? Essay, Research Paper
Article VIII: What Does It Really Mean?
Article VIII states:
? Excessive bail shall not be
required, nor excessive fines imposed,
nor cruel and unusual punishment?
(American Experience, p. 22).
Excessive bail was borrowed with a few slight changes from the English Bill of Rights Act. The concept of bail in both England and in the United States was never thought as right to bail in all cases, but to provide that bail would not be excessive in cases where it is considered legitimate to set bail.
The definition of Bail, as according to the Random House Dictionary of the English Language, property given as surety that a person released from custody will return custody will return at an appointed time. The concept of bail was first created by the Statute of Westminster the First of 1275 A.D., which created a detailed list of certain offenses that were bailable and those that were not. Because judges were permitted to imprison people with or without bail, the Petition of Right was enacted in 1628 A.D. Due to various frauds of petitions for habeas corpus which could not be presented the English Parliament enacted the Habeas Corpus Act of 1679 A.D., which established procedures for the release of prisoners from prison and created penalties for judges who did not comply with the Act. As a result of this, the judges then set bail so high, that it could not be met. With this Parliament responded by including in the Bill of Rights of 1689 A.D. a provision that excessive bail should not be required.
In America excessive fines were given meaning during the early part of the twentieth century. In an early case, the Supreme Court held that it had no authority to revise the sentence of an inferior court, despite the fact that the excessiveness of the fines were quite apparent on the face of the records. With the inability to pay, the poor were then sentenced to jail and thus giving meaning to the term ”excessive fines” as it applied to the person sentenced. During the time the Eighth Amendment was adopted, the Supreme Court noted, that the word ?fine? was understood to mean a payment to a sovereign as punishment for some offense. The Eighth Amendment itself, was clearly adopted in order to place limits on the powers of the government. The Supreme court also decided that the Excessive Fines Clause was intended to limit only those fines directly imposed by, and payable to the government.
One congressional member got into an argument over the true meaning of Cruel and Unusual punishments. He said that ”the import of [the words] being too indefinite,” while another Member said: ”No cruel and unusual punishment is to be inflicted; it is sometimes necessary to hang a man, villains often deserve whipping, and perhaps having their ears cut off; but are we in the future to be prevented from inflicting these punishments because they are cruel? If a more lenient mode of correcting vice and deterring others from the commission of it would be invented, it would be very prudent in the Legislature to adopt it; but until we have some security that this will be done, we ought not to be restrained from making necessary laws by any declaration of this kind” (FindLaw 1). Though it might be clear that a lot of people were concerned with the absence of cruel and unusual punishments from the Bill of Rights.
At first, the Court took a historical outline on interpretation, determining whether or not a punishment was ”cruel and unusual.” They made their decisions by comparing and contrasting to see if and what forms of modern day punishment was considered ”cruel and unusual” as compared to those in 1789. The Amendment therefore stated that the only true way to decide which punishments are cruel and unusual and which are not, is from societies ever evolving standards of decency.
The Eighth Amendment is only relevant to the criminal justice system, and acts as a guideline. It tells all those who work within the criminal justice system of standards and explains what these standards are and what they represent. It states that if and when bail is set in a particular case, it has to be set a reasonable price. This reasonable price in not only for bail, but for fines as well. Not only that, but no person is to be subjected to any sort of cruel and unusual punishment. As far what is considered to be ?cruel and unusual,? this is to be decided by societies ever changing values of what is to be considered proper and improper.
The death penalty has to be one of the most controversial issues surrounding the eighth amendment today. This strict form of punishment has been used throughout the history of the United States. Today many people feel that it is a strict violation of the constitutional concept of cruelty. The campaign against death penalty has been around since the early 1960?s. As a result of this anti-death penalty campaign, the US Supreme Court did their own investigation and study as to whether or not it should be considered as a cruel and unusual punishment. ?…agreed to hear a series of cases directly raising the question of the validity of capital punishment under the cruel and unusual punishments clause, and, to considerable surprise, the Court held in…that the death penalty, at least as administered, did violate the Eighth Amendment…those cases in which a large threat….where the lives of many may have been present as in airplane hijackings, may constitute an exception to the Court?s narrowing of the crimes for which capital punishment may be imposed…a death penalty statute…comes before the courts bearing the presumption of validity which can only be overcome upon a strong showing by those who attack its constitutionality. Whether in fact the death penalty validly serves the permissible functions of retribution and deterrence, the judgments of the state legislatures are that it does, and those judgments are entitled to deference. Therefore, the infliction of death as a punishment for murder is not without justification and is not unconstitutionally severe. Neither is the punishment of death disproportionate to the crime being punished, murder? (FindLaw 2).
To summarize this statement as quoted above, the United States Supreme Court felt that it was their responsibility to reconsider and decide whether or not the death penalty did violate the Eighth Amendment, as being a ?cruel and unusual? punishment. In the end they deiced that the death did violate the Eight Amendment, but in certain cases where the suspect had risked many lives or committed the act of murder, the death penalty is a legitimate means of punishment and could be considered a good deterrent of crimes of that nature.
I completely feel the Eighth Amendment is a good guideline for criminal law, but it needs some improvement. It is my belief that excessive bail and fines are indeed a bad thing, because the poor suffer more than the rich. This is not just in a democratic society. I also feel that we need to update what should be considered cruel and unusual punishment. Our society is living in the fear of being robbed, murdered, kidnapped, etc. Recently there have a large number of crimes where lots of people have been killed and it seems right that these crimes should have a large bail set. But for other less sever crimes, more reasonable bail should be considered.
Bibliography
1) Green, Martin, ed., Core II The American Experience. Acton: Copley Custom Publishing Group, 1998.
2) ?U.S. Constitution: Eighth Amendment: Annotations.? Internet. 3 June 1999. Available: www.FindLaw
Другие работы по теме:
Po Essay Research Paper The article Child
Po Essay, Research Paper The article ?Child abuse ?rewires? brain, produces adult problems?, Marilyn Elias, talks about how child abuse and neglect cause brain damage, that may last throughout your adult life. Elias brings up Martin Teicher?s report, published in the journal Cerebrum, which states that the brain changes due to impact of a trauma.
King Hussein Essay Research Paper Jeffery SheuINTRODUCTIONHi
King Hussein Essay, Research Paper Jeffery Sheu INTRODUCTION Hi, my name is Jeff, my topic is about Jordan and the peace talks, or in other words about King Hussein dying, the fights with Palestinians. I personally chose this theme because it really interests me. I could have done Y2K, the space station, or even the President, but those did not interest me so if I did do it I wouldn t have gotten a good grade.
Men Essay Research Paper Experiment Aims to
Men Essay, Research Paper Experiment Aims to Get Real Men to Go to the Doctor This article from the New York Times explains men not admitting their sick or hurt. The men which were tested in this article men would ignore their aches and pains, mental and physical, until it is too late. I think that it is true that some men are afraid to look ?wimpy? or be called.
The Relationship Between Heredity And Environment Essay
, Research Paper The Relationship between Heredity and Environment February 22, 2000 William Lee People of the world believe that the way you turn out as a person depends on either your inherited genes or the environment around you. In the article, The Wild boy of Aveyron it talks about how a boy was found in the wild, and how he was in isolation from the human race for so long, that he didn t really have any human characteristics.
Artificial Intelligence Essay Research Paper A Critical
Artificial Intelligence Essay, Research Paper A Critical Analysis of “12: Machines Will Be Smarter Than We Are” In today’s rapidly changing world, technology has given us a possible future in the field of Artificial Intelligence. An August, 1999 article entitled “12: Machines Will Be Smarter Than We Are,” explains how Artificial Intelligence is inevitable.
Nature Vs Science Essay Research Paper In
Nature Vs Science Essay, Research Paper In the article The Myth of Beneficent Nature: The Risks of Herbal Preparations , is a persuasive article by Ryan J. Huxtable. In the article Huxtable is arguing that herbal teas and medicines are not healthy and should be band. After reading the article, I disagree with Huxtable, and he was not able to convince me.
Theo Essay Research Paper SummaryThis article shows
Theo Essay, Research Paper Summary This article shows us how Christianity has changed throughout the ages. We can see how Jesus has become the dominant figure in today?s western culture. It tells of how Christianity differed with the teaching of the ancient Romans, and how God wanted us to live our lives. People stopped being afraid of death and their values were changing, becoming much different than those of the Romans.
Journalism Today Essay Research Paper Summary Leads
Journalism Today Essay, Research Paper Summary Leads ( Why are they are effective) The summary lead is the most widely used lead. It provides a brief summary of the facts in the article in the first sentence. Summary leads work best in inverted pyramid stories. I think that summary leads are effective because if the reader has an interest in the subject after reading the short summary at the beginning, then they will read the whole article.
Smoking Essay Research Paper According to these
Smoking Essay, Research Paper According to these 2 article many teens decide to smoke because of peer pressure and looking cool. According to this recent article that was in the Detroit News about an Edsel Ford High School student they asked him why he started smoking and he said he didn t no he just did. All most every article I came across said that Joe Camel was to blame but researchers aren t sure if that s still the case.
Up My Ghan Essay Research Paper protection
Up My Ghan Essay, Research Paper protection because the total revenue did not exceed the variable costs that was incurred in the barial of people that wish to be baried in their cementary. Article #1 Date: November 2, 1999
Human Rights Essay Research Paper Human Rights1
Human Rights Essay, Research Paper Human Rights 1. The UDHR and the United States Bill of Rights do not have as many similarities as one might think, but some do exist. One of these similarities of these two documents is the freedom from torture and inhumane treatment. In the UDHR this freedom can be found in article 5 when it is stated protection is provided against, “torture, under any circumstances.” This coincides with article 8 of the United States Bill of Rights, which states, “excessive bail shall not be required, nor excessive fines imposed, nor cruel and unusual punishments inflicted.” Freedom of religion is also mentioned in both documents.
Reaction Why DonT You Say What You
Mean?? Essay, Research Paper Well, finally got my book, so now I can write reaction papers?.yay! Anyway, I read the article ?Why Don?t You Say What You Mean?? I have to be honest with you, one of the biggest reasons I chose to read this particular article was because it was short. But my, was it interesting.
American Fed Essay Research Paper American federalism
American Fed Essay, Research Paper American federalism is a form of government in which the constitution distributes governmental powers between the national government and the subsidiary governments of the states. Article I, Section 8, and the Tenth Amendment are good examples of this definition. In Article I, Section 8, the Constitution defines the powers delegated to the national government, such as the power to regulate commerce and to enact laws necessary and proper for the execution of its powers.
Driving In India Essay Research Paper Driving
Driving In India Essay, Research Paper Driving in India Traveling in India is an almost hallucinatory mixture of sound and sight. It is frequently heart-rending, sometimes hilarious, mostly exhilarating, always unforgettable – and, when you are on the roads, extremely dangerous.
Adhd Essay Research Paper ADHDUnderstanding the ProblemUnderstanding
Adhd Essay, Research Paper ADHD Understanding the Problem Understanding the Problem | Getting Help | Sustaining Hope This three-part article provides an excellent overview of the current state of knowledge regarding a disorder that is often called the most “over-diagnosed” mental problem–attention deficit hyperactivity disorder or ADHD.
Developing Ways On How To Counsel Children
Essay, Research Paper Developing Ideas on How To Counsel Children Introduction This article identifies several special characteristics of children that require adaptations of adult effective counseling skills. This article also offers modifications of basic skills to make them more applicable to the needs of children.
Op Essay Research Paper Article Critique
Op Essay, Research Paper Article Critique ? New Hotel Project The article talks about the possibilities of making ?One card, For Many Doors?. They are trying to make a room key with an internal credit card. Using a new system guests will be able to check in and issue a room key (double encoded) using their own credit card.
A Fair Chance For The Girls Essay
, Research Paper ?A Fair Chance for the Girls? In this article the author Edward Clarke writes about the harmful effects of education on the sexual development and reproductive capacities of women. While reading this article I was forced to be open minded and accept every aspect of this reading in order to fully understand it.
Fuck You Bitch Essay Research Paper Dear
Fuck You Bitch Essay, Research Paper Dear Anne Landers,This article is in response to the Midwestern Realists article about today s American teenagers. I am 14, and am in 8th grade. It is completely unfair of you to make such a large generalization. I am in advanced math, and am getting pretty good grades in all of my classes.
Article 23 Essay Research Paper Universal Declaration
Article 23 Essay, Research Paper Universal Declaration Of Human Rights ARTICLE 23 -Everyone has the right to work, to free choice of employment, to just and favourable conditions of work and to protection against unemployment-
Tips For Life Essay Research Paper Ryan
Tips For Life Essay, Research Paper Ryan Franzman Period 1 Nov. 3 Ann Landers gives several tips for leading a good life in her newspaper column but are these tips for everyone? Most of the points in the article are actually quite good, most people live by these tips and they don?t even realize it. The article ?Tips for Life? should be read by everyone although it should be made clear that they have the right to rephrase several of the tips to better suit themselves.
Losing Battles Against Drugs Essay Research Paper
LOSING BATTLE AGAINST DRUGS The article, Losing Battle Against Drugs, is true. I agree with the article that the regulation of drugs into America is impossible to manage. You can spend millions and billions of dollars to decrease the drug trafficking but drugs are going to find another way into the country.
Analysis Of A Newspaper Articl Essay Research
Paper 131-81 Analysis of The Union Racket There is an article in the April 24,2000 issue of The Detroit News called The Union Racket . This article explains how the International Brotherhood of Teamsters currently stands with its lawsuit against its former president. Though the essay dose communicate many useful points, is dose a poor job of not meeting the seven failure requirements for any writing as established by Orwell.
Article Review Essay Research Paper REFLECTIONI read
Article Review Essay, Research Paper REFLECTION I read the article “High-Wire ACT,” by Meg Lundstrom featured in the May/June 2000 issue of Scholastic Instructor. In the article, a fourth grade teacher from a New York elementary school explains how her students have been successful in reading class. She says that phonics and literature need to be taught to all students.
Dieting Essay Research Paper The article I
Dieting Essay, Research Paper The article I chose to write about is entitled ?The Lazy Guy?s Guide to Health?; it is foundin the October 1998 issue of Maxim Magazine. The magazine is promoted towards menand mainly covers issues dealing with men?s health. The whole point of the article is to
Bob Grahm Essay Research Paper My article
Bob Grahm Essay, Research Paper My article came from TIME magazine, July 17, 2000. This is a very short article on the Florida state senator, Bob Grahm. The basic issue is, can Bob Grahm be Al Gore?s Vice President? Basically the article talks about his obsessive behavior. Bob Grahm has over 4,000 journals of his daily life for the past 23 years.
Durkheim On Sociology Essay Research Paper To
Durkheim On Sociology Essay, Research Paper To begin his article Durkheim is says that Sociology is in the stage of system-building because the problem is proposes is not clear-cut. What he is saying here is that Sociology is not a fully excepted science at this time because of the uncertainties that possesses.
Article Essay Research Paper EN102018 January 2001The
Article Essay, Research Paper EN1020 18 January 2001 The Article ?British Airways sacks pilots seen drinking before flight?, talks about how pilots abuse the drinking rules set up by the airlines. One of the airlines, British Airways, announced that they had fired two of their pilots because they had been filmed while drinking and they were due to fly the very next day.