Macbeth by William Shakespeare Year 10 GCSE English Coursework: Media
Compare the two films of Macbeth. How do they differ and in what ways are they similar? Which film do you prefer and why?
William Shakespeare wrote Macbeth the play. Many directors in their own style have interpreted this play. I will be comparing two films played by different directors. Different directors make the two films. The two films are based on the same story but the differences occur in the way each director has interpreted the text. The traditional style of Macbeth was done by Roman Polanski and the modern version was done by Penny Woolcock. The traditional version was made in 1979 and the modern BBC vision was made in 1997. The traditional version was made in Scotland and the modern version was set in Ladywood in Birmingham. The actors used in the traditional version were pretty famous and known but in the modern version ordinary people who have little knowledge of acting play the characters. The traditional version was made for a worldwide audience and to be put on cinema. The modern version was made for the BBC to be put directly on TV for England.
Both films tell a story of Macbeth. Three witches prophecy that he will be King and this leads him to kill Duncan the King of Scotland. He becomes more and more involved in murder and terrible deeds. He arranges for his friend Banquo to be murdered because he is afraid that Banquo s after sons will become Kings. Macbeth goes back to the witches who tell him that “no man of woman born will harm him and until Birnam Wood comes to Dunsinane (his castle) he will not be harmed. Macbeth gets so obsessed with this prophecy that he has Macduff s wife and children murder. Lady Macbeth who encourages Macbeth to kill the King goes mad and dies. Then Macduff comes back to seek revenge for his family and kills Macbeth because Macduff was “from his mother’s womb untimely ripped”.
The two films were set in very different settings. Polanski s Macbeth was set in the open countryside in Scotland and his castle was more like the setting of the play, which made it more traditional, and there were the mountains and woodlands where the whether created an atmosphere. By putting the music on in the background the weather was cloudy and made it look eirie. The witches where more traditional and lived in the moors. Whereas the BBC version is set in the Ladywood flats and local facilities we used as film sets such as the playgrounds and parks. Then made a very good use of outdoors and indoors. In the BBC version there is not much use of dark because most of it is going on in the light unlike the traditional version where they use light and dark wisely to reflect shadows of the wall. The music in the BBC Macbeth was more modern and the women sing the song “I will survive”. This is ironic because both of them die. In the traditional vision the witches music was out of tune and discordant, this is to make it sound more atmospheric and build up tension. In the traditional Macbeth the weapons were more to suit Shakespeare’s time. They used daggers, swords and armor whereas in the modern version they used knives and guns, which suit our time. The settings of these two films differ because Penny Woolcock thought that the greed and power that was wanted by Macbeth exists in modern society through gangsters. So she found the features and based it on a modern society whereas Roman Polanski thought it would only suit in the traditional form of the play. The budget for Roman Polanski would have been much larger than Penny Woolcock s because Penny Woolcock s vision was made to be put straight onto television and not for the big audience. So there were no special effects unlike in the traditional version where the film was for a worldwide audience and so to make it more interesting special effects were used and more money was spent to hire settings and weapons.
The actors in the two films were very different to each other. The two directors had a very large difference in their budget. Polanski had a lot of spending money so he had the money to pay for some big famous actors and actresses but Penny Woolcock the BBC director had a lower budget and so the actors she used were less well-known and many local residents who weren t actors at all. In Polanski s version he chooses actors and with particular looks because they are more effective and look traditional like we would expect them to be instead of more modern like the BBC version. The traditional version used traditional clothes and there were no black actors in it, but in the BBC version they wear modern clothes and there are many black actors. Polanski s version was made in 1971 and their would not to be many black actors in England anyway and also it could be that Polanski wanted it to be very traditional and in the time it was set there would be no black people in Scotland. A modern production would be more likely to have and black actor s part of the community the modern vision was set in and the board also targets anti-racism to the people watching it on television. The witches is also differed in the two versions, in the traditional version they were old women like we would expect them to be with cauldrons. But in the modern vision they were three children, which is very shocking because children are supposed to be innocent and not evil.
Out of the two types of witches I think the traditional ones are more effective because they are more like we would expect them to be found and looked more like witches.
In Polanski s vision Macbeth dies in a sword fight with Macduff who was not born of a mother’s womb. There is a lot of violence and blood, they both get injured but at the end Macbeth s head gets chopped off and waved around on a stick. But in the BBC version he gets shot and dies very quick. Polanski uses a long ending with lots of violence and injuries and can also pay for the special effect when he Macbeth s head is put on a stick this is because it was for cinema they want to put some extra excitement and have a build up to the ending. Whereas the BBC did not have a large budget and so they did not have a long ending because they would not want to introduce too much violence into the film because it was for direct home viewing.
I think Polanski s version of Macbeth was the best because it was more like what we would expect it to be, very traditional and had good special effects. Whereas the BBC’s version was not very exciting and was not really what I would expect it to be. The director had a different view of projecting her image of the story. She felt that the story of Macbeth could be found in modern society and so she was not afraid of putting her views forward.
I also liked Polanski s version because it had good special effects and was more violent and interesting than the BBC s version.
Другие работы по теме:
Macbeth Essay Research Paper MacBeth the protagonist
Macbeth Essay, Research Paper MacBeth, the protagonist, in the play MacBeth by William Shakespeare was a dynamic character. He changed from an admired, loyal, courageous, loved man in the beginning to a tragic, jealous, selfish character in the end. MacBeth is both good and evil, even though he used more evil than good.
Power In Macbeth Essay Research Paper There
Power In Macbeth Essay, Research Paper There are many different types of power which a person may have. Some of the time, however, the person in that power is not the best person to be in that power. This is especially true in William Shakespeare’s Macbeth. Throughout the course of the play, the Three Witches and Lady Macbeth are the people with the most power over Macbeth’s life.
Macbeth And Witches Essay Research Paper Macbeth
Macbeth And Witches Essay, Research Paper Macbeth by William Shakespeare tells the story of how one mans love of power leads him to murder and madness. Macbeth is a great soldier, a man that is fit
Macbeth Essay Research Paper Lady MacBeth hated
Macbeth Essay, Research Paper Lady MacBeth hated Duncan when he came to the land. She hated the fact that he stood a chance of being king over her husband which ment she stood a chance of not being queen. Knowing this,
A Foul Mood Essay Research Paper The
A Foul Mood Essay, Research Paper The first scene in William Shakesphere?s, Macbeth, immediately sets the dark, evil, mood of the play by focusing the readers’ attention to the involvement and suspense of the supernatural. The
ShakespeareS Macbeth Essay Research Paper Illusion versus
Shakespeare?S ?Macbeth? Essay, Research Paper Illusion versus Reality in Shakespeare’s “Macbeth” Throughout the entire text of William Shakespeare’s play, “Macbeth”, there is an evident struggle between reality and illusion. In the very first scene of the play, the Weird Sisters prophesize a future that Macbeth is assured will come true.
Macbeth Character Sketch Essay Research Paper MacbethMacbeth
Macbeth Character Sketch Essay, Research Paper Macbeth Macbeth is the main character in the play. In the beginning of the play he is a nobleman and Scottish general in King Duncan’s army. Macbeth later becomes the Thane of Glamis and Cawdor and King of Scotland. Macbeth is a man who is easily persuaded, brave, good-hearted, and overly-ambitious.
Macbeth Vs Macduff Essay Research Paper Macbeth
Macbeth Vs. Macduff Essay, Research Paper Macbeth vs. Macduff The conflict between Macbeth and Macduff is very important, one which ultimately leads to the demise of Macbeth. Macduff, who at one point is very loyal to Macbeth, becomes Macbeth s adversary as time progresses.
Macbeth Choices Essay Research Paper Choices In
Macbeth- Choices Essay, Research Paper Choices In The Tragedy of Macbeth by William Shakespeare characters often could not escape the consequences of their choices. The choices that some characters made in the play put them in a position which they could not escape. In most of these cases the character feels remorse for the choice they had made.
Macbeth Essay Research Paper Macbeth EssayFrom the
Macbeth Essay, Research Paper Macbeth Essay From the very beginning Macbeth has been a victim of the witches? prophecy and Lady Macbeth?s ambition. With no support he soon succumbed to the pressures of each.
Macbeth Criminals Essay Research Paper Most criminals
Macbeth Criminals Essay, Research Paper Most criminals are influence to the way of crime by some kind of ambition or purpose. Pressure, motives or weakness are examples of ambitions that might turn an ethical person into a criminal. In Macbeth by William Shakespeare, Macbeth formerly a good man falls to the trap of evil as a result of being negatively ambition.
MacbethTragic Hero Essay Research Paper MacbethTragic HeroAs
Macbeth-Tragic Hero Essay, Research Paper Macbeth-Tragic Hero As I finished reading Macbeth by William Shakespeare I realized the true reason that Macbeth is considered a tragic hero. Like all other tragic hero?s he had many good things going for him in his life before he messes with self- destructing things and threw it all away.
My Presentation Of Macbeth Act 3 Scene
4 Essay, Research Paper 10Hn This essay will show my interpretation of Act 3 Scene 4 from Macbeth. This scene is a turning point in the play because we see the first glimpse of Macbeth?s guilty conscience, which becomes the cause of
Macbeth Character Analyse Essay Research Paper Macbeth
Macbeth Character Analyse Essay, Research Paper Macbeth Character analyse In the play Macbeth by William Shakespeare, Macbeth is introduced to us as a hero by clearly defining the courage that he had shown in the defence of Scotland, this is a very significant part in the play because it shows us the reader that Macbeth was not always a follower of his wife’s bidding and the witch’s visions
Imagery In Macbeth Essay Research Paper Imagery
Imagery In Macbeth Essay, Research Paper Imagery plays a very important purpose in the revealing of the character of Macbeth nearthe beginning of the story. It helps to reveal Macbeth as being brave and full of ambitionwhen the captain describes him like Valour s minion ( I, II, 20). This allows theaudience to see, without actually observing, just how brave a man Macbeth really is.
Macbeth By Shakespeare Essay Research Paper Macbeth
Macbeth By Shakespeare Essay, Research Paper Macbeth by William Shakespeare In the play Macbeth by William Shakespeare, Lady Macbeth unconsciously uses Macbeth and others as a shield for guilt. When she wants something but doesn’t have the guts to perform the task herself, she calls upon anyone but herself to do it.
Macbeth Essay Research Paper In the first
Macbeth Essay, Research Paper In the first act of the play, Macbeth, by William Shakespeare, the reader is introduced to the two characters that will play the most significant part in the play’s storyline. Even though they are man and wife, Macbeth and Lady Macbeth have much dissimilarity. One can tell how their personalities differ as the plot moves forward.
Macbeth Essay Research Paper The Downfall of
Macbeth Essay, Research Paper The Downfall of Macbeth Macbeth’s love for Lady Macbeth, in William Shakespeare’s tragedy Macbeth, caused Macbeth to feel the need to prove his manhood, which eventually lead to his downfall. Macbeth was not secure in his manhood, so he felt the need to prove himself to Lady Macbeth.
Macbeth Witches Essay Research Paper Macbeth who
Macbeth Witches Essay, Research Paper Macbeth, who is hailed by the three witches as the ancestor of kings. Macbeth is an intelligent spiritual likeness of a villain-hero who feels his own guilt
Why Macbeth Is Guilty For His Actions
Essay, Research Paper Macbeth, THE REASONS WHY MACBETH IS MORE GUILTY BY HIS ACTIONS THENLADY MACBETH IS BY HERS. – William Shakespeare Macbeth is a very exciting story containing all kinds of plots and murders. The characters that are killing and are planning murders are all very deceiving and treacherous.
Macbeth Downfall Essay Research Paper In Macbeth
Macbeth Downfall Essay, Research Paper In Macbeth there were a few factors that contributed to the degeneration of the Macbeth character. There were three factors that destroyed Macbeth. The main
William ShakespeareS Macbeth Essay Research Paper William
William Shakespeare`S Macbeth Essay, Research Paper William Shakespeare differentiated Macbeth’s and Lady Macbeth’s reactions towards the murder of Duncan in the tragic play Macbeth. The plotting of the homicide, the actual assassination, and the actions after the slaughter demonstrate these responses due to the murder. “First, as I am his kinsman and his subject, / Strong both against the deed; then, his host, / …/ Not bear the knife myself.
Macbeth Essay Essay Research Paper Macbeth
Macbeth Essay Essay, Research Paper Macbeth – Tragic Villain or Victim Of Fate The story of Macbeth, by William Shakespeare, is one of many tragic plays he composed. Macbeth is about a sadistic general that takes a prediction to the limits. In most stories, we root for the good guys…but in this story, get ready to root for the dark side.
Banquo Soliloquy Essay Research Paper John SpitzerEnglishIn
Banquo Soliloquy Essay, Research Paper John Spitzer English In Macbeth, a play by William Shakespeare, Banquo’s soliloquy at the beginning of the third act explains some of his present feeling towards Macbeth. He believes that Macbeth killed to become the King of Scotland. He explains that he is the one who will start a chain of kings, not Macbeth.
Symbolism In Macbeth Essay Research Paper In
Symbolism In Macbeth Essay, Research Paper In William Shakespear’s Macbeth, symbolism is abundantly used in exemplifying the overall theme of murder. There are several prominent forms of this throughout the play. The contrast of light and dark representing good and evil plays a major role in the advancement of events in the play.
Analyzing Shakespear
’s Sonnet 55 And Fletcher’s Licia Essay, Research Paper Many factors can be used to analyze Sonnet 55 by William Shakespear and Licia by Giles Fletcher. Sonnet 55 and Licia share the subject of eternal love. In Sonnet 55, the narrator says that the memory of his love will last through wasteful wars that destroy tangible objects (Shakespear 5).
Macbeath Essay Research Paper Anthony Sears12298Period 2Macbeth
Macbeath Essay, Research Paper Anthony Sears 12-2-98 Period 2 Macbeth Macbeth and Lady Macbeth are two megalomaniacs. Their actions in the first two acts are very childish and selfish. Their lust for power and control over runs their lives and becomes something to die for. Lady Macbeth is very persuasive, and Macbeth will almost follow her very word.
Lady Macbeth Essay Research Paper At the
Lady Macbeth Essay, Research Paper At the start of the play, Lady Macbeth seems to have a very strong character – almost stronger than Macbeth’s – but by the end she is reduced to being afraid of the dark. At the beginning she is Macbeth’s ‘dearest partner of greatness’, but at the end she is his ‘fiend-like queen’.
Macbeth Novel Essay Research Paper Compare and
Macbeth Novel Essay, Research Paper Compare and Contrast: Macbeth and Lady Macbeth Ambition, the world?s driving force to achieve their goals. Ambition is a characteristic of human nature,