– Is It Working Essay, Research Paper
The American juvenile justice system was designed over 100 years ago to reform kids found guilty of minor crimes, minor crimes such as petty theft and truancy. Today, the system is becoming overwhelmed by crimes of violence. Stealing and skipping school have been replaced by rape, robbery, and murder. The juvenile justice system was never meant to deal with these problems.
Juvenile delinquency describes the antisocial behavior of many different types of youth who are in trouble, or who are on the brink of trouble with the law. In general terms juvenile delinquency means different things to different people. By law, a juvenile delinquent is a minor under seventeen who commits a criminal act determined by law and found guilty in court. Juvenile courts, see a juvenile delinquent as a youth who goes against a state or local law.
Children are not just born delinquents, they are products of circumstances and chance, and culture and environment. A youth named a delinquent by circumstance and chance is just a youth who has been in the wrong place at the wrong time. Usually, the juvenile who commits a delinquent act by chance is a part of a gang that takes part in unlawful behavior temporarily. Most juveniles become delinquents because of the culture and environment that surrounds them. Juveniles who are in an area of violence and crime learn to go against authority and engage in crime because it is the acceptable thing to do.
The juvenile justice system originated about 1819, and on July 1, 1899 the first juvenile court in the United States was set up in Cook County, Illinois. It represented a dramatic change in the way the criminal justice system and all of the American society viewed criminally involved youth. The new court was founded on the principle of parens patriae , the idea that children should not be treated as criminals, but as wards of the state.
Parents patrae tried to show that children were not fully responsible for their conduct and were able to be rehabilitated. Parens patraie tried to explain the view that children were fully responsible for their conduct and were able to be rehabilitated. Parens patraie remains the base of the juvenile justice system in Massachusetts and across the country. Then, like now, juvenile court was designed more to protect the child that to punish bad behavior.
Most people feel that until recently, the juvenile justice system served our country and our children pretty well. Beginning in the 1970 s, the nature of juvenile crime became different. Juvenile crime grew more common and more violent, and the system was not prepared.
The biggest problem facing law enforcement today may be the very structure of the juvenile justice system. A system that neither punishes nor rehabilitates is useless. Examples of juvenile justice system failures are found everywhere throughout the United States.
In Rhode Island, Craig Price, age fifteen, deliberately killed a mother and her two young daughters. Yet, this wasn t his first offense, or murder. Two years earlier he had murdered another woman. He also had a long record of assaults, burglaries, and other crimes.
In Chicago, two of the neighborhood s toughest bullies lured a five year old boy and his eight year old brother up to an empty fourteenth floor apartment. While up there one of the bullies decided to dangle the helpless five year old out the window by his feet. As the eight year old tried to help his younger brother, the bully dropped him, and he plunged fourteen floors to his death. The bullies, who were both ten years old, are not even going to juvenile prison. Journalist Richard Lacayo calls these kids predator juveniles (Lacayo 60), because they steal the life of others.
Closer to home, the system is just as corrupt. A sixteen year old boy from Somerville has been charged with killing his next door neighbor, his best friends’ mother. According to police the boy was infatuated about her, and before killing her, he beat her and then stabbed her seventy-two times.
Violent juvenile crime is increasing at twice the rate of violent crimes made by adults. By the year 2,005, the number of teenagers between ages’ fourteen and seventeen will grow by twenty-three percent. How can this epidemic of violence among our young people be controlled? First and foremost is education, in elementary school, in middle school, in high school, and most important, education at home. Learning the difference between right and wrong begins at birth. Early childhood is the most crucial time for this learning to take place. Parents must be held responsible for teaching their children what is right and what is wrong. If parents refuse to except their roles as teachers, then the government will be forced to step in. Education is most important because its goal is prevention rather than rehabilitation.
First time offenders, in both adult and juvenile systems are very rarely punished, unless they are charged with a very serious crime. Children must learn that they are accountable for their actions. We are wrong when we do not teach them that their actions do have significant consequences. A young child who runs across a busy city street will most certainly face immediate punishment at the hands of his mother. The same should go for the juvenile offender the first time he breaks the law. After all, how will the offender learn that he or she will be accountable for their actions.
With almost everyone agreeing that the juvenile justice system is a failure, some alternative punishments should be considered. In East Boston District Court, Judge Domenic Russo sets a strict curfew on all juvenile first time offenders. The curfew is determined by the age of the juvenile. It is one-half of their age, so a sixteen year old, such as myself would have to be in at home at eight in the evening.
Some judges and elected officials are now sending juvenile offenders too military like boot camps. The boot camps are very similar to Marine Corps basic training, where there is strict discipline. Boot camp can last for several months, at the end of which the juvenile either succeeds and graduates or fails and returns to the system.
Another new form of punishment is not new at all. Corporal punishment has been used for thousands of years. Presently it is illegal in the United States. However, the recent event in Singapore, where a teenager from the United States was caught spray-painting a car and was sentenced to be caned (whipped) changed the way many viewed the laws of the United States.
Had he been caught spray-painting cars in his hometown of Dayton, his crime would have been regarded as commonplace and his neighbors opinion would not have mattered (Rush 3).
Where Singapore is relatively crime free, in the United States there is an epidemic of crime. To some people, corporal punishment should be brought back.
What about the most vicious crime that society has to deal with, murder? Remember Craig Price?
If Craig Price had been two and a half weeks older, and if he had murdered the Heaton Family in Oklahoma — or in one of the several other states which authorize the imposition of Capital punishment of sixteen-year-olds– he almost certainly would have been sentenced to death for his crimes (Dershowitz 2).
Should all juveniles convicted of murder be put to death? Probably not, but, certainly those teenagers guilty of the most violent and vicious killings should at least be tried as adults and sent to prison.
Everyone agrees that the juvenile justice system needs to be improved. The question is how can this be accomplished. Is the present system in such bad shape that we should abandon it all together, or should we keep it and simply make small changes to make a better system? I believe that the whole system in the United States should be changed completely. We need new ideas in order to derive new solutions. However, everyone must become involved: kids, parents, politicians, and judges. All must do their part if we are to save our future generations.
Work Cited
Lacayo Richard. SUPERPREDATORS ARRIVE. New York: Newsweek, 1996. 57.
Bernard, Thomas. The Cycle of Juvenile Justice. New York: Oxford University Press, 1992. 1- 10, 56.
Dershowitz, Alan. The Abuse Excuse. New York:Time Warner Electronic Publishing, 1995. 1- 2
Eldefonso, Edward. Youth Problems and Law Enforcement. New Jesey: Prentice-Hall, INC., 1972. 2-8, 45-50.
Hyde, Margaret. Juvenile Justice and Injustice. New York: Franklin Watts, 1977. 1-6, 22-30.
Reilly, Tom. Youth crime has changed- and so must the juvenile justice system. Boston: Boston Globe, 1996. 13
Rush, Richard. WHEN KIDS GO BAD. New York: Time Magazine, 1994. 26, 60.
Другие работы по теме:
Kids On Death Role Essay Research Paper
“Kids on Death Row” The Juvenile Justice System consists of a more or less integrated network of agencies, institutions, organizations, and personnel that process juvenile offenders. This network is made up of how enforcement agencies, prosecutors, and courts; corrections, probation, and parole services; and public and private community-based treatment programs that provide youth with diverse services.
Bills In Congress Essay Research Paper Bills
Bills In Congress Essay, Research Paper Bills Waiting to be Passed Bill summaries and statuses in congress. Some are still floating around in congress waiting to get passed. One bill is the Juvenile Crime Control Act of 1997. This bill states that if a juvenile is alleged of committing an offense to the United States Juvenile Delinquency Act be surrendered to the state authority and be tried as an adult.
Revolving Door Justice Essay Research Paper Revolving
Revolving Door Justice Essay, Research Paper Revolving Door Justice 1) Plea Bargaining is when a person may agree to lesser crime as to not clog up the jury system but when this can be made the accused will wait for a good deal. I think that this is a bad idea because it makes it seem like the justice system can be bought or bargained with and laws can be bent.
Crucible 3 Essay Research Paper Justice Systems
Crucible 3 Essay, Research Paper Justice Systems In The Puritan Societies Justice systems have changed greatly over the years. In the Puritan justice system, much has been improved. In 1692, in the town of Salem, many people lose their lives or are punished unfairly due to their justice system. Justice to Puritans really is not justice at all; it is a quick fix to a complicated problem.
The Effect Of Landmark Supreme Court Cases
On Juvenile Justice Essay, Research Paper 4 February 2000 The Effect of Landmark Supreme Court Cases on Juvenile Justice Thesis: In the past juvenile offenders were held to the same standards and sanctions as adult offenders. The juvenile justice system has changed in the past 100 years as result of several case laws.
The Inequality Of American Justice Essay Research
Paper David Cole wrote, “our criminal justice system affirmatively depends on inequality” (5). Cole has substantial grounds for making this statement. Race and class have long been issues in the criminal justice system, but does the system “affirmatively depend on inequality?” Does the criminal justice system depend on the disparities of the people that it serves? American justice is supposed to be blind.
The Juvenile Death Penalty Essay Research Paper
The execution of juveniles began in 1642 with Thomas Graunger, Plymouth Colony, Massachusetts. In the 358 years since that time, a total of approximately 361 persons has been executed for juvenile crimes. (Execution of Juvenile Offenders) Juvenile execution has been an arduous debate for several years.
Juveniles Or Adults Essay Research Paper Eric
Juveniles Or Adults Essay, Research Paper Eric Dinger English 2, sec 48 Ms.Brock Proposal paper 2/27/01 Juvenile or Adult? With the increasing large amount of crimes being committed by juvenile’s, official are trying to come up ways to prevent these crimes from ever happening. More and more teens are committing crimes because they know they can get away with because of their age, especially in gangs.
Criminal Justice Essay Research Paper In this
Criminal Justice Essay, Research Paper In this paper I will attempt to explain how the United States Criminal Justice System and Ireland has some different characteristics. They both share some of the same practices in each system. I will give a brief history of both countries and the way their system works.
Justice
& Fairness Essay, Research Paper Justice & Fairness When a person commits a crime, many people call for him to be brought to justice. To many people, it means punishment. If a person commits murder, some say he should be brought to justice by having to serve a long prison sentence or even face the death penalty.
Juvenile Delinquents Essay Research Paper On March
Juvenile Delinquents Essay, Research Paper On March 7, 2000, Californians voted in favor of Proposition 21 – The Juvenile Justice Initiative. . The number of crimes committed by juveniles has risen dramatically, and it will continue to rise unless some action is taken. Thus, juvenile offenders should be punished more severely to deter other teenagers from committing crimes and for the safety of all citizens.
Juvenial Justice Essay Research Paper All legal
Juvenial Justice Essay, Research Paper All legal systems were have distinguished between juvenile delinquents and adult criminals. Youth are usually not considered morally responsible for their behavior. Under the code of Napoleon in France, an example is limited responsibility was given to children under the age of 16.
The Young Offenders Act Essay Research Paper
This essay was written to show the advantages anddisadvantages of the Young Offenders Act over the previous JuvenileDelinquents Act. Also it should give a theoretical understanding ofthe current Canadian Juvenile-Justice system, the act and it’simplications and the effects of the young offenders needs and mentalhealth on the outcome of the trials.In the interest of society the young offenders act was broughtforth on april second 1984.
Juvenile Justice System Essay Research Paper The
Juvenile Justice System Essay, Research Paper The German playwright, Schiller, once said that in good drama every good character is right. In this paper, I am going to discuss Schiller’s comment with regard to Amanda Wingfield, Laura Wingfield, and Tom Wingfield.
Imbalance In The American Justice System Essay
, Research Paper Imbalance in the American Justice System The United States of America probably has the best justice system throughout the entire planet but; Is this true? There is corruption within this system, which causes it to be constitutionally imbalance.
Upgrading Justice Essay Research Paper Taylor E
Upgrading Justice Essay, Research Paper Taylor E. Schuss English 205 31 August 2000 Upgrading Justice What is justice? By definition the word Justice can mean different things. To most Americans, justice is when someone who has committed a crime goes before a judge or a jury of his or her peers and is punished for their actions.
Should Juveniles Be Tried As A Essay
, Research Paper Adult Crimes Deserve Adult Treatment Thursday, May 21, 1998. In Springfield, Oregon, 15-year old Kip Kinkel opened fire in the cafeteria
Juvenile Justice System Essay Research Paper As
Juvenile Justice System Essay, Research Paper As late as the nineteenth century, crimes committed by juveniles were handled in the adult courts. By the late 1800’s, reforms in this area began,
Should Juveniles Be Tried As Adults Essay
, Research Paper Should juveniles be tried as adults? For many years, juvenile criminals have been accorded special treatment in the courts. In recent years, however, the public has become dissatisfied with that system. Many people are
Juvenile Justice Essay Research Paper There are
Juvenile Justice Essay, Research Paper There are many theories of why juveniles become delinquent. Some theories that relate to Gloria are the Biosocial, Choice, Psychological, Social Structure Theories. The first theory that can apply to Gloria is neurological a Biosocial theory. This states that juveniles become delinquent due to learning disabilities such as attention deficit hyperactive disorder.
Juvenille Courts Essay Research Paper The Juvenile
Juvenille Courts Essay, Research Paper The Juvenile Court system was a system set up to deal with minors who find themselves in trouble. In trouble with their parents, or the law. This system has its benefits and its
Youth Violence Essay Research Paper Are we
Youth Violence Essay, Research Paper Are we solving youth violence by sending minors to jail in adult prisons? In the article ?Tough Justice for Juveniles? author Edward Humes discusses the underlining problems with the Juvenile Justice System. In this article Humes claims in paragraph 2 that: ?Our national fixation with meting out adult punishments to young criminals has blinded us to the underling crisis?the juvenile system?s shocking inability to impose meaningful penalties, or even supervision, on offenders before they become the ?predators? we so fear.? Personally, I agree with the Humes, the Juvenile Justice System is so readily willing to punish young criminals to the furthest extent of the law.
Juvenile Offenders Essay Research Paper Juvinile Should
Juvenile Offenders Essay, Research Paper Juvinile Should Juveniles be waived to adult court Philosophy 14 Nov 98 Should juveniles be waived to adult court. There has been tension between teens (pre-teens) and adults for thousands of years, and the question how to deal with the youth of a culture, in a punishment sense, has been with us for just as long.
Young Offenders Act Essay Research Paper The
Young Offenders Act Essay, Research Paper The Young Offenders Act This essay was written to show the advantages and disadvantages of the Young Offenders Act over the previous Juvenile
Truth Of Juvenile Delinquency Essay Research Paper
A movement has taken hold nationally to change the juvenile justice system, and erase any distinction between young offenders and adult criminals. Almost all fifty states have overhauled their juvenile justice laws, allowing more youths to be tried as adults and scrapping long-time protections to help rehabilitate delinquent kids and prevent future crimes.
Juvenile Offenders And Capital Punishment Essay Research
Paper Although there are many different views and points to look at when discussing capital punishment, juvenile offenders should be excluded from the death penalty, because capital punishment is cruel, inhumane and barbaric. Capital punishment does not belong in the penal system of any modern, progressing culture.
Juvenile Offenders Essay Research Paper Juvenile Offenders
Juvenile Offenders Essay, Research Paper Juvenile Offenders Justin Meunier Ever since the mid-nineteen eighties, juvenile crime has been on the rise. The number of crimes committed by juveniles has risen dramatically, and it will continue to rise unless some action is taken. Thus, juvenile offenders should be punished more severely to deter other teenagers from committing crimes and for the safety of all citizens.
Judgement Essay Research Paper 1 In this
Judgement Essay, Research Paper 1. In this situation, the judge has many different options. These options include probation, placement in a group home, being sent to a juvenile detention center, restitution, being fined, or doing community service. Probation is when a judge sets conditions for a juvenile delinquent that cannot be violated and if they are the juveniles will be sent to a juvenile detention facility, until he is 18.
Juvenile Justice In Australiaa Essay Research Paper
Juvenile Justice The Juvenile Justice Act 1992 (QLD) defines a juvenile as a young person under the age of 17 years. It maintains that a child under the age of 10 years is not considered criminally responsible, and is incapable of forming ‘criminal intent’. Similarly, a child under the age of 14 years is not considered criminally responsible, unless it is proven that the child understood the offence was morally wrong.
Rhabilitating Juvenile Offenders Essay Research Paper Rehabilitating
Rhabilitating Juvenile Offenders Essay, Research Paper Rehabilitating Juvenile Offenders America has a problem with juvenile offenders. Yes, it would be easy to lock them up but that costs too much and does little to rehabilitate the juvenile. If detention homes were a deterrent, then crime levels committed by juveniles wouldn?t be so high.