Down Essay, Research Paper
Separation
In the book ?The Spirit Catches You and You Fall Down? by Anne Fadiman, a child named Lia Lee is taken away from her parents by Child Protective Services and placed in foster care. Because they aren?t giving her medication for epilepsy. Although resulting in some medical benefits those benefits were lost because of destructive psychological and emotional damage to Lia.
Dr. Neil Ernst decided to call child protective services when Lia Lee?s parents Nou Kou and Foua were reluctant to give her her medicine. Dr. Neil Ernst said: ?I felt it was important for these Hmongs to understand that there were certain elements of medicine that we understood better than they did and that there were certain rules they had to follow with their kids? lives. I wanted the word to get out in the community that if they deviated from that, it was not acceptable behavior.?(pg. 79 Fadiman). Dr. Ernst could have also been arrested for not reporting it. There were some alternatives to calling Child Protective Services such as my favorite one; having a nurse visit the Lees? three times daily to administer the medications, but this thought did not occur to Dr. Ernst and/or seemed unreasonable at the time. Although Fadiman does not mention what Dr. Ernst thought about this course of action, I can only suspect that it would have been too expensive to have a nurse visit three times a day. Also they shouldn?t be rewarded for their noncompliance by having someone else administer their daughter?s medication. It might have also provoked the Lees? to anger because they didn?t like to give Lia the medicine because of how the medicine made her depressed and sullen. After Lia was taken away for a period of a few weeks, Nou Kou almost beat an interpreter named Sue Xiong who was interpreting for a CPS
(#)
social worker.
Nou Kou said: ?I was outside and Sue came inside and she called me and said, Come in here, you come in here. At that time I was ready to hit Sue, and I got a baseball bat right there. My son-in-law was with me, and he grabbed me and told me not to do it.?(pg. 91 Fadiman), so you can see the Lees? were violent natured. The second reason the Nou Kou and Foua did not want to give their daughter the medicine was that they believed like other Hmongs that people with epilepsy are caught by a good or bad spirit which makes them fall to the ground (the Hmong word for epilepsy translates into: the spirit catches you and you fall down) and while their under siege they get messages from the gods. Many people in their culture with epilepsy become cultural healers or shamans.
The plan of sending a nurse would have been my plan. It would have been allot of time and money though. And when the Hmong community is already draining our resources through welfare doesn?t make much sense to spend more money on them. It also would not have said that ?our medicine is better? as good either. Although Dr. Neil?s plan of letting CPS handle it worked out for him it did not work out for Lia for she had more seizures at her foster home with the medicine than at home with missed and half dosses. The reason is because she did not want to be separated from her parents, and the emotional damage from the separation. Some people would say it was selfish and lazy that Dr. Ernst did not at least try to use a nurse to administer the medication. I believe if I was Him that I would try sending a nurse for Two weeks to see if it would work and then make a decision. But on the other hand I believe that these stubborn, ignorant people shouldn?t be pampered when they are already helping themselves to so much
(#)
from the tax payers through welfare. Because of these two issues of Dr. Ernst?s quickness to
make a decision, and the Hmong community taking so much and giving nothing back, it is hard for me to make a decision and I feel myself ?slipping? towards Dr. Ernst?s decision. I don?t blame Dr. Ernst for his decision which I think is the most logical choice and even if he tried my Two weeks idea it still wouldn?t make sending a nurse any less expensive. All I am saying is that he should not have worried about teaching the Hmong community a lesson on reality so much and think more about the health of the individual named Lia Lee.
The Hmongs believe that to treat the body you must also treat the soul, what happened here is that Lia?s soul got hurt so she didn?t get better at all, nor much worse. That is why I think the medicine didn?t work effectively. It is unfortunate that cultural misunderstanding and language barriers got in the way of what could have been resolved much more easily.
(#)
Citation
Fadiman, Anne. The Spirit Catches You and You Fall Down. New
York: The Noonday Press, 1997
(#)
Другие работы по теме:
Calvinism Vs Arminianism Essay Research Paper According
Calvinism Vs. Arminianism Essay, Research Paper According to Arminianism, salvation is accomplished through the combined efforts of God (who takes the initiative) and man (who must respond) – man’s response being the determining factor. God has provided salvation for everyone, but His provision becomes effective only for those who, of their own free will, “choose” to cooperate with Him and accept His offer of grace.
Catching The Spirit Essay Research Paper Catching
Catching The Spirit Essay, Research Paper Catching the Spirit The American Heritage Dictionary defines sportsmanship as, “an act in which one abides by the rules of a contest and accepts victory or defeat graciously.” All those in athletics are not the only ones who need to be good sportsmen. It must also be required by coaches, cheerleaders, fans, and school administrators.
Compare And Contrast Goundhog Essay Research Paper
Compare and Contrast Groundhog s Day and The Fall Steve Perri George Brown These two works have a very similar story to them. In Groundhog s Day, Bill Murray s character, Phil is stuck in the same day until he can become truly happy. In The Fall, the main character is suffering from an identity crisis. As we watch and read we find that these two people have a very similar predicament.
Social Control Theory Essay Research Paper The
Social Control Theory Essay, Research Paper The article “Arizona wants special prison for foreiners” is one example of how ethnicity and crime are an issue and how some feel it should be delt with. As some may see this as a positive thing to do inorder to help the process of deportation or what ever the consequences may be, many others are calling it a plan that would segregate Mexican inmates, being that 89 percent of the foreign inmates would fall under that race.
Things Fall Apart Essay Research Paper Things 2
Things Fall Apart- Essay, Research Paper Things Fall Apart- There was a man who dreamed as a child of being well known and respected throughout his village and neighboring villages. This man,
Independent Spirit Essay Essay Research Paper There
Independent Spirit Essay Essay, Research Paper There can be a difference between a dependent and independent spirits. Independent spirits can be found in everyone and how your independent spirit can help others.
Gimpel The Fool Essay Research Paper In
Gimpel The Fool Essay, Research Paper In Isaac Bashevis Singer s Gimpel the Fool , Gimpel is treated with no respect from his peers or the society of Frampol where he lives. Gimpel s life has been riddled with tricks and lies from the townspeople for as long as he can remember. No one respects Gimpel or has any sympathy for him and his misfortunes.
Loss Of Innocence In Catcher In The
Rye Essay, Research Paper ?Nature?s first green is gold, Her hardest hue to hold. Her early leaf?s a flower; But only so an hour. Then leaf subsides to leaf.
Catcher In The Rye 2
Catcher In The Rye’s Holden Caufield Essay, Research Paper Happy endings offered throughout novels are results of spiritual reassessments or moreal reconciliation of specific characters. Considered as a more relaxed novel, Catcher in the Rye catches the spirit of the reader with its moral reconcilliation, defining the book’s meaning as a whole.
Puritanism Essay Research Paper Puritanism Sinner
Puritanism Essay, Research Paper Puritanism Sinner’s In the Hands of an Angry God Jonathon Edwards Puritanism, a religious reform movement in the late 16th and 17th century which sought to “purify” the Church of England, Anglican Church. Puritans became noted for a spirit of moral and religious pledge that determined their whole way of life, and they sought through church reform to make their lifestyle the pattern for the whole nation.
Rock Climbing Essay Research Paper My Rock
Rock Climbing Essay, Research Paper My Rock Climbing Experience I know that all of you have hobbies that you enjoy doing, and that you, more than likely, do quite well. I like to go rock climbing. Granted there is not to many places in East Texas that you can do this sport. Rock climbing is a sport that a friend of mine in California introduced me to but it is a sport that many people either enjoy watching or doing.
Nkohma Essay Research Paper Acts Summary xThe
Nkohma Essay, Research Paper .Acts Summary x The book of Acts is written by the author Luke the Apostle who also wrote the book Luke that is one of the four books in the Gospel of the New Testament. The book of Acts is a linking book that shows and describes the transition of Jesus final ministry by sending the Holy Spirit after His ascention into Heaven.
John Milton Essay Research Paper John Milton 2
John Milton Essay, Research Paper John Milton’s “Paradise Lost” describes the fall of man in a poetic lyric. His book closely details the character God, Satan, and how Adam and Eve came do their downfall. God’s first human creation, Adam, was given all luscious gifts of paradise, including free will. The Tree Of Knowledge was Adam and Eve’s only forbiddance.
Lady Of Shalott Essay Research Paper FALLFor
Lady Of Shalott Essay, Research Paper FALL For me the fall is an exhilarating time of year. A time of change, an in-between period of muddled and varied weather. For others who view fall as a short time before a dreary winter, fall takes on a less colorful face. Alfred Lord Tennyson uses fall metaphorically throughout “The Lady of Shalott” to illustrate how the Lady of Shalott’s life (or lack thereof) progresses.
Puritans Compared To Apostles Essay Research Paper
Drew Morgan, of Jack Cavanaugh’s The Puritans, is similar to Paul the apostle through his life’s experiences and challenges. In the 1700’s, a religious group of people called Puritans began to sail to the New World in search of religious freedom and the ability to worship as they pleased. Even though Drew Morgan’s life seemed to mirror Paul’s, he had his own, one-of-a-kind experiences he had to face.
How It Feels To Be Colored Me
Essay, Research Paper How It Feels to Be Colored Me “How It Feels to Be Colored Me has a irrepressible spirit in the face of what are clear inequalities in America, for its ironic self-representation, and for the sheer delight it gives to think that Hurston has triumphed after all.” -A.L.
Breaking Up Essay Research Paper Cause and
Breaking Up Essay, Research Paper Cause and Effect In keeping with my research topic I chose to Wright my cause and effect paper over breaking up. There are many causes why people break up. In everyone life there comes a point and time when they finds one person whom they fall madly in love with. Real life relationships are different what we see in the movies where two people fall in love and go on to live happily ever after.
The Crucible Essay Research Paper What Willy
The Crucible Essay, Research Paper What Willy meant to Biff Did not like him that much. Ruined his life. Was his role model until he catches them in bed. What Willy meant to Happy
Fake Myth Essay Research Paper Many centuries
Fake Myth Essay, Research Paper Many centuries ago, before you, before me. Before water existed. There was a god, who roamed the earth in search of something, anything. He roamed the barren landscapes and searched under all rocks. Until one day he found something. It was a hole, a hole that seemed bottomless.
After The Fall Essay Research Paper After
After The Fall Essay, Research Paper After the Fall Arthur Miller has written many great plays in his life, such as A View from the Bridge ,Death of a Salesman ,The Misfits, The Crucible, and After the Fall. Out of all his
The Destruction Of The Human Spirit In
Frankenstein And The Picture Of Dorian Grey Essay, Research Paper The human spirit is one of the most beautiful forces in the world, but it is also one of the most vulnerable.In the novels Frankenstein by Mary Shelley and The Picture of Dorian Grey by Oscar Wilde, this idea of the human spirit is portrayed clearly.Both novels have similar aspects about the human spirit, but they also have their differences.Both novels have main characters who are influenced greatly by someone that they admire, and they are destroyed by that influence.The difference that these novels have is that in Frankenstein, the main character is influenced and destroyed by something he creates himself, while in The Picture of Dorian Grey, the main character is influenced and destroyed by his friend and mentor.Again, both novels portray the human spirit’s motivation and vulnerability.
What Makes Us Love Essay Research Paper
What Makes Us Love? What makes us love? This question has been studied for centuries by philosophers, scientists, and even writers in search of a sensible answer.
The Kubla Khan Or A Vision In
A Dream By Samuel Taylor Coleridge. Essay, Research Paper The Kubla Khan: or A Vision in a Dream By Samuel Taylor Coleridge. When the author dreamed about the content of this poem, he was in a lonely farm house, because he was sick. The doctor prescribed a drug that made him drowsy and fall into a profound sleep for a few hours.
3rd Annual Fall Festival Of Music Essay
, Research Paper This report is about the 3rd Annual Fall Festival Of Music, Held at Eisenhower High School, Ca. It was a local tournament at the end of marching band season. Some kids came to win, some to hope, and some to work. The primary reason for this tournament was to raise money for the Eisenhower Golden Eagle Alliance.
Blithe Spirit Essay Research Paper Anthony J
Blithe Spirit Essay, Research Paper Anthony J. Perrotta October 3, 1999 Blithe Spirit Frankly, I was amazed by the set of Blithe Spirit. I am not sure whether it was because I had a hand in building it and all of the skills I acquired in doing so or just the fact that it was a great set. Either way I was extremely impressed.
Spirit Of Mountains Essay Research Paper Spirit
Spirit Of Mountains Essay, Research Paper Spirit of the Mountains Grace, Beauty, tranquillity, man conquering majestic mountains, mammoth in size. Thus describes the experience, of a mountain. Like
If A Body Catches A Body Essay
, Research Paper “If a body catches a body ” Holden Caulfield’s monologue in The Catcher in the Rye is an examination of one boy’s struggle of entering into adulthood. He is a classic screw up with no goals, just as Stradlater, his roommate at Percey, states; “you don’t do one damn thing the way you’resupposed to” (Salinger 41).
My Thoughts On Love Essay Research Paper
My thoughts on Love What is love for? Why does it have to be just a word thrown around like a misguided sin? Why do people fall in love? Is it because they want to be hurt? If people realized that love
Julius Caesar A Dead Man
’s Party Essay, Research Paper JULIUS CAESAR: A Dead Man?s Party In Shakespeare?s Julius Caesar, the character of Caesar remains a active force throughout the play, even after his assassination. Caesar is
Calvinism Essay Research Paper Since John Calvin
Calvinism Essay, Research Paper Since John Calvin first introduced the belief of election, it has caused debate among theologians in many Protestant churches. John Calvin?s beliefs consisted of five general themes.
The Holy Spirit Essay Research Paper The
The Holy Spirit Essay, Research Paper The Holy Spirit Paul talks lot about the Holy Spirit and the role that He plays in peoples lives in Romans 8:3-17. His main point though, is that there is a very distinct difference between people of the flesh and people of the Spirit. If the Spirit of God is alive in a person, then that person is alive because they died to sin.
Legends Of The Fall
— Literal Analysis Essay, Research Paper Legends of the Fall Legends of the Fall are a fictional drama/romance film by Edward Zwick. Set during World War 1 in the hills of Montana. The main setting was in the Ludlow ranch, where the author develops five particular characters: Colonel Ludlow, Alfred, Samuel, Tristan, and Susana.
Propsero
’s Relationship With Caliban Essay, Research Paper Prospero generally greets Caliban and Ariel with the words ’slave’ and ’servant’. Prospero calls Ariel the servant and rarely uses Ariel’s name. Prospero also calls Ariel ’spirit’. It is quite apparent that Prospero feels that he owns Ariel, always calling Ariel ‘My brave spirit’ and ‘Why that’s my spirit’ using ‘my’ in these sentences when he speaks to Ariel, showing possesion.
Barbed Wire By Mary Emeny Essay Research
Paper Mary Emeny?s poem, ?Barbed Wire,? depicts war as a negative force, destroying every decent aspect of human existence. Written during the Vietnam War, the work displays Emeny?s negative views on war. In one way or another everyone experiences and identifies with the presence of war. Although some wars are fought for justifiable reasons, every war tears into the lives of those undeserving.