Portia the Control Freak (The-Merchant-of-Venice)
I would love to write a critical essay about the role of Portia in
Shakespeare’s “Merchant of Venice,” hailing her as one of Shakespeare’s
greatest contributions to the society of the sane; however, I find this
impossible after re-reading the text. At first, I hung on her every
word and was amazed at her wit, but later I found her to be just
another Shakespearean psycho. Basically, I understood Portia to be
nothing less than an obedient daughter obeying the whims of her dead,
over-protective father. She speaks in terms of respect about the coffin
ritual, and the reader believes her to be sincere. Later as her character
is unfolded, the reader sees a wife in love with the husband who was wise
enough to earn her love (and consequently her fortune!). Beware, gentle
reader! Do not fall under the spell of Portia the control freak! The
following scenerios must be proof that this woman is not to be trusted!
First of all, let’s evaluate the scene where Portia and Bassanio
are before the caskets where Bassanio must make his choice. The
dialogue directly preceeding the finding of the casket is basic lover’s
speech, but wait! Listen carefully to what Portia says: “If you do
love me, you will find me out” (III ii 41). Portia leads Bassanio to
believe that the choice he makes in the caskets is his own. She leads the
reader to believe that Bassanio’s love for her is the only force which
leads to the discovery of the correct casket. However, earlier when
Portia is speaking of the preparations for the casket choice, she
speaks of music which is to be played while Bassanio makes his choice.
Ok, this seems innocent enough; but examine the song–the first two
lines of the song rhyme with lead! It doesn’t take long for the
subliminal message to be absorbed in Bassanio’s brain, and the lead
casket is chosen. This manipulative device is an indication to me that
Portia has a need to make things go her way. She is afraid that
Bassanio will make the wrong choice, and therefore assists him.
Point #2. Portia creates a way of controlling the future of the
relationship between herself and Bassanio. Portia gives Bassanio
a ring with the words, “I give you this ring, which when you part from,
lose, or give away, / Let it presage the ruin of your love”. Of course,
Bassanio gives away the ring first chance he gets. Portia later makes
known that the man he gave the ring to was her, and she proceeds to
scold Bassanio for his lack of love. Bassanio is trapped! No matter
what he does for the rest of their relationship, in his mind will
remain the idea that Portia is watching! This is a clever device
invented by Mr. Shakespeare; however, it does display a certain
obsessive, manipulative air about Portia. Hmmmmm….
Lastly, I would like to take a venture. I was wondering earlier
while reading the “Merchant of Venice” why Shakespeare used the doppel-
ganger technique in his presentation of Nerissa and Portia. Nerissa
follows Portia about and makes the same decisions Portia does. Nerissa
is not as bright as Portia, and yet she meets the same ultimate fate
as Portia. I am wondering if Shakespeare could have used Nerissa to
point out the manipulative characteristics of Portia. It is true that
one way that manipulative people feed is through weaker people who
uphold them and their values. If anyone has any insight on this
thought, let me know!
Well, there you have it. My true feelings on Portia. Sure she is
to be admired in some aspects, but perhaps as all great archetypes she
has her foibles and faults. If anyone finds anything about the
aforementioned aspects of Portia’s character, please let me know. I have
had not luck finding ANYTHING about Portia on the web. Thanks.
Другие работы по теме:
Shakespeare Merchant Of Venice Essay Research Paper
Portia is Definitely a Man s Name Why must we label some women s jobs while men s aren t? A basketball team needs to be changed to the women s basketball team when women participate. Women operate as the other in society, many being unacknowledged and treated as such. Judging by some of Shakespeare s works, it seems this same social placement existed in his time.
Gun UnControl Essay Research Paper Gun Control
Gun Un-Control Essay, Research Paper Gun Control 1st affirmative speech Anyone who thinks that we have enough gun control laws is either NRA, or severly mistguided. And since I’m probably going to end up getting brushed off in the long run anyway, I’ll get my teams two cents in. There is really no place to begin, so I’ll dive on in head first.
The Merchant Of Venice 3 Essay Research
Paper The Merchant of Venice I believe that S. T. Coleridge’s phrase “representation of men in all ages and all times” applies to this play because I feel that the characters in this play, even the female ones, portray universal elements of the nature of man. One of these elements is honor, which Antonio displays bravely.
Trial Scene Essay Research Paper Shakespeare uses
Trial Scene Essay, Research Paper Shakespeare uses contradictory emotions and beliefs though out the play. He raises many questions about racism and morality. Theses attitudes are relevant to the period the play was written. The play confronts the subject of Christians and Jews. There was great conflict between Christians and Jews, and Shakespeare portrayed this incredibly well thought out his play.
Carrie Essay Research Paper I read the
Carrie Essay, Research Paper I read the book, Carrie. It was about this girl that didn t have very many friends. Her mom was a religious freak and thought that almost every thing was a Sin. Carrie has telekinetic powers. One of the girls that made fun of her started to feel sorry for her and got her boyfriend to go to the prom with Carrie.
The Caskets In The Merchant Of Venice
Essay, Research Paper In Shakespeare?s play The Merchant of Venice, the nature of man is shown on the inscriptions of the caskets. The gold casket represents what men desire, the silver casket
Casket Essay Research Paper The CasketsThe significance
Casket Essay, Research Paper The Caskets The significance of the caskets inscriptions in the play, The Merchant of Venice were that each message on the outside of the caskets left clues to which one is the casket that will win Portia and her fortune. There were three caskets: one filled with gold, one filled with silver, and one filled with lead.
The Concepts Of Peace And Justice In
Shakespeare?S Merchant Of Venice Essay, Research Paper The Concepts of Peace and Justice in Shakespeare?s Merchant of Venice ?If you want peace, work for justice.? Unknown
The Merchant Of Venic 2 Essay Research
Paper THE MERCHANT OF VENICE During The Merchant of Venice, the theme of loss is constantly brought up and just about every character encounters it. This play provides a look at some tragedy with a small amount of “old” humour. When you talk about tragedy ,loss is always included. In the opening scene, Antonio supposedly loses his ships.
Gun Control Essay Research Paper Topic
Gun Control Essay, Research Paper Topic: Gun regulation 1. Do you believe firearms should be banned all together including police and military? 2. Do you believe firearms should be banned from civilians only?
The Sly Side Of Portia Essay Research
Paper The Sly Side of Portia In The Merchant of Venice, Shakespeare presents the theme; looks can be deceiving. This is seen in the character of Portia. She portrays herself as a pleasant person when it comes to Bassanio, but is deceitful and mean when it comes to her suitors. She also disguises herself as Balthazar, a young doctor who is to judge in the courtroom of Shylock and Antonio.
Merchant Of Venice-Portia
& Bassanio’s Indifference To Wealth Essay, Research Paper “How little is the cost I have bestowed in purchasing the semblance of my soul,”(3.5.19-20) is where the heart of this play is in my eyes. Portia doing what she can for her one true love, Bassanio. Money is of no importance to her especially when it comes to the happiness or unhappiness of Bassanio.
Brutus A Tragic Hero Essay Research Paper
Brutus, A Tragic Hero “Not that I loved Caesar less, but that I loved Rome more.” (Shakespeare 3.2.21-24) William Shakespeare s play, The Tragedy of Julius Caesar, is based mainly on the assassination of Julius Caesar. Ironically Brutus, Caesar s loyal friend, who was fashioned by Cassius and the Conspirators, is the one who made the assassination happen.
Merchant Of Venice Essay Research Paper When
Merchant Of Venice Essay, Research Paper When William Shakespeare wrote, The Merchant of Venice, he included a female character that influences the play dramatically. In most of Shakespeare’s plays,
The Merchant Of Venice The Relationship Between
Antonio And Bassanio Essay, Research Paper The Merchant of Venice: The Relationship between Antonio and Bassanio Antonio, the protagonist of the story, is extremely good friends with Bassanio.
Tragic Women Of Shakespeare Juliet Portia Ophelia
, And Cordelia) Essay, Research Paper Women in Shakespeare’s plays were not of importance, compared to the male characters. Though, the women had a minor role in the plays, they played a big role in the lives of others in the play. Some of them will end tragically, or end the same way they started, as nothing.
Women In Julius Ceasar Essay Research Paper
In the theatrical work of Julius Caesar by William Shakespeare, the wives of key characters play a small but extraordinarily significant role. Female characters such as Portia the wife of Brutus, and Calpurnia wife of Julius Caesar, offer readers or viewers insight into the characters of their mates. Each wife shows different aspects of their companion.
Julius Ceasar 3 Essay Research Paper In
Julius Ceasar 3 Essay, Research Paper In Act Two of Julius Caesar, the reader was introduced to the characters of Portia and Calpurnia. They were similar in many ways.
Calpurnia And Portia Essay Research Paper In
Calpurnia And Portia Essay, Research Paper In William Shakespeare s play Julius Caesar Calpurnia and Portia are two women of similar characters. Calpurnia is the wife of Julius Caesar, and Portia is the wife of Brutus. Both women are concerned with their husband s well being and fear for their lives. These two women of similar character show how women of early roman times acted towards their husbands.
Merchants Of Venice Portia Essay Research Paper
Portia: The Best Female Shakespearean Part? Portia is one of Shakespeare?s best parts for an actress as, apart from being one of the central characters within the main plot of the play; she displays great wit and intelligence. These are assets which none of Shakespeare?s other female roles ever had as women who lived around the same time as Shakespeare, were not considered to have such honourable traits.
Merchant Of Venice Portia Essay Research Paper
Portia: Is she the best female Shakespearean part? Portia is one of Shakespeare?s best parts for an actress and within this play she displays great wit and intelligence. Those are traits that no other female character has ever established. Shakespeare wrote The Merchant Of Venice, between 1595 and 1598 and some of the main characters in the play include: Antonio, Portia, Shylock, Bassanio, Lorenzo, Jessica, Gratiano, Nerissa, Launcelot Gobbo and County Palatine.
The Role Of Women In Julius Ceasar
Essay, Research Paper In the play “Julius Caesar” by William Shakespeare, women play an important role. The women are important factors in foreshadowing and in the development of many of the characters. To look at the role of women in the play we must look deeper in to the roles of the only two women in the play; Calpurnia, wife of Caesar, and Portia, wife of Brutus.
Julius Caesars Women Essay Research Paper Portia
Julius Caesar`s Women Essay, Research Paper Portia and Calpurnia are the two main women in the story of Julius Caesar. They had two totally different parts in the story. One was kind of a servant wife and
Portia The Ideal Woman Essay Research Paper
Portia, The Ideal Woman. When one thinks of something ideal one may think of things in their ideal form rather than as they really are. In Shakespeare?s play, The Merchant Of Venice, one of the major themes is appearance verses reality. In the play Portia is portrayed as the ideal woman. In the opening scene, Bassanio describes her as the Golden Fleece.
Why Me Essay Research Paper What was
Why Me? Essay, Research Paper What was I going to do? My mom was going to freak out on me. Oh no! Not my Dad, he is going to kill me. I have no idea what I am going to do? Who is going to be there for me and help me get through all this.
Whats Normal Whats A Freak Essay Research
Paper Whats normal Whats a freak I ask a question, as the title of my paper, in hopes of relaying a point. No one for sure knows what the answers to these questions are. I m sure I don t, but I do have my own judgements as to what the answers may be. I have friends that say they are normal. But, what else would they know.
Gun Control Essay Research Paper Gun EssayShould
Gun Control Essay, Research Paper Gun Essay Should we really just keep adding gun control laws? Well, I don’t think so. I think that Senator Larry E. Craig said it best “the criminal that wasn’t stopped by 20,000 laws won’t stop at 20,001.“ My viewpoint is that we should have better law enforcemnt.
Review The Freak Essay Research Paper
Carol Matas is the award-winning author of many highly acclaimed young adult novels. The Freak is another wonderful book. Her previous stories include, Lisa, Jesper, The Burning Time, Sworn Enemies and her latest book, Telling.
Neat Freak Essay Research Paper Neat freakSarah
Neat Freak Essay, Research Paper Neat freak Sarah and I have been best friends since the sixth grade. During our freshman year of high school I spent about two weeks straight at her house. My mother had gone away and I needed somewhere to stay because my mother didn t trust me at home by myself. It was during those two weeks at Sarah s house I found out her dark secret; My best friend Sarah is a neat-freak!
Freak The Mighty Essay Research Paper Freak
Freak The Mighty Essay, Research Paper Freak the Mighty Freak the Mighty by Rodman Philbrick is about two boys, Kevin a.k.a. ?Freak? and Max. Max is always putting himself down saying, ?I?m a big, dumb, idiot?. Then one day Freak comes along and Max finds fulfillment in him because he is a small, smart ?know-it-all?, the exact opposite of himself.
Analization Of The Song Super Freak Essay
, Research Paper Super Freak or Slut, You Decide. In the song ?Super Freak? written and sung by Rick James, he speaks of an encounter with a woman with whom he had sex. Since this song was written during the sexual revolution and James has confessed to sexual encounters with ?thousands? of women, I believe it was about one particular woman with whom he had a lot of wild and kinky sex.