Gay Marriage Essay, Research Paper
Homosexuals should be allowed to marry because the disallowance of it violates their constitutional rights. Marriage is an institution long recognized by our government under the right to pursue happiness, and denying that right to any couple, regardless of gender, is unconstitutional. This argument, though, is not disputed. In fact, none of the arguments raised in opposition to the allowance of homosexual marriages takes into account the constitutional rights afforded to all humans. The arguments are only in relation to the possible repercussions (real or imagined) of granting these rights.
Our nation was built and has always been based on the fundamental principles of freedom expressed in the Declaration of Independence and through our Constitution. The opponents of homosexual marriage need to remember what freedom means to America, and understand the significance of setting a precedent that denies that freedom. The Supreme Court has long recognized that the institution of marriage is one of the rights guaranteed to all Americans by our Constitution. Banning same-sex marriage is discriminatory. Marriage is a basic human right and should not be denied to any individual. At various times in U.S. history, other minorities have been prevented from marrying: African-Americans, for example. Interracial marriage was also legally prohibited in various states, until the Supreme Court ruled such bans unconstitutional in 1967 (?Should Gay? 31).
At this time, however, marriage is only granted to heterosexual couples. Although homosexuals live under the same constitution, they are not afforded the same rights as heterosexuals. The reasons presented against the allowance of homosexual marriage are flimsy, and have nothing to do with the constitutional rights that are supposed to be afforded every American. All of the arguments against homosexual marriages have to do with the repercussions of granting the constitutional right of marriage to homosexuals, but not with the constitutional rights of homosexuals. The arguments offered are remarkably similar to the arguments offered 30 years ago against interracial marriages. Marriage plays an important role not only in people?s experience of daily living but also in our culture?s received ideals.
Marriage viewed as a cultural ideal is one way to explain the strength of the backlash against gay marriage. Legally married heterosexuals would not lose any legal right or material benefit if gays were allowed to get legally married (Mohr 22). Then why the fuss? There is no moral reason to support civil unions and not same- sex marriage unless one believes that admitting homosexuals would weaken a vital civil institution. This was the underlying argument for the Defense of Marriage Act (DOMA), which implied that allowing homosexuals to marry constituted an “attack” on the existing institution. The DOMA basically concludes that homosexuals are inherently depraved and immoral, allowing them to marry would inevitably spoil, and defame, the institution of marriage (Sullivan ?State? 18). This claim strays from the realm of traditional social policy enters the realm of cultural symbols. But symbols matter: it is chiefly in terms of symbols that people define their lives and have identities. Marriage viewed as a symbolic event, enacts, institutionalizes, and ritualizes the social meaning of heterosexuality. Part of the attraction of marriage for some heterosexuals, is that it confers status. One of the ways it does this is by distinguishing such people from homosexuals. If you remove that cultural status, you further weaken an already beleaguered institution (Sullivan ?State? 18). Marriage is the chief means by which culture maintains heterosexuality as a social identity, and is the social essence of heterosexuality. In consequence, on the plane of symbols and identities, if one did not get married, one wouldn?t be fully heterosexual. Using the same argument, if others were allowed to get married, one wouldn?t be heterosexual either (Mohr 22). This analysis explains why our government can claim that marriage by definition is the union of one man and one woman as husband and wife, even though this definition is circular, lacks any content, and defines nothing. The function of this definition is not to clarify or explain; its function is to assure heterosexual supremacy as a cultural form. (Mohr 22)
Supporting the civil union while opposing marriage is an incoherent position, based more on sentiment than on reason, more on prejudice than principle. Marriage, under any interpretation of American constitutional law, is among the most basic civil rights. “Separate but equal” was a failed and pernicious policy with regard to race; it will be a failed and pernicious policy with regard to sexual orientation. The many advances of recent years, the “domestic partnership” laws passed in many cities and states, the generous package of benefits finally granted in Hawaii, the breakthrough in Vermont–should not be thrown out. But neither can they be accepted as a solution, as some straight liberals and gay pragmatists seem to want. In fact, these half-measures, far from undermining the case for complete equality, only sharpen it. For there are no arguments for the civil union that do not apply equally to marriage. To endorse one but not the other, to concede the substance of the matter while withholding the name and form of the relationship, is to engage in an act of pure stigmatization. It risks not only perpetuating public discrimination against a group of citizens but adding to the cultural balkanization that already plagues American public life (Sullivan ?State? 18).
Particular religious arguments against same-sex marriage are rightly debated within the churches and faiths themselves. That is not the issue here: there is a separation between church and state in this country. Supporters are only asking that when the government gives out civil marriage licenses, those who are gay should be treated like anybody else. Of course, some argue that marriage is by definition between a man and a woman. But for centuries, marriage was by definition a contract in which the wife was her husband’s legal property. And that changed. For centuries, marriage was by definition between two people of the same race. That also changed. These things were changed because society recognized that human dignity is the same whether one is a man or a woman, black or white. No one has any more of a choice to be gay than to be black or white or male or female (Sullivan ?Let Gays? 26)
The matter is ultimately simple enough. Gay men and women are citizens of this country. After two centuries of invisibility and persecution, they deserve to be recognized as such. A random woman can marry a multimillionaire on a Fox TV special and the law will accord that marriage no less validity than a lifelong commitment between Billy Graham and his wife. The courts have upheld an absolutely unrestricted right to marry for deadbeat dads, men with countless divorces behind them, prisoners on death row, even the insane. In all this, we make a distinction between what religious and moral tradition, expect of marriage and what civil authorities require sanctioning it under law. It may well be that some religious traditions want to preserve marriage for heterosexuals in order to encourage uniquely heterosexual virtues. And they may have good reason to do so. But civil law asks only four questions before handing out a marriage license: Are you an adult; are you already married; are you related to the person you intend to marry; and are you straight? It’s that last question that rankles. When civil law already permits the delinquent, the divorced, the imprisoned, the sterile, and the insane to marry, it seems revealing that it draws the line at homosexuals (Sullivan ?State? 18).
Mohr, Richard D. “The Stakes in the Gay Marriage Wars.” The Gay and Lesbian Review 2000: 22.
“Should Gay Marriage be Legal?” U.S. News & World Report 3 June 1996: 31.
Sullivan, Andrew. “Let Gays Marry.” Newsweek 3 June 1996: 26.
—. “State of the Union – Why “Civil Union” Isn’t Marriage.” The New Republic 8 May 2000: 18.
Другие работы по теме:
Same Sex Marriage Essay Research Paper How
Same Sex Marriage Essay, Research Paper How do most couples show the world that they are in a loving, devoted, committed relationship? How does one express that they want to spend the rest of their life with one particular person? This is normally done through a marriage, celebrated by a wedding, certified by a marriage license.
Queers Essay Research Paper In this age
Queers Essay, Research Paper In this age of liberation and relative morality it is no surprise that homosexuals have tried very hard to gain ground in the way of civil rights. Homosexuals say they want equal rights, and they want homosexual-marriages to be legalized. However, what they are asking for is not reasonable.
Homosexuality Is Wrong Essay Research Paper Scriptures
Homosexuality Is Wrong Essay, Research Paper Scriptures from King James version – The Holy Bible I don’t understand how anyone believing in God can accept homosexuality as a normal way of life. In Chapter 19 of Genesis, two angels were sent to get Lot (a Godly man) and his family out of the city of Sodom. God was going to destroy the city because it was it was inhabited by all homosexuals.
Marriage Essay Research Paper Most couples spend
Marriage Essay, Research Paper Most couples spend a great deal of time, energy and money on a wedding ceremony that lasts a couple of hours. It is much easier to prepare for a successful wedding than a successful marriage. Marriage is an exciting process that does not come with a clearly outlined instruction book.
Making Adam And Steve A Reality Essay
, Research Paper Bigotry and discrimination are two things that should not be legally permitted in modern society, yet there are laws that permit, if not encourage discrimination against homosexual people. One of these laws is the inability for homosexual couples to be legally married. The simple truth is that homosexuals are religiously married everyday, but they are not entitled to the legal benefits of marriage such as tax breaks and legal inheritances.
Implied Attitudes In The Work Of Kate
Chopin Essay, Research Paper ?The Story of an Hour? and ?The Storm? are two greatly appreciated pieces of work written by Kate Chopin. The two stories differentiate in attitude toward marriage and its
Same Sex Marriages Essay Research Paper The
Same Sex Marriages Essay, Research Paper The way our soci ety views sexuality is that anything aside from being heterosexual is wrong. Homosexuals face many controversial issues, such as being banned from the military to marital laws. I feel that homosexuals should have all the same rights as heterosexuals and they should not be judged by their sexual orientation alone.
Sex Before Marriage Essay Research Paper Wait
Sex Before Marriage Essay, Research Paper Wait To Have Sex Although there are many people having sex, you shouldn’t. I am going to give you some reasons on why you shouldn’t. First of all, you
Lawfully Wedded Essay Research Paper Lawfully WeddedAre
Lawfully Wedded? Essay, Research Paper Lawfully Wedded? Are gay rights a fall in morals or the right decision? Gay rights have just recently come up in the media as being a controversial issue, but a Vermont court has decided that it is no longer an issue, but the gay?s constitutional rights. Many people think that it is about time a decision was made in favor of the gays, yet others say that the court is violating morals and the constitution.
Discrimination Against Gays Essay Research Paper discrimination
Discrimination Against Gays Essay, Research Paper discrimination against gaysAbout ten percent of the population is homosexually oriented and discriminated against. Discrimination denies lesbian and gay individuals or couples rights in today’s society. Problems that homosexuals face on a daily basis are employment in the military, encountering issues being a couple, and acceptance among others.
SameSex Marriage Essay Research Paper Samesex Marriage
Same-Sex Marriage Essay, Research Paper Same-sex Marriage The 8th Amendment talks about freedom of speech and freedom of living life. It is not true for everyone to live his/her life by choice. When one ask someone, he/she will tell that they are in favor of equal rights for homosexuals. They will all say that gay should have equal access to government benefits and equal protection of the law, but if someone ask them about gay marriage, all this talk of equality stops.
SameSex Marraige Equal Right Essay Research Paper
Same-Sex Marriage: Equal Rights for Everyone Most people these days are in favor of equal rights for homosexuals. They agree that gays should have the same rights in housing, jobs, public accommodations, equal access to government benefits, equal protection of the law, etc. Then you get to the subject of same-sex marriage and suddenly all of the talk about equality stops dead cold.
Argument Essay Essay Research Paper In today
Argument Essay Essay, Research Paper In today s society there are many couples that live together. Why let unmarried couples live together? There isn t a specific problem with unmarried couples that live out in the American Society. People are getting divorced left and right in today s age. More than 50% of marriages broke up during the decade of the 90 s.
Should Homosexual Ideas Be Taught In School
? Essay, Research Paper Should Homosexual Ideas Be Taught In School ? Nowadays, homosexuality is becoming more and more popular in the society. According to some experts, homosexuals are born homosexuals, and they do not
Marriage Essay Research Paper In the United
Marriage Essay, Research Paper In the United States most Americans have trouble understanding the concept of an arranged marriage. Arranged marriages not only affect individuals, but also society. I believe that arranged marriages are better then personal choice marriages. I came to this conclusion on the basis of other cultures other then the culture of the United States.
Family Marriage And Gender Roles Essay Research
Paper Family, Marriage, and Gender Roles At the core of American identities and American dreams lies a family. Throughout time, families serve as a connection between the individual and the outside world. The individual?s identity, his or her dreams, in large part depend on the family of origin or a family of choice.
Marriage Easy Divorce Essay Research Paper Marriage
Marriage: Easy Divorce Essay, Research Paper Marriage: Easy Divorce Although I do not agree with getting married until you are positive that you want to have a huge commitment to another person, I favor the easier divorce.
Homosexual Marriages Essay Research Paper Itani 1Homosexual
Homosexual Marriages Essay, Research Paper Itani 1 Homosexual Marriages Homosexuals should be allowed to marry because the disallowance of it violates their constitutional rights. Marriage is an institution long recognized by our government under the right to pursue happiness, and denying that right to any couple, regardless of gender, is unconstitutional.
Should Gays Or Lesbians Be All Essay
, Research Paper Topic: Should gays or lesbians be allowed to get married? In the 21st century, the age personal freedom and relative morality, there is no wonder why the homosexuals tried their very best to obtain social recognition, especially the right of homosexual marriage. Human rights and the freedom of choices, as a part of human rights, fortified their grounds.
Adoption By Gays Essay Research Paper Adoption
Adoption By Gays Essay, Research Paper Adoption by Gays is all right by me With this being an age when people are supposedly more open-minded, why is it that gays are frowned upon or denied when they want to adopt a child? Why is it that they are treated unfairly because of their sexual orientation? Many Americans are uncomfortable with the idea of gay parents.
Same Sex Marriage Essay Research Paper Same
Same Sex Marriage Essay, Research Paper Same Sex Marriage In order to address this issue, one must first define the concept or meaning of marriage. However, this is a rather subjective approach, because the way we define marriage depends on our own views and interpretations.
Aging And Marriage Essay Research Paper Reaction
Aging And Marriage Essay, Research Paper Reaction Paper: Marriage and Aging A big aspect in keeping a marriage successful is how much communication occurs between the two people involved. For a healthy relationship there is a need for quite a bit of communication. Communication, as stated in class, is one of the key elements to a successful marriage.
Gay Marriages Essay Research Paper The constitution
Gay Marriages Essay, Research Paper The constitution states that all men are created equal. If this is true, then why is there so much controversy involving a person’s sexual preference? Martin Luther King said it best when he stated that everyone has a dream. Why then rain on someone’s dream when all they want to do is love each other? Homosexuals are fighting for what they deserve: the freedom that every citizen has the right to love whoever they want to.
Gay Rights Essay Research Paper GAY RIGHTSOur
Gay Rights Essay, Research Paper GAY RIGHTS Our society is composed of homosexuals. We often see them walking on the streets or maybe sitting right next to us. However, do we really know what are homosexuals? During our elementary years in school, we were taught that if a person is attracted of the same sex, he/ she is to be consider homosexual.
Persuasive Essay Gay And Lesbian Rights Essay
, Research Paper Persuasive Essay – Gay and Lesbian Rights “If anyone says, ‘I love God,’ yet hates his brother, he is a liar. For anyone who does not love his brother, whom he has seen cannot love God, whom he
Gay And Lesbian Essay Research Paper Gay
Gay And Lesbian Essay, Research Paper Gay and Lesbian Adoption Adoption has long been a way for a loving family who cannot have children on their own, or a family with some extra love to give to have children. Today, adoption has taken a turn for the worse, Gay and Lesbian couples who of course cannot children are adopting kids.
Samesex Marriages Essay Research Paper Legalization of
Same-sex Marriages Essay, Research Paper Legalization of Same-Sex Marriages The right to marry should be a fundamental human right. Same sex marriages being legalized would make health coverage and other benefit plans available to gay and lesbian committed couples, it would allow the simple right to a minority to form a committed partnership with a loved one, as well as contribute to the public acceptance of same-sex relationships.
Gay Marriage Essay Research Paper Gay Marriage
Gay Marriage Essay, Research Paper Gay Marriage Just about anyone would tell you they’re in favor of equal rights for homosexuals. Just name the situation, and ask. They’ll all say, yes, gays should have the same rights in housing, jobs, public accommodations, equal access to government benefits, and equal protection of the law.
Do Gays Have The Right To Marry
Essay, Research Paper Do Gays Have the Right to Marry? Do gays have the right to marry? This topic was under legal scrutiny during the last congressional election. The Citizens of Hawaii voted against a proposal that would make marriages among gays legal. In fact, in recent years, gays and lesbians have had more attention focused on them.