Essay, Research Paper
FoxMeyer’s Delta Information System
CASE STUDY:
The Failure of a Strategic Information System
Cara Roken
IRM 100
October 23, 2000
In the year1994, FoxMeyer was the fourth largest drug wholesaler in the United States with an annual sales of approximately $5.1 billion. The company filled orders from thousands of pharmaceutical companies with shipments of up to 500,000 items per day. However, in the same year, due to rapid growth and consolidation of the pharmaceutical industry, FoxMeyer’s management was concerned about competition from the larger competitors. The threat imposed required drastic measures. The whole industry competed on low profit margins. Therefore, FoxMeyer decided to stay ahead of the competition by implementing a new information system.
Previously, the Information Technology department consisted of the Unisys mainframe, which was able to track inventory accounts. In addition, the company’s warehouse had out-dated packaging and shipping technology. FoxMeyer believed that by improving information technology, warehousing and customer service, that the competitors could be outpaced by a wide margin. FoxMeyer decided to automate their inventory and delivery process in an attempt to provide better service at a lower price than their competition.
The bulk of the project was changing the warehouse from manual to automated. They implemented bar code readers and bar coded all their products for faster tracking capabilities. Further efficiency was added with the installation of automated conveyor belts. The belts lifted the products and delivered them to docks were they were placed in the appropriate trucks for shipment.
Also, the new information system tremendously supported FoxMeyer by making the business process of tracking sales and inventory easier and faster. First, it automated the order taking process by allowing hospitals to enter their orders directly into FoxMeyer’s inventory computer system. Secondly, the system allowed robots to automatically gather the orders and send them off to the shipping docks for rapid delivery. This was thought to have the most strategic impact to fill the most orders.
The direct computer order entry system facilitated control over their inventory. The information system was designed to pick up eighty percent of all items automatically, as compared with an industry average of thirty-three percent (Bulkeley, 1996) definitely, giving FoxMeyer an advantage of superior service over the competition. The new information system tremendously supported FoxMeyer by making the business process of tracking sales and inventory easier and faster.
Conceptually, FoxMeyer’s information system planned to conduct business with its customers on a daily basis. FoxMeyer focused its value chain on activities in their business where competitive strategies could be best applied. (Porter, 1985) However, the implementation was inconsistent with the changing business environment. The new system caused problems at every step of implementation. Problems ranged from inadequate time allocation for development, testing, debugging, lack of interaction between management, systems personnel, consultants and low user involvement.
Initially, FoxMeyer’s management were supportive and committed appropriate funding of $56 million to develop and install the newly named Delta Information System. However, to build its new 340,000-square-foot warehouse, FoxMeyer spent an additional $18 million. The company hired Anderson Consulting, a leading international information systems consulting firm, both to advise them about the project and to supply skilled personnel to construct the system.
Also, FoxMeyer purchased R/3, an inventory management software system from SAP AG, a giant German software company. Although SAP had been designed to run on Digital Equipment Corporation hardware, FoxMeyer purchased a Hewlett-Packard Company client/server system at a cost of $4.8 million. The vendor for the warehouse system was Pinnacle, a system not tightly integrated with SAP R/3. (Caldwell, 1998)
The software had a reliable reputation and was designed to run on client/server hardware. It also enabled its users to replace their old mainframes. The hardware choice proved to not be an issue, as the software ultimately ran well on the Hewlett-Packard equipment. However, the company had serious problems because client/server software is quite complex and was still relatively new at the time. Some difficulties were expected.
However, once the SAP implementation started, management adopted an out of sight, out of mind attitude towards problems that were encountered. In essence, senior management had no desire to know about the problems. This case is a classic example of management over commitment to a project that should not have been undertaken (Neumann and Sabher, 1996). Even management personnel involved in the implementation were discouraged from criticizing the system.
Furthermore, management failed to understand the complexity and risks involved in the implementation process and even fast tracked the project by three months, prior to having the system fully tested. The system, when first installed, was full of bugs and kept shutting down such critical elements as carousels and conveyors. Also, the scanners often failed to read the bar codes on the boxes. The warehouse opened in August 1995, three months late, and with many of the same bugs still not corrected.
As the system at the new warehouse repeatedly failed during the busiest working hours, the operators had to stop and then restart it. Boxes did not reach their loading position on time. Much of the work had to be done manually with the data being entered into the computer, leading to many errors in the system.
However, the most significant problem was that many orders were shipped with items missing, but with an invoice for a complete order. In most instances, the missing items had arrived at the dock late, due to system problems, and they were then put on a follow-up truck. Customers saw service quality deteriorate, as they did not receive invoiced items when the original shipment arrived. The customers called FoxMeyer’s customer service, which ordered the missing items and shipped the items the following day. Later, the missing items would arrive on trucks.
The result was that when the shipment of missing items ordered by customer service arrived the next day, many customers had received many duplicate items. However, because the SAP inventory system produced accurate bills based only on the order, customers were not billed for the duplicate deliveries. (Caldwell, 1998) The expected result was that many of the customers did not bother reporting the extra deliveries. The enormity of the duplicate orders was not clear until inventory, but the problem led to huge loses to FoxMeyer. The company was forced to announce a $34 million charge to cover the non-collectible losses from customer orders. The fact was that the company did not know to whom the duplicate orders were sent or what was the content of those orders.
The most serious reason why the system was dysfunctional can be seen in FoxMeyer’s management of the project. Their implementation of the project entailed a top-down approach, whereby management, Andersen Consulting and few technical people planned and implemented the project right from the outset. User participation was not solicited and client participation was missing. Few end users participated in the analysis, design and implementation of the system. Therefore, the communication gap that developed between users and system personnel was predictable.
The lack of all departments’ involvement in the project left workers threatened by the implementation of the system, particularly at the warehouse level. The workers had zero input into the automated system. Consequently, workers left for opportunities elsewhere. As the workers left, the company replaced them with temps until the new warehouse opened, but the temps were not able to handle the job and service deteriorated significantly. FoxMeyer was forced to open the new warehouse before the problems were corrected. The result was the crippling of the warehouse inventory management system and ultimately customer service.
The Delta Information System failed because FoxMeyer’s management neglected to understand the complexity of the project. They also did not recognize the risks, timelines, resources and testing in the implementation process. Furthermore, the technological factors related to the lack of understanding and knowledge of the intricacy of the system. The result was a system that was nonfunctional and inadequate.
FoxMeyer’s stock suffered heavily from the automation problems. Their stock, which reached a high of $26 per share in 1994 when the Delta Information System project was announced, dropped to about $3 per share by December of the following year. (Bulkeley, 1996) The company eventually filed for court protection under Chapter 11 of the Federal Bankruptcy law. A spokesperson for FoxMeyer, claimed that “fundamentally, the computer-integration problems we had were a significant factor leading to the bankruptcy filing.” (Madden, 1998)
Later, the McKesson Corporation purchased the FoxMeyer Drug Company. They bought the company at the bargain price of a mere $80 million in cash. Interestingly, it is obvious that the Delta Information System’s technology was capable of functioning as designed, since McKesson Corp made the technology work, including the automation of the warehouse.
In the competitive world of business, changes must be made to stay on top. Often, information technology is the change a company needs to ascend them ahead of the rest. In the case of FoxMeyer’s Delta Information System, the technology was ready and capable; however, the management was defective. FoxMeyer bet its company on the new system and lost.
Bibliography
Resources
1. Bulkeley, W. (1996, November) “When Things Go Wrong” The Wall Street Journal.
2. Caldwell, Bruce. (1998, July) “FoxMeyer Sues Andersen Consulting Over Flawed SAP R/s Implementation” InformationWeek Online.
3. Madden, John. (1998, November) “SAP Dismisses as ‘Unfounded’ a $500 Million Lawsuit Filed by the Trustee of a Bankrupt Drug Company” Philadelphia Business Journal.
4. Neumann and Sabher (1996) “How Information Can Help You Compete” Harvard Business Review.
5. Porter, M. (1985) “Competitive Advantage” New York: Free Press.
6. The SAP Home Page sapinfo/
Другие работы по теме:
External Suppliers Essay Research Paper The US
External Suppliers Essay, Research Paper The US Army Reserve Personnel Center is in need of upgrading its information technology. Currently, the workers are having trouble with their existing mainframe system, and sharing information. Documents must be printed out in order to view formats. Personnel must go the basement for printouts, and AS400 maintenance.
President Bush And The AntiBallistic Missile Treaty
Essay, Research Paper When the Cold War came to a finish in 1972, the Soviet Union and the United States of America knew some sort of action needed to be taken to evade a nuclear war in the future. The U.S. wanted an agreement with the Soviet Union for the limitation of ?strategic offensive arms?. From this dilemma, the Anti-Ballistic Missile (ABM) Treaty was produced, and signed, by both countries to put an end to their aggression towards each other and to limit anti-ballistic missile systems designed to defend against strategic ballistic missiles.
Proposal Essay Research Paper zOverviewImplementation of the
Proposal Essay, Research Paper Overview Implementation of the proposed electronic security system began on Monday, April 10, 2000.This first phase will be completed by the 31st of May 2000 at a cost of approximately 1.8 million Jamaican dollars.
Privacy In The Information Age Essay Research
Paper Privacy in the Information Age: I N T R O D U C T I O N ———————————————————————— The world is changing rapidly. There used to be a time when we could be confident that no one could learn too much about our personal lives. There used to be a time when information was merely a way of keeping records. That time is gone and with it went a large amount of what we might call our personal privacy.
Ornamental Doors Inc Essay Research Paper Ornamental
Ornamental Doors Inc. Essay, Research Paper Ornamental Doors Inc. Summary of Important Facts Ornamental Doors Inc. (ODI) has shown great innovation in the decorative door and window market. Through superior customer relations and an excellent R & D department, ODI has achieved exceptional sales and customer satisfaction.
School Vouchers A Ticket To F Essay
, Research Paper School Vouchers: A ticket to failure How do you solve the problem of failing public schools? The question has been answered many times by teachers, parents and students alike. It seems only logical that those who are a part of a failing school system are the only ones who know the magnitude of the problem and its possible solutions.
A Transactional Communication Analysis- Can Managers Really
Agree? Essay, Research Paper Introduction This paper provides my analysis of an oral presentation using the transactional model of communication. This model is most appropriate to my analysis, as this presentation seeks understanding and agreement of a mid-level management group. The goal of the transaction is to gain buy-in and support of a training program from mid-level managers.
Change Essay Research Paper Change is an
Change Essay, Research Paper Change is an essential requirement for organizational health. Without adequate adaptation to potential future situations, no organization can optimize its future performance and achieve success. Changes are necessary in all systems, processes,
Scripts Essay Research Paper 30
Scripts Essay, Research Paper 3.0 Variables Scripts may contain variables. Variable names must begin with a letter or an underscore (’_'), and may contain any sequence of upper- or lower-case letters, digits, and underscores. You cannot use a reserved word as a variable name. For more information, see the list of reserved words at the end of this document.
The Internet Vs The Library Essay Research
Paper The Internet vs. the Library Overall, when one compares the Internet vs. the Library, the Library is superior. This is because, though it takes a bit longer to use, the Library has a standard information research tool; the Dewey decimal system. This organized system makes finding books simple, and with the added assistance of a librarian, finding information can be easy.
Information Security Essay Research Paper Emerging Opportunities
Information Security Essay, Research Paper Emerging Opportunities and The Internet – Information Security by Margaret Headley “Using encryption on the Internet is the equivalent of arranging an armoured car to deliver credit card information from someone living in a cardboard box to someone living on a park bench.” Gene Spafford, computer security researcher, Purdue University.
The Goal Is Insight Essay Research Paper
The June issue of Strategic Finance Magazine has an interesting article called, “Provide Insight or Face Extinction,” by Noah P. Barsky and Anthony H. Catanach
The Fight Theory And The American Legal
System Essay, Research Paper The aim of the legal profession is to seek out the truth and provide justice for those who were wronged. Lawyers represent clients who are on opposite sides of the case, and who most often have opposite views of the truth. In the legal system there exist two opposing views on the method of uncovering the truth.
Failure In Ethan Frome Essay Research Paper
Failure in Ethan Frome The main theme of the book Ethan Frome is failure. It is shown in three ways throughout the story: Ethan’s marriage, him not being able to stand up to Zeena, and his involvement in the “smash up”.
Assuming No Pollution Explain Why A Road
Is Only An Example Of Market Failure When It Is Congested. Essay, Research Paper Assuming no pollution, explain why a road is only an example of market failure when it is congested.
Domain Name Server Essay Research Paper The
Domain Name Server Essay, Research Paper The Domain System Network software generally needs a 32-bit Internet address in order to open a connection or send a datagram. However users prefer to deal with computer names rather than numbers.
Are Faa Inspections Really Goood Enough Essay
, Research Paper ARE FAA INSPECTIONS REALLY GOOD ENOUGH? One hundred and ten people were killed on board ValueJet s flight 592 May 11, 1996. Federal Aviation Administration s (FAA) failure to correct the problems found in an inspection contributed to this tragic crash (McKenna 59). FAA inspections are contributing to too many deaths on board major airlines.
Memory Essay Research Paper Memory is the
Memory Essay, Research Paper Memory is the process of storing and retrieving information in the brain. Memory is viewed as a three-step process, which include sensory memory, short-term memory, and long-term memory. Along with memory there is also forgetting. There are two types of forgetting, availability and accessibility.
Functions Of Memory Essay Research Paper THE
Functions Of Memory Essay, Research Paper THE FUNCTIONS OF MEMORY Memory is the ability to remember past events, images, ideas, or previously learned information or skills. Memory is also the storage system that allows a person to retain and retrieve previously learned information.
International Nuclear Information System Essay Research Paper
The origins of the International Nuclear Information System (INIS) date to 1966 when consultants from the former USSR and USA outlined a scheme for an international information system. The birth of such a globally oriented nuclear information system, however, was some years in the making.
Geographical Information System Essay Research Paper GIS
Geographical Information System Essay, Research Paper GIS Geographical Information System originated in the 1960s. During the early days of the technology the use was limited to a small group of practicioners. It is a information technology which analizes, stores, and displays both spatial and non-spatial data.
Computer Fundamentals Essay Research Paper The very
Computer Fundamentals Essay, Research Paper The very first operating system used on the earliest IBM PCs was called simply the Disk Operating System, abbreviated DOS. There are few PC users who have not heard of DOS; at one time it was used on pretty much every PC, and it is still around today in many different forms.
Expert Systems In Health Care Essay Research
Paper A case referring to the beneficial use of the expert systems in the health sector was the attempt of the LDS Hospital in Salt Lake city,Utah to build the most complex artificial intelligence system ever created according to the words of DR David Classen.Its name was AIC or Antibiotic Computer Consultant and it was part of HELP(Health Evaluation through Logical Processing), which was LDS s hospital information system.
Metric System Essay Research Paper Metric SystemThe
Metric System Essay, Research Paper Metric System The Metric System, also known as the System Internationale (SI) was developed in France in 1799. The Metric System was created because the French and English were not in agreement politically, therefore the French did not want anything to do with the English including their system of measurements.
Improper Watering Essay Research Paper Background InformationImproper
Improper Watering Essay, Research Paper Background Information Improper watering is probably the greatest reason for failure in the small garden. In the small garden the soil needs to be at field capacity, a state in which the water is equally distributed throughout the soil, otherwise know as equilibrium.
Ms Fields Cookies Essay Research Paper The
Ms Fields Cookies Essay, Research Paper The textbook, Information Technology in Business – Principles, Practices and Opportunities, defines the purpose of information systems as, “An (IT) Information system is a system which data and information flow from one person or department to another.” (Senn, 1998, p.643).
Information Management Essay Research Paper Information Management
Information Management Essay, Research Paper Information Management 1CourseworkQuestion 2 Information Management is the structured organisation of predifined data John Wiley & Sons, NY., 1997 Information refers to data that has meaning Dr. A Taylor & S Farrell, IM in Business Organisations, 1998.
How To Maintain A Computer System Essay
, Research Paper How to Maintain A Computer System Start a notebook that includes information on your system. This notebook should be a single source of information about your entire system, both hardware
Cpu Internal Organisations Essay Research Paper CPU
Cpu Internal Organisations Essay, Research Paper CPU Internal Organisations The input/output (I/O) interface, bus structures, microprocessor, memories and peripherals (also known as external or I/O devices) are the major components of a computer system. These components constantly trade information and instructions to complete assigned operations.
Disaster Recovery Essay Research Paper Windows on
Disaster Recovery Essay, Research Paper Windows on Management – Disaster Recovery in the New Information Age This window talks about some of the benefits of a recovery system for businesses with round the clock electronic commerce. If a disaster happens and these companies don’t have a recovery system, it can cause massive delays and that can lead to loss of business and profits.