Essay, Research Paper
Tinker v. Des Moines, Kuhlmieir v. Hazelwood
Scott Nagao 3/10/97 Period 7
About 32 years ago, in December of 1965, a group of adults and students
from Des Moines, Iowa gathered to show their dislike towards American
involvement in the Vietnam War. They decided to wear black armbands and fast on
December 16 and 31 to express there point. When the principals of the Des
Moines School System found out their plans, they decided to suspend anyone who
took part in this type of protest. On December 16 – 17 three Tinker siblings
and several of their friends were suspended for wearing the armbands. All of
them did not return to school until after New Years Day. Acting through their
parents, the Tinkers and some other students went to the Federal District Court,
asking for an injunction to be issued by Iowa. This court refused the idea,
forcing them to take the case to the Supreme Court. After hearing their case,
the Supreme Court agreed with the Tinkers. They said that wearing black
armbands was a silent form of expression and that students do not have to give
up their 1st Amendment rights at school. This landmark Supreme Court case was
known as Tinker v. Des Moines Independent School District.
From the case of Tinker v. Des Moines Ind. School Board obviously came
some conflicting viewpoints about the armbands. The school board said that no
one has the absolute right to freedom of expression, where the Tinkers said that
only banning armbands and not other political symbols was unconstitutional. The
school board said that the armbands were disruptive to the learning environment,
where the Tinkers said they were not. Finally, the school board said that order
in the classroom, where political controversy should be discussed, is entitled
to constitutional protection. The Tinkers believed that the armbands were worn
as the students views, and therefore should be constitutionally protected and
respected by the school. These were all important arguments in the case.
Personally, I agree with the Supreme Court’s decision to uphold the 1st
Amendment rights of the students in school. Why shouldn’t students have the
same rights as other people? If the students wore obscene clothing, ran out of
classrooms, or set the school on fire in protest of the war, then yes, I could
see disciplinary action being taken against them. However, the Tinkers simply
wore black armbands. Because this was not disruptive or obscene, I feel the
school should not have punished them.
Another landmark Supreme Court decision came in 1988 in the case of
Hazelwood School District v. Kuhlmeier. In 1983 the principal of Hazelwood East
High School removed two articles from the school newspaper. He objected to
these articles because they described three students’ experiences with pregnancy
and divorce. He felt that topics such as these would be inappropriate for
student readers. The school board voted in favor of the principal’s action.
Cathy Kuhlmeier and several other students sued the school district in the U.S.
District Court of St. Louis. Despite claiming that their 1st and 14th Amendment
rights had been violated, the Court found no violations. After taking the case
to the United States Court of Appeals, their case was taken to United States
Supreme Court. The Supreme Court, however, also upheld the principal’s actions
finding no violation of their rights. They said that because the newspaper was
run by school officials, that it could be controlled by them, “so long as their
actions?related to legitimate pedagogical concerns?”.
This case also had some arguments to consider. The school district said
that students’ rights are not violated when educators use editorial control for
educational reasons. Kuhlmeier believed that this was unconstitutional. The
school district said that because the paper was not a public forum that
censorship was appropriate. Kuhlmeier believed that the paper was a public
forum, therefore, she should be able to express her opinion to the community.
Finally Hazelwood School District believed that educators were responsible for
controlling school publications because they reflect on the school itself.
Kuhlmeier believed that controlling school publications stifled the students’
free thought and expressions; it limited them to only school-approved subjects
or opinions.
In this case, I agree with Cathy Kuhlmeier. I am not saying that
certain subjects such as obscene and non-school related topics shouldn’t be
censored, because they should. However, in Kuhlmeier’s case, I feel that
pregnancy and divorce are issues that face students at school. Because of this,
I believe that the principal’s actions were wrong, and that the articles should
have been published.
In comparison, both of these cases shared some very similar qualities.
Both cases were composed of a student versus a school district. Both cases
ended up in the Supreme Court. But the biggest similarity was that both cases
concerned students’ rights at school, mainly the 1st and 14th Amendment, the
freedom of expression. Both plaintiffs felt that their rights were being
violated by the decisions and actions made by the school districts.
In contrast, the time periods in which these cases took place were very
different. In the 1960’s, the war in Vietnam was going on, and there were a lot
of controversial issues and viewpoints facing students at schools. In the
1980’s, the war was over and there weren’t as many controversial issues
surrounding students’ rights. One case involved freedom of expression through a
school newspaper, the other through articles of clothing, but the major
difference between the two cases were the decisions made by the U.S. Supreme
Court. They agreed with the Tinkers in the belief that freedom of expression
through armbands was okay. However, they disagreed with Cathy Kuhlmeier’s
belief in freedom of expression through a so-called public forum.
As a student, I believe that freedom of expression is one of our most
important rights. Without this right people won’t know who we are; they won’t
understand our generation. Because of the many different definitions of freedom
of expression, people will always be in controversy over them. Let’s hope that
our school district never faces a problem as big as the ones presented in this
paper.
Другие работы по теме:
School Uniforms Essay Research Paper Did you
School Uniforms Essay, Research Paper Did you know that as many as twenty-five percent of the nation s pubic elementary, middle, and junior high schools have successfully implemented a school uniform policy? (Isaacson, 1998) School uniforms greatly benefit both the students and faculty by creating an atmosphere in which the students are able to get the most out of their educations.
School Uniforms 4 Essay Research Paper School
School Uniforms 4 Essay, Research Paper School Uniforms School uniforms are creeping back into the classroom as a way to bring back a sense of community and promote a better learning environment in schools. Proponents have linked school uniforms to fewer behavior problems and higher academic achievement while also promoting school pride and self-esteem.
School Uniforms Essay Research Paper Uniforms have
School Uniforms Essay, Research Paper Uniforms have existed since the beginning of time. Recently, uniforms have become a pressing issue among public school officials. The requirement of wearing school uniforms in public schools is unconstitutional. Uniforms will not help stop violence in schools, or create a better learning environment.
Elisa
’S Life In “The Chrysanthemums” Essay, Research Paper Elisa’s Life in “The Chrysanthemums” Thesis: In “The Chrysanthemums,” John Steinbeck talks about Elisa’s frustration for her lack of children, appreciation as a woman and realization of her life.
Farewell To The King Essay Research Paper
An Analysis Of Farewell To The King When I first watched Farewell to the King, I simply thought that it was just the story of how an American GI, through a series of unusual circumstances, became the king of Borneo and then was forced to lead his tribe into a war that he no longer wanted any part of. Upon further analysis, it became evident that this was really the story of Nigel Fairborn who comes into the story with a strong sense of British superiority, loyalty to the King of England and the desire to be a successful military leader.
The Yellow Wallpaper And The Chrysanthemums
– Symbols Of Entrapment Essay, Research Paper Talents and dreams, hopes and desires, shunned by the husbands and times of the women in ?The Crysanthemums? and ?The Yellow Wallpaper.? The wife, Elisa, in ?The Crysanthemums?, reflects an internal struggle with herself to find her place in a world of definite gender roles. ?The Yellow Wallpaper? traces the treatment of a woman who descends from depression to madness in the male-imposed psychiatric confinement of her room.
Destruction Of 1St Amendment Rights In Our
Schools Essay, Research Paper Destruction of 1st Amendment Rights In Our SchoolsIn 1787 our forefathers ratified the constitution of the UnitedStates of America, which contains the most important document toany American citizen, the Bill of Rights. The first amendment of theBill of Rights states:Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment ofreligion, or prohibiting the establishment thereof; orabridging the freedom of speech; or of the press; or the right ofthe people peaceably to assemble, and to petition thegovernment for a redress of grievances. these freedoms (commonly called the freedom of expression) are ofthe most important rights in a truly democratic society.
You Might Be A Nerd Essay Research
Paper You Might Be a Computer Nerd if… written by Nosferatu ? Your web page is more popular than you. ? Your favorite sport is Tetris. ? You know what fuzzy logic is.
Tropical Rain Forests
– Physical Factors, Politics Essay, Research Paper Tropical Rain Forests: Physical Factors, Politics and Possible SoltutionsEvery year 11 million hectares of tropical rain forest are lost through commercial and subsidence pressures (Winterbottom and Hazelwood, 1987). The pressures that cause forest clearance varies geographically.
Home Burial Essay Research Paper
Hazelwood 1 Robert Frost?s "Home Burial" is a narrative poem that speaks of life?s tragedies. Frost?s writings style is very straightforward and direct. In "Home Burial the setting appears to be the background of a tragedy that centers around the death of a child. It is important for the reader to recognize that "Home Burial" was written in the early 1900 hundreds.
The Chrysanthemums Essay Research Paper Page 1In
The Chrysanthemums Essay, Research Paper Page 1 In John Steinbeck s story The Chrysanthemums he makes the story very interesting with his usage of setting, local color, and the characterization he uses. Steinbeck wrote The Chrysanthemums as part of a collection of stories in The Long Valley in 1938. Steinbeck who is of Irish and German ancestry was born in Salinas, Monterey County, California.
John SteinbeckS The Chrysanthemums Essay Research Paper
Elisa Allen, Confused? Like many short stories, John Steinbeck’s “The Chrysanthemums” deceives most readers by appearing to be a simple short story. “The Chrysanthemums,” which only occupies about eight pages in textbooks, captures the emotional pain of a woman trying to live in the 1930’s. As critic Stanley Renner wrote, “’The Chrysanthemums’” shows “a strong capable woman kept from personal, social, and sexual fulfillment by the prevailing conception of a woman’s role in a world dominated by men” (Renner 306).
The Chrysanthemums Essay Research Paper Symbolism in
The Chrysanthemums Essay, Research Paper Symbolism in The Chrysanthemums (The Chrysanthemums By John Steinbeck) John Steinbeck gives a different type of symbolism in The Chrysanthemums. Many symbols appear, giving simple meanings and even foreshadowing the story to limited degree. Elisa seems to be content with her garden caring only for the welfare of her plants, with a special regard for the chrysanthemums.
School Uniforms A Cheap Educational Reform Or
Purely Effective? Essay, Research Paper Throughout the history of dress codes in school, many districts have toyed with the issue or whether school uniforms would create a more unified educational environment or perhaps only cause chaos and complaint. As a graduating senior, I do not believe school uniforms will have any effect on the unity or safety of our school, they would only cause problems.
Discripitve Essay Moving Essay Research Paper Moving
(Discripitve Essay) Moving Essay, Research Paper Moving to a Better Life I have had a fortunate life. I have never had to experience the death of an immediate family member, or any violence to deal with. Whenever someone asks me What event has changed your life? I reply, The only event that I can truly say has changed my life is when my family moved to Sioux City, Iowa.
Tech Essay Research Paper Imagine thirty or
Tech Essay, Research Paper Imagine thirty or forty years form now. Biotechnology has really advanced. Scientist can now clone people and also change their DNA strands making them better or perfect all around. Do you think that it is safe to tinker with Mother Nature? Is it wise to try and control Mother Nature? Better yet can she ever be controlled? Whether or not she can be controlled is a big of deal.
Exxonvaldezoilspill Essay Research Paper The Exxon Valdez
Exxon_valdez_oil_spill Essay, Research Paper The Exxon Valdez oil tanker left the Trans Alaska Pipeline terminal at 9:12 PM March 23, 1989. The Exxon Valdez was the companies second newest tanker, it was 987 feet long and was carrying 53,094,510 gallons of crude oil. It’s destination, Long Beach California.
Same Sex Marriages Essay Research Paper SameSex
Same Sex Marriages Essay, Research Paper Same-Sex Marriages ?Alex knows that his family is unusual, to say nothing about his conception. In 1982, a family friend bicycled an oyster jar of his own sperm over to Bonnies’ [Tinker] house. [Bonnie] She administered the insemination herself. Alex [Tinker] considers Bonnie and Sara [Graham] his parents.
Students Rights In The Public School System
Essay, Research Paper Students Rights in the Public School System I chose to do my report on students rights in the public school system. Lisa Rowe, then sixteen a student at Teaneck High School, in New Jersey, thought
Trifles Essay Research Paper Trifles was a
Trifles Essay, Research Paper Trifles was a play based on a real life tragedy. A tragedy in which a man was found strangled in his bed while the wife unknowingly sleeps. The author, Susan Glaspell, was on staff at the Des Moines Daily News when the murdered occurred. The play is said to draw upon a detective s story.
Trifles Essay Research Paper Susan Glaspell was
Trifles Essay, Research Paper Susan Glaspell was born in 1882 in Davenport, Iowa. She graduated from Drake University and worked as a journalist on the staff of the Des Moines Daily News. When her stories began appearing in magazines such as Harper’s and The Ladies’ Home Journal, she gave up the newspaper business.
The Serial Rapist By Hazelwood MS And
? Janet Warren Essay, Research Paper Research Paper #2- Rape Overview Rape, a horrible crime that scars thousands of females each year, it is such a traumatic experiences that it can leave physical and emotional scars for the rest of the victim’s life. “The Serial Rapist” that was written by Robert R Hazelwood, M.S. and Janet Warren, D.S.V. gives us a lot of valuable information to help us understand whom serial rapist, how they act, and how they choose their victims.
Hazelwood History Of Censorship In Education
Essay, Research Paper Hazelwood: History of Censorship in Education Imagine for a moment that everyone in America who favors censorship of one kind or another suddenly got their wish. Imagine they could clap their hands and cause any material that they objected to, for whatever reasons, to disappear . . .
My Analysis Of The Short Story
“The Chrysanthemums” Essay, Research Paper My Analysis of the Short Story: “The Chrysanthemums” The short story “The Chrysanthemums” gives insight into the life of its author. John Steinbeck was born on February 27, 1902, in Salinas, California. The locale of the story is of key resemblance to the Salinas in which Steinbeck was born and bread. “Salinas was a typical American small town, [differing] only in location and a few distinctive features” (McCarthy 3).
Is Implementing Uniforms In School The Right
Thing To Do? Essay, Research Paper The argument whether uniforms should be allowed in school has been debated over the last few decades. By implementing a uniform policy within schools would help reduce the rise of violent crimes. In today’s high schools, too many innocent youths become fatalities due to gang warfare that has spread into the school system.
Sharing Love Not Chrysanthemums Essay Research Paper
Sharing Love, Not Chrysanthemums The effects on Elisa from sharing her plants are not normal, at least compared to an ordinary gardener?s sharing of plants, in Steinbeck?s ?The Chrysanthemums.? Elisa is a sexually frustrated woman who cares for chrysanthemums in order to gain the happiness and stimulation that she doesn?t get from her husband, Henry.
The Chrysanthemums By John Steinbeck Essay Research
Paper In John Steinbeck?s short story The Chrysanthemums a struggle for equality is portrayed through the character Elisa Allen. Elisa is a frustrated woman living in a male dominated society. This theme is introduced to the audience at the beginning of the story. Elisa?s figure is described as ?blocked and heavy? and her home is described as ?hard-swept? and ?hard-polished.? I believe that Elisa is possibly unhappy with her female role, so in turn, she tries to reach out into some masculine areas or activities.
Character Study Of Eliza Henry Essay Research
Paper A Character Study of Eliza Henry Eliza Henry is a talented, strong-willed woman who will not take charge of her own life. In other words, she is a mass of contradictions. On one hand she yearns to leave her prison of a marriage for a more exciting and fulfilling life. On the other, Eliza realizes the limitations pressed upon women and does the best she can to make her situation better.
Oil Spills Essay Research Paper Oil Spills
Oil Spills Essay, Research Paper Oil Spills: It will happen again Imagine that you are a just a small, ordinary seabird. It is March 24, 1987 and far away from you is an enormous tanker called the Exxon Valdez, coming at an astonishing speed. You do not worry, for these huge ships come along very occasionally in the Alaskan waters.
Bethel School Distric Vs Fraser Essay Research
Paper Bethel School District vs. Fraser This case involved a public high school student, Matthew Fraser who gave a speech nominating another student for a student elective office. The speech was given at an assembly during school as a part of a school-sponsored educational program in self-government. While giving the speech, Fraser referred to his candidate in what the school board called “elaborate, graphic, and explicit metaphor.” After his speech, the assistant principal told Fraser that the school considered the speech a violation of the school’s “disruptive-conduct rule.” This prohibited conduct that interfered with the educational process, including obscene, profane language or gestures.
Observations And Views Between Dillard
& Leopold Essay, Research Paper Observations and Views Between Dillard and Leopold Aldo Leopold was born in 1887, died in 1948, in 1949 his book A Sand Country Almanac was published. He was a renowned scientist, scholar, teacher, philosopher, and gifted writer. His book is a collection of his nature writing, lyrical writings, praise for nature, and manifestos for people.
Miller V State Of California Law Brief
Essay, Research Paper The articles that were written in the high school newspaper, Spectrum , were blatant stories of misconduct amongst the students. When a student walks on the school ground their parents