Am Essay, Research Paper
THE SECOND MEDITATION: I THINK THEREFORE I AM
———————————————
“The first precept was never to accept a thing as true until I knew it as such without a single doubt.”
–Ren? Descartes
Le Discours de la M?thode, I
In the First Meditation, Descartes invites us to think skeptically. He entices us with familiar occasions of error, such as how the size of a distant tower can be mistaken. Next, an even more profound reflection on how dreams and reality are indistinguishable provides suitable justification to abandon all that he previously perceived as being truth. (18, 19) By discarding all familiarity and assumptions, Descartes hopes to eliminate all possible errors in locating new foundations of knowledge. An inescapable consequence of doubting senses and prior beliefs is the introduction of the possibility that God is in fact a malicious deceiver, an all-powerful being capable of confounding the senses. (22)
As the Second Meditation begins, Descartes again faces the “inextricable shadows” brought forth by the previous day’s thoughts. (24) He continues to disregard anything that “admits the least doubt” – including all that is perceived by the senses – since anything that is tainted with doubt might as well be considered totally false. (24) However, once an element of truth is discovered and verified, it can be used as a basis for establishing other elements of truth.
The first element of truth that is known for certain is that nothing can be confidently known. Such a statement has a curious sort of circular nature: how can I know that nothing is certain, if nothing can be known for certain? The answer simply contains itself in the definition. By knowing that there is nothing for certain, Descartes must abandon all that is reported to him by his senses and believed by him in his thoughts (including his body and the conception of the world around him). (24) At this point, Descartes is not prepared to accept that either himself or God exists. He cannot say that God exists, because there remains the possibility that his thoughts are in fact originating from himself (in which case there would be no need for God). Since he has abandoned all notions of existence and certainty, which includes his own body and senses, is it possible that he himself does not exist? To think a thought is bound to existence by definition; one must exist first before having the ability to think. Even if an all-powerful deceiver made it so that I do not exist, it would generate a contradiction since I cannot think that I exists if I don’t. (25) Thinking about existing requires existence as a prerequisite. Descartes has arrived at his first truly tangible and useful element of truth: that it is necessarily true that he exists.
The next task that Descartes must consider is to define what he is, and in doing so be careful not to make assumptions. He cannot consider himself to be an animal, since that would require a definition of what an animal is. Such an examination is beyond the discussion. (25) Instead of making random guesses, Descartes begins to think about what came to mind when he considered what he was. (25, 26) The first thought that occurs to him is that he has a body – something that by definition has a determinable shape, defined location and that can occupy space. However, if an all-powerful deceiver is at work, then that which he perceives as being his body might be something else altogether. Without a body, the attributes that would have naturally followed from it’s definition – that he must be nourished, that he changes position and that he engages in sensory perception – must all be discarded. (27) In a flash of inspiration, Descartes realizes that ‘thinking’ is the quantity that is inseparable from existence. He will exist for as long as he is thinking, and for the duration of his existence, he will remain a thinking thing. Thinking is the ability to doubt, affirm, deign, act on will, and use imagination and sensory perceptions.
When Descartes affirms that he exists, he recognizes that his existence cannot depend on anything that he could “feign in [his] imagination”. (28) The word ‘feign’ is at the root of the potential error; to feign an idea is to invent it. So it is clear that the things that are thought of in the imagination are inherently fictitious. Imagining something tangible (or “corporeal”) is to perceive its “shape or image”. (28) Such images could be dreams, so it is clear that using the imagination to establish truths is a flawed approach. Imagining one’s existence is as useless and flawed as choosing to enter a dream in order to better understand something that was seen in reality.
What is the purpose of this dialog that Descartes is having with himself? It is more then an invitation to philosophical reflection, since he is encouraging his readers to follow along and conduct the arguments with him. Descartes is guiding the reader to discover purely intellectual conceptions of mind, matter and God. The ultimate goal is a true, unpolluted view of the world. In Descartes’ view, the only way to arrive at true conclusions is to begin with premises that are never false. By this method, one starts by accepting nothing as being true – even those things that we would never think of questioning. If one thing can be found to be true, it can be leveraged and used to build a strong foundation for knowledge. In the Second Meditation, Descartes sets out to prove that the pinnacle truth is that he exists. At first, this truth must be disconnected from other perceptions and thoughts, such as those conjured by the senses (his body, and the world around him). The next realization is that his existence is connected to thinking, since thinking cannot be accomplished without existing and vice versa. Therefore he is a thinking thing. Finally, Descartes is careful to point out that even though imagination is an ability granted to him by virtue of the fact that he is capable of thinking, it should not be used to further the investigation at hand. Such abstinence is justified because things perceived in the imagination are likened to things perceived in dreams, and are subject to falsity or malicious tampering by an all-powerful deceiver. All of this sets the stage for subsequent meditations in which Descartes will attempt to prove the existence of God and acquit her of malicious intent.
Bibliography
All page references are to Descartes, Rene, “Excerpts from ‘Meditations’” from Meditations on First Philosophy, Pp. 52-54; 57-67, ? Hachett, 1995.
360
Другие работы по теме:
Ren Descartes Essay Research Paper Prove
Ren Descartes Essay, Research Paper Prove It I dare YOUProve It, I Dare YouFor many years philosophers have disputed argued, dissected and used countless of other devices in order to prove God’s existence. Is there someone or something that has been there since time started? All my life I was raised to believe that God exists.
Martial Arts Essay Research Paper To most
Martial Arts Essay, Research Paper To most martial arts is about the hard-style, external arts such as Karate and Maui Thai. Tai Chi Chuan however, developed out of Taoist ideology and the concept of universal balance. Primarily it was committed to physical fitness and spiritual progress, but over time, the monks needed protection against growing warlords and thugs and so, the external aspect of Tai Chi Chuan evolved and an usual mixture of a healing art, exercise and meditation developed.
Descartes Existence Of God Essay Research Paper
The existence of God has been a question since the idea of God was conceived. Descartes tries to prove Gods existence, to disprove his Evil demon theory, and to show that there is without a doubt something external to ones own existence. He is looking for a definite certainty, a foundation for which he can base all of his beliefs and know for a fact that they are true.
I Felt A Funeral In My Brain
Essay, Research Paper In my opinion, Emily Dickinson as a transcendentalist used her poetry to describe the process of transcendental meditation, particularly the meditation of death. In this poem she tries to allow us to expierience our true nature by entering directly into our conscious. The poem is a deep seeking of the nature of death, the death that is a process of expansion and transformation from solidarity to a spaciousness.
Descartes Essay Research Paper The way Descartes
Descartes Essay, Research Paper The way Descartes chose to write this piece literature captivated me. Descartes was a very intelligent man who wanted to make sense of the world he lived in. The format he used was unusual. It seems to me that he may have used this format, which is a replication of the book of Genesis in the Bible, to have a deeper and more profound impact on the reader.
How Can We Be Certain That Physical
Objects Exist? Essay, Research Paper In his sixth meditation Descartes must return to the doubts he raised in his first one. Here he deals mainly with the mind-body problem and tries to prove whether material things exist with certainty. In this meditation he develops his dualist argument; by making a distinction between mind and body; although he also reveals that the are significantly related.
The Different Views Of The Buddha And
The Mahavira On Reaching Nirvana Essay, Research Paper The Mahavira and the Buddha share the same fundamental beliefs in Karma and dharma, however, their philosophies on how to achieve Nirvana differ greatly. Self denial,
Yoga Essay Research Paper Jen ButlerNovember 191999Yoga
Yoga Essay, Research Paper Jen Butler November 19,1999 Yoga Yoga and HIV When I read the article Strike a Pose , I was pleasantly surprised to find out about all the benefits yoga had to offer. I knew some people practiced yoga to relieve stress or to clear their mind but to actually relieve your body of illness was a shocker.
Yoga And Emotions Essay Research Paper Yoga
Yoga And Emotions Essay, Research Paper Yoga and Emotions Hinduism believes that yoga has many different paths to enlightenment. Jnanic, Bhaktic, Karma, and Raja yoga’s are the different paths. They are different paths, but the Hindus believes that they all lead to the same destination, which is spiritual freedom.
Failure To Succeed Essay Research Paper Success
Failure To Succeed Essay, Research Paper Success at Failing to Succeed at Failing to Succeed at Failure Pay attention! Read, listen and learn from the master. Failure, as an objective, is much like meditation in that is so simple that
John Donne And Death In Poetry Essay
, Research Paper Throughout the writings of John Donne, many different influences were used to get his point across. None of these was used more often than the influence of death. Regardless of the overall subject of a poem, odds are death has been tied in as a theme. Perhaps John Donne s obsession with death comes from the fact that his era was one of aging and decline.
The Paths Of Yoga Essay Research Paper
?Yoga? comes from the Sanskrit verb yui, which means to yoke or unite. It is a ?union of the individual consciousness with the Infinite consciousness? (Fisher, 89). The goal is to unite oneself with God and the practice of yoga is one of the paths that are taken to accomplish that goal. There are four main paths of yoga: Raja is the path of physical and mental control.
Meditation Essay Research Paper By Nick CarrollLet
Meditation Essay, Research Paper By Nick Carroll Let my work benefit all!! Pryor High School Students: You would be really dumb to plagiarize this. It ran in the school paper, so you will definitely be caught! Have fun!
Meditation I Rene Descartes Essay Research Paper
Meditation I In Meditation I, Rene Descartes, talks about beliefs that he believed were true, but were those of falsehood. He also talks about deception and how he is always being deceived in the world. Rene, talks about getting rid of his worries and living peacefully in this article. He does this by justifying some of his beliefs that are false.
Paradise Lost Essay Research Paper Where Connotations
Paradise Lost Essay, Research Paper Where Connotations Serve to Clarify Julнan Marнas, a Spanish philosopher proves to be no exception to the numerous writers attempting to describe California?s effect on both visitors and residents alike almost predictably invoking the idea of paradise in their evaluation.
Descartes Vs Berkeley
03/05/95 Essay, Research Paper In Descartes’ First Meditation, Descartes writes that he has come to the conclusion that many of the opinions he held in his
Descartes Meditations Essay Research Paper Analyze in
Descartes Meditations Essay, Research Paper Analyze in detail Descartes First Meditation and the beginning of the Second Meditation. Do you believe Montaigne could not reply to Descartes and therefore that Descartes has succeeded in defeating skepticism? Descartes First Meditation sought out to offer reasons to doubt everything in order to, after taking doubt into consideration, discover what we of what we believe is true.
Descartes First Meditation Essay Research Paper Descartes
Descartes First Meditation Essay, Research Paper Descartes first meditation, his main objective is to present three skeptical arguments to bring doubt upon what he considers his basic beliefs. Descartes believes this to be an intricate part of his complete epistemological argument. Descartes skeptical arguments are not intended to be a denial of his basic beliefs.
Descartes Sixth Meditation Essay Research Paper In
Descartes Sixth Meditation Essay, Research Paper In the Sixth Meditation, Descartes makes a point that there is a distinction between mind and body. It is in Meditation Two when Descartes believes he has shown the mind to be better known than the body. In Meditation Six, however, he goes on to claim that, as he knows his mind and knows clearly and distinctly that its essence consists purely of thought.
Distinction Between Mind And Body Essay Research
Paper Distinction between Mind and Body In Descartes Meditation VI, he takes on the task of explaining his ideas of the distinction between the mind and body. Descartes claims that they are in fact two separate and distinct things. These ideas initiate many objections from his contemporaries because if their very different beliefs.
Buddha
’s Meditative Position. Essay, Research Paper I feel that Buddha Being in this particular position expresses many things. First, one has to be able to understand what Buddhism represents. Buddhisn is a religion based on the teachings of Siddhartha Gautama, the Buddha or “Enlightened one,” promised to offer an escape from suffering.
Bhagavad Gita Essay Research Paper Nonexistence can
Bhagavad Gita Essay, Research Paper Non-existence can be considered a state of not being. In this sense, the faithful followers of the Bhagavad Gita find ways to reach this state within its chapters. Through advice of the ‘lord’ Krishna, followers use yoga and meditation to obtain a pure karma and self-realization for a better life after reincarnation.
The Bhagavad Gita Essay Research Paper Upon
The Bhagavad Gita Essay, Research Paper Upon the reading of chapters 1-6 of the Great Scripture of Hinduism, The Bhagavad Gita (the Lord s Song ), I am completely and utterly fascinated. The story s emphasis on selfless acts, devotion, and meditation is like no other I have ever encountered before. Through the narration of Sanjaya and the conversation of Sri Krishna (Vishnu incarnate) and Prince Arjuna, the principles of Hinduism are eloquently illustrated.
Paradise Essay Research Paper Where Connotations Serve
Paradise Essay, Research Paper Where Connotations Serve to Clarify Jul an Mar as, a Spanish philosopher proves to be no exception to the numerous writers attempting to describe California s effect on both visitors and residents alike almost predictably invoking the idea of paradise in their evaluation.
Meditation Essay Research Paper MeditationWebster
Meditation Essay, Research Paper Meditation Webster’s dictionary defines meditation as “to reflect on; ponder, to engage in contemplation,” which it really is, although, many people believe that meditation is a
Transdental Meditation Essay Research Paper The Meditation
Transdental Meditation Essay, Research Paper The Meditation exercise that we performed in class was refreshing. It cleared my mind of all stress that day. As I lay on the mat, I had no idea I was that tensed. It was somewhat hard to imagine a flame below my navel. The music in the background was relaxing It was flicking with the flame in my mind.
Meditation Essay Research Paper ctoria DrizinFebruary 2
Meditation Essay, Research Paper ctoria Drizin February 2, 2000 Culture Div. Class Professor Manning My Personal Meditation I was very skeptical and cautious about the lesson on meditation. A few years back I had taken a course on relaxation, which I had found to be only somewhat helpful. I was hoping to find another alternative to calm myself and release the stress.
Buddhist Meditation Essay Research Paper Meditation is
Buddhist Meditation Essay, Research Paper Meditation is very difficult to describe and can only truly be explained once experienced. It is the practice of mental concentration leading ultimately through a sequence of stages to the final goal of spiritual freedom, nirvana. The purpose of Buddhist meditation is to free ourselves from the delusion and thereby put an end to both ignorance and craving.
Meditation Essay Research Paper Meditation is a
Meditation Essay, Research Paper Meditation is a private devotion or mental exercise consisting of a number of techniques of concentration, contemplation, and abstraction to heighten spiritual awareness. It has also been defined as, Consciously directing your attention to alter your state of consciousness.
Descartes Sixth Meditation Essay Research Paper Descartes
Descartes Sixth Meditation Essay, Research Paper Descartes Sixth Meditation In his sixth meditation must return to the doubts he raised in his first meditation. In this last section of his sixth meditation he deals mainly with the mind-body problem; and he tries to prove whether material things exist with certainly.
The Religion Of Jainism Essay Research Paper
The Religion of Jainism Jainism is an Indian religion. This religion has its historical origins in the same region of northern India as Buddhism. Jina or Victor who is the leader of the movement was a “contemporary of the Buddha” (Smart 277). The teachings of Jainism were transmitted orally. The Jain religion split into two sects one being the Digamabaras and the other being the Svetambaras.
Descartes Second Meditation Essay Research Paper Descartes
Descartes Second Meditation Essay, Research Paper Descartes Second Meditation Descartes’s Second Meditation discusses how a “body” can perceive things, such as objects. Perception is vital to his first theory that “[he] thinks, therefore [he] is.” In order to prove his conclusion; he goes through a series of premises, or arguments, that lead him to his final conclusion.