Of The Approaches To Language Development: Associationist, Cognitive Essay, Research Paper
Language development is a very important part of the overall development of the child, and has been a focus of attention for many years. Within the last forty years, there has been a progression of theories which attempt to account for the speed and success of the young child’s acquisition of language – the most recent of which is the functionalist (social interactionist) theory. This theory takes some of what is good from associationist (behaviourist), Chomskian (linguistic) and cognitive theories, and combines this with aspects which they tend to neglect, to make what is presently the most convincing theory of language acquisition. A brief resume of its forerunners is necessary in order to view functionalism in the correct way. In ‘Verbal Behaviour’ (1957), Skinner proposed a theory which accounted for language acquisition in purely behavioural terms: the child as a passive recipient learns language through extended classical and operant conditioning. Although such a theory has obvious shortcomings, it still attracts some followers. Chomsky responded to the behaviourist theory in 1959, when he stated his own theory based on linguistics: language is an innate ability for which there is a language acquisition device (LAD) in the brain, and every child is equipped with inborn knowledge about syntax and semantics (structured knowledge)- for example that actors perform actions on objects. “Learning is primarily a matter of filling in detail within a structure that is innate,” (Chomsky, 1976). The linguistic theory provided much of the impetus for subsequent research into language. The third theory on which functionalism draws is cognitive, based on the work of Piaget. Here, the child must be in possession of the semiotic function in order for language development to occur. These theories have provided much data which functionalists have used, as well as a starting point for a new theory. In functionalist theory, the child is seen as having an innate pre-disposition to learn language (as opposed to the cognitivist’s innate grammar), but he/she needs the environment to stimulate development. This is in contrast to the behaviourist notion that the environment is the sole source of language. Functionalism takes as its data the precursors and prerequisites to language. The fundamental belief is that language’s purpose is communication, whatever its syntax or semantics, and the child shows his/her intention to communicate even before language itself appears. The child demonstrates this by behaviours such as gazing at objects in which he/she is interested, in order to direct the mother’s attention: the mother is less likely to look away when the infant is gazing than when the infant is not gazing (Stern, 1974). The mother, or primary caretaker, helps to mould these communicative intentions, as she treats the child from the start as a conversational partner; any noise that the infant makes is regarded as her turn in the conversation, for example when she burps, the mother may respond with “Yes, that’s right!” (Snow, 1977). By seven months, the mother only responds to high quality vocalisations, and in this way, ’shapes’ the child’s behaviour. Despite the evident necessity of there being an intention to communicate for language to occur, this has been neglected in earlier theories. Behaviourists see the child as a passive recipient, who merely imitates what she hears, not as someone with active intentions. Linguistic theory ignores the precursors to language altogether – if language is innate, then there is little point in studying it precursor, and intent is taken for granted. Finally, cognitivists view the child very much as a separate entity, that is, they concentrate on what is going on in her head, not her social intentions. It seems that functionalism takes up an important aspect of language development that has hitherto received little attention. Similarly, functionalism emphasises the role of the infant-caretaker dyad: the unique relationship between mother and child provides a social and conceptual framework in which the infant learns what to say, and how and when to say it. Play is an important part of this, particularly games in which there are prescribed roles, and which follow the same pattern every time, such as ‘peekaboo’ teaching the child about turntaking: she learns that when the other person pauses, you perform a behaviour, and vice versa (Bruner, 1975). The mother’s language (known as ‘motherese’) which she uses with the child is also tailored to maximise development: it is repetitive, context-bound and ritualistic (Ferrier, 1978), which enables the child to come to expect a certain language in a certain situation, and it speech register is adapted to best suit the child’s hearing (Snow, 1978). Previous theories have tended to neglect the importance of this active partnership between mother and child; behaviourism recognises that the caretaker is important, as someone who provides the input on which the child bases her language, but it does not consider this as a relationship in which both partners have an active, interactive role, and develop to meet the changing demands of the other. Linguists, on the other hand, see a language almost as something that comes from within; the LAD simply has to ‘find out’ which language the child is learning and the child will assimilate her innate knowledge with what she hears. No real mention is made of input, or of the role of the mother. Similarly, cognitivists see language as dependent on something within the child (her concepts and abilities), not as something which is part of an interactive environment. Of course, not everything which has been put forward by the three older theories has been found to be incorrect; indeed, much of their data is used to support functionalist claims, and some aspects of each may also be viewed as evidence in favour of functionalism. This is inevitable as one may view functionalism as merely a logical progression from its predecessors. The basic claim of behaviourism, i.e. that language is acquired by the child hearing words and repeating them, is to a certain extent quite correct – input is essential to the development of any recognisable language (although it has been known for children with no input to create a very simple, symbolic language of their own). A phenomenon often cited in support of linguistic theories may be seen as evidence of the child’s creativity in language, i.e. her active role; all English speaking children go through a stage of overgeneralisation of rules, such as when they discover the rule that past tenses are formed by adding ‘-ed’ to the verb stem, they stop using the correct form of strong verbs and begin to so ‘goed’ ‘doed’, etc. Here they are actively creating their own small grammar based on rules. Many of the cognitivist’s assertions may be seen in this functionalist light, for example, that naming only begins to develop once the object concept has been grasped. Note, however, that Gopnik and Choi (1987) studies Korean, French and English children, finding that in Korean, language appears to affect cognition: verbs are more salient than nouns and children tend to perceive the world in terms of actions rather than objects. There is certainly a link between cognition, language and the environment, an important basis of functionalism. However, functionalism is a relatively new theory and in many respects has not been adequately assessed. For example, its proponents fail to state precisely how motherese help the child to learn language or if it is really causal at all. In fact, Shatz (1982) states explicitly that the gestural features of maternal speech do not help language acquisition. As to the interpretation of pre-linguistic communicative acts by the caretaker, it is very difficult to say whether the intention is conscious on the part of the child, or whether it is provided by highly motivated mothers – as much of what the child utters in the early stages is impossible to understand (Ryan, 1974). In addition, there are variations in the attitudes of mothers to the child’s communicative intent: middle class mothers are more anxious to ‘find’ this intent, whereas working class mothers are more laissez-faire (Howe, 1975). Speech data reported by Bowerman (1978) provides evidence that, concerning the extension of words to novel referents, function is not as relevant as perception, suggesting that it is perhaps not as salient to some aspects of language development as its supporters would believe. Although this may seem a reasonable amount of evidence to refute functionalism, we must remember that functionalism has yet to be fully developed and investigated, and that so far functionalism has tended to draw on data used by other theories. It seems clear from the evidence presented above that the field of language acquisition has always been a controversial one, probably due to its great importance in development. Several theories have been put forward which attempt to account for the data; however, these theories have tended to be succeeded usually because they have not considered all of the data, but have concentrated on a small area which seems to support their assertions. The most recent theory, functionalism or social interactionism, appears to be the most reliable in explaining the available data. Although it has yet to completely account for language acquisition, it certainly provides a sound basis on which future research may be carried out. Approx 1,500 words. Bibliography Bowerman (1978) ‘The Acquisition of Word Meaning’ in Waterson and Snow (eds); The Development of Communication; John Wiley, London. Bruner (1975) ‘Ontogenesis of Speech Acts’, Journal Of Child Language, vol 2. Chomsky (1976) Language Development (1979), Open University Press, Milton Keynes Ferrier (1978) ‘Some Observations of Error in Context’ in Waterson and Snow (eds) The Development of Communication; John Wiley, London. Shatz (1982) in Berko Gleason (1985), The Development of Language, London.
Другие работы по теме:
Microsoft Essay Research Paper Microsoft has had
Microsoft Essay, Research Paper Microsoft has had a couple of though months since July last year, when Judge Thomas Jackson ordered the company to break up in two. However, since the beginning of this year things have just looked better for Microsoft.
Jefferson Country School SystemJcss Essay Research Paper
Q1. Evaluate the process that JCSS used to select its vendors and software. A computer selection committee (most of the major users of the system such as assistant principals, deans, counselors, teachers, the personal director and the chief accountant) was appointed to evaluate available systems and recommend a vendor to the JCSS School Board.
God Vs Minos Essay Research Paper God
God Vs Minos Essay, Research Paper God Versus Minos The journey that life takes one on is sometimes long and difficult. There are many obstacles to overcome and decisions to make. Occasionally, one makes a bad judgement and, in consequence, commits a malevolent act. Although this act is resentful, one’s entire life is not based on this single action.
MediaUnbiased
& Objective?? Essay, Research Paper The media has tremendous power to shape the political agenda, shape our images of politicians and policies, and to influence our images of our society and ourselves. From this, the question arises whether it s possible to have an unbiased and objective news coverage. The answer to that is a simple no.
The Player Piano Essay Research Paper Evaluate
The Player Piano Essay, Research Paper Evaluate the effectiveness of diction as an adjunct to meaning in John Updike’s “Player Piano”. In “Player Piano”, John Updike uses personification to give life to a ?unhuman’ piano. By using diction to communicate his ideas, he effectively allows the reader to explore the psyche of a “Player Piano”.
Australia
– Monarchy Or Republic Essay, Research Paper Australia – Monarchy or Republic Even before James Cook discovered this continent that later would be named Australia, there where people living on this continent. They are being called Aboriginal and are the origin population of Australia. In the year of 1788 the first convicts are being sent to Australia because of over crowded prisons in Britain.
Solving Problems
– Group Work Essay, Research Paper I. Define the problem A. Why don’t students use study groups? B. Key Terms – study group: a group of people working together on a common problem
Cunsumer Credits Essay Research Paper ASK CONSUMERS
Cunsumer Credits Essay, Research Paper ASK CONSUMERS CREDIT SERVICES, INC. FEE AGREEMENT CONTRACT COPYRIGHT 1997 1. Have CLIENT send for his/her file from each of the three (3) major credit reporting agencies to review his/her credit files in order to evaluate the problems and develop the best course of action for correcting the errors therein for CLIENT, as spelled out in the AGREEMENT CONTRACT, paragraph number 1.
Gods Gift To Calculators The Taylor Series
Essay, Research Paper Gods Gift to Calculators: The Taylor Series It is incredible how far calculators have come since my parents were in college, which was when the square root key came out. Calculators since then
Experience That Influenced You Essay Research Paper
The prompt is: Describe and evaluate one experience that significantly influenced your academic interests. Be sure to explain how this experience led to your setting the goals you know have for yourself and why you think the academic program for which you are applying will help you to reach these goals.He Opened the Door to Anywhere and AnythingMr.
Hedda Gabler 2 Essay Research Paper Hedda
Hedda Gabler 2 Essay, Research Paper Hedda Gabler is not an easy character to get to know. At first reading she seems a bitter personality portrayed in an old-fashioned script set in an out-outmoded and foreign society. How could a woman in 102-year-old play possibly be understandable or relevant to the late-twentieth-century student? However, upon further examination,Hedda Gabler’s fictional reality not only offers us the opportunity to observe the art and social concerns of Ibsen’s day, but extends to us a paradigm by which we may compare and evaluate the principles of our day.
Ap English Essay Part 2 Question Essay
, Research Paper Kyle Newby October 22, 2000 AP English Emma essay A tale of an illegitimate child cast in the path of a rich and well to do socialite. How would their paths cross? What are they like, how do they act, and how are they characterized? Many times in literature authors use characters in their stories to characterize and evaluate other characters in the same story.
Poetry Paper Essay Research Paper There are
Poetry Paper Essay, Research Paper There are particular poems that seem to catch peoples eye, but while we read the poem we drop our attention. It is very difficult to evaluate these types of poems. Robert Hayden s, Those Winter Sundays, is the complete opposite of the type of poem that was just described. The title is quite bland, and the title is one of the first parts of a selection that seem to catch the eye.
COGNITIVE AND EMOTIONAL GROWTH Essay Research Paper
EVALUATION OF COGNITIVE AND EMOTIONAL GROWTH The child that I have chosen to evaluate is a boy named Eric. I chose Eric because I have been following his growth since September of 1998. Eric is a student in my seventh grade social studies class, and he was in my sixth grade social studies/language arts class last year.
Five Rings
– Wind Book Essay, Research Paper The wind book The wind book focuses on the faults of other schools in combat. In this section Musachi evaluates other schools and their styles. He points out the faults of the various styles. There are three main teachings of these schools. The first is to rely on an extra long sword.
Peer Gynt Essay Research Paper I have
Peer Gynt Essay, Research Paper I have just recently attended a play called Peer Gynt on the night of March 2, 2001. In seeing and writing this paper I was asked to evaluate one of the major characters in the production. So for my evaluation I have picked the character of Peer Gynt. In this paper I will evaluate many different items about the character and his contribution to the overall glimpse of the play I can portray to you.
Chronicle Of A Death Foretold Essay Research
Paper Chronicle of a Death Fortold, by Gabriel Marquez, is concerned with death in life and life in death. It was rainy on the day of Santiago Nasar’s murder, and yet by the account of others, it was not. His death is so mingled with illusory images that everything seems mystified: much like death itself. The fact that the story is about how a death consumes the lives of the entire town as well as the victim, shows that it is concerned with death in life and asks us to evaluate our own views.
Body Shop Essay Research Paper 1 Is
Body Shop Essay, Research Paper 1) Is Anita Rod*censored* correct when she claims that it is possible to run a business in a very ethical and socially responsible manner and still “give shareholders a wondrous return on their investment”?
Communication Roles Essay Research Paper In my
Communication Roles Essay, Research Paper In my life, the five most important roles I fill are as follows: father, head of household, son, student, and friend. Each role is very challenging and requires a lot of attention.
Analyzing Search Engines Essay Research Paper 1
Analyzing Search Engines Essay, Research Paper 1. Formulate five criteria for the evaluation of search enginesTo effectively evaluate three different search engines from the perspective of an advanced web user, the following criteria were established:
Describe And Evaluate Two Explanations Of The
Behaviour Of Crowds Essay, Research Paper Describe & Evaluate Two Explanations of the Behaviour of Crowds When people are alone, their behaviour can be different to when they are part of a crowd, and sometimes this change in behaviour can even lead to violence. When you consider that crowds exist in nearly all walks of life, such as work, sports and general social life, this can become a problem, so why is it that a persons behaviour does in fact change?
Evaluate Different Socological Approaches To Poverty Essay
, Research Paper Evaluate different sociological approach to the definition of poverty The definition of poverty is the centre of a farce debut. This is if the definition is absolute or relative poverty. The farce intensity of this debut became prominent in the late part of the 19th century and the early parts of the 20th century.
How Do We Evaluate Art Essay Research
Paper How Do We Evaluate Art? When we are trying to evaluate art, how do we know it is good or not? We usually fit our personal feelings to the good or bad decision. If the
Othello Treatment Of Women Essay Research Paper
Throughout history, the treatment of women has been an ever-changing issue. Othello by William Shakespeare is a story in which the women characters are treated in the unfair way that women of the time of the story were treated. This makes the story a great model for comparison of the treatment of women in the present time and in the past time when the story takes place.
Job Training Essay Research Paper Job TrainingPart
Job Training Essay, Research Paper Job Training Part I: The Importance of Training A new employee in the job of Banquet and Conference Services Manager will need training so that they can be as effective as possible in their job function. Although the new employee will come to the Statler with at least two years of experience in banquets or catering, there are still many skills to be learned or improved upon.
Passage To India Essay Research Paper
“A Passage to India” E.M. Forester’s novel, “A Passage to India” focuses upon cultural differences clearly exemplified through the cultures of the English and Indian. The central problem exists in two forms. One being a psychological conflict and the other being a literal conflict. The literal conflict is a simple one.
Marketing Case Study Essay Research Paper 1
Marketing Case Study Essay, Research Paper 1. EVALUATE THE PRESENT MARKETING STRATEGIES: Currently, O?Keefes owner Manuel Gray has successfully established a market segment with the ice hockey players. However, he wishes to diversify his operation with the introduction of public skating, much like the format of rollerskating rinks.
Athletic Training Essay Research Paper 1 The
Athletic Training Essay, Research Paper 1. The occupation is an athletic trainer. The job description is to work with athletes in an effort to prevent injuries. They work in amateur and professional sports. Once injuries occur, the athletic trainer is required to evaluate the problem and get the athlete the proper medical treatment.
Starbucks Essay Research Paper IntroductionThis report will
Starbucks Essay, Research Paper Introduction This report will evaluate and inform the reader about Starbucks corporate strategy from 1998 and into the future. This report will give a brief history, list strategies in 1998, and evaluate these strategies followed by a conclusion.
Gemini Project Essay Research Paper GEMINI PROJECT
Gemini Project Essay, Research Paper GEMINI PROJECT The Gemini Project was established as a way of advancing knowledge about ace and how to build space capsules better and safer. Thier were twelve Gemini missions with different goals and settings for the astronauts. Their were majors goals that went along with this project in which were needed to go to the next step with was the Apollo Program.
Tv Advertising Essay Research Paper TV Advertising
Tv Advertising Essay, Research Paper TV Advertising Of the three major types of advertising television, print and direct mail TV is by far the most costly and effective method. Research shows that TV advertisers spent a total of $29.5 billion in 1992. With these vast sums being spent, advertisers must carefully evaluate advertising costs, consumer exposure opportunities, and consumer buying strategies.
Vpn Essay Research Paper A company must
Vpn Essay, Research Paper A company must evaluate a variety of things when making networking decisions, especially when embarking on an expansion that would include