Comedy Versus Tragedy Essay, Research Paper
SHAKESPEARE:
Tragedy versus Comedy
Undeniable similarities can be drawn between two Shakespearean masterpieces, “A Midsummer-Night’s Dream” and “Romeo and Juliet”. These similarities involve themes and classical Shakespearean character types. Both plays have a distinct pair of lovers, the confused couple, Hermia and Lysander, and the romantic couple, Romeo and Juliet. Both works could have also easily been transformed into the opposite with a few effortless modifications. A tragedy is a play in which one or more characters have a moral flaw that leads to his or her downfall. On the other hand, a comedy has at least one humorous character, and then a successful and/or happy ending. Comparing these two particular Shakespearean plays is helpful to find how Shakespeare uses similar character types in a variety of different situations, and the wonderful versatility of the themes he utilizes.
In “Romeo and Juliet”, Juliet is young, “not yet fourteen”, and she is beautiful. Romeo’s reaction after he first sees her is,
“O, she doth teach the torches to burn bright!
It seems she hangs upon the cheek of night
Like a rich jewel in an Ethiope’s ear;
Beauty too rich for use, for the earth too dear!”
Romeo is awestruck by her magnificent beauty. It is love at first sight. Yet young Juliet is sensible, “?although [she feels] joy in [Romeo], [she would] have no joy in this contract tonight. It is too rash, too unadvised, too sudden.” She feels that since their relationship is still undeveloped they should not be childish and ?swear? by each other?s love. She also implies that since they are still early in their affair they will definitely be abstaining from sexual intercourse.
One massive impasse in the young lover?s relationship is the constant quarreling of their stubborn parents. Because of these feuds, their parents would never allow the lovers to be together. They were quite auspicious that they kept the affair veiled from their parent?s attention.
In both the couple?s lives involve an outside presence for help. Juliet and Romeo seek the assistance of Friar Lawrence. The Friar tries to make their relationship work to the best of his ability. Though in the end most his attempts fail. Another character that helped the young lovers is Juliet?s nurse. Since the nurse loved Juliet so dearly, she tried everything she could to make her sweet Juliet happy. Most of the involvement the nurse had worked for the best.
Comparable to Juliet is Hermia. She too is young, beautiful, and sensible. Lysander eagerly suggests that “One turf shall serve as a pillow for both of us, One heart, one bed, two bosoms, and one troth.” Hermia intelligently replies, “Nay, good Lysander. For my sake, my dear, lie further off yet; do not lie so near.” Although their relationship is a slight more developed than Romeo and Juliet?s, Hermia still attempts to attain her purity and her innocence. She abstains from sleeping near Lysander even though she believes he does not have tainted intentions.
In a different fashion Hermia is forbidden to marry Lysander. Hermia’s father Egeus states to Theseus, Duke of Athens,
“Full of vexation come I, with complaint
against my child, my daughter Hermia.
Stand fourth, Demetrius. My noble lord,
This man hath my consent to marry her.
Stand forth, Lysander: and, my gracious Duke,
This man hath bewitched the bosom of my child:”
Egeus tells the Duke that he permits the marriage of Demetrius and Hermia, but prohibits the groom to be Lysander. Hermia believes that both men are equal. And she wants to marry the man that she is happy with, not the man she is permitted to marry.
Hermia and Lysander also seek the help of another. While leaving to secretly be together they attain the aid of Lysander?s aunt who lives in the woods near Athens.
There are well-built parallels in ?Romeo and Juliet? and ?Midsummer-Nights Dream?. Such as young lovers, forbidden love affairs, controlling parents, and unforeseen occurrences. And with a few simple adjustments “A Midsummer-Night’s Dream” could have effortlessly become a tragedy, while “Romeo and Juliet” transformed into a comedy. Shakespeare often uses many of the same character types: young, prudent, rebellious lovers, and controlling family members, in both comedies and tragedies. The end results being character molds, along with theme patterns that can be easily translated into almost any plot, in any play.
Другие работы по теме:
Oedipus The King Essay Research Paper 3
Oedipus The King Essay, Research Paper 3. How Sophocles? Oedipus the King fits the description of tragedy provided by Aristotle? Why does Aristotle believe tragedy is superior to epic poetry?
Taking Versus Giving Essay Research Paper Speak
Taking Versus Giving Essay, Research Paper Speak to the people of Israel and take for me a contribution from each person according to the generosity of his heart take My contribution (Shmot 25:2).
Greek Tragedy Essay Research Paper The Greek
Greek Tragedy Essay, Research Paper The Greek Tragedy The tragedy was a large part of people’s lives in ancient Greece. Tragedies became prominent long before Christ was born. A tragedy, or goat-song, usually were seen during festivals in ancient Greek times. Tragedies gradually increased in seriousness until they were given utmost importance.
Playwrights Aeschylus Sophocles And Euripides Essay Research
Paper The starting point when discussing comedy and tragedy would be to define the main terms. Comedy is the dramatic genre that focuses on human weakness through humor. Comedy celebrates the regeneration of life through love and reconciliation. Tragedy is the dramatic genre initiated by ancient Greek playwrights such as Aeschylus, Sophocles, and Euripides.
Problem Of Genre Essay Research Paper Problem
Problem Of Genre Essay, Research Paper Problem of Genre in Drama When a reader thinks of a play that has been labeled a comedy he thinks of light-hearted and happy plots. The reader would not think of family tension, arguments or even perversion. The genre of comedy takes on the responsibility of making the audience laugh and walk away from the production with a satisfied feeling.
Tragedy Essay Research Paper What makes a
Tragedy Essay, Research Paper What makes a tragedy tragic? Though the dictionary makes the word tragic seem like an accident or a bad happening, I think what makes a tragedy tragic is more than events, which occur through out a piece of writing. It is more of a feeling than a physical action or specific event.
Columbine Essay Research Paper Columbine Cause and
Columbine Essay, Research Paper Columbine: Cause and Effect The Columbine tragedy has struck another victim last week. If all thoughts were that the tragedy was behind us, no one has considered the effects of the massacre. A student that was injured in the massacre was making progress on recovering, when backlash from the tragedy struck.
Mid Summer Night
’s Dream Essay, Research Paper In Shakespeare’s, MIDSUMMER NIGHT’S DREAM, he wrote about a tragedy that he turned into a comedy. He did this to show his audience how stupid humans can act upon their emotions. There are three plots that tie together with one main situation. There is Hermia and Lysander, two star crossed lovers that can’t be together.
Shakesphere Essay Research Paper When a play
Shakesphere Essay, Research Paper When a play that was written by William Shakespeare is presented to an audience, the audience automatically assumes that the play will have tragic or dramatic connotation. But is there a such thing as a Shakespearean comedy? This question is answered when Shakespeare s The Comedy of Errors is read.
Shakespearean Comedy Essay Research Paper Shakespeare is
Shakespearean Comedy Essay, Research Paper Shakespeare, is quite possibly one of English literature?s most esteemed and influential writers/playwrights, in history. His talent for composing classic scripture shines through his comedies, A Midsummer Night?s Dream, in particular. In this play, Shakespeare incorporates many distinct types of comedy to accent his knack for creating heart-felt plays that have deeply touched millions.
Shakespearean Comedy Essay Research Paper Suzanne KirbyCOMEDY
Shakespearean Comedy Essay, Research Paper Suzanne Kirby COMEDY IN SHAKESPEARE Shakespeare s comedies can be recognised in terms of plot, structure and characters. We can see that Shakespearean comedies follow the same structural pattern, a basic plot on which the play is based. For example, a key feature of all comedies is that they depend upon the resolution of their plots.
Measure For Measure Essay Research Paper Shakespeare
Measure For Measure Essay, Research Paper Shakespeare’s theatrical works are generally categorized into three all encompassing groups: the uplifting comedy, the lamented tragedy, and the excruciatingly boring history play. However, things can get a little confusing when you end up with a comedy like Measure for Measure or a tragedy like Titus Andronicus.
Characteristics Of Comedy (Much Ado About Nothing)
) Essay, Research Paper Characteristics of Comedy There are many characteristics that make up a comedy. Characteristics such as mistaken identity, battle of the sexes, and jumping to conclusions are what set the comedic story apart from the tragedy. Within a comedy, no matter how much fault, and dismay may appear within the story, there always seems to be the classic ending of “…and they all lived happily ever after…” Comedies capture the viewer with a sense of compassion and love for the characters in the story.
Velocity Essay Research Paper Instantaneous Versus Average
Velocity Essay, Research Paper Instantaneous Versus Average Velocity A position versus time graph or a displacement versus time graph can be used to analyze the motion of an object in one dimension. The slope gives the object’s velocity. The slope of a line segment joining two points on the graph gives the average velociy during that interval.
Oedipus Rex Essay Research Paper There have
Oedipus Rex Essay, Research Paper There have been many tragedies throughout history, including Sophocles play Oedipus Rex. I utterly agree with Aristotle in saying that Oedipus Rex, is one such tragedy. Through the plot, character and thoughts it is evident the Oedipus Rex is a model tragedy.
Comdey Essay Research Paper Ryan Zimmerman21600Some may
Comdey Essay, Research Paper Ryan Zimmerman 2/16/00 Some may say that comedy is a philosophy of life, and that it is an always changing art form. People also say comedy can sometimes even be considered to be a personal expression of a person?s world around them, a way to communicate thoughts and feelings in a very non-serious way.
Allegory In The Divine Comedy Essay Research
Paper Dante wrote The Divine Comedy between 1308 and 1321. The Divine Comedy was written as an allegory, Which is a narrative that takes place on both a literal and a figurative or symbolic level. Dante uses himself as the main character and uses allegory to describe himself in the epic.
Poetics Essay Research Paper The subject of
Poetics Essay, Research Paper The subject of the Poetics is poetry, including epic poetry, tragedy and comedy. Unlike Plato, Aristotle regards poetry as a techne. The practice of poetry is governed by rules; these rules can be formulated and taught. Poetry is rationally comprehensible.
John Minnie And Petie A Love Triangle
Essay, Research Paper Karen Rayne Mrs. Wolf English 102.004 2 March 2001 John, Minnie, and Petie, A Love Triangle: Comedy and Tragedy in Susan Glaspell’s Trifles
Conflict In The Miracle Worker Essay Research
Paper In my opinion, all the types of conflict occur in ?the Miracle Worker?. There is internal conflict such as man versus self. There is also external conflict such as man versus man, man
Romeo And Juliet Tragedy Of A Family
Or A City? Essay, Research Paper Romeo and Juliet: Tragedy of A Family or A City? Is Romeo and Juliet’s death a tragedy of two families or a tragedy of a city? In the following quote, W. H. Auden says, “The tragedy of Romeo and
Hamlet Appearance Vs Reality Essay Research Paper 2
Hamlet Appearance Vs. Reality Essay, Research Paper Appearance vs. Reality The theme of appearance versus reality has shown up in some of the major works read this year. The themes were present in William Shakespeare?s play The Tragedy of Hamlet, Prince of Denmark and also in the epic poem Beowulf. In both plays the topic was evident during the plot of each story.
Cruel Tears Essay Research Paper In reading
Cruel Tears Essay, Research Paper In reading the play Cruel Tears, you will find that there is definitely a tragedy. However, it is unclear as to what the tragedy is caused by. In looking at Johnny and Jack you can start to unwind this debatable event. Did Johnny s weakness or Jack s jealousy cause this tragedy? It is unfortunate that more history of the relation between Johnny and Jack is not available.
Human Comedy Essay Research Paper One Day
Human Comedy Essay, Research Paper One Day Homer Macauley signs up for a telegram delivery job and gets it. While he delivers these letters he discovers the truth about love, hope, and pain
Conflicts Essay Research Paper ConflictsIn the three
Conflicts Essay, Research Paper Conflicts In the three stories To Build a Fire, The Use of Force, and A and P there are some different conflicts. A conflict is struggle between two or more objects. In these stories the three different conflicts are man versus nature, man versus man, and man versus self. The three stories that contain these conflicts are To Build a Fire by Jack London, The Use of Force by Williams Carlos Williams, and A and P by John Updike.
The Cherry Orchard Essay Research Paper Not
The Cherry Orchard Essay, Research Paper Not a Laugh There is a convincing debate whether The Cherry Orchard is a tragedy or a comedy. Chekhov strongly argues that the play is a comedy and should be performed as a comedy. The philosopher Aristotle can support Chekhov perception of his play. Aristotle defines a comedy as “an imitation of characters of a lower type who are not bad in themselves but whose faults possess something ludicrous in them.” The misinterpretation of The Cherry Orchard is due to a misunderstanding of what a comedy is.
Something About Mary Essay Research Paper Something
Something About Mary Essay, Research Paper Something about Mary Its a comedy film, that came to Spain in November of the 1998. It was directed by the Farinelli brothers. And his main stars are: Cameron Diaz (Mary), Matt Dylon (a strange detective) and Ben Stiller (Ted).
Hamlet And Tragedy Essay Research Paper Peter
Hamlet And Tragedy Essay, Research Paper Peter Gillis April 20, 2001 Block 4 Hamlet: A Tragedy When you think of William Shakespeare, Hamlet is the first thing most people think of, as his work. Hamlet is also a classic example of a tragedy. In all tragedies the hero suffers, and usually dies at the end. All good pieces of literature written way back when, are usually tragedies.
As You Like It By William Shakespeare
(1564 – 1616) Essay, Research Paper One of Shakespeare’s most famous works, As You Like It possesses many classic elements of comedy. The personal divisions at the outset (two Duke-brothers at war, two other brothers filled
PARADISE LOST Essay Research Paper THE PURPOSE
PARADISE LOST Essay, Research Paper THE PURPOSE OF CLASSICAL TRAGEDY IS TO AROUSE PITY AND FEAR AND THUS TO PRODUSE IN THE AUDIENCE A CATHARSIS {PROPER PURGATION} OF THESE EMOTIONS THAT HE AS A SPECTATOR OWNS. THE AUDIENCE SENSE OF PITY TOWARDS THE HERO OCCURS BECAUSE THE HERO THROUGH HIS TRAGIC FLAW {HAMARTIA} BECOMES A TRAGIC BUT REMAINS A NOBLE FIGURE.
My Dog Essay Research Paper My dog
My Dog Essay, Research Paper My dog has a hat, and the hat has a shoe and that show is you. How many dogs is there in a mile to get to the other side of the siterate substance. It is known that is Shakespear’es tragedies main chatcaters die in the end,a nd in his comedy people marry. SInce Romeo and juliet is a tragedy, romeo and juliet are going to die in the end.