Total Quality Management Essay, Research Paper
Does TQM benefit employees?
As with almost all issues surrounding Total Quality Management, there is much confusion in academia as to whether TQM benefits employees. Much of the confusion arises from the difficulty of defining TQM. Academics and practitioners often disagree about the benefits (and even the objectives) of TQM.. Several quality “gurus’” and consulting firms are guilty of pushing a “condense(d) TQM theory” which has been simplified “to an easily imitated formula.” (Steel 17). All agree that with the introduction of TQM, employees tend to have more work. The question of what (or whether) the workers gain from the increased workload and challenge is pivotal to an assessment of TQM practices. Unfortunately, because of the lack of a commonly accepted definition-and the difficulty in measurement of effect-few academicians have focused research efforts in this area.
The theory of TQM is thought to have been a collaboration of the work of Crosby, Deming, Feigenbaum, Ishikawa, and Juran. Stephen Hill and Adrian Wilkinson, authors of “In Search of TQM” argue that there are three fundamental principles of Total Quality Management. The first is “customer orientation”. Much emphasis is placed on fulfilling clearly defined customer requirements. For example, employees are assigned both internal as well as external customers. The second principle is “process orientation.” For instance, work processes are broken down into basic tasks in an effort to reduce variability and improve quality. The final principle is that of “continuous improvement”. The best method for a work process can always be improved. There is emphasis on change identification and execution by the actual worker.
The academic community has focused little on TQM-largely because of the difficulty in assessing the effects of TQM on an organisation. It is difficult to prove that changes in an organisation are the result of the introduction of TQM. That workers are content or that profitability improves may be due to other events-subsequent to the introduction of TQM-such as increase in demand across an industry. “The research literature on TQM effects includes few studies whose designs permit definitive statements to be made about cause and effects.” (Hackman 324) Because of the lack of research there certainly is no definitive answer to the question of whether TQM increases employees’ job satisfaction.
Deming and Ishikawa identified three different sources of worker motivation associated with TQM initiatives. The first is “growing, learning, and developing one’s self.” (Hackman 327) J. Richard Hackman and Ruth Wegman, authors’ of “Total Quality Management: Empirical, Conceptual and Practical Issues”, emphasise that “TQM is pro-learning, with a vengeance.” (Hackman 330) TQM recommends creation of cross-functional quality teams. These teams allow members to encounter a variety of different perspectives which they would otherwise not encounter. TQM also emphasises employees learning new work processes, again helping the employees to grow. As a result, the organisation’s labour force achieves greater flexibility.
The second source of motivation cited by Deming and Ishikawa is “task motivation, the good feeling that comes from accomplishing things and seeing them actually work.” (Ishikawa, 1985; Deming, 1986; cited in Hackman 325) Employees are constantly challenged with TQM, for example to continuously improve work processes. This is clearly seen in the implementation of TQM at Pirelli Cables, examined in a case study written by P. Dawson. The author describes the creation of TQM teams, made up of 6 to 8 shopfloor volunteers and a facilitator. The team were challenged with a problem and given difficult but achievable targets. “Graphs showing efficiency rates are located next to machines undergoing investigation and were seen to provide a source of motivation for TQM teams.” (Dawson 79) The results of the teams appeared to be generally very good, as seen by the many tangible benefits mentioned in the case study.
Deming and Ishikawa also cite “social motivation, the energy that comes from cooperating with others on a shared task and the incentive provided by recognition from others.”(Ishikawa, 1985 and Deming, 1986 cited in Dawson 325-326) TQM stresses the importance of social interaction through its “emphasis on teamwork and cross functional relationships.” (Dawson 326) The employees at Pirelli Cable certainly appear to have benefited from the team projects. Dawson states that “the TQM Groups, in fostering a team spirit and breaking down traditional boundaries, represented the first step towards teamwork on the shopfloor.” (Dawson 79) Dawson praises the subjective benefits at Pirelli Cables, “such as the development of team spirit, commitment and the shopfloor acceptance of change.” (Dawson 80)
Although it certainly appears that TQM inevitably leads to employees doing more, this certainly does not necessarily mean that they are getting less. In fact, employees may enjoy the benefits of the increased workload, such as the challenge and education as well as the improvement of the social cohesiveness of the entire workforce. Jacqueline A-M. Coyle-Shapiro performed a longitudinal study on the impact of a TQM intervention on employee attitudes at a production unit of a U.K. supplier of engineering and electrical components.
employees gain increased satisfaction from working under TQM despite the
potential for TQM to require employees to increase their effort and responsibility
over work related issues. TQM may provide the mechanism to enhance their
(employees’) responsibility and influence on quality and improvement issues,
eliminate obstacles they experience in carrying out their work, and enhance the
feelings of job security. (Coyle-Shapiro, 157)
However, the author also states that the above is clearly not true for all employees.
One employee “benefit”-the use of performance pay in TQM-is controversial. As Elizabeth Morrison points out “rewards play a central role in a majority of organisations that have adopted TQM.” (Morrison 218) Use of rewards is one of the major differences between TQM theory and application. Deming argues strongly against the use of rewards. Research performed by Deci and Ryan (Deci 1985; cited in Morrison 221) suggests that Deming may have been right. Their research showed that external incentives such as performance pay may decrease intrinsic incentive to complete the task. The external incentive might make the employee feel as if he is being “controlled and to contribute their behavior to external pressure rather than intrinsic effort.” (Morrison 221) Therefore performance pay may actually reduce the positive benefits of the increased workload referred to earlier.
Critics of TQM argue that it results in employees doing more and getting less. David M Boje and Robert D Winsor present a scathing attack of every facet of TQM in “The Resurrection of Taylorism: Total Quality Management’s Hidden Agenda.” The authors argue that workers’ tasks are designed by management and meticulously controlled as seen similarly in scientific management.
TQM is extolled for its ability to indoctrinate workers into a rhythm of self-
surveillance and self control under the rubric of “returning control to the
workers.”"(Boje 61)
The authors argue that teamwork is used as a control mechanism. The members of the group apply pressure to other members when mistakes are made. Criticism from another member of the group faces far less opposition than that from management. Teaching employees multiple skills, the authors add, is only done as to eliminate any rest period for the worker, who upon finishing his or her task must now aid slower workers. Also, since absenteeism results in increased work for the group, workers pressure each other to not miss work. The attempt to create a new corporate “quality” culture is management’s “attempt to dominate the whole worker body, mind, soul, and aspirations.” (Boje 67)
Due to the lack of extensive research, any statement as to the benefits of TQM for employees is quite speculative. It is clear that at least in some cases, TQM increases job satisfaction. The criticism of TQM as a “resurrection of Taylorism,” although making a few intelligent arguments, seems rather extreme on the whole. Although it is certainly true that not all employees enjoy the benefits of more work, theory and the little research there is provides good reason to believe that employees are working harder and enjoying greater job satisfaction as well under Total Quality Management.
Другие работы по теме:
Cover Letter Essay Research Paper To whom
Cover Letter Essay, Research Paper To whom it may concern: I am writing to you because I am interest in a Software Engineer position. I heard about your opening through the career department at George Mason University. This position fits with my major, experience, and career interest.
Breakeven Point Essay Research Paper Breakeven is
Breakeven Point Essay, Research Paper Breakeven is the point at which a business is neither making money nor losing money, and managing to cover their costs exactly. This is a businesses main objective from
Management Practices Essay Research Paper 1 Managers
Management Practices Essay, Research Paper 1.) Managers must have great personal skills so that they can effectively communicate goals of the manager to his or her workers. Managers must also be great motivators. If workers are motivated to perform at their best and want to do the best job they can, the results of their work will be better.
Time Management Essay Research Paper Time management
Time Management Essay, Research Paper Time management. It can help you put events in perspective, avoid double or overlapped appointments, prioritize your schedule, and keep you on track. It works for school as well as other parts of your life like work and friends/family.
Curbo Company Essay Research Paper Curbo CompanyRecently
Curbo Company Essay, Research Paper Curbo Company Recently, Curbo Company has received a large sum of money from the estate of a former stockholder. Management is undecided about the most profitable means of investing this money. The Accounting Department has worked with the Engineering and Production Departments, and the Market Research Department is evaluating the alternatives available.
Servqual Essay Research Paper PS1 What is
Servqual Essay, Research Paper PS.1 What is the ServQual model ? PS.2 What are the advantages and disadvantages of the model? PS.3 In what situation can it be used?
Multi Strand Science Essay Research Paper NAME
Multi Strand Science Essay, Research Paper NAME: DUE DATE: YEAR 12 MULTI-STRAND SCIENCE Choose ONE of the following local industries and prepare a resource management case study for that industry.
Education Essay Research Paper One of the
Education Essay, Research Paper One of the greatest problems in American society today is a variation in the quality of education, dependent upon the wealth, or lack thereof, in particular areas. This problem is especially notorious in areas of destitution. Lower standards for the schools in these poorer neighborhoods are another step in the cycle of poverty.
Total Humiliation Essay Research Paper There are
Total Humiliation Essay, Research Paper There are few things in life that are more embarrassing than being the cause of a held up queue. The main reason why this causes shame, lowered eyes, nervousness, sweaty palms and that intense wish that you were someone else, is because of the disdain we hold for people who cause us the delay when we are standing in a queue eager to get on with the next part of out day.
Total Quality Management Essay Research Paper Today
Total Quality Management Essay, Research Paper Today s marketplace is changing at a rapid pace, with new technologies, increased competition, more governmental regulation, a changing workforce and new customer requirements. To survive in the face of these and other challenges, many companies are working hard to reduce costs, downsize, reorganize, and improve service and customer satisfaction.
Case Study Essay Research Paper Twill Enterprises
Case Study Essay, Research Paper Twill Enterprises Limited is a successful printing and packaging company based in Toronto, Ontario. Recently the company has been plagued with many problems. One of the main problems that the company faces is its inability to change the management structure in the midst of growth.
Henry Foyal Essay Research Paper Henry Fayol
Henry Foyal Essay, Research Paper Henry Fayol’s Principal of management Fayol was a key figure in the turn-of-the-century Classical School of management theory. He saw a manager’s job as:
Quality Report Essay Research Paper Main characters
Quality Report Essay, Research Paper Main characters: The main characters are Uncle Beazley the dinosaur, Nate Twitchel the owner of the dinosaur and Doctor Ziemer the scientist. The setting is in Freedom New Hampshire and it is summer there.
American Education Essay Research Paper As far
American Education Essay, Research Paper As far as the world standard goes, American public education is near the top of the ladder. But, when you compare the education here to other first world countries, we fall way short. This is not to say that all public schooling institutions are of poor quality, though, because there are many public schools in America that do provide quality education.
IMPROVING DOCUMENT PRODUCTIVITY Essay Research Paper IMPROVING
IMPROVING DOCUMENT PRODUCTIVITY Essay, Research Paper IMPROVING DOCUMENT PRODUCTIVITY My plan for improving my productivity in producing documents is to focus on time management and on work organization. If you can improve both of these factors, my overall productivity will be significantly higher.
Conflict Management Essay Research Paper In the
Conflict Management Essay, Research Paper In the dictionary conflict is defined as a struggle, a battle, even mutual antagonism. Some people seem to thrive on creating conflict while others do their best to avoid conflict.
Saturn A New Kind Of Car Essay
, Research Paper Saturn: A New Kind of Car Saturn has brought new production and marketing concepts to its business, which helped it achieve the goals and standards set for its cars. During the 70 s GM was experiencing a market decline, this was the main factor in the decision to launch an entirely new line of cars.
Poetry Research Paper Essay Research Paper Poetry
Poetry Research Paper Essay, Research Paper Poetry can both broaden and intesify an experience9…0 it can also illuminate, clarify, and deepen an occurence in a way a reader never considered.9…0poetry communicates expereince by appealing to both the thoughts and feelings of its reader.Poetry demands total response from the individual-all the intellect, senses, emotion, and imaginaTION. (CL)
Unmanaged Heart Essay Research Paper Can a
Unmanaged Heart Essay, Research Paper Can a person?s heart be controlled? Do all people go have some form of emotional management or emotional labor in their lives? In the book, The Managed
Quality Control Essay Research Paper Since quality
Quality Control Essay, Research Paper Since quality control is an important aspect in industry, organizations seek registration under the quality standards set forth by recognized standards organizations for a variety of reasons. The most common motives are to satisfy market expectations or customer requirements, or to develop process consistency and a baseline for benchmarking performance.
Classroom Management Essay Research Paper Philosophy Of
Classroom Management Essay, Research Paper Philosophy Of Classroom Management I believe that a good classroom management system is essential for any teacher who wishes to have a productive learning environment in their classroom. It is my goal to have a well managed classroom. I want to establish a productive working environment that allows student involvement and cooperation in all classroom activities.
Reflection As Revision Essay Research Paper Reflection
Reflection As Revision Essay, Research Paper Reflection as RevisionAll through life I have always been told by people that it’s quality not quantity that matters. I cannot even remember the first time I heard it. If I only had a dollar for every time I was told that. If ever asked for the ultimate clichi, I would have to say quality not quantity.
Recreational Use Of Drugs Essay Research Paper
The Recreational Use of Drugs “Junk yields a basic formula of “evil” virus: “The Algebra of Need”. The face of “evil” is always the face of total need. A dope fiend is a man in total need of dope. Beyond a certain frequency need knows absolutely no limit or control. In the words of total need: “wouldn’t you?” Yes you would.
Tqm Essay Research Paper Incorporating TQM in
Tqm Essay, Research Paper Incorporating TQM in All Activities The personnel in a small company are analogous to the famous “20-mule team” that pulled Borax raw materials out of Death Valley. If a single team member is not doing his or her best, the performance of the entire team is negatively affected. Quality and customer satisfaction is everyone’s job!
Tqm Essay Research Paper Total Quality Management
Tqm Essay, Research Paper Total Quality Management By Jeff Russell A new type of structure is being used in many organizations today. That structure is labeled Total Quality Management (TQM). This approach involves guaranteeing that an organization functions with a commitment to quality and continuous improvement in meeting its consumer’s needs.
Total Quality Management Essay Research Paper I
Total Quality Management Essay, Research Paper I feel it’s important to learn about the subject of total quality management (TQM) when dealing with operations management. Total Quality Management and continuous improvement put tremendous emphasize on the importance of empowering employees within an organization.
Tqm Essay Research Paper The Granddaddy of
Tqm Essay, Research Paper The Granddaddy of Total Quality Management(TQM): Dr. W. Edwards Deming was known as the ?Granddaddy? of total-quality-management. Total Quality Management (TQM) can provide organizations with the incentive for positive change, stirring the workforce and creating an environment that gives a company the competitive edge.
Accounting In The New Millenium Essay Research
Paper Accounting IndustryThe role of accounting in the future looks good. Based on the articles I read, Management Accounting is going to be the wave of future for accounting. Because of new management techniques, accounting has become more vital to the company as a whole. Some of the new ways of management include total quality management (TQM), just-in-time (JIT) production and purchasing methods and activity-based costing.
How To Writing A Research Essay Essay
, Research Paper How To Writing A Research Essay The toughest part of the essay, for me, was taking all the information I had gained and reduce it to a mere few pages essay. After all, quality is better