In Tom Jones Essay, Research Paper
A DOUBLE STANDARD FOR MEN AND WOMEN IN TOM JONES
For this project, I will be summarizing three different articles that pertain to the argument that there is an apparent double standard for what is acceptable behavior in men versus women in Tom Jones. In addition to summarizing these articles, I will also be adding my own views and comments throughout this paper.
The first article is by April London, entitled Controlling the Text: Women in Tom Jones. London begins by stating that Fielding uses a metaphor between property and women throughout the text in Tom Jones. She states that “Fielding plays with the multiple meanings of property, undercutting the equation of female and helplessness, to offer versions of power unconstrained by gender which are. . . contradicted by . . . Sophia’s subordination [at] the novel’s happy ending” (323). London argues that although Fielding seems to put aside the gender bias, he actually enforces it by the way his character Sophia changes at the end of the novel. I think this is an interesting observation that has some merit. London does a good job of providing examples to reinforce her argument.
London claims that throughout the novel Sophia steps over the bounds of authority in order to maintain her own integrity, something rather uncommon for women to do back in the 18th century. The most outright example of this, of course, is when Sophia refuses to marry Blifil and runs away after her father locks her in her room, intending to keep her there until the day of the wedding. London says that “the structure of authority . . . arose from property” (325) and that Sophia is testing her father’s power of acquisition of that property. Because she decides to place herself in her aunt’s care, Sophia takes control of her own life.
According to London, throughout most of this novel, the female characters sort of control the plot and course of action, which is really unusual for its time. Furthermore, a few of them, Lady Bellaston in particular, actually demonstrate assertiveness and determination, which is again, unusual for the time period. London states that “female power, although most richly evoked in negative terms as an expression of carnality, also has its positive embodiment in the person of Sophia” (329).
This seeming rise of feminine power stops abruptly, however, with Sophia’s concession and marriage to Tom. According to London, “Sophia . . . is correspondingly diminished as she becomes part of the property relations that now define her husband” (331). She goes on to say that this development brings the 18th century values concerning land (and women through the use of the property metaphor) back into line: symmetry, stability, and continuity. London finishes by stating that in all of Fielding’s novels, including Joseph Andrews, Amelia and Tom Jones, women are given power only so that they can later give it up through the ceding of their property to their male counterparts once the men have “revealed themselves as prudential” (331). She argues that “Relinquishing the possibilities of character, they are absorbed into the ethic of property relations, becoming metaphoric attributes of the constitutional order Fielding defends” (331-2).
It is apparent that while Fielding does attribute a certain power to the women of this novel, he finishes by adhering to the traditional views of the time and almost implies that Sophia was really a means to an end: she ultimately cedes her property and wealth to Tom, which allows Tom to establish himself and his position in society.
The Mitigated Truth: Tom Jones’s Double Heroism by Peter J. Carlton is the second article. Carlton argues that Tom gets away with a variety of actions, especially illicit sex, with very little punishment and even less guilt. Tom’s actions are always minimized by the actions of other characters, very often female characters, as well as by the convenient surrounding circumstances. For example, Tom is involved with Molly Seagrim, but his involvement is minimized by a character sketch of Molly that Sophia’s maid Honour shapes when she states that Molly was always a forward, willing wench and that when wenches are so coming, men are not so much to be blamed, for it’s only natural to act on this forwardness (398). This double standard is actually stated and “justified” by another woman, which accurately highlights the way of thinking in the 18th century that Fielding evidently recognized.
Later, when Molly is found to be pregnant, Allworthy lectures Tom much in the same way he lectured Jenny Jones years ago, but according to Carlton, Fielding “minimizes its impact in Tom’s case” (399). These two instances are a few of many examples of this double standard for men and women. Carlton sums up the view of women when he states,
Fielding relies on . . . the traditional view of women, implicit in the fact that it is always the woman who is the aggressor in Tom’s affairs . . . women are perceived as either “purer” than they are or more sexually ravenous than they are (the familiar ‘virgin/whore’ polarization), but never simply as they are. At one extreme, they are seen as semidivine beings . . . at the other, women are portrayed as insatiable sinks of lust (399-400).
Sophia and Lady Bellaston seem to represent these two extremes precisely. Sophia is often referred to with heavenly and divine inferences, while Lady Bellaston is the instigator of an on-going affair with Tom. Tom is viewed as an innocent bystander who falls victim to ‘an evil temptress’ of sorts.
Carlton tells us that another critic, Battestin, remarks that “at a time when the double standard was widely accepted, Fielding strove to define the morality of sexual relationships for men as well as women” (402). Carlton refutes this, however, by saying that rather than trying to make an ideal judgment about sexual behaviors of men and women, Fielding simply compares Tom’s actions to those of Nightingale and Will Barnes and demonstrates that Jones’s behavior is not as loose in morals as is his peers (402).
Carlton goes on to discuss the depiction of heroism in Tom, most of which does not apply in the scope of this paper. However, he does argue that one facet of Tom’s heroism is a “Cavalier heroism, a dashing blend of sexual and martial prowess” (403) which seems to excuse Tom’s promiscuous behavior and even adds to his attraction. While the women involved in these affairs are looked upon as evil and tempting, Tom is actually looked upon as a dashing cavalier hero. This development speaks volumes about the double standard apparent in Tom Jones.
To further support these arguments is a third article by Gene S. Koppel entitled Sexual Education and Sexual Values in Tom Jones: Confusion at the Core? Most of this article talks about the sexual education and lack thereof in Tom, focusing on inconsistencies throughout the novel. Again, most of this is not within the scope of this paper, but Koppel does make one statement that completely supports the double standard argument. He says, “After all, it is quite obvious that Fielding accepted, at least partly, the traditional Western ‘double standard,’ which considered males to be sexually ‘grosser’ than females and allowed them (unofficially, at least) more sexual freedom than it permitted women” (7).
Again, Fielding seems to maintain a double standard for what is acceptable behavior in men versus women. This is highlighted through endless examples and situations throughout the novel which would provide formidable arguments for anyone who sought to argue otherwise.
Carlton, Peter J. “The Mitigated Truth: Tom Jones’s Double Heroism.” Studies in the Novel XIX, no. 4 (Winter 1987) : 397-409.
Fielding, Henry. Tom Jones. New York: Bantam. 1997.
Koppel, Gene S. “Sexual Education and Sexual Values in Tom Jones: Confusion at the Core?” Studies in the Novel XII, no. 1 (Spring 1980) : 1-11.
London, April. “Controlling the Text: Women in Tom Jones.” Studies in the Novel XIX, no. 3 (Fall 1987) : 323-333.
Другие работы по теме:
Кроссворд Финансовая система
КРОССВОРД по теме «Финансовая система» Работу выполнил ученик 11 «Б» класса средней школы №2 Терентьев Д.В. Учитель: Нагорнова Г.В. Вятские Поляны. 2002 год.
Характеристика материала Ст3пс
Способ сварки газовая Марка детали Ст3пс Вид соединения тавровое Толщина свариваемой детали 8 Расшифровка: крупноспокойная сталь с 0,3 % углерода Характеристика материала Ст3пс.
Основные механизмы деградации трубопроводов
Наиболее характерные механизмы деградации определяются особенностями реакторной установки, материалами, условиями эксплуатации и т.д. К основным механизмам деградации относятся:
Характеристики ионоселективных электродов
Марка Диапазон концентраций pX Мешающие ионы Отзывы ЭМ-Ca-01 0.65-4 Mg - 0.2, Ba - 0.02 Na ,K- 0.002, NH4 - 0.003 4.5-10 Теоретический наклон у градуировки бывает редко.
а
Реферат сдается в отпечатанном виде, на листах формата А4, размер шрифта 14, межстрочный интервал 1,5
работа
План-график учебного процесса МИНСКИЙ ФИЛИАЛ МЭСИ УТВЕРЖДАЮ Зам. директора ___________ В.Н.Кривцов «____» _____________ 200__ г. ПЛАН-ГРАФИК учебного процесса
Зач работа
Ахунов А.В. заочное 440з экз Историография - неудов зач Курсовая работа - отсут. по неув. зач Спецдисциплина № 3 - отсут. по неув. Владимирова Э.Н. заочное
Дисциплины
Специальность 080507 "Менеджмент организации" Дистанционная форма обучения п.п. по сем. Название дисциплины Стоимость регистрации, руб.
Перечень лекарственных препаратов
Перечень лекарственных препаратов, знание которых необходимо для студентов IV курса, при изучении цикла факультетской хирургии Наименование препарата
Задачи по Математике 3
Задача 1 Решить графическим методом задачу линейного программирования А) найти область допустимых значений многоугольник решений Б) найти оптимумы целевой функции F=2x1 + x2 max min 2X1 + X2 ≥ 4 2X1 - X2 ≤ 0 0 ≤ X1 < 2 0 ≤ X2 < 8 Решение:
Эффективность действий в бадминтоне - темп или точность
Возраст спортивных достижении Л.Н.Жданов Для успешного планирования подготовки спортсменов важно иметь точные данные, сколько времени требуется в разных видах спорта для достижения определенных уровней спортивного мастерства. Чтобы ответить на вопрос, в каком возрасте конькобежец, пловец, легкоатлет может достичь своего высшего результата, надо знать многое - и возраст начала занятий спортом, и время начала специализации, и степень одаренности спортсмена.
Единый национальный календарь Индии
Единый национальный календарь Индии Был разработан в Индии в 50-х годах XX века. Принят с 22 марта 1957 года. В основу нового календаря положена эра Сака, широко применявшаяся в течение двух тысячелетий во многих календарных системах Индии. 1892 год эры Сака соответствует времени с 22 марта 1970 года по 21 марта 1971 года григорианского календаря.
Римские императоры
Принципат Август 27 до н.э. - 14 н.э. Династия Юлиев-Клавдиев Тиберий 14-371 Калигула 37 - 41 Клавдий 41-54 Нерон 54-68 Гальба. 68-69 0тон Вителлий Веспасиан
Women In The Oddessy Essay Research Paper
Women in The Odyssey In The Odyssey the main character, Odysseus, meets and entertains an impressive array of women. All of the women that he meets are very different
The Beauty Myth Essay Research Paper The
The Beauty Myth Essay, Research Paper The Beauty Myth, published by Doubleday in New York City, hit the shelves in 1992. Naomi Wolf wrote this 348-page book. Wolf attended Yale University and New College, Oxford University, where she was a Rhodes Scholar. Her essays have been printed in many well-known magazines and newspapers, including Esquire and the New York Times.
Comparing The House Of Bernarda Alba And
Chrinicle Of A Death Foretold Essay, Research Paper In both The House of Bernarda Alba, and Chronicle of a Death Foretold, the double standards of society are clearly illustrated through sex, marriage and everyday life. These aspects of society, both in the physical form and the very concepts expose the double standards of people.
Analysis Of Women In The Military Essay
, Research Paper Women have been compared to the frailty and beauty of ripe apricots in modern poetry; the reference could be construed as sexual. However, in spite of their frailty and beauty, women have served in
The Murder By John Steinbeck Essay Research
Paper “The Murder” “The Murder” by John Steinbeck is a classic look at life in the rural United States in the early nineteenth century. This story is a tale of a man and his wife from a foreign
Laura Purdy Essay Research Paper In Laura
Laura Purdy Essay, Research Paper In Laura Purdy?s essay ?Are Pregnant Women Fetal Containers?? the issue that is dealt with is the relationship between pregnant women and their unborn
Abortion 14 Essay Research Paper AbortionOne of
Abortion 14 Essay, Research Paper Abortion One of the most heard about topics today in society is the topic of abortion. Abortion is that act killing a human before it is even born into the world. Many people have different views on if it is right for a woman to have an abortion or not. The people on both sides of this topic have reasoning for their own way of thinking.
An Essay On A Dolls House Essay
, Research Paper In the play, A Doll?s House, by Ibsen, a standard of behavior was not followed. The main character, Nora shocks the readers with her behavior. She does not behave as she is expected to during that time period. Her and her family must face consequences, which effect the overall work.
Thw Wife Of Bath Chaucer
’s Feminist Character Sketch Essay, Research Paper In the medieval period when women were viewed as property, held to sexual double standards and considered to be little more than heir-makers, Chaucer wrote a rather biting piece that draws attention to the inequalities in standards for men and women that were supported by society.
Double Standard Essay Research Paper I was
Double Standard Essay, Research Paper I was surprised finding out that the topic for our paper was about our feelings of our gender. In the world we live in now, men and women have differences in their attitudes, feelings and lifestyles. Also, men and women treat and look at each other differently from the way they treat their same sex.
Mozart
’s Perspective Of Women Essay, Research Paper Mozart’s Perspective of Women In Mozart’s time (the late 1700s), women were viewed much differently than they are viewed today. Women were perceived as being inferior (intellectually and physically) to men. As we all know, the women were supposed to spend their time in the house cleaning, cooking, and taking care of the children.
Herland As A Feminist Work Essay Research
Paper Feminism is the advocating for social, political, and all other rights of women equal to those of men (Random House College Dictionary). This story depicts just that. It is about a society made entirely of women with no need for men. We see the perspective of men through the eyes of our narrator. He gives us the point of view from three different men about women.
Double Standard Essay Research Paper Double StandardAs
Double Standard Essay, Research Paper Double Standard As a traffic engineer, I am obviously more qualified to be operating a moving vehicle than anyone else on the road. After all, I know the proper term for those little sparkly things that they glue to the pavement: bidirectional amber reflectorized pavement markers.
Our Town Mrs Webb Is Mrs Gibbs
Essay, Research Paper Mrs. Gibbs is Mrs. Webb is Mrs. Gibbs In Thorton Wilder s classic play about life in a small town, no other two characters share so much in common with one another as Mrs. Gibbs and Mrs. Webb do. Their purpose in the story, on a figurative level, is to represent the monolithic thinking of a small town.
Growth Of Women On Rise Essay Research
Paper Education, voting, working were three things women could not do. Before the late 1800’s women had mimited rights. As the years past by women slowly gained priviledges that men already had. Although women cant handle some of the tasks that men take on, women have many other advantages.
Women Essay Research Paper Women in early
Women Essay, Research Paper Women in early American society regardless of their culture faced many of the same gender roles. Native American, Black, and European women were the main keepers of the home. In spite the former occupation of African women as farmers, once slaves in America they too were molded to be in charge of the house keeping duties.
Men And Women Are Different Essay Research
Paper Men and Women Different? Are women and men really that different? I think so. I am at a stage in my life where I think all men are after one thing. Sex. When I sit here and think about it, I really have to think, do women and men have anything in common. Women communicate in a completely different manner than women.
Men And Women Essay Research Paper Men
Men And Women Essay, Research Paper Men and Women Whoever said men and women are equal must be blind. Women have always taken a back seat to men in American society. This occurrence is not only found in the United States, but in other countries as well. It’s safe to say that the Declaration of Independence started it and it has continued to the present.