Literary Utopian Societies Essay, Research Paper
Literary Utopian Societies
?The vision of one century is often the reality of the next?? (Nelson 108). Throughout time, great minds have constructed their own visions of utopia. Through the study of utopias, one finds that these ?perfect? societies have many flaws. For example, most utopias tend to have an authoritarian nature (Manuel 3). Also, another obvious imperfection found in the majority of utopias is that of a faulty social class system (Thomas 94). But one must realized that the flaws found in utopian societies serve a specific purpose. These faults are used to indicate problems in contemporary society (Eurich 5, Targowski 1). Over the years, utopian societies have been beneficial in setting improved standards for society. By pointing out the faults of society, improvement is the most likely next step. Citizens should take advantage of utopian literature in order to better future societal conditions (Nelson 104). Because it is impossible to create a perfect society in which everyone?s needs can be met, society must analyze utopias in order to improve their existing environment.
Plato?s Republic was the first ?true? work considered to be utopian literature. In fact, the Republic influenced almost all later text written on the subject of utopia (Manuel 7). Although the Republic was one of the most influential works in utopian literature, the society that it represented also had many obvious flaws. First, Plato?s utopia had a distinct class system (Morely iii, Bloom xiii). The privileged class that ruled the society also enforced censorship in order to keep control over the Republic (Manuel 5). To perform all of the lowly tasks of the society, a system of slavery was enforced (Manuel 9). In addition, different forms of propaganda were used to keep the citizens in check (Manuel 5, Bloom xiv). The political and economic systems, in which the wealthy class controlled all the funds, were extremely restrictive (Mumford 4, Bloom xiii). With the society being in opposition to change, it would have obviously failed. A static society, in which propaganda is used to promote the State, disrupts the creative thinking process. And, without the creative thinking process, intellectual growth as a whole also slows (Mumford 4, Benz 3).
Yet another famous Utopian society that appears to thrive on the surface is that of Sir Thomas More?s Utopia. More?s society was similar to Plato?s Republic in many ways (Will 1). The State, in More?s Utopia, controlled the masses through the use of propaganda just as in Plato?s Republic (Adams 154). Speaking out against the State was made an unthinkable action (Adams 253). The government of More?s Utopia was so centralized, that it was unable to adapt to changes and face problems (Mumford 4). This Utopia turned out to have a number of underlying problems.
Aldous Huxley?s a Brave New World was another utopia with many imperfections. In the novel, the characters living in utopia were under complete control of the government. They were exposed to propaganda beginning at birth and continued to be exposed to it throughout their lives. The course a person?s life would take was already determined before he was born. Basically, the citizens of this utopia were robots. They did as they were told, and they had no accurate knowledge of what was going on around them (26). Only the elite class of Controllers had an unobstructed view of the world (235). Another theme that was put forth throughout the novel was that of the class system. In Huxley?s utopia, the quality of one?s genes determined his social class. No person had a chance of leaving his caste, and his conditioning had programmed his mind into believing that this was all acceptable (66).
When looking at utopian literature as a whole, one realizes that utopias are merely a way that man uses to improve himself and the environment in which he lives (Eurich 7). The purpose of texts written about utopian societies is to inform the public of current social problems and to inform them how to fix these problems (Targowski 1). ?Almost every utopia is an implicit criticism of the civilization that served as its background.? (Mumford 2). And with this criticism, positive change arises and sets us in another direction. Utopias give people examples on how to improve our society (Eurich 7). While utopias point out problems in contemporary society, they also point out ways to fix these problems (Mumford 2). In fact, ?Utopias are rational efforts to make the world a better place?? (Mumford 1). So, when looking at the classic utopias once again, one realizes why the authors of these texts created the problems that appeared in their utopias.
In the Republic, Plato?s showed how a small group of corrupt politicians could control a whole society (Bloom xvi). By making the ruling class in his Republic corrupt, he showed his dissatisfaction with the current role politicians played within the government. Plato?s answer to this problem was what is now known as communism (Bloom 1). Not only did Plato disapprove of politicians and their power, but he also despised the authoritarian nature of the government (Manuel 3). The controllers of Plato?s society had absolute control and managed the masses through the use of propaganda (Mumford 4). Yet a further disgust that Plato had was the role that women played in society. He believed that women should have more equal duties when being compared to men (Kateb 3). Through the Republic, Plato showed his feelings towards the society that surrounded him.
Throughout More?s Utopia, one can find that More?s goal was to satirize various contemporary European mistreatments (Adams 150-1). At the time of Utopia?s conception, Europe had various economic problems. The agricultural class was losing its property to rich landowners who had no real use for the land (Nelson 100). More also discussed the role women played in society. He agreed with Plato in the fact that women should have more responsibilities when being compared to men. More?s answer to this problem was communism as well (Nelson 102). By creating a Utopian society with the same problems that his current society had, More offered his input on how to adapt to these troubles.
The similarities between Plato?s Republic and More?s Utopia seem to be endless (Benz 3). This is due to the fact that most utopian authors follow a certain chain of thought (Nelson 120). Because utopian authors write about contemporary societal problems, certain themes reoccur throughout the history of utopian literature. More?s Utopia and Plato?s Republic share many of the same troubles. This is because both authors detested the fact that government had excessive amounts of money and control. The two authors wrote their works in order to improve their societal conditions, not to envision a perfect civilization that could never be accomplished in reality.
Although Aldous Huxley did not use a Brave New World to protest societal conditions, he did have a primary reason in writing his novel. Huxley used a Brave New World to show that technological advances and scientific advances are not the answer to creating a perfect society. By perfecting the use of genetic engineering, propaganda, hypnoaedia, and drugs, Huxley?s Brave New World was supposed to be the ideal utopia. But in reality, all of the pleasures resulting from theses advances were empty. Genetic engineering was the basis for social structure and an unjust class system. By using propaganda and hypnoaedia to program its own citizens, the utopia maintained complete control of everything that went on within the society. No one ever questioned the way the society was run. When something did happen to go wrong, citizens were instructed to take soma, which made its users forget about all of their worries. By creating a flawed society that was technologically advanced and scientifically advanced, Huxley showed people that science and technology are not the answer to happiness.
In recent times, many theorists have questioned the belief that utopias cannot exist. People such as G.K. Chesterton and Nicolas Berdiaeff (Berdiaeff is quoted in the introduction of a Brave New World.) believed that due to technological advances, achieving utopia is a realistic ambition (Kateb 81). But, these theorists fail to present any valid data that would support their position. The technology that would allow these utopian societies to thrive is never mentioned. Without proof of this new technology, it is not possible to prove that utopia is attainable.
Throughout time, utopias have been models of contemporary society. By examining various utopias, one finds that certain faults have been purposely inserted (Thomas 96). This is because the authors of these works intended their texts to be used as objections against troubles in modern society (Coupland 3). After publication of this utopian literature, change often arose, and the problems, which had been discussed in the text, had been resolved (Nelson 100). As a result of writing about the injustices of the time, society has set improved standards for itself (Adams 178, Fitting 5). With more utopian experiments in the works, one can only hope that society will once again answer the call to improve, and progress into the next century.
Adams, Robert M., ed. Utopia. New York: W. W. Norton & Company Inc., 1975.
Benz, Phillip, ed. Utopia3. 6 Jan. 1999 <perso.wanadoo.fr/multiverse/utopia/index.html>.
Bloom, Allan. The Republic of Plato. New York: Basic Books Inc., 1968.
Coupland, Philip, ed. University of Warwick. 11 Jan. 1999 <utopianstudies.mcmail/>.
Eurich, Nell. Science in Utopia A Mighty Design. Cambridge, Massachusetts: Harvard University Press, 1967.
Fitting, Peter. The Society for Utopian Studies. 16 Jan. 1999 <utoronto.ca/utopia/index.html#About>.
Huxley, Aldous. Brave New World. New York: Harper & Brothers, 1932.
Kateb, George, ed. Utopia. New York: Atherton Press, 1971.
Manuel, Frank E., ed. Utopias and Utopian Thought. Boston: Houghton Mifflin Company, 1966.
Morley, Henry, ed. Ideal Commonwealths. New York: Kennikat Press, 1968.
Mumford, Lewis. The Story of Utopias. New York: The Viking Press, 1962.
Nelson, William, ed. Twentieth Century Interpretations of Utopia. Englewood Cliffs, New Jersey: Prentice-Hall, 1968.
Taragowski, Henry W. Utopia. 6 Jan. 1999 <euro/mark-space/glosUtopia.html>.
Thomas, John L., ed. Looking Backward 2000-1887. Cambridge, Massachusetts: Harvard University Press, 1967.
Utopia and Utopian Philosophy. Ed. Jon Will. 1999. Utopia Pathway Association. 6 Jan. 1999 <users.erols/jonwill/>.
Validation of Electronic Sources
Phillip Benz received a Master?s Degree in English Literature and currently teaches in France.
Philip Coupland is a professor at Warwick University.
Jon Will is the Vice President of the Utopia Pathway Association.
Henry Taragowski is a professor at Xavier University.
Peter Fitting is the Chairman of the Society for Utopian Studies.
Другие работы по теме:
Parent Relationships Essay Research Paper In many
Parent Relationships Essay, Research Paper In many of the works of literature I have read in this particular class, I noticed that many of the characters are parents. Which leads me to ask the following questions? How are parent/child relationships represented in early literature and how do these representations compare with representations, either real or literary, in our society?
Rimbaud Essay Research Paper Part II
Rimbaud Essay, Research Paper Part II A man so confused and confusing as Arthur Rimbaud, it is a wonder that he can even be analyzed, critiqued, and judged by his literary works. Never the less it has been done, however how accurate can they be, when even Rimbaud said in his Lettre Du Voyant that for the I is someone else.
Life Of Equiano Essay Research Paper Olaudah
Life Of Equiano Essay, Research Paper Olaudah Equiano (Gustavus Vassa) was kidnapped from his African village at the age of eleven. Shipped through the ardous “Middle Passge” of the Altantic Ocean. More than two centuries later, this work is recognized not only as one of the first works written in English by a former slave, but perhaps more important as the paradigm of the slave narrative, a new literary genre.
Utopian Society Essay Research Paper Animal Farm
Utopian Society Essay, Research Paper Animal Farm, like Brave New World, shows the idea of a Utopia . The animals yearned for their perfect farm where they could run themselves and their work would be rewarded rather than be given more work. It was their idea of a flawless society, where everyone was happy and cooperated.
Epic Of Gilgamesh And The Book Of
Genesis Essay, Research Paper The Epic Of Gilgamesh is an important Middle East literary work, written in cuneiform on 12 clay tablets about 2000 BC by the oldest human author that we can name. The Epic tells the story of a great Mesopotamian king,Gilgamesh,who finds his kindered spirit and goes on a spiritual quest for understanding of death and the after life.
Utopian Socialism Essay Research Paper Since the
Utopian Socialism Essay, Research Paper Since the beginning of the idea of money, there have been those who have wealth, and those who want it. Utopian socialism is not a new idea, and it has remained popular since its creation. Many people know what socialism is, but not that many know the principles Utopian Socialism.
Literary Terms Essay Research Paper Figurative Language
Literary Terms Essay, Research Paper Figurative Language - Language using figures of speech, such as simile, hyperbole, metaphor, symbolism and personification to form imagery is figurative language. It is used to increase shock, novelty, appearance, or illustrative consequences.
Slaughterhouse Five 2 Essay Research Paper The
Slaughterhouse Five 2 Essay, Research Paper The Use of Literary Devices in Kurt Vonnegut s Slaughterhouse-five Kurt Vonnegut used many literary devices in his novel Slaughterhouse-five. These different devices serve to carry his varying themes through the story. He uses a system of two narratives that separates himself from the story, also there is the repetition of certain phrases which cycle you through the tale.
1984 Essay Research Paper The lesson to
1984 Essay, Research Paper The lesson to be learned from George Orwell’s 1984 is that an “ideal” of having a Utopian society will never really work. George Orwell may have written 1984, in order
Wuthering HeightsBronte Essay Research Paper Critique Wuthering
Wuthering Heights-Bronte Essay, Research Paper Critique- Wuthering Hieghts Wuthering Hieghts is the prototype of all the gothic novels. It contains all the literary elements such as, symbolism, supernatural, and the dark solemn mood classic to all gothic novels. Although the book was well written and rich with literary devices, it did not retain my attention.
Odes Of Keats And Shelley Essay Research
Paper J.A. Cuddon, writing in The Penguin Dictionary of Literary Theory and Literary Terms, defines an ode as "a lyric poem, usually of some length . . . [which]
The Adventures Of Huckelberry Finn
– Critique Essay, Research Paper Critical Biography Mark Twain, the pseudonym of Samuel Clemens, was, as a literary writer, a genius. His use of numerous literary devices throughout the novel are quite unique. Examples of them would be, irony;
The Cask Of Amontillado Lit Analysis Essay
, Research Paper Clint Kale 11/22/97 Literary Analysis Literary Analysis: The Cask of Amontillado In Edgar Allan Poe’s short story, “The Cask of Amontillado,” a character named
Essay Writing Essay Research Paper email 7cdgqlinkqueensucaEssay
Essay Writing Essay, Research Paper email: 7cdg@qlink.queensu.caEssay Writing An essay is a literary composition. The purpose of a good formal essay is to try out an idea, thesis, or opinion, within the confines of a proper literary composition. To do this successfully one must know their topic, formulate a thesis, and finally write the essay.
Watership Down 2 Essay Research Paper Watership
Watership Down 2 Essay, Research Paper Watership Down as Good Literature Watership Down, by Richard Adams, is considered good literature because of the literary techniques and because of the plot. Several literary techniques are used to pull the reader in and the plot is a well constructed to hold their attention.
Macbeth Literary Essay Essay Research Paper Literary
Macbeth Literary Essay Essay, Research Paper Literary Essay – Macbeth In William Shakespeare s Macbeth, the play s central character Macbeth displays the atrocities created by greed, one of the play s many themes. The play Macbeth, illustrates to the reader how greed for power and wealth can destroy oneself and everyone in his treacherous path.
Marvell Vs Herrick Essay Research Paper Corretta
Marvell Vs Herrick Essay, Research Paper Corretta Sanders Poetry Essay Englis 1302 Instructor Mize Herrick vs. Marvell “To the Virgins, to Make Much of Time” by Rober Herrick and Andrew Marvell’s “To His Coy Mistress” have many similarities and differences. The tone of the speakers, the audience each poem is directed to, and the theme make up some of the literary elements that help fit this description.
Herrick Vs Marvell Essay Research Paper Corretta
Herrick Vs Marvell Essay, Research Paper Corretta Sanders Poetry Essay Englis 1302 Instructor Mize Herrick vs. Marvell ?To the Virgins, to Make Much of Time? by Rober Herrick and Andrew Marvell?s ?To His Coy Mistress? have many similarities and differences. The tone of the speakers, the audience each poem is directed to, and the theme make up some of the literary elements that help fit this description.
Lord Byron And His Literature Essay Research
Paper Lord Byron and His Literature Lord Byron was a man whose passion for life seemed unequaled by any of the other Romantic figures. Byron?s personal character, though not entirely so, could be seen in his literature as well as his life.
Literary Analysis Of A
& P Essay, Research Paper Literary Analysis of A & P The short story A & P, by John Updike, can be broken down into a number of components, which include characters, setting, plot, point of view, and the theme.
Geographical Knowledge Essay Research Paper
Not overly impressive knowledge ? many geographical books came to aid literary understanding. ? Map most important for officials to conceptualise land on their borders etc.? Theodosius II orders map of the world. ?
Visions And Voices Essay Research Paper Visions
Visions And Voices Essay, Research Paper Visions and Voices The biographical film of Langston Hughes is both informative and entertaining. It approaches Hughes s life with insightful observations from the people that personally knew him. The film goes into detail on his family background and early life before his poetic success, and continues through his life in Harlem, his literary achievements, and legacy.
Spring Essay Research Paper George Manley Hopkin
Spring Essay, Research Paper George Manley Hopkin s poem, Spring is a sonnet. The poem deals with the rebirth of a soul. Hopkins writes his poem about the season of spring. Within the poem, Hopkins uses imagery as well as literary devices to portray his meaning.
Literary Analysis On 2
Literary Analysis On “My Antonia” Essay, Research Paper Tessa Stephens English Literary Analysis The novel My Antonia tells us that it takes time to find out what people are really like. It also helps us realize that it is scary to be new and it takes time to adjust. When Jimmy sees his grandmother give Antonia?s mother her metal pot, he realizes that he didn?t really know Antonia?s family as well as he thought he did.
18th Century Literature Essay Research Paper 18th
18th Century Literature Essay, Research Paper 18th Century Literature The 18th century is a period of great literary works. The styles are different throughout the period, but the unity of the work is still present.
Vision Essay Research Paper Literary analysis Vision
Vision Essay, Research Paper Literary analysis: Vision Out of the Corner of One Eye. The main character of “Vision out of the Corner of One Eye “, a short story by Luisa Valezuela, goes through a complete one hundred-eighty degree change over the course of the story.
Literary Techniques Essay Research Paper 1 ImageryImagery
Literary Techniques Essay, Research Paper 1. Imagery Imagery is one of the main techniques used through out Waiting for Godot. The first image that appears is a tree. This simple tree in the middle of a desolate setting alludes to many symbols. To start, the tree represents the Tree of Knowledge, for it creates a reverse Garden of Eden.
Symbolism Essay Research Paper In the novel
Symbolism Essay, Research Paper In the novel To Kill A Mockingbird by Harper Lee, symbolism is the key literary device. Symbolism is when one thing stands for another. It is a sin to kill a mockingbird. This is because mockingbirds do not harm anything, they just sing to you. The mockingbird symbolized both Tom Robinson and Boo Radley.
Shakespeare Authorship Essay Research Paper No discussion
Shakespeare Authorship Essay, Research Paper No discussion group on Shakespeare would be complete without someone discussing whether the Stratford man really whote all the works attributed to Shakespeare. Some claim Christopher Marlowe to be the author; others, Francis Bacon; and several web pages are devoted to the premise that Count Edward deVere wrote these books.
Huck Essay Research Paper Elements of Racism
Huck Essay, Research Paper Elements of Racism in Huckleberry Finn Despite all the criticism, of racism and other questionable material for young readers, Mark Twain?s The Adventure of Huckleberry Finn is a superbly written novel, which in the opinion of this reviewer should not be remove the literary cannon.
Transendentalism In Emerson
’s Poetry Essay, Research Paper Ralph Waldo Emerson always considered himself a poet despite his many volumes of Essays and other works. Therefore this essay only deals with Emerson s poetry. Emerson told a lot with his prose but he told more with his poetry. Often, fundamental aspects of transcendentalism are shown through literary devices in his poetry.
Educating For The Perfect Essay Research Paper
“The hope of making (The Utopian State) would lie in culture. If people could be persuaded to read and write, not just eat and make love, there was still a chance that they might come to reason.” This