Essay, Research Paper
Role of Government Intervention in Environmental Issues
In environmental cases, a policy framework is sometimes more effective
when there is less government intervention. As the level of government
intervention diminishes, this allows more flexibility for corporations to
achieve efficiency. Furthermore the traditional command and control approach
has proven to be costly, bureaucratic and often inefficient.
It is important to address the fact that there are numerous benefits that can
be achieved for both policy makers and industries, if a policy framework is
based on market forces. However it is important that there is a need for some
government intervention, but should be as minimal as possible.
I have chosen to examine the article from the New York Times entitled
RU.S. Seeking Options of Pollution RulesS. Although pollution is detrimental to
our environment, you have to take into account that it is almost impossible to
entirely prevent pollution. This is scientifically impossible and it would have
severely negative economic impact on the industries. So the core issue becomes
the fact no matter what, there will always be pollution, as long as these
industries exist. So we should focus on how we can minimize this and yet at the
same time have an efficient market system? Furthermore, we should also focus on
how we can accomplish this so that sustainable growth and development can take
place. So there is definitely a need for some form of government intervention
to enforce and monitor this. Reason being that there is always an element of
equality that has to be enforced, when dealing with cases such as this. For
instance, larger corporations may have an advantage over smaller corporation,
since they have stronger influence on politicians and lobbyists. So the
governmentUs role should be to ensure that all industries (regardless size
and/or power) have equal opportunities to benefit from this type of approach.
In another words, the government should simply be a RwatchdogS. Government
should monitor so that the distribution and transaction of the permits are done
in an appropriate manner.
The case of Minnesota Mining & Manufacturing Corporation is a classic
example of tradable permit approach. Under this model corporations are able to
buy, sell and trade permits that legally allows emission. Many economists have
favored this approach because this also provides incentives for technical
improvement. So the aggregate effect would be that most industries would try to
maximize their profits by trying to come up with new techniques to reduce the
level of emission. This in turn would allow them to reduce the cost that they
would have to pay from polluting. Norm Miller also endorses this approach by
stating that Rperformance-based approaches are more efficient, both for industry
and for governmentS.
Allowing a company to devise and manage their own pollution control
plan is another effective (and Rde-regulativeS) approach. In the article, this
was exemplified in an Arizona based company called Intel. Individual companies
such as Intel knows what is best for the company. This means that each
individual companies know what the best equipment is and what the best
procedures are to achieve established standards. Rather than having the
government telling them what to do, the people at Intel were able to devise
their own plan. This saved them a great amount of time with out the usual
cumbersome, bureaucratic procedures. The Intel company, in this case, bought
the effluent from the cityUs waste water treatment plan. This allows
corporations to work more closely with the local communities. Usually, the
result is that both parties would benefit and even achieve a common goal.
There are, however, potential problems that may occur from this.
Although we can presume that market forces will allow everything to work itself
out, it may still promote degradation. Reason being that, under this model
there is still a notion of Ryou can pollute as long as you can pay for itS. So
if a great number of corporations are financially able to pay for their level of
emission, the aggregate effect on our environment would be devastating. Under
this model, it is also difficult to penalize the polluters. Where as under the
command and control approach, severe fine or even imprisonment can be imposed to
prevent pollution. There is also a possibility that this may lead to
individualistic attitude. In a competitive market, everybody (or every
corporation) tries to maximize their gain by acting in an individualistic manner.
Individualistic type of behavior has been known to lead to greater level of
environmental degradation.
Market based approach is definitely an economically liberal (and also
RReagan-esqueS) approach, since there is the Rhands-offS notion. But if the
initial framework is implemented in an appropriate manner, this can turn out to
be very flexible, user friendly and environmentally friendly approach.
In my opinion, government role should simply be initiating, implementing and
monitoring with minimum regulatory intervention. However, government should set
forth some sort of environmental goal before implementing a regulation. If this
prevails, it will allow growth in a sustainable manner.
Другие работы по теме:
A Nation Divided Essay Research Paper A
A Nation Divided Essay, Research Paper A Nation Divided America, although one country, is divided in its political beliefs about how the federal government should intervene in the lives of its citizens. Throughout history, even to present day, politicians have debated this balance. Today we live in a system which depends for its expansion and vitality upon the government (Source 9).
Environmental Economic Impact Of Pollution In Chesapeake
Bay Essay, Research Paper Environmental Economic Impact of Pollution in the Chesapeake Bay The Chesapeake Bay is the nation’s largest estuary with six major tributaries, the James, the Potomac, the Susquehanna, the Patuxent, the York, and the Rappahannock Rivers, feeding into the bay from various locations in Maryland, Virginia, Pennsylvania, and the District of Columbia (Chemical Contaminants in the Chesapeake Bay – Workshop Discussion 1).
The Role Of The U.S. In The
Third World In The Year 2000 Essay, Research Paper The Role of the U.S. in the Third World in the Year 2000 The United States budget will continue to tighten and we must better
How The Enlightenment Adresses Essay Research Paper
GOLDINA, OLGA ANALYZE THE WAYS IN WHICH ENLIGHTENMENT THOUGHT ADDRESSED RELIGIOUS BELIEFS AND SOCIAL ISSUES IN THE 18TH CENTURY During the 18th century, the Enlightenment addressed religious beliefs and social issues, which were controversial among all the people and were not accepted by the government.
Art And Politics Essay Research Paper This
Art And Politics Essay, Research Paper This essay explores the question do art and politics mix? According to Brett whitely, Art and politics don t happily mix , which implies that art in more readily accepted when it conveys images of beauty, rather than a typical political agenda which makes up much of modern art.
Environmental Archaeology Essay Research Paper IF
Environmental Archaeology Essay, Research Paper IF we want to know how humans functioned we must know what their world was like ? thus environmental reconstruction Geomorphical and biological processes occurring
The Reform Of Schools Essay Research Paper
The Reform of Schools The government of Ontario proposes there is a need to make universally accepted rules in the school system. For students to be more disciplined, the government needs to achieve new province wide standards. If the new school standards will not discipline the students, and if each school entails its guidelines, then the government s province wide code of conduct will fail.
Fifra Essay Research Paper Toxics
Fifra Essay, Research Paper Toxics & Pesticides Enforcement Division Pesticides: The Federal Insecticide, Fungicide, and Rodenticide Act (FIFRA) The Federal government first regulated pesticides when Congress passed the Insecticide Act of 1910. This law was intended to protect farmers from adulterated or misbranded products.
Marketing Essay Research Paper FOREWORDThe first time
Marketing Essay, Research Paper FOREWORD The first time I visited an IKEA-store was in Elisabeth, New Yersey, The U.S. The year was 1995 and I still rember the joy and excitement when I entered the building. It was huge and it
Mercantilism Essay Research Paper Mercantilism as a
Mercantilism Essay, Research Paper Mercantilism as a global economic policy tends to subscribe to the following premises: wealth is an essential means to power, power is essential as a means to the acquisition of wealth, wealth and power are each proper ultimate ends of national policy, and there is a long run balance of trade between these ends.
Elimination Of Agricultural Programs Essay Research Paper
The government should eliminate all agricultural programs because they do not benefit consumers. Agree? Disagree? Why? Why not? I do not think that the government should eliminate all agricultural programs. These programs were proposed and put in motion for particular purposes. Many lawmakers worked on them.
MEDIA HOW EXXAGERATING IT IS Essay
, Research Paper The media plays a big role in our perception of the world . television news producers choose events that are out of the ordinary. They also combine bizarre
Psychotherapy Vs Crisis Intervention Essay Research Paper
Psychotherapy, also known as crisis counseling, is an organized conceptual framework, which uses multiple psychological theories to assist an individual towards problem resolution. This type of therapy / counseling may be appropriate after crisis intervention since the goal of psychotherapy is problem resolution and the goal of crisis intervention is problem management.
Environmental Debate
– 2000 Essay, Research Paper After following the elections and debates between Al Gore and George W. Bush for quite some time, I found that they each have their own separate views on ?helping? the environment. On one side, the democratic representative who has been dubbed the ?environmental extremist? seems to understand much about the earth?s current state.
Legislative Influence On The Economy Essay Research
Paper Legislative Influence on the Economy Throughout history, there have been instances of the government affecting the economy, be it with the B.U.S. or with the Fair Labor Standards Act, the government has played an important role in our economy. The government rescued the United States from the Great Depression by increasing demand and lowering taxes.
What Leads To Intervention A Case
Study Of Intervention During The Bush Administration Essay, Research Paper What Leads to Intervention?: A Case Study of Intervention During the Bush Administration
Governments In The Canadian Ec Essay Research
Paper Governments play a big role in our economy today. From environmental rules to price regulations, it is generally assumed that governments are needed to keep the economy moving. It was Adam Smith who first challenged the thoughts of government in the economy. His theory was that an economic system functions best when there is no interference by government.
Social Essay Research Paper The three most
Social Essay, Research Paper The three most important ways the government should intervene with the economy is through social programs, health and safety controls and environment protection. Government funded social programs are essential for an economy and a country as a whole to prosper. Some of the social-insurance programs in place are welfare, pension and disability.
Environmental Apocalypse Essay Research Paper Environmental Apocalypse
Environmental Apocalypse Essay, Research Paper Environmental Apocalypse The environment is in a terrible condition and although an environmental apocalypse is not imminent we are definitely headed down that road. Some of the reasons for our Earth s trouble are overpopulation, consumerism, and overconsumption.
Air Pollution And Government Itervention Essay Research
Paper It is generally accepted that the cause of air pollution is the ill-defined private property rights on air. But transaction costs matter too. Market is costly. After the defination of private property rights on air, it is very difficult, even impossible to charge the people who pollute air. The transaction costs of doing so is considerable.
The Role Of A Government Essay Research
Paper Sue Ellen Webb Mrs. Caudill English III Honors-5 20 January 2000 The Role of a Government Henry David Thoreau often took extreme positions on the issue of government and its role in society. To this somewhat rebellious transcendentalist, government should not govern people at all and law was often meant to be broken.
Ngos Help Or Hindrance Essay Research Paper
NGOs: Help or Hindrance? In his article, John McCormick establishes that the number of NGOs present in the world today probably exists well into the six figures (P. 60). Assuming that the role of NGOs is to keep governmental organizations in check when it comes to environmental issues, it frustrated me to think that there actually could be such problems with environmental issues.
Epa Essay Research Paper Environmental Protection AgencyDuring
Epa Essay, Research Paper Environmental Protection Agency During the 1970?s Richard Nixon took office. His administration had many goals for the future. During these years people were ready to change the way our society was going by helping the environment. Before it could get any worse the government decided to form an environmental protection agency after chemical pesticides were used.
Our Political System Essay Research Paper Our
Our Political System Essay, Research Paper Our Political System Government Institutions and Public Policy By definition, any government is the individuals, institutions, and process that makes and enforces the rules of society. Government has the responsibility to provide for public good, police powers, public services, taxes, and most importantly, to protect the power of the people.
Intelligence Essay Research Paper Intelligence hereditary
Intelligence Essay, Research Paper Intelligence: hereditary or acquired? Is intelligence determined primary by heredity or by the environment? This issue has aroused intense debates because many believe it has a little bit of both, but to what extent? The ones that believe that believe that every person is born with a fixed amount of intelligence argue that there is little one can do to improve intelligence, so special education programs should not be expected to produce an increase in the children?s IQ.
Our Government 2 Essay Research Paper Our
Our Government 2 Essay, Research Paper Our Government Government today is a lot different then the government that was created by our founding fathers. When they sat down to sign the declaration of independence, I wonder what they would have thought of our country as it exists today. The government has become an uncontrollable beast much like the government those heroes gave their lives to escape.
The Modified Market Economy Essay Research Paper
What is a modified market economy? What factors have been responsible for the emergence of this kind of economic system? How do governments influence economic decision making in such systems? Use Australian examples to illustrate your answer.
My Political Views Essay Research Paper I
My Political Views Essay, Research Paper I see myself as a quite liberal person on political, social, and economic issues. I believe the public has some duties to the government such as pay taxes. In turn, the government should fund programs to help the people who need assistance. Unfortunately, much of the American public has lost its trust in the federal government because of corruption and special interest groups.
Government Intervention Essay Research Paper Government Intervention
Government Intervention Essay, Research Paper Government Intervention: A Time and A Place The twentieth century has been the age for the most varied experiments in political policies that the world has ever seen. Governments are continually trying to improve and create the best system of regulation for their citizens.
Mandatory Voting Essay Research Paper Political ScienceMr
Mandatory Voting Essay, Research Paper Political Science Mr. Costello 11-18-00 Mandatory Voting Imagine a country where the voter turnout rate was one hundred percent. A country where all of the people of the nation came together to choose their future leaders. Unfortunately, this ideal is impossible without government intervention.
Free Rider Problem Essay Research Paper The
Free Rider Problem Essay, Research Paper The Free Rider ProblemThe free rider issue has become one of the most serious economic issues today. The free rider is a lazy type person who wants the benefits that others bring in without having to do the work. The free rider typically takes advantage of a public good.
Why Nature Is A Large Matter I
Essay, Research Paper Environmental issues are a major concern facing the world today. The detraction of the Ozone Layer, Deforestation, and numerous oil spills are issues leading to end of the world.