Research Paper There is one part of my life that no one knows about. This secret has caused me to act in ways I thought I wasn’t capable of doing. For the past five years, I
Std Presentation Essay Research Paper STD PresentationI
Std Presentation Essay, Research Paper STD Presentation I was impressed about how well the subject of STD’s was presented to us, because it actually had a positive effect on me. It made me realize that I need to be extra careful, especially here at college because of the high STD rates. I didn’t know how common Aids has become over the past few years, the nationwide figure is 1 in 500 people are infected which seems like a lot.
Freedom And Rights Essay Research Paper Freedom
Freedom And Rights Essay, Research Paper Freedom and Rights How would you feel if your individual rights and freedoms were stripped from you during a national crisis? In many countries, the people s individual rights and freedoms are supposed to be protected by the government. But, in some cases, those individual rights and freedoms were taken away from the people during a national crisis.
Petroleum Crisis Essay Research Paper Everyone wants
Petroleum Crisis Essay, Research Paper Everyone wants appliances such as toasters, microwaves and fridges to be cheap even though they are rich, but what about the poor people or so called middle class. What will they do if the prices are too high to afford? Petroleum is something that we all need to go from place to place, anyways most of us do; four to five years ago, when I first came to Canada, the gas prices were quite low, but in the past 2-3 years, it is still increasing up to date.
Iran Essay Research Paper 1Politics Power and
Iran Essay, Research Paper Politics, Power, and U.S. Policy in Iran, 1950-1953 1 by Francis J. Gavin On 19 August 1953, elements of the Iranian army, acting on orders from the Shah and
What Is Life Essay Research Paper What
What Is Life? Essay, Research Paper What is life? This question perplexes even the most philosophical thinkers because the idea is incredibly difficult to grasp. The sheer number of different perspectives and the vagueness of the whole subject also contribute to this quandary. One of the more comprehensible ones is —_____ s idea; life must be lived forwards, but can only be understood backwards .
Rape Crisis Center Essay Research Paper Prof
Rape Crisis Center Essay, Research Paper Prof. Musa Box 1176 Case Study: Ch 10: Submerging the emergent culture Rape Crisis Center The Rape Crisis Center (RCC) has experienced some problems with the shift of management. The former director, Anne, was a team member, very relaxed, ran open-agenda meetings, and made decisions after discussions.
WHAT CAUSES A CRISIS Essay Research Paper
Title of Paper : crisis Grade Received on Report : 92 WHAT CAUSES A CRISIS? Such a question may at first seem unanswerable because there are so many different kinds of unpleasant situations into which we humans can get ourselves. In one word, however, the
Past Essay Research Paper Michelle Brandon My
Past Essay, Research Paper Michelle Brandon My Past: I was born in Calgary, Alberta in 1983 then in 1985 I moved to Germany. I stayed in Germany for 3 years then I moved to calgary for 2 years. Cakgary is a nice place to live it s a big city compared to Germany. Germany is a beautiful place to go, I would like to go back to Germany for a visit.
MY HERO Essay Research Paper TO ME
MY HERO Essay, Research Paper TO ME A HERO IS A PERSON WHO HELPS A LIFE. NOT NECESSARILY SAVE IT… BUT AFFECT IT IN A SPECIAL WAY. TO ME THIS PERSON IS MY FATHER.
The Iraq Crisis Essay Research Paper The
The Iraq Crisis Essay, Research Paper The Iraq Crisis The recent military action against Iraq by the USA and Britain has plunged the world closer to large-scale war than we have been since 1945. The question is, why have the USA instigated such actions?
The Graduate Essay Research Paper In the
The Graduate Essay, Research Paper In the movie The Graduate, the main character Ben returns home from college and encounters a psychological crisis in the sense that he doesn t know who he is or what he wants. This is due in large part to his smothering parents. Though it may seem like he is a free man and entitled to do as he wished, it is much the contrary.
Asian Crisis Essay Research Paper The continuing
Asian Crisis Essay, Research Paper The continuing Asian economic crisis that began in mid-1997 ranks as Asia’s second biggest event since World War II. The crisis suddenly halted the region’s unprecedented three decades of rapid economic growth.
Asian Crisis Essay Research Paper Asian Crisis
Asian Crisis Essay, Research Paper Asian Crisis The financial crisis that erupted in Asia in mid-1997 has led to sharp declines in the currencies, stock markets, and other asset prices of a number of Asian countries. It is hard to understand what these declines will actually do to the world market. This decline is expected to halve the rate of world growth in 1998 from the four percent that was projected pre-crisis to an estimated outcome of about 2 percent.
Identity Crisis Essay Research Paper Identity Crisis
Identity Crisis Essay, Research Paper Identity Crisis: The Teenage midlife crisis By Erica C. Bowman There are many issues that face today?s teenagers. Probably one of the most common is the issue of individualism or identity. The teenage years harbor some of the most confusing and impressionable years in the life of any human being.
Cover Letter Essay Research Paper February 14
Cover Letter Essay, Research Paper February 14, 2001 XXX Inc PO Box 827 Angola, IN-46703 Dear Ms XXX: I am applying for the summer internship in information systems, which we discussed during the Career Exposition at Tri-State University in Fort Wayne on (02/12/01). My bachelor’s degree in Information Systems and academic record are my strongest qualifications for this position.