ADA Essay, Research Paper
Reasonable Accommodation in the Work Place Under ADA
There may be as many as one thousand different disabilities that affect over forty-three million Americans. Of all the laws and regulations governing the treatment of those Americans the American with Disabilities Act (ADA) is the most recent major law. It was passed in 1990 and although it is spelled out in a technical ADA manual that is several hundred pages in length. Two of ADA’s two major sections, Titles II and III concern the operation of state and local government and places of public accommodation. They require new public and commercial facilities to be accessible to people with disabilities. Modifications to existing facilities need to be made only if the cost is “readily achievable” and does not cause an undue financial or administrative burden. This essay will concentrate on Title I, the employment aspects of the law. This section forbids employment discrimination against people with disabilities who are able to perform the essential functions of the job with or without reasonable accommodation.
This definition poses three main questions: Who is considered disabled? What is an essential function of a job? What is considered Reasonable Accommodation?
To be protected under the ADA an individual must have a physical or mental impairment that substantially affects one or more major life activities. The impairment may not be due to environmental, cultural, or economic disadvantages. For example a person who cannot read because they have dyslexia is considered disabled but a person who cannot read because they dropped out of school is not. In addition persons who are perceived to be disabled are protected by ADA. For example, if a person were to suffer a heart attack, when he tries to return to work the boss might be scared the workload will be too much and refuse to let him come back. The employer would be in violation of the ADA because he perceives the employee as disabled and is discriminating based on that perception. Two classes that are explicitly excluded from protection under ADA are those individuals whose current use of alcohol or illegal drug is affecting their job performance. However those who are recovering from their former use of either alcohol or drugs are covered.
The Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC), the federal agency responsible for enforcing the ADA and other EEO laws that apply to most public and private employers, separates job duties into two categories: essential and marginal. Essential functions are those duties that each person in a certain position must do or must be able to do to be an effective employee. Marginal functions are duties that are required of only some employees or are not critical to job performance. The ADA requires that employers make decisions about applicants with disabilities solely on the basis of their ability to perform essential job functions.
Reasonable accommodations are the actions taken to accommodate the known disabilities of applicants or employees so that disabled persons can enjoy equal employment opportunities. Since it is not generally acceptable for a potential employer to ask about a disability or conduct test such as HIV test to look for disabilities, it is the responsibility of the applicant or employee to inform the employer of the disability and needed accommodation. At that point the employer must make “reasonable accommodation for the known disability. An employer may not deny employment in order to avoid providing the reasonable accommodation unless it would cause an undue hardship. Even then the applicant or employee should be given the option of providing accommodation himself.
The employment provisions began to be enforced for business with 25 or more employees on July 26, 1992. This affected approximately 264,000 employers. The second phase of the employment provision went into affect July 26, 1994, and was implemented for the approximately 666,000 U.S. employers with 15 or more employees.
Many opponents of the ADA suggested that the law would cost small businesses too much. They contended that the legislation would backlog the courts with lawsuits from scorned job applicants. However this has not been the case. Over eighty percent of the discrimination complaints filed with the EEOC have been entered by current employees who claim a prior disability or recently disabled workers who contend that their employers have not reasonably accommodated their needs under the law. According to EEOC records the most common type of disabilities suffered by workers who claim employment discrimination is back problems, which account for about eighteen percent of complaints. Mental illness has the next largest portion of complaints, making up about ten percent. It is followed by heart trouble, neurological disorders, and diabetes. Only around twenty percent of all complaints filed argue that the employer failed to provide them with reasonable accommodations for their jobs. Ten percent of complaints received claim that they have unfairly disciplined because of their disability, while nearly four percent contend they have been denied rightful benefits. Although the ADA was passed to bring disabled people into the mainstream, these numbers show that most of the complaints filed have not been what would traditionally be called handicapped people. In fact only six percent of all the actions filed during the first three years the law was in force were filed by the blind and the deaf.
As of November 1994 two-thirds of all severely disabled adults remain unemployed, the same number as when ADA was passed in 1991. Many experts believe that people with traditional disabilities are not exploiting the law as expected, partly because many fear losing comprehensive medical benefits from programs like Medicaid. “Most of us are scared to death to get a job and lose out on poverty-based health care,” said Justin Dart, former chairperson of the President’s Committee on Employment of People with Disabilities. Meanwhile, the ADA has armed less severely disabled workers with a law that is broad and vague.
The cost of “reasonable accommodation” has been a controversial topic since the bill’s inception. Many feared it would force many small businesses under or at least add another barrier to entry for small business. In one example a Denver restaurant owner paid thousands of dollars in additional construction cost, legal fees, and fines to comply with the ADA. By the time he was finished these additional expenses amounted to more than half the original cost of opening the business. This is however by no means the norm. To the contrary, studies show that costs of installing required accommodations average less than one percent during construction. If the job had been done right at the outset, none of the additional expenses would have been incurred, according to the former Democratic representative from California who was the principle author of the ADA. In fact according to a two year survey from the Job Accommodations Network at West Virginia University, two-thirds of respondents said their accommodations cost less than $500, and only four percent said the accommodations cost more that $5000. The survey also reported that business persons estimated they get back $30 in benefits such as increased productivity for every dollar they spend. Over half of the sixty-one thousand businesses that participated in this survey last year had less than a thousand employees.
Experts agree that a proactive and collaborative approach is the best way to accommodate workers with disabilities and thereby avoid litigation. Since the first step is for the employee or applicant to identify himself as disabled, the employer is not obligated to consider or provide any kind of accommodation until that identification is made. The request should be made in written form. At that point the individual and the employer collaborate in identifying the barriers that limit the employee’s ability to perform essential job functions. There are standardized surveys that may assist in determining the employee’s existing or potential accommodation needs. One example is the Work Experience Survey, which is a structured interview that enables respondents to determine career adjustments and advancements in a variety of areas. Next the employer should identify a variety of accommodations, using the person with the disability as a resource. The alternatives are the considered and employer determines which would impose fewest economic hardships, considering the employee’s preference when two equivalent accommodations have been identified. The chosen accommodation is then implemented. As with any company policy, it is important to document it and provide for ongoing reviews. Another important factor is to make sure there is a clear channel of communication with the disabled person for addressing future needs.
According to an article in HR Focus there are some steps employers can take in designing work areas to easily accommodate employees. Some of the suggestions include: Use panel systems so that work spaces can be easily modified and work surface heights can be raised or lowered as needed. Install electronically controlled work surfaces and tables. Lower storage areas or install storage areas that are movable. Install adjustable keyboard pads that adjust easily with little hand pressure. Install adjustable lighting with variable intensity that can add more or less light to the work space as needed.
The Americans with Disabilities Act was enacted with the best of intentions. Although it has undergone much scrutiny it is clearly a step in the right direction. As is apparent by the previously mentioned statistics and surveys, the ADA has not put too large a burden upon business to provide reasonable accommodation. However since the employment rate of the traditional handicapped person has not been affected since the laws inception there is obviously much work to be done. In the future if handicapped people are going to be integrated into the mainstream of society it will take a collective effort not from the United States Government, but from society in general. People from both all walks of life, including handicapped and nonhandicapped, must want the changes and take some initiative to make it happen.
Bowers, Brent. “ADA Compliance comes cheap, a survey finds.” Wall Street Journal
16 Sep. 1994 p(b)2 col 5.
Coelho, Tony. “A sad story, but not typical.” The Washington Post 19 Feb. 1995 p(c)6.
Gomez-Mejia, Luis R., David B. Balkin, Robert L. Cardy. Managing Human Resources. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice Hall, 1995.
Mullins, James A, Jr. “Use a Collaborative approach to reasonable accommodation”. HR Focus Feb. 1994 p16.
Renolds, Larry. “ADA Complaints are not what experts predicted.” HR Focus Nov. 1993 p6.
Smolowe, Jill. “Noble Aims, Mixed Results” Time 31 July 1995.
“Some quick tips to make workspaces more flexible” HR Focus July 1992 p12-14.
Stamps, David “Just how scary is the ADA?” Training June 1995 p93.
“Who are the Disabled?: At work: A controversial law falls down on the job”. News Week 7 Nov. 1994.
Другие работы по теме:
Types of holiday
Holiday is an extended period of recreation, especially spent away from home or travelling. A break from work or a day of festivity or recreation when no work is done is also called the same way.
12 Angry Men Essay Research Paper Vinny
12 Angry Men Essay, Research Paper Vinny Menichetti 12/12/99 English10RS/Mrs.Krause Period 2 Thank you Ladies and Gentlemen for all your time and service. I believe my client is innocent of these charges and you must keep in mind that if you have a reasonable doubt in your mind that this boy is innocent then u must vote not guilty and save his life.
What Changes Have Taken Place In This
Area Around The Lee Valley Essay, Research Paper The Lee Valley Regional Park Authority was set up in 1967 by an act of parliament to develop the areas along the Lee, many
Crime Of Passion Essay Research Paper Picture
Crime Of Passion Essay, Research Paper Picture the scenario,a male supervisor invited a new female employee to lunch to discuss her work. On other occassion, over drinks,he attempted to fondle her. Situations like this occured everyday in the working place, and the term for this is sexual harrassment. Gender issues such as sexual topics.
That Place In Your Mind (What Is
Hell, Related To Dante’s Inf Essay, Research Paper That Place in Your Mind Hell is a place that is created in one’s mind. It is different for each person, depending on what they believe. It can be a never-ending pit, or a room a barren room at the center of the earth, that is super hot. It can be a table with mounds of food, that people are sitting at, but cannot eat the food.
Work And School Essay Research Paper Many
Work And School Essay, Research Paper Many people have busy lives, especially someone who has to juggle more than one task per day. The people in particular that I am talking about are college students. How some
Thomas McGrath
’s Statement To HUAC Essay, Research Paper After a dead serious consideration of the effects of this committee’s work and of my relation to it, I find that for the following reasons I must
Human Resources Essay Research Paper 1 Name
Human Resources Essay, Research Paper 1. Name and explain at least 5 factors that have caused the HRM to act strategically to meet the competitive challenges which companies face.
How To Get Out Of A Speeding
Ticket Essay, Research Paper How to Get Out of a Speeding Ticket There are many approaches that we humans use to weasel out of a speeding ticket. This is not an easy task, but it has been mastered by a select few. The very reasonable way of just not speeding is used quite often. The method of lying is frequently used.
Random Locker Searches Essay Research Paper Opposing
Random Locker Searches Essay, Research Paper Opposing Side- Random Locker Searches The IV amendment states ?The right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures, shall not be violated, and no Warrants shall issue, but upon probable cause…? This means that a person will not have their private property searched or taken without a warrant or probable cause.
Ethics Essay Research Paper Managing ethics in
Ethics Essay, Research Paper Managing ethics in the workplace holds tremendous benefit for leaders and managers, benefits both moral and practical. With the work place becoming more diverse, managers face ethical choices more and more every day. With that they must be prepared to not only answer to it, but also to set the example for their subordinates.
In Law What Are Express And Implied
Terms Essay, Research Paper The first step to answering this question is to define what is meant by “express” and “implied” terms in the context of a contract. A contract contains a number of terms which, in effect, are the obligations of the contract.
Ada And Eeoc Essay Research Paper Issues
Ada And Eeoc Essay, Research Paper Issues with the ADA and EEOC Preemployment screening can help management avoid hiring problem employees. However, employers must carefully walk through the screening process, or they may find themselves in violation of the discrimination laws set by the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA).
Sex And Work Essay Research Paper Sex
Sex And Work Essay, Research Paper Sex and Work Women have made some strides in overcoming harassment and discrimination, but there is still a long way to go. When a corporate meeting is taking place, before the meeting, all the guys will be sitting around telling their little stories, until a woman walks in.
Integrity In The Work Place Essay Research
Paper Integrity In The Workplace Integrity directly relates to the workplace and keeping one’s word. It is important to have integrity in the workplace because without it, there would be little reason for an employer to keep you. Employment is given with the trust that the person being hired will keep their end of the bargain by completing the necessary work they’ve been hired for.
ADA Essay Research Paper The Americans with
ADA Essay, Research Paper The Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) of 1990 The purpose of the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) is to provide equal access and opportunity for the more than forty-three million disabled Americans living in the United States. On July 26, 1990, President Bush signed into law the ADA.
TLO Vs New Jersey Essay Research Paper
TLO vs. New Jersey: When Is The Constitution Invalid? In the case of New Jersey vs. TLO, I rule in favor of the petitioner, the state of New Jersey. In this case, I found no reason in the claims made by
Global Crisis Essay Research Paper In times
Global Crisis Essay, Research Paper In times of global crisis, is it reasonable to expect that nation-states will put aside rivalries and join together to deal with the crisis?
Lava Lamp Paper how To Make Essay
, Research Paper Things you can use to make a Lava Lamp. There are many things you can use to make a Lava Lamp. Aside from wax and water, there are many other substances that you can use to make the lamp work in the same fashion. For example, you can use mineral oil as the lava and 90% isopropyl alcohol mixed with 70% isopropyl alcohol (rubbing alcohol) as the liquid inside the lamp.
Social Work Essay Research Paper Social Workers
Social Work Essay, Research Paper Social Workers in the United States have many roles and needs to fill in society. They are seen as the people that nurse the homeless, unemployed, hunger-stricken, and destitute back to life. It is their choice to help those more unfortunate than themselves, and although it is considered a “job”, it is really a way of life.
Trade Commission Essay Research Paper The Federal
Trade Commission Essay, Research Paper The Federal Trade Commission, in submitting a Request For Public Comment Concerning Guides For The Dog And Cat Food Industry, is asking the American Public to assess guidelines for monitoring the pet food industry that have been in place since 1969. Since the basic thrust of the original guidelines was to control misrepresentation in the industry, it is hard to imagine that the public would disagree with the original intent of the guidelines.
Bartender Essay Research Paper If you want
Bartender Essay, Research Paper If you want to make a lot of money and have fun doing it, then becoming a bartender would be a good choice. The only thing you really need to do to become one, is go to a vocational school. Even then, that can t set you back too far. You would only have to take a couple of classes, then you re in.
Americans With Disabilities Act Essay Research Paper
On July 26, 1990, the Americans with Disabilities Act was signed into law intended to make the American society more accessible to people with disabilities. The general purpose of this legislation is to extend the prohibition against discrimination on the basis of race, sex, religion, and national origin to persons with disabilities.
Paul Cronan Essay Research Paper Paul Cronan
Paul Cronan Essay, Research Paper Paul Cronan Case This case involves a corporate response to AIDS in the workplace. The return to work of Paul Cronan, a person with AIDS, after a much publicized law suit, led to a walkout of his coworkers. This case documents the circumstances which preceded the work stoppage.
Dreams And Realities Essay Research Paper After
Dreams And Realities Essay, Research Paper After I wake up I quickly come to a reality check. Realizing that I will have a white collard job. Working through the ranks from the bottom up to reach a reasonable goal. I will have diplomas and achievements, but I doubt if I will manage a billion dollar company. In my reality working hard is part of every day life.
Drug Testing In The Work Place Essay
, Research Paper In almost every career job, before a new employee is hired, drug testing is administered. However many jobs stop at that point; not believing, or choosing to ignore the fact that employees may be using drugs. Random drug testing in the work place is a good practice. Although people complain that it is a violation of privacy, companies have a business to run and don’t need the responsibility or the hassle of a drug addicted employee.
Accomodation Leads To Destruction Essay Research Paper
Literary Essay In the play King Lear, by William Shakespeare, we see that accommodation leads to the destruction of Lear’s family, of Lear’s physical health and of Lear’s sanity. The play opens with King Lear bestowing three separate dowries to his three daughters. These dowries are divided according to how much each daughter says they love their father.
Public Relations Contigenct Theory Of Accommodation And
Advocacy Essay, Research Paper “Contingency Theory of Accommodation and Advocacy” Contingency theory of accommodation/advocacy is a more realistic depiction of public relation strategies or models based on a continuum. The contingency theory represents the organizations possible stance on a wider range of publics than an individual one fostering rigid and exclusive categorization mostly found in a limited set communication models.
An Analysis Of Hamlet Essay Research Paper
It is reasonable to wonder what Shakespeare had in mind while writing Hamlet. After all, Shakespeare wasn’t a philosopher or historian,or even a literary critic. He was a playwright. He didn’t leave us critical essays examining his work. It is left to us to examine his work and decide for ourselves, if we care to, what Shakespeare was thinking.
Attitude Essay Research Paper Does Attitude Affect
Attitude Essay, Research Paper Does Attitude Affect What Happens? Attitude is more important than facts. Attitude how does it affect people? It affects people by changing their mood. According to Charles Swindell, people are now convinced that life is ten percent of what happens to people and ninety percent of how people react to it (1).
Stress In The Work Place Essay Research
Paper Stress in the Work Place. How to Create a Productive and Healthy Work Environment. Under the author’s perspective, the justification of studying stress in organizations is due to its effect, positive or negative, on the efficiency and vitality of employees and organizations as a whole. Stress is a common denominator in organizations all over the world.
Drugs In The Work Place Essay Research
Paper Drug Addiction in the School and Work Place How has work efficiency changed as a result of drug addiction in the sch a couool and work place? In the 1960 and 1970’s, men and women worked long hours to support their family. For many, these strenuous hours were hard to handle without taking drugs. The use of “uppers” and “downers” was then considered a way to tolerate those long work hours.