The Nuclear Power Debate
In 1953, nuclear energy was introduced into America as a cheap and
efficient energy source, favoured in place of increasingly scarce fossil fuels
which caused air pollution. Its initial use was welcomed by the general public,
as it was hoped to lower the price of electricity, and utilise nuclear power for
it’s potential as a resource, not a weapon. However, as people became aware of
the long term dangers involved in storing nuclear waste, it’s use was criticised.
Two accidents, at Three Mile Island and Chernobyl, demonstrated to the world
the enormous risks involved in producing nuclear power.
Nuclear power provides 17% of the world’s electricity but coal is the
main source, making up 39%. However, fossil fuels such as coal, require greater
quantities to produce the equivalent amount of electricity produced from Uranium.
The use of nuclear power opposed to burning fossil fuels has reduced carbon
dioxide emissions by 2 billion tonnes per year, minimising the global warming
effect on the atmosphere. Carbon dioxide is responsible for half of man made
gases contributing to the Greenhouse Effect, and has sparked action from the UN
Intergovernment Panel on Climate Change. Their consensus is a concern for the
environment in the next century if fossil fuels continue to be used, even at
present global levels. The Panel claims that for carbon dioxide to be
stabilised to safe levels, a 50-80% reduction in all emissions would be required.
The United Nations has predicted a world population growth from 5.5
billion to 8.5 billion by the year 2025, meaning demand for energy will increase.
Nuclear power is the only practical source, in consideration for the
environment, cost and efficiency. Coal-fired generation of electricity would
increase carbon dioxide emissions, and renewable sources such as solar and hydro,
are not suitable for large scale power generation.
Nuclear power is not without its own implications. The process includes
disposing of radioactive waste, which poses a threat to the environment and the
world if not contained properly and temporarily disposed of with maximum
security. In the thesis, “Nuclear power: an energy future we can’t afford”,
by Peter Kelly from Hamilton College, he wrote,
“…we’d still have to worry about terrorists making bombs out of nuclear waste.
Just five pounds of plutonium, a component of nuclear waste, is enough to make a
nuclear bomb. Such a bomb could topple the World Trade Centre and kill hundreds
of thousands of people…Terrorists may be able to recruit disgruntled
scientists…”
Disposing of nuclear waste is extremely controversial, because it takes
thousands of years to decompose, and the radiation remains active.
Other than the environmental effects of disposing nuclear waste, the
potential of radioactive fallout from a faulty reactor is a dangerous
possibility, and the events following the accident at Chernobyl demonstrated the
long term destructiveness radiation is capable of. In 1986 at Chernobyl, an
unauthorised experiment conducted with the cooling system turned off, lead to
the explosion of one of the reactors. The radioactive fallout spread through
the atmosphere, reaching into northern Europe and Great Britain. The Soviets
claim 31 people died directly from the accident, while deaths due to radiation
are yet to be determined. Radiation sometimes causes genetic mutations in the
child whose parents were exposed to radiation. A few years ago on the
television program ?60 Minutes’, they presented a story on the after effects of
the Chernobyl accident. They revealed horrific shots of mutated embryos
preserved in jars, the most disturbing, an embryo named ?Cyclops’, because it
only had one eye.
While nuclear power is more efficient and environmentally safer in terms
of global warming than fossil fuels, it has a destructive potential that cannot
be ignored. Electricity, generated from the nuclear fission of Uranium 235 or
Plutonium 239 are both elements which are used in nuclear weapons. Radiation
either from waste or fall out from a reactor explosion can cause detrimental
effects, both long and short term, to the environment and society. Precautions
must be taken in security, disposal, and generation of nuclear power and its
waste, in order for it to be a successful resource and temporary alternative.
At present, renewable energy sources are too expensive and are not suitable for
large scale power generation. However, advancing technology may improve on
current systems, making them more efficient and suitable for major electricity
generation. Peter Kelly concluded his thesis, ?…nuclear power should be seen
as a way to tide us over to an age of conservation and renewables. Barring an
unexpected breakthrough in fusion, the age of nuclear power will end in the
foreseeable future.?
BIBLIOGRAPHY
1. Microsoft Encarta `95
Microsoft Corporation
1994-95
2. Nuclear power: an energy future we can’t afford
Peter Kelly
3. World
Energy Needs and Nuclear Power
Nuclear Issues Briefing Paper 11
Unknown
Другие работы по теме:
Nuclear Power Essay Research Paper People use
Nuclear Power Essay, Research Paper People use a lot of natural resources on the earth. These resources are gradually being diminished. As these resources are diminished we will continue to look for alternative energy sources. Currently the only short term solution to this problem is nuclear power. The problem with that though is that nuclear power is not as safe as burning coal, gas, or oil.
Nuclear Proliferation Essay Research Paper What is
Nuclear Proliferation Essay, Research Paper What is the best way to address the question of nuclear proliferation in the coming century? In this paper I will state my views on the inevitability of nuclear proliferation and the views of others, as well as addressing what will come of the vertical proliferation of nuclear technology and delivery systems.
Nuclear Weapons Essay Research Paper Even though
Nuclear Weapons Essay, Research Paper Even though the United States and Russia have just concluded the most far-reaching nuclear arms reduction treaty in history, the danger that nuclear weapons will actually be used is growing rather than declining. George Bush and Boris Yeltsin’s START II accord does represent an important step in winding down the U.S.-Soviet nuclear arms race (Fromuth, 1993).
The Nuclear Threat Essay Research Paper The
The Nuclear Threat Essay, Research Paper The United States, once a defender of world peace and an international police power, seems today to be loosening the grip that has in the past prevented so much violence through out the world. At a time when “renegade” nations are arming with nuclear weapons, the Senate has voted not to ratify the Comprehensive Nuclear Test Ban Treaty, a document that in the President’s words “is critical to protecting the American people from the dangers of nuclear war”.
Nuclear History Essay Research Paper WHAT IS
Nuclear History Essay, Research Paper WHAT IS NUCLEAR ENERGY ? Nuclear energy is made up of tiny atoms. All matter has atoms. One drop of water has one six tillion atoms. It would take one hundred million atoms to equal the length of one centimeter. An atom is mostly empty space. At the center of an atom, there is a nucleus.
Nuclear Power Plants Essay Research Paper Nuclear
Nuclear Power Plants Essay, Research Paper Nuclear Plants The question of whether the U.S. should have nuclear power plants is very controversial. There are two sides that one can take; however, both sides have their own share of problems. If you chose to not have nuclear plants, then eventually all natural resources will run out.
Fire 2 Essay Research Paper Thousands of
Fire 2 Essay, Research Paper Thousands of years ago human beings learned to make fire. By collecting and burning wood they were able to warm themselves, cook food, and manufacture primitive tools. Later, the Egyptians discovered the principal of the sail. Even more recent was the invention of the water wheel.
Nuclear Medicine Essay Research Paper Nuclear MedicineThere
Nuclear Medicine Essay, Research Paper Nuclear Medicine There are many things to be said about Nuclear Medicine. During the 20th century the world has seen many changes in medicine. One of the most ingenious creations of the century in the health field is Nuclear Medicine and Radiology. It is easily argued that modern medicine is the greatest accomplishment in human history1.
Nuclear Power Plant Essay Research Paper New
Nuclear Power Plant Essay, Research Paper New form of Energy for Capetown Capetown is considered to be the largest city in South Africa, having a population of over 2,727,000 inhabits. The energy form used in Capetown at the moment, is Gas Turbine, wich provides most of the city+s electricity. The use of electricity in Capetown is very low compared to western countries, for example there is only one TV for almost ten people, the energy consumption per inhabit a year is about 4000 kWh, wich is 2550 kWh less than the energy consumption per inhabit a year in Paris, France.
Nuclear Power Plant In Saskatchewan Essay Research
Paper Should There Be A Nuclear Power Plant In Saskatchewan? I think there should be a nuclear power plant built in Saskatchewan because I believe it would contribute to the province a great deal. There is a
Nuclear Terrorism Essay Research Paper Today the
Nuclear Terrorism Essay, Research Paper Today, the terrorists have innumerable opportunities to attack where they want and also, how they want. The reason? Nobody knows, but how would you like if you would be able to put some nuclear stuff in a small box instead of looking for a place where you could drive your wagon full of explosives.
The First Reactor Essay Research Paper The
The First Reactor Essay, Research Paper The First Reactor The First Reactor chronicles the conception and implementation of the first self-sustaining nuclear pile. The booklet has three main sections to it. The first one tells of the history and background of the organizations and research that were used for the momentous experiment, as well as the actual proceedings that occurred on December 2, 1942.
Nucelar Enargy Essay Research Paper nuclear reactornuclear
Nucelar Enargy Essay, Research Paper nuclear reactor nuclear reactor, device for producing NUCLEAR ENERGY by controlled nuclear reactions. It can be used for either research or power production. The reactor is so constructed that the fission of atomic nuclei produces a self-sustaining nuclear chain reaction, in which the produced neutrons are able to split other nuclei.
Nuclear Power Plants Essay Research Paper Chem
Nuclear Power Plants Essay, Research Paper Chem. Com. Project Lynsey Boggess Nuclear Power has its advantages and disadvantages. However it is a lot safer than most people think. The chances of a meltdown or a radiation leak are extremely small. There are many safety features, which make nuclear power one of the safest electricity sources.
Should The United States Invest More Money
In Renewable Energy Research And Development As Opposed To Fossil And Nuclear Fuels? Essay, Research Paper The United States should invest more money into the research and development of renewable energy. These renewable resources would take the place of fossil fuels, which are non-renewable resources.
Emergence Of The Nuclear Age Essay Research
Paper Emergence of the Nuclear Age I feel the most important issue which I learned in class was of the emergence of the nuclear age. I feel that this is important due to the fact
Nuclear Weapons Essay Research Paper The topic
Nuclear Weapons Essay, Research Paper The topic of nuclear weapons is one that will be around forever. One of my favorite lines from the reading we had was that we cannot uninvent nuclear
The Spread Of Nuclear Weapons More May
Be Better Essay, Research Paper The Spread of Nuclear Weapons: More May Be Better ??????????? Kenneth Waltz, produces an interesting and semi compelling argument for the use of Nuclear weapons as a way of maintaining the
Plutonium Essay Research Paper Plutonium239 an isotope
Plutonium Essay, Research Paper Plutonium-239 (an isotope of plutonium) is used in making nuclear weapons. Plutonium- 238 is used to power equipment on the moon by means of the heat it emits. Plutonium is also used in radionuclide batteries for pacemakers.
Bignerds Essay Research Paper Why nuclear fusion
Bignerds Essay, Research Paper Why nuclear fusion is so cool……. For a fusion reaction to take place, the nuclei, which are positively charged, must have enough kinetic energy to overcome their electrostatic force of repulsion. This can occur either when one nucleus is accelerated to high energies by an accelerating device, or …
Personal Statement Essay Research Paper Personal Statement
Personal Statement Essay, Research Paper Personal Statement: Interests, Experiences, and Goals in Nuclear Engineering Money and fame do not motivate my goals. Engineering in all forms is a field of innovation and invention. Aspirations of any great engineer should be to introduce to the world a new idea, product, or service that will make people happier and the environment safer.
Energy Essay Research Paper The first question
Energy Essay, Research Paper The first question, which I must ask in order to write this essay, is, what is energy? Energy gives us the ability to do thing. Everything in the world needs a supply of energy, and so energy is used to make things work. The word energy is taken from the Greeks and means the work within and nearly all energy originally came from the sun.
Alas Babylon Essay Research Paper Alas Babylon
Alas, Babylon Essay, Research Paper Alas, Babylon Essay In the book Alas, Babylon, the author, Pat Frank, discusses the condition of the human race. Mainly, his view differs from others because rather than write about the countries in a nuclear war, he writes about people living in the countries that are involved in that war.
Nuclear Energy Essay Research Paper Nuclear Energy
Nuclear Energy Essay, Research Paper Nuclear Energy should be produced because it is an alternative to fossil fuel. Nuclear energy helps to conserve our national resources that we use as fuel such as coil, oil, and natural gas. Another pro of nuclear energy is that radiation that is given off by nuclear energy is mostly thought of a very dangerous thing but it can be used in positive ways too.
Chernobyl 2 Essay Research Paper The Chernobyl
Chernobyl 2 Essay, Research Paper The Chernobyl disaster began in the early morning hours of April 25, 1986 when a shift operating the nuclear reactor exploded showering radioactive debris from the power
Pollution Essay Research Paper Pollution What is
Pollution Essay, Research Paper Pollution. What is pollution? According to the Merriam Webster Dictionary pollution is ?the action of polluting esp. by environmental contamination with man-made waste.? The United States runs on power. Much of the United States? powers come from various nuclear power plants all across the country.
Us Affairs Essay Research Paper The US
Us Affairs Essay, Research Paper The U.S. plays a major role in most of the international affairs because the U.S. is considered to be a powerful nation. The Economy of America is strong, and the military power is one of the biggest in the world. There was a Persian Gulf War back in 1991 when the U.S. attacked Iraq.
Energy Essay Research Paper Electricity is the
Energy Essay, Research Paper Electricity is the fuel and catalyst for so many peoples worldwide. What started as an experiment in Edison s laboratory has grown to mammoth proportions as we it today. Nuclear power, introduced in the late 50s, was thought by many to be the answer to all of our energy needs. Both source s developments have pushed humanity to advanced places and beyond the question is how far?