Charter Of Rights And Freedoms Essay, Research Paper
BACKGROUND OF THE BILL OF RIGHTS
The United States Bill of Rights came into being as a result of a promise made by the Fathers of Confederation to the states during the struggle for ratification of the Constitution in 1787-88. A great number of the states made as a condition for their ratification, the addition of amendments, which would guarantee citizens protection of their rights against the central government. Thus, we have a rather interesting situation in which the entrenchment of a bill of rights in the American Constitution was done by the virtual demand of the states, they themselves fearing a central government which was not legally constrained and restricted as far as its powers were concerned.
The resulting Bill of Rights is appended to the American Constitution as the first ten amendments. These amendments automatically became an integral part of the original document, making them part of The Supreme Law of the Land. It was then actually entrenched, as the phrase is used in Canadian terminology.
The American Civil War had a very profound effect upon the American Constitution and upon American constitutionalism generally. The Civil war had indeed been fought over a question of states rights, among other things, and the states rights interpretation had actually lost and was, to a degree, a casualty of the wartime period. Further, that casualty was swiftly hammered into its coffin by three amendments which were enacted in 1865, 1868 and 1870 the Thirteenth, Fourteenth and Fifteenth Amendments. The Fourteenth Amendment ultimately became the heart and soul of the modern American Constitution. Most of the legal battle s surrounding the United States Bill of Rights have been to make it a truly national document such that states may not violate its provisions. The Fourteenth Amendment finally made this possible.
A more sudden, but perhaps equally profound event is the adoption in 1982 of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms. Whereas before the adoption of the Charter Canadian legislatures were supreme, having power without limit within their jurisdictions, they now have debatable supremacy within altered jurisdictions. Moreover, although no powers or rights have been explicitly reserved to the people, supporters of the charter nevertheless appear to give Canadians hope that the possibility may exist.
COMPARISON OF BILL OF RIGHTS AND THE CANADIAN CHARTER
Whether the American record has great significance for Canada poses a question which reasonable people may disagree. The entrenchment of rights in the Canadian Constitution comes after long experience with a system of parliamentary supremacy. The American judicial tradition of treating the written constitution as fundamental law cannot have an instant Canadian counterpart. Thus, it does not follow that the Canadian courts will necessarily claim a role comparable to that of courts in the United States, nor is it clear that the representative bodies in Canada would tolerate such a judicial assertion of power. Opposition by government bodies to the Charter have already occurred in Canada, where the Parti Quebecois government of Quebec invoked the notwithstanding the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms clause for the purpose of protecting their language laws from attack under the charter. This report will attempt to note some of the common and distinctive features of the text of the two constitutions as well as to how they differ.
Three major classes of rights are protected by both the Canadian and United States constitutions. Freedom of expression, religion, and assembly are safeguarded in part I section 2 of the Canadian Constitution Act, 1982, and in the First Amendment of the American Constitution. The Legal Rights listed in sections 7-14 of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms, protecting criminal suspects and defendants by various procedural safeguards, are paralleled by American rights to have counsel against double jeopardy, excessive bail, etc., which find expression in the Fourth, Fifth, Sixth and Eighth Amendments. Finally, the drive in modern democracies to provide greater legal protection against discriminatory official policies and actions finds expression in section 15 of the Canadian Charter, which bans discriminatory actions and authorizes affirmative action programs to remedy the injuries of past discrimination. The American equivalent, the equal protection of the laws in the Fourteenth Amendment, has served to justify court decisions outlawing segregated schools, unequal treatment of women, and certain forms of discrimination against aliens and other minorities.
As similar as the Canadian and American constitution may be in regards to their provisions respecting rights, both constitutions include provisions which are unique to their own respective documents. One of the most notable differences in the American Constitution, which has no direct counterpart in the Canadian system, is the right to bear arms, which finds expression in the Second Amendment. In regards to the Canadian Constitution there are at least four provisions which deserve a special comment.
First is section 1 of the Charter, which states a single standard, applicable to all of the rights set out in the Charter, for judging the legitimacy of governmental justifications for limiting rights. United States law has a variety of standards for judging the adequacy of governmental justifications, for limiting constitutional rights, depending on the nature, strength and history of the particular right.
Second is the intelligent avoidance of a problem that has occasioned much debate throughout American history: What is the textual source of the power of judicial review? Section 24 (1) specifically provides that one whose rights are infringed shall have an appropriate judicial remedy. Chief Justice John Marshall derived a comparable authority for American courts from the nature of a written constitution and the doctrine of the separation of powers, since the constitutional text was silent on the issue. Without clear textual support, defenders of the legitimacy of judicial review of acts of Congress (and the president) have had to battle generation after generation with those who assail it as an usurpation.
Third is section 24 (2) where the Canadian framers deal with the exclusionary rule, a frequently invoked American judicial rule penalizing illegal law enforcement practices. This rule was applied after 1914 to federal criminal proceeding and since 1961 to state proceedings. There is a substantial body of opinion to the effect that the rule is not required by the United States Constitution and is simply a judicially created remedy that could be changed by legislation or court decisions. The Canadian provision is a compromise between the common law rule and the exclusionary rule.
Fourth, there is the fascinating puzzle in the Canadian Charter in section 33, the notwithstanding clause. Unlike the Unites States where the doctrine of incorporation ( due process clause of Fourteenth Amendment) made the Bill of Rights a truly national document by prohibiting states from violating its provisions. Section 33 of the Charter allows the federal or provincial governments the power to declare that a statute shall operate notwithstanding sections 2 or 7-15 of the Charter.
As stated earlier, one should bear in mind, that what the American experience has been is not by any means necessarily what the Canadian experience will be. The Charter of Rights is similar, in many respects, but as shown, there are also some potentially important textual differences. Most notably, the notwithstanding clause in section 33 of the Charter, and section 1 of the Charter, which states a single standard, applicable to all rights set out in the Charter. Although the two constitutional documents may be similar in respect to their provisions respecting rights, it would not necessarily follow that claims of violation of rights would receive the same response from the courts of both nations. A proper analysis of why this is so would require a book-length account of the constitutional and political history of Canada and the United States. It would include but would not be limited to the selection and role of judges, the role of legislatures and political leadership, the attitudes and practices of the police and administrative agencies, and, not least, popular attitudes towards rights, minorities, and government. In short, the whole of a people s way of life.
Bibliography
McKercher, William R., ed. The U.S. Bill of Rights and the Canadian Charter of Rights
and Freedoms. Toronto: Ontario Economic Council, 1983
Dumbauld, Edward. The Bill of Rights and What it Means Today Norman: University
Of Oklahoma Press, 1977.
Steven Talos, Michael Liepner and Gregory Dickinson. Understanding The Law
Toronto: McGraw-Hill Ryerson Ltd, 1990.
Black, Charles L. The People and the Court: Judicial Review in a Democracy
New York: Macmillan, 1960.
Другие работы по теме:
Civil Liberties Essay Research Paper Civil LibertiesThe
Civil Liberties Essay, Research Paper Civil Liberties The term civil liberties refers to the “freedoms that individuals enjoy and that governments cannot invade”. These rights include a persons freedom of speech and religion.
Limiting Rights Essay Research Paper Government is
Limiting Rights Essay, Research Paper Government is justifiable in limiting the rights of the people it governs for the welfare of the group, and even themselves (the people). If people has use of their absolute rights, meaning they were allowed to do anything because they have the right to do anything they choose, rights of other people would be infringed on.
Does The Government Control Our Rights Essay
, Research Paper How many rights do you have? You should check, because it might not be as many as you think. Some people are not concerned that the police can execute a search warrant without knocking, set up roadblocks, and interrogate innocent citizens. Nor are they concerned when a drug dealer receives a life sentence for selling a quarter gram of cocaine for $20 (Bailey).
Bill Of Rights And Constitution Essay Research
Paper First of all as for the long quote on the term paper handout, I would have to agree with it due to the fact that it was probably written back in the days and back then this quote would justify many issues and arguments. I agree with the quote due to the fact that there were many criminals back then and harder to control, such as the Ku Klux Klan where they had control over certain things.
Japanese Internment Essay Research Paper One of
Japanese Internment Essay, Research Paper One of the original arguments for adding a Bill of Rights to the United States Constitution was that it was needed to protect individuals and minority groups from a potential ?tyranny of the majority.? Did it work? Well, it depends on your viewpoint. Whether it was the Americans or the African-Americans, the Native Americans, or the Japanese Americans.
Making Adam And Steve A Reality Essay
, Research Paper Bigotry and discrimination are two things that should not be legally permitted in modern society, yet there are laws that permit, if not encourage discrimination against homosexual people. One of these laws is the inability for homosexual couples to be legally married. The simple truth is that homosexuals are religiously married everyday, but they are not entitled to the legal benefits of marriage such as tax breaks and legal inheritances.
Civil Rights Essay Research Paper The Constitution
Civil Rights Essay, Research Paper The Constitution Protects the Civil Rights of Americans but again the Constitution does protect the civil rights of Americans. Even though some laws are passed that violate the civil rights of people in the United States, the Supreme Court corrects these errors. The cases reviewed here ask if it is okay to compose and mandate prayer in schools, whether the death penalty is Constitutional, and how much privacy is given to the American people.
Renaissance Essay Research Paper Throughout history there
Renaissance Essay, Research Paper Throughout history there has always been a struggle for power between absolute rulers and the people and somewhere in the middle they compromise at democracy. In the past the people have written documents to that limited the of the king and obtain their natural rights. The Magna Carta became known as one of the first documents to ever degrade the power of a king.
Human Rights Essay Research Paper Human Rights1
Human Rights Essay, Research Paper Human Rights 1. The UDHR and the United States Bill of Rights do not have as many similarities as one might think, but some do exist. One of these similarities of these two documents is the freedom from torture and inhumane treatment. In the UDHR this freedom can be found in article 5 when it is stated protection is provided against, “torture, under any circumstances.” This coincides with article 8 of the United States Bill of Rights, which states, “excessive bail shall not be required, nor excessive fines imposed, nor cruel and unusual punishments inflicted.” Freedom of religion is also mentioned in both documents.
AntiFederalists Essay Research Paper AntiFederalists were people
Anti-Federalists Essay, Research Paper Anti-Federalists were people who opposed the ratification of the Constitution. They believed strongly that the Constitution would not be able toe maintain a system of republican government because the Federalists were proposing a government that was the opposite of what they believed in.
Right To Attorney Essay Research Paper Winston
Right To Attorney Essay, Research Paper Winston Churchill once said that the true measure of a civilized society is how it treats people accused of crimes. Although the Bill of Rights included a number of protections for people accused of crime, many of these guarantees went unenforced in state courts, which were held to be outside the reach of the federal Bill of Rights.
Gun Control In Ca Essay Research Paper
Firearm regulation has had little effect in decreasing the violence in California. Laws were passed to restrain in the rising percentages of violence. One example of such a law is the Brady Bill. The bill was passed in 1993 and enforced a fifteen-day waiting period for firearm purchases. Due to the passing of gun control laws in the state of California, a lot of controversy has risen because many citizens consider being able to carry a firearm a part of their legal.
Television Censorship Essay Research Paper It is
Television Censorship Essay, Research Paper It is an Unalienable Right Television censorship should not be implied. In the Bill of Rights the first amendment states that we have the ?Freedom of religion, speech, press, assembly, and petition?? (Bill of Rights, 1971). If this country worked so hard in order to gain these rights and preserve them, why would it want to abolish them? The constitution and the United States of America gave people these rights and freedoms so a person should be able to use them as they please.
The First Amendment Essay Research Paper THE
The First Amendment Essay, Research Paper THE FIRST AMENDMENT The Bill of Rights is one the greatest documents ever created. It was purpose was intended to help promote the freedom to think and hold an opinion. As the centuries passed the interpretation of the Bill of Rights, especially the First Amendment, have become blown out of proportion.
Natural Laws Essay Research Paper Natural LawsJohn
Natural Laws Essay, Research Paper Natural Laws John Locke?s piece called Second Treatise Government, was written to express his beliefs on how a government should be established. John Locke was born in 1632 and died in 1704. He was a statesman as well as a philosopher, a political theorist and a main contributor to the Enlightenment period.
Define Democratic Government Essay Research Paper 1
Define Democratic Government Essay, Research Paper 1. Define Democratic Government. Suggest three Democratic inadequacies in Britain today. Democratic government is a political system based on the principles of freedom and equality. Democratic government mental systems embrace multi-party Parliament.
Puritans Essay Research Paper Why Puritans Came
Puritans Essay, Research Paper Why Puritans Came to America: Freedom When the English came to America to escape religious persecution, things commenced at a shaky start. For example, Puritans fled from England
Exploration Essay Research Paper Ratificating the constitutionThe
Exploration Essay, Research Paper Ratificating the constitution The US Constitution was written and ratified in 1787. It is over 200 years old. People think that this document has always been honored, but this is not true. There were many people who supported this Constitution who they were called the Federalists and people who opposed it who were called the Antifederalists.
Civics Questions Essay Research Paper 1
Civics Questions Essay, Research Paper 1. How is government authority in the United States limited? Give one example. The government can not interfere with those rights granted to the people through the Constitution
Bill Of Rights Essay Research Paper The
Bill Of Rights Essay, Research Paper The Bill of Righs was written for the American people for two reasons. The first was to pacify the Anti-Federalist’s fears of an overwhelmingly powerful central government provided by the Constitution and the second was, in fact, to protect the freedoms secured by the Americans after their war for independence.
Bill Of Rights Essay Research Paper
The Declaration of Independence is the document, written by Thomas Jefferson, that separated us from British rule and gave us Americans our freedom. The Bill of Rights is the first
A Bill Becomes A Law Essay Research
Paper When a Senator or a Representative introduces a bill, he or she sends it to the clerk of his or her house, who gives it a number and title. This is the first reading, and the bill is referred to the proper committee.
The Bill Of Rights Essay Research Paper
The Bill of Rights Bill of Rights The first ten amendments to the US constitution are called the Bill of Rights because they provide basic legal protection for individual rights. The
How A Bill Becomes A Law Essay
, Research Paper A delegate or senator has an idea for a bill, usually from a constituent. He or she presents the idea to the Division of Legislative Services and requests that it be drafted into a bill. The bill is signed by the patron, introduced, and printed.
Another BIll Gates Essay Research Paper William
Another BIll Gates Essay, Research Paper William or Bill Gates was born on October 28, 1955. Bill had two sisters and they grew up in Seattle. Their father William H. Gates II is a Seattle
Patrick Henry Fight Against The Constitution Essay
, Research Paper Although Henry refused to serve on the Constitutional Convention, Madison needed Henry’s persuasive ways. Henry had a way to make people agree with his ideas. Even though Henry didn’t serve on the Constitutional Convention, he was still present to put in his word. As soon as the meetings opened, Henry began to argue against the Constitution.
What Is Human Rights Abuse Essay Research
Paper What are Human Rights Abuses? Human Rights Abuses are occurrences where there are violations on an individual’s right to act in a way to make moral decisions. Tis includes violations against an individual’s political rights,worker rights, and freedom of religion,speech, press,peaceful assembly and association.
The Incorporation Doctrine Essay Research Paper The
The Incorporation Doctrine Essay, Research Paper The Incorporation Doctrine The Incorporation Doctrine was devised by the Supreme Court to apply the state rights that are enumerated in the Bill of Rights. This is to ensure that the individual states are not by-passing the Bill of Rights in their decision making process.
Human Rights Essay Research Paper Human RightsThroughout
Human Rights Essay, Research Paper Human Rights Throughout history, people?s human rights have been violated, but efforts have also been made to address the violations, and protect their rights. Human rights are rights as regarded as belonging fundamentally to all persons. Today, everyone is entitled to the same rights.