Fort Pillow Attack Essay, Research Paper
THE GRAND FABRICATION
It is almost as difficult to find consistent information about the
incident at Fort Pillow as it is to determine the moral significance
of its outcome. Scholars disagree about exactly what transpired on
April 12, 1864 at Fort Pillow, when General Nathan Bedford Forrest
captured the fort with his 1,500 troops and claimed numerous Union
lives in the process (Wyeth 250). It became an issue of propaganda for
the Union, and as a result the facts were grossly distorted. After
close examination it is clear that the ?Fort Pillow Massacre? (as it
became known by abolitionists) was nothing of the sort. The 1,500
troops under the command of General Nathan Bedford Forrest acted as
men and as soldiers in their capture of Fort Pillow.
It is first necessary to understand what happened in the battle
before any judgment can be made. A careful study performed by Dr. John
Wyeth revealed the following information: from April 9-11, 1864,
troops under the command of Ben McCulloch, Tyree Harris Bell, and
Brig. General James Chalmers marched non-stop to Fort Pillow to begin
their assault under the command of General Nathan Bedford Forrest.
Confederate sharpshooters claimed the lives of several key Union
officers during the morning assault on the fort. The losses included
the commanding officer Major Loinel F. Booth, and his second in
command shortly after that. These losses created a complete breakdown
of order and leadership among the Union troops within the fort. (251)
During the morning engagement, the gun boat the New Era was
continually attempting to shell the Confederate forces from the
Mississippi, but with minimal success. The Union forces fought back
heartily until around one o?clock in the afternoon, when both sides
slowed down. Around that time the New Era steamed out of range to
cool its weapons. It had fired a total of 282 rounds, and its supplies
were almost totally exhausted. During this hiatus in the firing, while
Confederate troops waited for supplies that would arrive around three
o?clock, Forrestwas injured when his horse fell on him after being
mortaily wounded (252). When the supplies arrived, Confederate troops
under a flag of truce delivered a message from Forrest that said, ?My
men have received a fresh supply of ammunition, and from their present
position can easily assault and capture the fort,? (253). Forrest
demanded ?the unconditional surrender of the garrison,? promising
?that you shall be treated as prisoners of war? ( 253). This
agreement was refused by Major William F. Bradford using the name of
Major Booth, and Forrest was left with no option but to attack (Long &
Long 484).
Without a word, Forrest rode to his post, and a bugle call began the
charge. The soldiers stormed the fort under the cover of sharpshooter
fire. The Union spent their rounds on the charging mass, and the
second wave was to all intents and purposes a ?turkey shoot.? As
hordes of soldiers came over the wall, a considerable number of Union
lives were lost to point blank fire, an action that was deemed murder
by the northern press. (255) However, it must not be forgotten that
those Union troops who died were in the process of reloading their
rifles. Even knowing that they were severely outnumbered, they had
demanded the fight (Henry 255).
By this point most of the Union officers in the fort had been killed,
and the remaining troops fled the fort toward the river where they had
provisions waiting . There was also a plan for the New Era to shell
the Confederate troops in the fort with canister, but the shelling
never happened(. Confederate troops were waiting at the bottom of the
fort to prevent access to the supplies by the Union forces. With the
Union flag still flying upon the fort and Union forces still firing on
the run, Confederate troops claimed many more lives on the river bank.
It was reported by Colonel FIRST NAME Barteau that
they made a wild, crazy, scattering fight. They acted like
a crowd of drunken men. They would at one moment
yield and throw down their guns, and then would rush
again to arms, seize their guns and renew the fire. If
one squad was left as prisoners … it would soon
discover that they could not be trusted as having
surrendered, for taking the first opportunity they
would break lose again and engage in the contest.
Some of our men were killed by Negroes who had
once surrendered (256).
With this type of activity, it is understandable how a superior
force could claim so many casualties. However, the issue is not so
clear to Civil War historians. The first and biggest problem has to do
with the information that different historians base their opinions on.
For example, in a historical account written by Carl Sandburg it is
reported that Forrest?s troops stood 6,000 strong. This is slightly
inflated from the actual 1,500 that were present. In this same account
Sandburg claims that the ?battle ended as a mob scene with wholesale
lynching?(Sandburg 247). It was distorted information such as this
that was used by the Union as propaganda against the South. After the
incident General FIRST NAME Kilpatrick was quoted saying Forrest had
?nailed Negroes to the fences, set fire to the fences, and burned the
Negroes to death?(Hurst 321). With reports like this, it is
understandable why abolitionist were outraged.
The Congressional Committee released a summary after the event. It
stated
?that the rebels took advantage of a flag of truce to place
themselves in ?position from which the more readily to charge the
upon the fort?; that after the fall of the fort ?the rebels
commenced in an indiscriminate slaughter sparing
neither
age nor sex, white or black, soldier or civilian?;
that this was ?not the results passions excited by
the heat
of conflict, but of a policy deliberation decided
upon and
unhesitatingly announced?; that several of the
wounded
were intentionally burned to death in huts and tents
about the fort; and the ?the rebels buried some of
the living the dead.? (Henry 260)
In the intensive studies performed by Dr. John Wyeth there were more
than fifty soldiers that were present at this battle who gave sworn
testimonies contradicting these findings.(260) This suggests that the
Union fabricated the truth to aid in its own cause.
The fact is that most of what was said about Forrest?s unethical
actions were false accusations. Testimonies from several different
sources (both Union and Confederate) claim that there were no
movements under the flag of truce, but that they had their positions
hours before. (Henry 260) It is true that the losses were huge in this
battle, but that is typical of many significantly unbalanced battles.
According to Wyeth there was only one incident of force against the
Union after the Union flag came down, and that resulted in an on the
spot arrest .
This entire incident was blown totally of proportion. It is tragic to
lose even one life, but on a battle field, death is inevitable. This
event became a monumental point in the war because of exaggeration
and lies told by Union supporters. These lies strengthened the Union
cause and further blemished the reputation of Confederate forces.
Morally, there is no fault in Forrest?s actions.
Subject:
for Fort Pillow Attack paper
Works Cited
Henry, Robert Selph. ?First the Most?-Forrest. . New York: The
Bobbs-Merrill Company, 1944.
Hurst, Jack. Nathan Bedford Forrest-A Biography. New York: Alfred
Knoph, 1993.
Lee, Guy Carleton. The True History of the Civil War. Philadelphia:
I.B. Lippincott, 1903.
Long, E. B. and Barbara Long. The Civil War Day by Day-An Almanac.
New York: Doubleday, 1971.
Sandburg, Carl. Storm over the Land–A Profile of the Civil War. New
York: Harcourt Brace: 1939.
Wyeth, John Allan. That Devil Forrest -The Life of Gen. Nathan
Bedford Forrest. New York: Harper & Brothers Publishers, 1959.
Другие работы по теме:
Fort Mchenry Essay Research Paper Fort McHenryFort
Fort Mchenry Essay, Research Paper Fort McHenry Fort McHenry was an American military installation built on a peninsula in Baltimore harbor in 1799. During the War of 1812 it was attack, September 13- 14, 1814 by a British fleet, an attack that inspired Francis Scott Key, a prisoner aboard a British ship, to write the “Star- Spangled Banner”.
Untitled Essay Research Paper Ticonderoga and Crown
Untitled Essay, Research Paper Ticonderoga and Crown point The immediate object of the attack on the British Forts at Ticonderoga and Crown Point on May 10 and 11, 1775 was first to capture the forts themselves, but also to obtain a cannon and supplies to use for the impending seige of Boston. Washington, who assumed command of the American forces on July 2, 1775, could not attempt this attack without heavy artillery, which was procured by Colonel Ethan Allen, Colonel Benedict Arnold and Colonel Seth Warner with Vermont?s Green Mountain Boys.
Fort Sumter Essay Research Paper Fort Sumter
Fort Sumter Essay, Research Paper Fort Sumter was a turning point in determining the outcome of the Civil War. Fort Sumter was built on a man-made island of seashells and granite. It was a pentagon shape that was fifty feet high and the walls were eight to twelve feet thick. Fort Sumter is located in South Carolina.
Angina Essay Research Paper AnginaWhat is Angina
Angina Essay, Research Paper Angina What is Angina? Angina is a, “Chest pain or pressure, lasting a matter of minutes, that may radiate into the neck or arms. A common symptom of coronary artery disease, angina occurs during periods of physical or emotional stress and is relieved by rest” (Topol, 309). Angina, also known as angina pectoris, is caused by a lack of oxygen to the heart; it most commonly affects men after the age of 30, and women after menopause.
ROTC Entrence Essay Essay Research Paper entrance
ROTC Entrence Essay Essay, Research Paper entrance essay For almost as long as I cn remember, I have been interested in th military. Influenced by such movies as “Patton”, and by my dad’s interest in military history, my
River Project Essay Research Paper Since the
River Project Essay, Research Paper Since the beginning of the Americas the rivers have been a very important source of transportation. If not for the river the shipment of goods would have taken a very long time and would have been almost impossible through the dense forests of the New World. The Mississippi in time has been used for transportation.
Fort Henry And Donelson Essay Research Paper
Fort Donelson, Tennessee, guarding the Cumberland River, became the site of the first major Confederate defeat in the Civil War. Victory at Donelson started Brigadier General Ulysses S. Grant on his road to Appomattox and the White House. His cool judgment under pressure saved the day after the Confederates threatened to break his troop lines, yet errors by his opponents handed him a victory that he did not fully earn on his own.
Glory Movie Essay Research Paper I thought
Glory (Movie) Essay, Research Paper I thought that Glory was an excellent movie. It really helped me to understand the importance of the 54th Regiment of Massachusetts a little more. I think that Col. Robert Shaw (Matthew Broderrick) had a very tough position the whole time in the movie. More so in the beginning and middle than in the end, though.
Life And Chess Essay Research Paper To
Life And Chess Essay, Research Paper To run, to hide, to fight, Are the questions we face, day and night. To run, to hide, to fight, You have options, choose well, choose right.
Nuclear Terrorism Essay Research Paper Today the
Nuclear Terrorism Essay, Research Paper Today, the terrorists have innumerable opportunities to attack where they want and also, how they want. The reason? Nobody knows, but how would you like if you would be able to put some nuclear stuff in a small box instead of looking for a place where you could drive your wagon full of explosives.
Event That Changed My Life Essay Research
Paper An Event That Changed My Life When I was very young an incident occurred that changed my relationship with my older brother John forever. John and I were in the tree fort behind our house playing with a piece of piping. John was on the upper level of our fort holding the large pipe when suddenly he dropped it on my head.
What Happened At The Battle Of Fallen
Timbers? Essay, Research Paper The Battle of Fallen Timbers started on Wednesday, August 20, 1794. The battle took place on the lower Maumee River Valley which is the present state of Ohio. Major General Anthony Wayne was encamped with a military force of 3,700 men, 2,000 of whom were part of the regular United States Army.
Jamestown 2 Essay Research Paper In June
Jamestown 2 Essay, Research Paper In June of 1606, King James I granted a charter to a group of London entrepreneurs, the Virginia Company, to establish a English settlement in the Chesapeake region of North America. By December, 104 male settlers sailed from London instructed to settle Virginia, and find gold and a water route to the Orient.
Patriot Games Essay Research Paper If your
Patriot Games Essay, Research Paper If your looking for a great novel full of action and suspense but much more believable than many science fiction stories, definitely
George Washington 2 Essay Research Paper Washington
George Washington 2 Essay, Research Paper Washington was born in Westmore County, Virginia, on February 22, 1732. He is the son of the late Augustine Washington and Mary Ball Washington. Augustine was a tobacco farmer and a stock raiser. Washington spent most of his early childhood on the Ferry Farm in Fredricksburg, Virginia.
Glory Essay Research Paper Glory is the
Glory Essay, Research Paper Glory is the story of the first black regiment to fight in the civil war. Under the name division fifty-four the courageous black troops voluntarily risked their lives for their country. The uneducated men trained hard to led the attack on South Carolina against the confederates at Fort Wagner, but were unsuccessful in there efforts The film portrays the courage and the struggle of the black soldiers, and how no matter how poorly they where treated the kept working harder and harder to gain respect.
Successes
& Failures Of Lieutenant Hornblower From C S Fores Essay, Research Paper C.S. Forester’s Lieutenant Hornblower In the novel Lieutenant Hornblower there were a few scenes were Hornblower
The War Of 1812 Should We Have
Fought Essay, Research Paper Was it really necessary to go to war with Britain…..again? Many people in America pondered this powerful question and eventually they agreed to defend their country with the consent of the President. Today, we know that the war might not have accomplished much, but back then, your choice would have been to go to war with Britain, too.
The Last Of The Mohicans Essay Research
Paper The Last of the Mohicans The story The Last Of The Mohicans takes place in eastern Canada and in the area of modern New York State. This area is also called the St.Lawernce Low
Lincoln Could He Have Preserved The Union
Essay, Research Paper From the time the South demanded the return of Fort Sumter and Fort Pickens, tension had been building in expectation of Lincoln?s reply. The options available to Lincoln were limited,
The Fallacy Of Personal Attack Essay Research
Paper Fallacy of Personal Attack The fallacy of personal attack involves assaulting the arguer rather than the argument. This fallacy is very common. Personal attack is like not accepting a argument
Heart Disease Essay Research Paper 4 COMMON
Heart Disease Essay, Research Paper 4 COMMON HEART DISEASE 1. CONGENITAL HEART DISEASE : IS THE DAMAGE TO THE HEART THAT CAN OCCUR BEFORE OR DURING THE BIRTH OF A BABY. THAT HAPPENS
Essay Topic A Realization Essay Essay Research
Paper Sometimes I think about all the things that have happened to me in my life and I wonder… what would the kids at school think if they knew that (Name)- straight A+ student, (Name) the Brain whohastopgradesandherparentsneverbughersowhatmorecouldshewant- spent most of her childhood crying and feeling inferior because no one ever wanted to play with her or go to the mall or do normal kid things or be her friend and that the reason those grades were so important was that they were all she had? What would people say if they knew that my mom got divorced because she was a manic depressive and had to be hospitalized leaving little me and my baby sister in the care of Nana, who never liked Mommy and said mean things and made me cry into my pillow at night?
The Real Arthur Essay Research Paper The
The Real Arthur Essay, Research Paper The Real King Arthur Arthur had been identified as the son of British king Uther Pendragon, who was the son of Constantine. Whatever else Arthur is, he is a composite figure of many different legends and beliefs. Some have even related his adventures to Greek mythology.
The French And Indian War Essay Research
Paper The French and Indian War The French and Indian War was fought on July 9, 1755. This battle took place at Fort Duquesne, in western Pennsylvania, which was one of the many
Margaret Cochran Corbin Essay Research Paper Margaret
Margaret Cochran Corbin Essay, Research Paper Margaret Cochran Corbin (1751-c.1800) fought alongside her husband in the American Revolutionary War and was the first woman to receive pension from the United States government as a disabled soldier. She was born Nov. 12, 1751 near Chambersburg, Pennsylvania, U.S.A., orphaned at the age of five and was raised by relatives.
War Of 1812 Essay Research Paper The
War Of 1812 Essay, Research Paper The war of 1812 was one of eight that our country has fought in. This war left us with a loss of people, property, and money. It was started over many things. One of the reasons was the British impressment of American soldiers.
Benedict Arnold Essay Research Paper Arnold was
Benedict Arnold Essay, Research Paper Arnold was born on January 14, 1741, in Norwich, Connecticut. Both his parents were of long-established, well-respected New England families. He was helper to a pharmacist when he was a young. However, he liked the battlefield to a druggist’s life and enlisted in the militia during the French and Indian War (1754-1763).
Cover Letter Essay Research Paper February 14
Cover Letter Essay, Research Paper February 14, 2001 XXX Inc PO Box 827 Angola, IN-46703 Dear Ms XXX: I am applying for the summer internship in information systems, which we discussed during the Career Exposition at Tri-State University in Fort Wayne on (02/12/01). My bachelor’s degree in Information Systems and academic record are my strongest qualifications for this position.
British War Essay Research Paper Gregg GiassonUS
British War Essay, Research Paper Gregg Giasson U.S. History Period B !! YOU ARE THERE !! The most important event in U.S. History in my opinion would be Washington s escape from the British Army at New York. This event changed the course of U.S. History because it was the closest the movement for freedom came to being crushed.
Louisbourg Report Essay Research Paper The Fortress
Louisbourg Report Essay, Research Paper The Fortress Of Louisbourg In all of North America, you will not find a more power fortress than Louisbourg. It was said to be indestructible, but was proven otherwise on a