Prisoners Dilemma Essay, Research Paper
THE PRISONER S DILEMMA
(I). In the prisoner s dilemma two people have been arrested, the one inmate is called Smith. In this situation the authorities are not interested in the truth but only want to convict someone. An interrogator lays out the consequences for Smith. If Smith does not confess but the other guy confesses against Smith, they will release him and Smith will be put away for ten years. If Smith confesses and the other guy does not Smith will be free. If both men confess, each will receive five years. Still, if neither of the men confesses, there will not be enough evidence to convict either one of them. Each man will be held for one year, and then let go.
Smith and the other man are being offered the same deal. One might assume that each man would confess against each other. In this case both men would receive five years and not obtain the minimum possible time spent in jail. If each man looked out for him self both will end up worse off than if they had acted in a more benevolent manner. This is what makes the prisoner s dilemma such a paradoxical situation. Both men will be better of if they look out for each other or rather not look out for themselves.
This is a situation that can be used in every day living.. Any time there are peoples’ interests that are affected not only by what they do but what other people do, a dilemma may occur. In some situations everyone will end up worse off if they individually pursue their own interests than if they simultaneously do what it not in their own individual interests.
(II). If I myself was in the prisoner s dilemma, and my goal is to spend as little time in jail, I would act in an egotistic manner to maximize my freedom. My reasoning, as an egoist, would be to rat out the other guy hoping that he will remain silent. This would create the most ideal situation for myself. I would spend no time in jail and the other guy s situation is not my concern. This is what makes me an egoist, someone who tries to do the best for themselves. This idea of egotism is not necessarily wrong but rather a way of thinking to create the best outcome for yourself.
(III). Rachel, in his essay, points out a catch in this line of reasoning. The catch is that if I act in a way to create the best outcome for myself, one would have to assume the other inmate would have the same reasoning. He may also be an egoist and might rat me out in hopes that I would take all the blame and let him get off with his maximum freedom. This shows that in reality that if we both act in an egotistic manner that it is not in our best interest to confess and implicate each other. By doing so we would both receive five years, where only one year each is possible.
(IV). The situation with the prisoner s dilemma affects many different aspects of life. Prisoner dilemma-type situations occur whenever two conditions are present. 1. A situation where peoples’ interests are affected not only by what they do but what other people do as well. 2. The situation must have negative consequences if the individual pursues their own interests than if they simultaneously do what is not in their own interests.
The dilemma may occur whenever two people live together or closely involved with one another. An example of this is true in every marriage. If each partner acts as an egoist, only looking out for their own good, the marriage would suffer. Each partner would cause more damage by only looking out for their own interests.
(V). A more realistic example of a prisoner s dilemma-type situation could happen just by finding someone s wallet. If an individual picks up a wallet that was lying on the ground in a public park, he might think to himself that he just ran into some good luck and the money inside is now his. The prisoner s dilemma can be used as a parallel to this situation.
Even still it would be in the best interest of the finder of the wallet to attempt to return the money and wallet instead of pocketing the money. One must think of it from the other guy s point of view. Statistically the chance of loosing your wallet is very high and every person, egoist or not, may lose their wallet someday. In the event that your wallet is lost it would be in your best interest to get it back. Your thoughts would be in hopes that the finder would be a benevolent person, and not an egoist like you may possibly be.
In this particular example it would be much easier to pocket the money without anyone knowing and no direct consequences. Looking out for yourself, the best situation would be that every one else in the world would be benevolent people, and you yourself could simply take advantage of them. Another word for this could be, “free rider.” The next best thing is to be benevolent yourself along with everyone else. This would ensure kind treatment at all times and you would not have to worry about other people s interests. The bad side of this situation is when you are benevolent but around you are egoist waiting to take advantage of you.
If in fact you were an egoist when you found the wallet, but all other people are egoist too, then this would be a bad situation. You would try to protect your own interest but would get no help from any other people. If for example you dropped your wallet that contained one hundred dollars. In a complete egoist society you would have to assume that your money was now in the hands of someone else s. Even if the next week you found a wallet containing two hundred dollars, the situation is still bad for the individual that lost the wallet. By acting in this way every one loses and both parties would be better off if they acted not in their own individual self-interest.
Другие работы по теме:
Andersonville the Movie Essay Research Paper Five
Andersonville (the Movie) Essay, Research Paper ?Five hundred men moved silently toward the gates that would shut out life and hope for most of them forever. Quarter of a mile from the railroad we came into a massive palisade with great squared logs standing upright in the ground. Fires blazed up and showed us a section of these and two massive wooden gates with heavy iron hinges and bolts.
The Allegory Of The Cave By Plato
Essay, Research Paper Plato was born 427 B.C. and died 347 B.C. He was a pupil under Socrates. During his studies, Plato wrote the Dialogues, which are a collection of Socrates’ teachings. One of the parables included in the Dialogues is “The Allegory of the Cave”. “The Allegory…” symbolizes man’s struggle to reach understanding and enlightenment.
Angola Essay Research Paper I feel that
Angola Essay, Research Paper I feel that Angola prison system is a very effective correction system. The video demonstrated how the system has different setups to keep the prisoners working to keep them out of trouble. Although Angola is a rough maximum-security system, it seems to have great control over the inmates.
Capital Punishment 6 Essay Research Paper CAPITAL
Capital Punishment 6 Essay, Research Paper CAPITAL PUNISHMENTCapital Punishment or Life Imprisonment? I think that capital punishment should be use more often than just life imprisonment. Life imprisonment is just not working. The death penalty does have some cons but it has its share of pros too. Lets start with the pros.
Hukle Berry Finn Essay Research Paper Huckleberry
Hukle Berry Finn Essay, Research Paper Huckleberry FinnAll right, then, I’ll go to hell.” Six simple words; yet they have a very deep and complex meaning. The above quote was taken from Twain’s Huckleberry Finn, and it illustrates how modern man copes with what Twain termed the “inescapable dilemma of Democracy.” In the novel, Huck is faced with the dilemma of whether or not to return Jim, the runaway slave, back to Jim’s owner.
Kosovo Essay Research Paper War crime suspects
Kosovo Essay, Research Paper War crime suspects hunted after jailbreak MITROVICA, Kosovo — Hundreds of NATO-led peacekeepers and U.N. police are searching for a group of Serb prisoners, many charged with war crimes, who escaped from a jail in the northern Kosovo city of Mitrovica.
Empire Of The Sun Essay Research Paper
Adam Wolf South Lake Tahoe Used: Summer 99′ The Empire of the Sun is based during World War II (1945) in China. The main characters are Jamie, Jamie s Father and Mother, and Baisie. Jamie at the beginning of the movie is probably ten or eleven years old. Jamie and his family are living in China at the time.
Ivan Denisovich Essay Research Paper Imagine being
Ivan Denisovich Essay, Research Paper Imagine being captive in a concentration camp for over eight years. Ivan Denisovich Shukhov has experienced just this. In analyzing only one day of Ivan’s life in a concentration camp, he displays many traits that show that he is a hero. Hero, can be defined in many different ways.
The Guest Essay Research Paper How does
The Guest Essay, Research Paper How does Camus generate suspense in The Guest ? Camus utilizes many different ways to generate suspense and the ways are affected by where and when the author wrote the story. Camus was a French author who was born and raised in Algeria and the country was in the middle of war while Camus was writing most of his stories.
Amnesty International Essay Research Paper Ashley JamesAmnesty
Amnesty International Essay, Research Paper Ashley James Amnesty International Thousands of people are in prison because of their beliefs. Many are held without charge or trial. Torture and the death penalty are widespread. In many countries men, women, and children have “disappeared” after being taken into official custody.
Logotherapy By Dr Viktor E Frankl Essay
, Research Paper Logotherapy, practiced and described by Dr. Viktor E. Frankl, is a form of psychotherapy that requires individuals to assume responsibility for their own existence to search for meaning. Dr. Frankl, himself a prisoner in a Nazi concentration camp during World War II, developed this psychotherapeutic method as a means to endure the horror and suffering he witnessed and endured in the camp.
The Auschwitz Complex Essay Research Paper Auschwitz
The Auschwitz Complex Essay, Research Paper Auschwitz was and still is one of the most highly known concentration camps of the holocaust. The Auschwitz complex was the site of scientifically and efficiently executed
Concentration Camps Essay Research Paper Concentration CampsThe
Concentration Camps Essay, Research Paper Concentration Camps The Holocaust was one of the most terrible catastrophes in modern history. Before world war II about nine million Jews lived in Europe. Six million died in the war and a lot of them died in the concentration camps.
Sonnet 29 Essay Research Paper Rob BenkovicMrs
Sonnet 29 Essay, Research Paper Rob Benkovic Mrs. Stahl Period 8 5/8/00 Explication of “Sonnet 29” The reader can find Shakespeare’s dilemma in the first two stanzas. His problem is quite clear: he is lonely and depressed. As an outcast of society, he feels unlucky and thinks that there is no hope for him. Not even God can help him.
Treatment Of The Prisoners In The Concentration
Camps Essay, Research Paper Interdisciplinary Research Research Proposal The Treatment of the Prisoners in the Concentration Camps The topic that I plan to focus on in my research paper is treatment inside different concentration camps during the Holocaust. I plan to focus on three different camps, but I have not narrowed down my choices yet.
Night 3 Essay Research Paper Night by
Night 3 Essay, Research Paper Night by Elie Wiesel Hitler won t be able to do us any harm, even if he wants to. So begins the book, Night, by Elie Wiesel an autobiographical work about Elie s struggle to survive the Holocaust while living at multiple concentration camps. Beginning at age 15, Elie Wiesel moves from a young man questioning the accounts of German hatred, to becoming a witness of many inhumane acts brought upon people.
Allegory Of The Cave Analysis Essay Research
Paper In Plato?s "The Allegory of the Cave," he suggests that there are two different forms of vision, a "mind?s eye" and a "bodily eye." The "bodily eye" is a metaphor for the senses. While inside the cave, the prisoners function only with this eye. The "mind?s eye" is a higher level of thinking, and is mobilized only when the prisoner is released into the outside world.
Capital Punishment By Lethal Inject Essay Research
Paper The process of execution by lethal injection involves a carefully organized program. As it is stated in the article My Friend s Execution by William Vance Trollinger Jr. the process of execution is divided in a number of steps. First, two days before the execution, the prisoner is moved into the death cell, which is located in the depths of the prison.
Prison Prevents Violence Essay Research Paper Prison
Prison Prevents Violence Essay, Research Paper Prison Prevents Violence Violence is a major concern amongst the youths of this generation. It is an important issue that is being neglected. Several causes that may lead to this behavior would be the surroundings the youths are brought up in, or the image they wish to present themselves as – macho, tough, and untouchable.
Aushwitz Essay Research Paper AUSCHWITZBY CHRISTOPHER JAMES
Aushwitz Essay, Research Paper AUSCHWITZ CHRISTOPHER JAMES The Nazis establishes Auschwitz in April 1940, under the orders of Heinrich Himmler. Heinrich Himmler was in charge of two Nazi organizations. The camp at Auschwitz originally housed political prisoners from occupied Poland and various concentration camps from within Germany.
Unabomber Essay Research Paper In Michael Ventura
Unabomber Essay, Research Paper In Michael Ventura’s essay, “The Ties That Bind”, he explains the dilemma in which David Kaczynski (brother of Ted Kaczynski, the infamous Unabomber) faces. He can either: 1) betray his brother turning him in, 2) do nothing and let society down. Either way he is left feeling extreme guilt.
Auschwitz Essay Research Paper AuschwitzAuschwitz was not
Auschwitz Essay, Research Paper Auschwitz Auschwitz was not one but three different concentration and execution camps. Each camp had it own purpose. The first camp was called Auschwitz I. It was mainly used as a central camp for Nazi officers, producing economic and military-industrial enterprise, and holding enemies of the Nazis.
Plato The Allegory Of The Cave Essay
, Research Paper Theory of Dimensions In Plato s The Allegory of the Cave, allows an individual to realize that which they already know. The situation in the cave seems dark and gloomy, like a place no one would ever want to go. However, the reality is that some people are at a point in their lives where that is where they are, in their own cave .
Rehabilitaitng Prisons Essay Research Paper Rehabilitating PrisonsTo
Rehabilitaitng Prisons Essay, Research Paper Rehabilitating Prisons To help the prisoners in american prisons the government should establish a more rehabilitating punishments as to giving loneger harsher time. Now some people say if they did the crime they should pay the time and then some. But, wait they are not thinking about the prisoners.
North Korea Essay Research Paper One of
North Korea Essay, Research Paper One of the misconceptions about the North Korean prisoner camps, where the extraordinary amount of brainwashing happening in them. The communists gave the American prisoners of war some reeducating. Brainwashing proved in the long run to be unproductive, but it did keep 21 Americans in camp.
Fahrenheit 451
– Symbolism Essay, Research Paper Symbolism in Fahrenheit 451 Light, especially fire, and darkness are significantly reoccurring themes in Fahrenheit 451. Guy Montag, the main character, is a fireman, but in this futuristic world the job description of a fireman is to start fires wherever books are found; instead of putting them out.
Mt Olive Prison Essay Research Paper Mt
Mt. Olive Prison Essay, Research Paper Mt. OliveThe trip to the Mt. Olive State Prison was an experience that I will never forget. I had never thought of all the little things they do to keep the prison safe and under control. From the very start of the tour I thought to myself, “Why does it matter if we have more than one key, or earrings, or any other kind of jewelry.
Prisoner
’s Dilemma Essay, Research Paper The Prisoner’s Dilemma: A Stepping-Stone To The Refutation Of Pure Self-Interest And A Guide To Political And Moral Obligation
Theory Of Dimensions Essay Research Paper PhilosophyDavid
Theory Of Dimensions Essay, Research Paper Philosophy David Doriot December 8,2000 The theory of Dimensions In Plato?s? The Allegory of the Cave, allows a person to realize that which they already know. The situation in the cave is dark and gloomy, a place no one would ever want to go. However, the reality is that some people are at a point in their lives where that is where they are, in their own self-made ?cave?.
Everglade Dilemma Essay Research Paper Everglade DilemmaThe
Everglade Dilemma Essay, Research Paper Everglade Dilemma The worlds systems of life are of such complexity that even modern man can’t fully understand and predict it. The common word for this is Mother Nature and the question is the mystery of life. Life was created by a specific set of environmental and geologic features present at the same time.
Prisons Vs Resorts Essay Research Paper Prisons
Prisons Vs. Resorts Essay, Research Paper Prisons vs. resorts Imagine, you re sitting in a courtroom, where a murder trial has just taken place. The Judge says John Doe, you have been found guilty of murdering John Smith and Lisa Franks. Now comes the sentence. I hereby sentence you to 4 years at the Utah County Resort.