Compromise Of 1850 Essay, Research Paper
December 20, 1995
American Studies
By the 1850’s the Constitution had become a source of sectional discord and tension due to the different interpretations taken by the North and South. The North’s interpretation was that slavery was immoral and not protected under the Constitution. The South, on the other hand, interpreted the Constitution as recognizing slavery where it existed. In addition, the acquisition of new land brought into question the expansion of slavery and the balance of power between the free states and slave states. The interpretations that both sides vindicated were irreconcilable; slavery was a necessity to the Southern way of life, and Northerners shared different views; effective compromises could not be achieved and ultimately this led to failure of the Union that the Constitution had created.
After the Missouri Compromise had established the 36.30′ line that divided the national domain between the North and South, the Compromise of 1850 threatened to break the sectional balance. The admission of California as a free state would create an imbalance in the senate, which stood at 15 states each for the North and South. This is evident from Document A. Essentially, admitting California would grant greater political power to free states, and therefore create a conflict between the North and South. However, the admission of the Utah and New Mexico territory under the premise of popular sovereignty almost guaranteed that they would be slave states; it was mainly inhabited by Southerners and the climate was more conducive for Southern products, namely cotton.
The sectional sentiment that was aroused by the Compromise of 1850 is obviously present in Document B, a letter from an anonymous Georgian. In his “Plain Words for the North” the Georgian emphasizes that the Constitution “recognizes slavery where it exists” and that unless this view is respected by the North, the “destruction [of the Constitution] is inevitable.” However in Document E, Garrison, an extreme abolitionist whose motto was “No Union with Slaveholders.” argued that the Constitution “never intended to give any protection or countenance to the slave system”. Thus the question arises, “Does the Constitution protect slavery as an institution?”
Since the framers of the Constitution did not explicitly condone or embrace slavery, the decision was left to Congress, the President, and the courts to supplement and implement any judgment concerning the issue. Although slavery was not mentioned in the Constitution, the context of it essentially supports slavery – many of the signers of the Constitution were slave owners. However, Northerners such as Emerson, (Document D) who addressed the Fugitive Slave Law, argued that slavery was immoral and foresaw the ending of the Union. Southerners, on the other hand, saw slavery as their natural right and regarded the three-fifths clause as evidence that slaves did not hold the rights of citizenship.
Southerners were aided in their argument by the Supreme Court decision Dred Scott (1857), which ruled that African Americans had no civil rights, and that the Missouri Compromise was unconstitutional. Although the decision was made on the basis of the interpretation of the Constitution, it also reflected the susceptibility of the court to be influenced by personal views and politics – several of the justices were slave owners. Even though the court decision settled the question of slavery expansion and strengthened the South’s position, it ironically fueled the Republican movement after the defeat of the Lecompton constitution and the admittance of Kansas as a free state.
Aided by the anti-slavery sentiment in the North, which had the majority of the electoral votes, the Republican party, led by Abraham Lincoln, was able to win the Election of 1860. With virtually no support in the South and only 40 percent of the popular vote, the election of Lincoln was a terrible political defeat for the southerners; he had been elected to office on the strength of the anti-slavery ballot. This revealed the importance of the electoral vote and the inability of the Constitution to establish equitable voting methods.
After Lincoln’s election in 1860, South Carolina, which saw secession as the only alternative left to protect their way of life and liberty, challenged federal authority and attempted to coerce other southern states to join them. On February 7, 1871, seven slave states declared independence, joined the Confederate States of America and elected Jefferson Davis president.
In Davis’ message to the Confederate Congress (Document H), he expressed his view that the Constitution set up a compact between independent states, rather than a national government made up of states. The misconception that the Constitution set up a national government, he said, was the perception of a certain political school in the North. In contrast, Lincoln’s message in Document I, questions how the Southern States (Secessionists) could withdraw from the Union without the consent of the other states.
As these two documents have pointed out, the different interpretations by which Northerners and Southerners interpreted the Constitution was one of the main sources of sectional discord and tension. Despite efforts at preserving the Union, social and economic forces were pulling the North and South apart. Both were progressing, but divergently. Northern society was being cultured by the industrial revolution, and by educational and humanitarian movements that had little effect in the South. Southern society was dominated by agriculture, and therefore slavery was a necessary institution and way of life. Since the North and South were essentially two different societies united under one common law, it seemed inevitable that the conflict over slavery and political power would arise. It would have been impossible to accommodate the differences between the North and South under one law that applied to both. Therefore the only solution to preserve the union would be to either abolish or accept slavery -
Другие работы по теме:
Expansionist Tension Essay Research Paper From 1800
Expansionist Tension Essay, Research Paper From 1800 to 1850 territorial expansion tore the United States apart. Territorial expansion itself was not a debated issue. Spurred by the concept of Manifest Destiny, almost everyone believed that America should extend from sea to shining sea and maybe even farther.
Great Compromises Essay Research Paper Would the
Great Compromises Essay, Research Paper Would the United States of America ever be united if it were not for compromises? I would say the chances are slim. During the early years of the new nation, there was a lot of conflict and turmoil. During the Constitutional Convention of 1786, one of the most essential compromises of the early United States was the Great Compromise.
Emily Essay Research Paper Emily and I
Emily Essay, Research Paper Emily and I were in love. She lived in North Carolina and I lived in Ohio. It wasn’t an easy relationship. We communicated often. We met in August. She was diagnosed with cancer in her knee in December. It started in her knee, but had spread too much through out her body. She was dying.
Laghston Hughes Essay Research Paper RPG Vault
Laghston Hughes Essay, Research Paper RPG Vault: Tor Andre Wigmostad – December 23, 1999 It’s the year 29,475 AD, and there isn’t a single elf in sight. Humanity has colonized much of the
U.S. Events In 1850
′S Essay, Research Paper In United States history, the events of the 1850’s proved to be the staging ground for disastrous Civil War of 1861-1865. Two examples were the Fugitive Slave Act and the Kansas-Nebraska Act. These events greatly affected the country at the time and in the long run.
Webster Essay Research Paper After the Whig
Webster Essay, Research Paper After the Whig Party was formed in 1834, Webster became one of its leaders, receiving the electoral vote of Massachusetts for President in 1836. In 1841 Webster was appointed secretary of state by President William Henry Harrison, a position he retained under President John Tyler.
Slavery Is The South Essay Research Paper
Slavery is the South Essay #3 Slavery played a dominating and critical role in much of Southern life. In the struggle for control in America, slavery was the South?s stronghold and the hidden motive
Crucible 2 Essay Research Paper It is
Crucible 2 Essay, Research Paper It is more noble to die with integrity than it is to compromise one s principle in order to live. —– Danforth: I say, will you confess yourself, Goody Nurse? Rebecca: Why it is a lie, it is a lie;; how may I damn myself? I cannot, I cannot. —–Arthur Miller s, The Crucible, was a play with many themes.
Great Compromise Essay Research Paper After arriving
Great Compromise Essay, Research Paper After arriving at Philadelphia the representatives from the thirteen colonies decided to scrap the old Articles of the Confederation, even with explicit instructions form Congress to only adjust. Many ideas were tossed around including the plan by the heavily populated colony of Virginia, which was called “the large-state plan”.
Religion Is Important Essay Research Paper I
Religion Is Important Essay, Research Paper I think culture, religion, ethnicity is very important in one’s life. They should know where there from and who they are. Everyone comes from somewhere around the world, even if they were born in another country, they still
Dred Scott Case Essay Research Paper The
Dred Scott Case Essay, Research Paper The Dred Scott case is one of the most significant cases in American history. Dred Scott was a former slave of a master named, Peter Blow. When Mr. Blow became financially in trouble he sold Dred Scott to Dr. John Emerson who was a physician. The military career of Dr. Emerson he traveled to many places including Illinois which at the time it was prohibited to own a slave which was stated in the Missouri Compromise of 1820.
Pro Choice Essay Research Paper Without a
Pro Choice Essay, Research Paper Without a woman’s right to do what she chooses with her body, her freedom and liberty are taken away. If for personal reasons, a women wants
The First Reactor Essay Research Paper The
The First Reactor Essay, Research Paper The First Reactor The First Reactor chronicles the conception and implementation of the first self-sustaining nuclear pile. The booklet has three main sections to it. The first one tells of the history and background of the organizations and research that were used for the momentous experiment, as well as the actual proceedings that occurred on December 2, 1942.
Sample Resume Essay Research Paper December 7
Sample Resume Essay, Research Paper December 7, 2000 Mr. Brian P. Coyle Bear Grossing Drive Orlando, FL 32476 Dear Mr. Coyle: You have the company’s deepest apology for the disaster and inconvenience that was placed upon you. Pictures are very important because they serve as memories that you can have for a lifetime.
Clay Essay Research Paper Henry Clay 17771852
Clay Essay, Research Paper Henry Clay (1777-1852), American statesman, who was secretary of state under John Quincy Adams and an unsuccessful candidate for the presidency in 1824, 1832, and 1844. He was one of the most popular and influential political leaders in American history. His genius in the art of compromise three times resolved bitter political conflicts that threatened to tear the nation apart, winning him the title The Great Pacificator.
Social Evils Essay Research Paper December 15
Social Evils Essay, Research Paper December 15, 1998 Social Evils Because I was brought up in a protected environment, it wasn’t until I was seventeen or eighteen when I learned of the evil prejudices that are in our world. Today isn’t as bad as yesterday, and hopefully tomorrow will be even better, but we must be reminded of our wrongdoings, so that they do not happen again.
Gangs Essay Research Paper la Springer Parent
Gangs Essay, Research Paper la Springer Parent and Child Development Tuesday, December 5, 2000 Gangs a Violent Reality Gangs are a violent reality that people have to deal with in today?s society. Kids
The Impeding Crisis Essay Research Paper An
The Impeding Crisis Essay, Research Paper An Impending Crisis The Missouri Compromise provided for the admission of Maine into the Union as a free state, the admission of Missouri into the Union as a slave state, and the removal of slavery north of Missouri. Importantly, this compromise reaffirmed the principle established in the Northwest Ordinance that Congress could, if it chose, prohibit slavery in the territories.
Republicans And The Crittenden Amendments Essay Research
Paper Republicans and the Crittenden Amendments Throughout the election of 1860, Republicans professed their strong platform, a platform that included the fateful promise of nonextension of slavery. On May 16, 1860, Republicans openly proclaimed, We deny the authority of Congress, of a territorial legislature, or of any individuals, to give legal existence to Slavery in the United States.
Compromise Of 1850 Essay Research Paper Clinton
Compromise Of 1850 Essay, Research Paper Clinton Jolts Canadians With a Plea On Federalism In Ottawa, Canadians on both sides of the nation’s deep linguistic divide say they were stunned by President Clinton’s unexpectedly passionate appeal for national unity and federalism.
Rockhampton Essay Research Paper Rockhampton Facilities and
Rockhampton Essay, Research Paper Rockhampton Facilities and Popular Attraction Compared to Other Cities Rockhamptons biggest attraction would be that it is the beef capital of Australia. {more information how it was the beef capital and when it was} Rockhampton was discovered in 1850 when gold and copper were discovered about 100 km away promoting this town’s growth as an agricultural market and port.
Comp Of 1850 Essay Research Paper The
Comp Of 1850 Essay, Research Paper The Compromise of 1850 The Compromise of 1850 was a series of five legislative enactment’s, passed by the US Congress during August and September 1850. These measures were designed
Compromise Of 1850 Essay Research Paper The
Compromise Of 1850 Essay, Research Paper The Compromise of 1850 The Compromise of 1850 was a series of acts passed in 1850, by which the United States Congress hoped to settle the strife between the opponents of slavery in the North and slave owners in the South. There is much speculation about how our country would be without this Compromise.
Compromise Of 1850 Essay Research Paper Compromise
Compromise Of 1850 Essay, Research Paper Compromise Measures of 1850 also known as the Compromise of 1850.This act was a series of five legislative enactment’s passed by United States Congress. Many territories from the west were now asking for admittance into the United States as an official state. This brought many questions to the table.
Trenton Battle Essay Research Paper THE
Trenton Battle Essay, Research Paper THE BATTLE OF TRENTON_________________________________________________ The Battle of Trenton was fought last night December 26,1776. As we all know before this battle, The Continental Army wasbeing badly beaten by the British forces. They were in need ofeverything from food to new uniforms and weapons.
Civil War Causes Essay Research Paper Causes
Civil War Causes Essay, Research Paper Causes of the Civil War Although some historians feel that the Civil War was a result of political blunders and that the issue of slavery
Winning In Sports Essay Research Paper Winning
Winning In Sports Essay, Research Paper Winning isn’t everything. It is the only thing. Like my father before me, I have a violent temper with which I have been struggling all my life, and with which I have had to effect a compromise. It is ineradicable, but it must not be irrational.
Compromise Of 1850 Essay Research Paper Drifting
Compromise Of 1850 Essay, Research Paper ?Drifting Toward Disunion? The Compromise of 1850 The annexation of Texas to the United States and the gain of new territory by the Treaty of Guadeloupe Hidalgo aggravated the hostility between the North and South. The controversial issue of slavery in the new territories arose again along with many other political differences that needed to be resolved.
Compromise On Public Policy Is Essay Research
Paper Compromising on Public Policy Issues: Is This Good or Bad? A public policy is a set of principles that directs government actions. The policy may take one of many forms laws, rules, programs, money, court decisions and even customs and traditions. These policies affect everyone, but not always in the same way.