The Panama Canal Essay, Research Paper
History of the Panama Canal
In 1825, a group of American businesspeople announced the
formation of a canal building company, with interests in constructing
a canal system across the Isthmus. This project was to take place in
an area now called Panama. The endeavor was filled with controversy.
Though the canal itself was not built until the early 1900’s every
step toward the building and ownership, was saturated with difficulty.
Walter LaFeber illustrates the dilemmas in a historical analysis. In
his work he states five questions that address the significance of the
Panama Canal to United States. This paper will discuss the historical
perspective of the book’s author, address pertinent three questions
and give a critique of LaFeber’s work, The Panama Canal.
For proper historical analysis one must understand the
importance of the Canal. The Panama Canal and the Canal Zone (the
immediate area surrounding the Canal) are important areas used for
trade. Even before the canal was built there were to large ports on
both sides of the Isthmus. Large amounts of cargo passed through the
Isthmus by a railroad that connected the two ports. The most important
cargo was the gold mined in California before the transcontinental
railroad was completed in the United States. It has strategic
significance because of its location, acting as a gateway connecting
the Pacific and Atlantic oceans. This allows for rapid naval
deployment between fleets in either ocean. These two facets make the
Panama Canal very important in the region.
LaFeber notes that Panamanian nationalism played a large role
in the creation of the canal and, consequently, the cause for the
area’s constant instability. The first expression occurred in the late
1800’s with Panamanian struggle for independence from Columbia. The
United States eager to build the canal, and control its operation,
used and backed Panamanian nationalist. During the Roosevelt
administration, not only did the United States manipulate factors
isolating Panama from other world powers through the Monroe Doctrine;
but it committed troops aiding the revolutionaries against another
sovereign state. The reason this is a surprise is because the
Roosevelt administration normally held a position favoring stability.
The United States had no legal right to use force against Columbia.
Nationalism came back to haunt the United States. With the
treaty signed and a 99-year lease given to the United States, the
Canal was built. Since then, the United States has varied on its
stance of ownership and the principles of sovereignty concerning the
Canal. The ever persistent debate of who owns the Canal and who should
have sovereign control over it, has not been solved. The United States
has occasionally attempted to “claim” the Canal zone through various
methods such as military occupation, exclusion of Panamanians for
important jobs in Canal operations and even through the customary
aspect of international law. However, each time the Panamanians have
managed to maintain claim to the Canal despite the United State’s
imperialistic posturing to get it.
The most recent and notorious of the United States’ attempts
to annex the Canal Zone was during the Reagan administration.
President Reagan said that the Canal Zone could be equated as a
sovereign territory equal to that of Alaska. The question here is, was
he correct? LaFeber points out that, “the United States does not own
the Zone or enjoy all sovereign rights in it.” He uses the treaty of
1936 in Article III that states, “The Canal Zone is the territory of
the Republic of Panama under the jurisdiction of the United States.”
The entire topic was summed up neatly by Ellsworth Bunker, a
negotiator in the region, when he said, “We bought Louisiana; we
bought Alaska. In Panama we bought not territory, but rights.” A
second important question, is the Canal a vital interest to the United
States? LaFeber gives three points suggesting that it is not. First,
the importance of the Canal decreased after 1974, because of the end
of the Vietnam War and all related military traffic ceased. Second, is
the age of the antique machinery dating back to 1914. Inevitably the
machinery will need to be replaced. Lastly, the size of the new
tankers and cargo ships. The capacity of the canal is too small to
handle such a large amount of tonnage. These are viable factors;
however, the first argument is concerning whether a war is taking
place. It is circumstantial in providing a solid reason for increased
traffic through the Zone. This can easily change through and emergence
of a new conflict or trading habits of other countries.
Thirdly, why have the Panamanians insisted on assuming total
control of the Canal. The Panamanians are making millions of dollars
annually and the United States run the Canal efficiently. LaFeber
points in the direction of economics as the principal factor and
nationalism as secondary. The Panamanians fear the amount of reliance
they have on U.S. investments. The fear is enhanced by the large
dependence of their national economy on MNC’s, American banks and
mining companies. LaFeber continues saying that Panamanians find it
difficult to cross the Zone because of check points and resent their
country being split in half. Continuing he asserts that perhaps if the
Panamanians were to have complete control the Zone the amount of
revenue would increase. Panamanians could also develop spinoff
industries such as drydocks and ship building creating an increase in
profits. Walter LaFeber develops a persuasive argument for the
interpretation of historical events surrounding the creation of the
Panama Canal. As is consistent with other LaFeber’s works, his
research and fact finding technique in The Panama Canal is complete if
not exhaustive. He presents an objective outlook on issues surrounding
the Canal. He uses a historical approach in presenting his
contribution to a subject that is lacking in information and scholarly
examination. In conclusion, this paper has addressed the historical
perspective that the author of the book used. A discussion also
included three important questions concerning the Canal, its
importance and the relationship between the United States and Panama.
Furthermore, this paper examines the effectiveness and usefulness of
LaFeber’s, The Panama Canal.
world book encyclopedia
Другие работы по теме:
Art History Essay Research Paper M
Art History Essay, Research Paper ?M & M ? s? When I entered in the gym, the outside morning quiet, softly blowing breeze stopped and the screams of go Phillips was
Panama Canal Treaties Essay Research Paper I
Panama Canal Treaties Essay, Research Paper I here by hand my report copy rights to Cheat House!, Phillip Mayhew The Hay-Pauncefote Treaty The Hay-Pauncefote treaty was an agreement, in 1901, between Great Britain and the United States of America. This agreement provided construction and also regulation of a canal across the Isthmus of Panama.
US Intervention In Panama Essay Research Paper
The U.S. has caused a lot of problems in Central American countries using intervention. One of the United States? biggest problems is with interfering in other nations business. The United States has intervened with many countries when they were in trouble. Such countries as Panama, Vietnam and Iraq have all been messed up by the United States.
A Trip To Panama City Essay Research
Paper A Trip To Panama City Day 1: We arrived at Omar Torrijos airport via American Airlines early in the afternoon. We purchased our required tourist cards (3 balboas, as US dollars are
Politics Of The Panama Canal Essay Research
Paper During the Spanish-American War the warship Oregon was summoned from the West Coast. The trip took two months to travel 14,000 miles around Cape Horn to the Atlantic. (The American Journey 741) How was the United States supposed to defend it shores if it took ships that long to get between them? The United State had to build a canal through Central America; national security depended on it.
American Imperialism Essay Research Paper The United
American Imperialism Essay, Research Paper The United States became an imperialist nation at the end of the 19th century because Americans wanted to expand over seas with their belief in manifest destiny. The three factors that started American imperialism were political and military competition including the creation of a strong naval force, economic competition among industrial nations and a belief in the racial and cultural superiority of people of Anglo-Saxon decent.
Panama Canal 2 Essay Research Paper Part
Panama Canal 2 Essay, Research Paper Part of Teddy Roosevelt s dream of making America a global power was realized through the construction of the Panama Canal. The French began construction in 1880 but nine years and about 20,000 lives later they realized their plans were flawed and abandoned the project.
Suez Canal Essay Research Paper The Suez
Suez Canal Essay, Research Paper The Suez Canal The Suez Canal is an achievement that man has made and a great help through the entire world. This is one of many difficult tasks that man has done and completed.
Imperialism Essay Research Paper US IMPERIALISM AROUND
Imperialism Essay, Research Paper U.S. IMPERIALISM AROUND THE WORLD ESSAY Imperialism, the process of building empires by controlling the politics and the economics in other countries, was in full effect around the 19th century. Most world powers were using the idea of imperialism; particularly the United States.
Foreign Policy Issues And War Essay Research
Paper Foreign Policy Issues and War Throughout the era of 1900 to 1950, the United States underwent many changes in every aspect of the nation. Two of the main areas dealt with were the U.S. foreign policy issues and war. In this timeframe, the U.S. partook in many actions with or against another country. In this paper, I will show that the United States, throughout this era, played peacekeeper.
Theodore Roosevelt Essay Research Paper Theodore Roosevelt
Theodore Roosevelt Essay, Research Paper Theodore Roosevelt was one of the most successful presidents in the United States history. He achieved many goals in life. Some of these goals were as follows: 1) He won the Spanish-American War; 2) He won the Nobel Peace Prize; 3) He was the youngest president in United States history.
Panama Essay Research Paper Spanish 111
Panama Essay, Research Paper Spanish 111 March 26, 1999 Panama The Republic of Panama is located in Central America between North and South America. Its position between two continents and separating two oceans has had a major part in Panama s history to the present day. Covered with large areas of rain forest, Panama has two long coastlines with numerous islands and bays.
Teddy Roosevelt And The Panama Canal Essay
, Research Paper Teddy Roosevelt was a man who liked to creat a stir wherever he went. He loved mingling with people to boost his own self-image.He loved to impress people with his cowboyism, his collection of guns, and his pintsize spectacles.Also, Roosevelt was a direct-actionist.He wanted to keep the country moving foward and preserve his public image at the same time.
America The Great Essay Research Paper America
America The Great Essay, Research Paper America the Great ? After the Spanish-American War, America became a super power of the world. That title has stuck since then. However, different political leaders have caused this country to become unworthy of such a title. Most of these leaders were democrats, such as JFK and Bill Clinton.
Panama Canal Essay Research Paper The history
Panama Canal Essay, Research Paper The history of the Panama Canal begins in the 1880 s when the Clayton-Bulwer treaty was signed on April 19,1880. This treaty between the United States and Great Britain stated that neither country could excavate in the Colombian area. At the time prospecting for Colombian oil was the key issue.
Invasion Of Panama Essay Research Paper Invasion
Invasion Of Panama Essay, Research Paper Invasion of Panama The U.S. invasion of Panama on December 20, 1989 was a mark of excellence on the behalf of the U.S. armed forces ability to effectively use the principles of war. The years leading up to the invasion set the climate for conflict; drug trafficking became a major problem between Panama and the U.S. in the 1980’s, as well as Manuel Noriega’s interference with the Panama canal employees rights under the Panama Canal Treaty; the final action that sparked the invasion was Noriega’s attempt to fix the national election and the military enforcement of the fix after the election.
Panama Deception Essay Research Paper Panama DeceptionWhat
Panama Deception Essay, Research Paper Panama Deception What can I say about the Panama deception that has not already been said it is obvious that this is just another part of US’s great plan to take over the world. I am sick and tired about all the false hope it has given its citizen as well as the rest of the world.
Jimmy Carter Essay Research Paper Jimmy CarterEconomy
Jimmy Carter Essay, Research Paper Jimmy Carter Economy can always make or break a president. President Jimmy Carter?s was a Democrat whose administration, that lasted from 1977-1981, was burdened with a recessive economy from the beginning. Inflation was rising rapidly due to the worst oil embargo United States history has ever witnessed.
US Expansionism Essay Research Paper
Through the course of history, many of the nations in the world expanded internationally through imperialism. These nations were creating empires throughout the world. The United States of America for example, during the late 19th century and into the early 20th century began to expand out into the world.
Nicaragua Essay Research Paper Caroline Bucherfinal paperHumanitarian
Nicaragua Essay, Research Paper Caroline Bucher final paper Humanitarian Aid. Playing the wrong role in the right game For the United States the Human Rights position in Latin America is based on image. History has taught us that as in any game, the United States also plays by their priorities, this meaning that depending on time, decisions change from ?good? to ?gains?.
Panama Canal 2 Essay Research Paper Intro
Panama Canal 2 Essay, Research Paper Intro In the 16th century, Europeans dreamed of building a ship canal across the Isthmus of Panama. Spanish kings considered building a canal to carry treasure from their South American colonies back to Spain, but no attempt was made. Such a project only became possible in the 19th century, with the machinery and knowledge produced during the Industrial Revolution, the transition from an agricultural to a mechanized economy.
The Panama Canal Essay Research Paper The
The Panama Canal Essay, Research Paper The shortest distance between the Atlantic and Pacific Oceans is the tiny Isthmus of Panama which joins Central and South America. The dreams of building a
Annexation Essay Research Paper In the early
Annexation Essay, Research Paper In the early 1900 s the U.S. made some very important choices. The U.S. acquired many territories in this time period. America annexed Hawaii, the Philippines, and Puerto Rico. The United States also intervened in the Cuban War of Independence and gained the control to open and maintain the Panama Canal.
Canal Building Before 1840 Essay Research Paper
Canal Building before 1840: Essay Throughout history, there has been a need for better mode of transportation in order to keep up with economical growth. Canals have been around since the Ancient
America In The 20Th Century Essay Research
Paper The Spanish-American War led America into the modern era. When President Teddy Roosevelt left the White House to lead the charge on San Juan Hill, it was a dramatic moment. The Spanish American War victory gave America possession of Cuba, the Philippines, Panama and the Virgin Islands. Once in control of Panama, the Americans began to build their canal.
Panama Canal Essay Research Paper Very few
Panama Canal Essay, Research Paper Very few human endeavors have ever conceded to change the face of the planet on which we live as did the successful completion of the interoceanic Panama Canal in 1914 by the United States. Such projects before this time had only managed to build up or tear down existing geographical features – the pyramids of Egypt, the Great Wall of China, the trans-continental railroads – but none had ever even aspired to accomplish something so incredulous as splitting the continents.
The History Of The Panama Canal Essay
, Research Paper The Panama Canal has been called the big ditch, the bridge between two continents, and the greatest shortcut in the world. When it was finally finished in 1914, the 51-mile waterway cut off over 7,900 miles of the distance between New York and San Francisco, and changed the face of the industrialized world (”Panama Canal”).
Panama Essay Research Paper The Panama CanalThe
Panama Essay, Research Paper The Panama Canal The history of the Panama Canal goes back to the 16th century. After realizing the riches of Peru, Ecuador, and Asia, and realizing how long it took the gold to reach
Panama Canal Essay Research Paper PANAMA CANAL
Panama Canal Essay, Research Paper PANAMA CANAL The canal is joining the Atlantic and Pacific oceans. It runs from Cristobal on lemon bay, a part of the Caribbean sea, to Balboa, on the Gulf of Panama. The canal is slightly more than 64 km long, not including the dredged approach channels at either end. The minimum depth is 12.5 m, and the minimum width is 91.5 m.
Railroads In Chicago Essay Research Paper James
Railroads In Chicago Essay, Research Paper James Little Explore Mid-Term # 4 There is one reason Chicago is as big as it is today and that is the fact that it is the largest rail city in the world. The railroad made Chicago what it is today, and although the canal was very important in the history of Chicago the railroads importance out weighs it by far.
Panama Canal 3 Essay Research Paper Panama
Panama Canal 3 Essay, Research Paper Panama Canal It didn t take long for the world to realize that Panama is the narrowest strip of land between the Atlantic and Pacific oceans. From the early sixteenth century, explorers, conquerors, treasure seekers, settlers, the military and engineers have descended on Panama to find a route that would join the two oceans.