Bilingual Education Essay, Research Paper
Bilingual Education
I am sure that if I was improperly placed in a bilingual program, others have also. How does this happen? What characteristics show school officials that a student needs the classes to begin with? These officials seem to think that standardized tests and parent questionnaires will identify who is in need of ESL, but this system allows students who are not really LEP to be placed in the program. And in order to keep the students out of the program, parents have to attend a conference with school officials. At such meetings, parents are often intimidated and criticized about their decisions and so they leave their children in the program.1 And once the student is in, schools keep them in there as long as possible because to them, it means more money.
In 1968, advocates of bilingual education started a small, 7.5 million dollar program to educate Hispanic children. By 1996, the program had become a multi-billion dollar industry. The federal program spends seventy-five percent of education tax dollars on bilingual education. Schools that offer bilingual classes get incentives such as federal and state grants. They also receive several hundred extra dollars for each student in a bilingual class. Teachers can earn up to five thousand dollars more a year. These incentives can explain why schools keep children in bilingual programs for such a long time. They want to get as much money as possible.
A typical student spends three to four years in an ESL program, but it could take as long as eight years to be fluent in English. Why is it that Hispanics are wasting time in bilingual classes that are not helping them master the language they desperately want to learn? At the same time, Arab, Asian, and European students go into mainstream classes and achieve higher academic scores and with a lower dropout rate than Hispanics, who after twenty-eight years of bilingual programs, still hold the highest dropout rate and the lowest test scores in the country.
Advocates of bilingual education claim that, according to Jim Cummings, knowledge and skills acquired in the native language literacy in particular are transferable to the second language and do not need to be relearned in English so there is no reason to rush students into mainstream classes . Advocates interpret Cummings to mean that students would be best prepared for learning English by first learning their native language proficiently, but in practice, these notions work against the goals of bilingual education-language mastery and academic achievement in English mainstream classrooms . Cummings hypothesis also assumes that children in bilingual programs belong there, which in many cases is not true.
My uncle teaches a bilingual class in Houston and says that students are placed in the program depending on whether or not they pass the TAAS test. If they don t pass, they don t go mainstream. How logical is that? These children may have other problems, but school officials seem oblivious to them. Instead, they place them in bilingual programs. How can the children learn English if they suffer from learning disabilities? An even greater problem arises when English proficient students are placed in bilingual classes simply because they fail to pass the TAAS. This transforms bilingual classes into remedial classes for students rather than helping non-proficient students English.
Even mothers of students who are not English proficient would rather have their children in mainstream classes. In the last ten years, surveys of the parents of limited-English students have shown that the majority give greater importance to their children learning English and being taught subjects in English than in Spanish. In a study conducted by the Educational Testing Service Mexican parents were asked if they wanted schools to teach reading and writing in both Spanish and English. Seventy percent answered yes, but when they were asked if they wanted Spanish taught if it meant less time for teaching English, only twelve percent were still in favor. Latino parents consider learning English more important than learning other subjects and especially more important than learning to read and write in Spanish. They want their children to learn English as soon as possible because they correctly believe that English literacy is the key to success in the United States . Immigrants fear that if their children do not learn English, their economic futures will be hopeless and that their reason for immigrating to the U.S, -to provide better lives for their children-would have been in vain. They know that unless they are fluent in English, their children will not attend college and will have to settle for low-paying jobs . School principals, counselors, and teachers sometimes play on ethnic pride to try to keep children in the programs. They insist that Latin children need to be taught in Spanish to improve their self-esteem, but many parents aren t buying it any more. They are fighting to give their children the education they want and deserve. The effects of such determination can be seen today in the state of California. California has become the best example of why bilingual education should be done away with. Despite all of the rhetoric decrying how California s non-English-speaking students would be harmed by the new English-immersion, just one year after Proposition 227 forced English immersion into California’s classrooms test scores in one school soared in every subject and for all ages. Seventh-graders, for instance, improved their reading scores by 475 percent and math scores by 155 percent. Across grade levels, reading scores rose on average by more than 180 percent and math scores by 120 percent . As expected, the greatest gains were made in school districts that chose the strictest interpretation of the initiative and implemented the most intensive English-immersion programs. Although LEP students in all grade levels showed improvement, there was less improvement for older students.
This suggests that younger students benefited most from English immersion classes while older students, who presumably had benefited from bilingual education previously, benefited the least. The most likely conclusion is that English immersion works best for younger students, contrary to the assertion of bilingual advocates that delaying English instruction until a student is older produces better results in terms of English achievement (read-institute).
In the end, the English immersion program was a huge success. There can be no doubt that Proposition 227 is working and continues to benefit California s language-minority students . If only the other states like Texas, Arizona, and Colorado who still implement bilingual education would learn from California, students nation-wide would be doing as well as those in California.
Some people, though, still believe that by doing away with bilingual education we do away with our culture, while others consider it to be discriminatory, but it s time to see reality: bilingualism does not work. It never has and it never will. If we continue to support it, we will only be hurting those students who will remain forever behind their native English-speaking counterparts California found that out, but how long will it take the rest of us?
Другие работы по теме:
Bilingual Profile Essay Research Paper Christian January
Bilingual Profile Essay, Research Paper Christian January 22,2K1 Bilingual Profile Good afternoon, my name is Christian. I was born in San Juan, Puerto Rico on February 2,1981. I am currently studying my second year at the University of Puerto Rico?s Mayag?ez Campus , and I am pursuing a Bachelor?s degree in Political Science.
Multiculturalism Essay Research Paper MulticulturalismOur country was
Multiculturalism Essay, Research Paper Multiculturalism Our country was founded on the belief in freedom. This freedom was meant for everyone. When our country was founded, many different cultures existed on our land. We abused other cultures because we did not understand them. The United States today is much different.
Bilingual Education Essay Research Paper Imagine being
Bilingual Education Essay, Research Paper Imagine being an immigrant from a country where the Spanish language is practically ubiquitous. Now imagine trying to learn in an American school using a foreign language and being expected to move into the mainstream with the other
Education Abstract Essay Research Paper There are
Education Abstract Essay, Research Paper There are several issues in bilingual and ESL education. First, are we providing each LEP student with an education that will encourage and enable them to succeed in society as adults. Another issue is the training that is offered for teachers and educators to provide them with the skills needed to ensure that they can impart a quality education.
BiLingual Education Essay Research Paper Bilingual EducationEducation
Bi-Lingual Education Essay, Research Paper Bilingual Education Education is very important. There use to be a time when you didn’t have to go to school. When it was only important for men to have an education. Times have really changed. Now it is crucial for everyone in our society to have an education. Survival is the main reason: a cohesive society is another.
Americanization Essay Research Paper AmericanizationWhat does it
Americanization Essay, Research Paper ?Americanization? What does it mean to be a true American? This question has been asked many times when it comes to the topic of immigration. Americanization in itself is a mysterious aspect of our society. In the world today, everyone has his or her own identity but not everyone is accepted or considered American because he or she might stray from the American way.
Bilnigual Education Essay Research Paper Imagine being
Bilnigual Education Essay, Research Paper Imagine being brought up in a family speaking only one language for your entire life and then you had to move to a foreign land where the language is different. If you had a choice of progressively learning this new language over the course of six to nine years or being put into a classroom and have to virtually teach yourself the language by listening to others around you which would you choose? Late exit bilingual education is a more effective form of bilingual education compared to the English immersion form of bilingual education in the fact that there are more benefits and less adverse effects.
Praise Of A Bilingual Country Essay Research
Paper Praise of a Bilingual Country In the essay English as Second Language, English as First Love , Stephen Baker, the author, suggests that the United States should adopt English as its official language. He does not like the idea of the United States not having an official language, and does not want the United States to become bilingual.
Public Education A Right Or A Privilege
Essay, Research Paper Public Education should be a right not a privilege. In my opinion, public education should be a right. We need public education. When it comes to voting,
Proposition 227 Essay Research Paper The result
Proposition 227 Essay, Research Paper The result of California election on June 4th, 1998 was predicted all along. Proposition 227, also known as the anti-bilingual education measure, won in 61% favorable to 39% unfavorable contest. In a seemingly routine contest, the proposition brought out one of the most disparaging groups of supporters and critics, displaying passion for their causes in rallies, forums, debates and TV ads.
Education Essay Research Paper In to day
Education Essay, Research Paper In to day’s society education is becoming more and more important. The children of today need education to get good jobs and keep up with this fast paced modern society. Nobody ever explained this to my teachers through. High school was the worst. THe teachers at my school were losers and dinn’t know what they were doing.
Strangers Essay Research Paper The term stranger
Strangers Essay, Research Paper The term stranger is hard to define. By definition, the stranger is not only an outsider but also someone different and personally known. (Parillo, 7) This definition could pertain to many people. One such group of people are the Hispanic Americans. Hispanic Americans are the ethnic group that attracts the most public attention.
National Language Essay Research Paper Good MorningRecently
National Language Essay, Research Paper Good Morning Recently the United States Congress has been debating whether or not to declare that English is the national language of the United States and that all instruction in public schools is in English. There is no question what the language of this country is, it is irrefutably English, it was the language of our Founding Fathers and the language that the Declaration of Independence was written in, as well as the United States Constitution.
Bilingualism In The Us Essay Research Paper
Bilingualism has had a bad rap lately. Prop 227, the Unz Initiative, successfully passed removing bilingual education from California schools replacing it with English immersion. For some reason, Americans feel that only one language is necessary and that language is English only. Although the general consensus is to remove any form of bilingualism in this country, research has shown that being bilingual is not bad but is actually a good trait to have.
Bilingual Education Essay Research Paper What is
Bilingual Education Essay, Research Paper What is Best For the Children? The controversial debate over English immersion and bilingual education programs has effects in almost every school system. Advocates of bilingual education believe that it is necessary for children to be instructed in their native tongue and gradually be introduced to English or else they may fall behind in school.
Bilingual Education In Miami Essay Research Paper
While California debates whether to stop teaching school children in two languages, the school system in Miami, Florida is expanding bilingual education. This city at the crossroads of the Americas is expanding bilingual education under the argument that students will need to speak, read and write in English and Spanish when they reach the business world.
Bilingual Education Essay Research Paper Bilingual EducationThe
Bilingual Education Essay, Research Paper Bilingual Education The amount of non-English-speaking minorities in the United States is continuously increasing. Be that as it may, there are people in today s society that feel that English should be the only language spoken. It is for that reason bilingual education may be eliminated from many public schools.
Bilingualism Essay Research Paper BilingualismWhat is Bilingualism
Bilingualism Essay, Research Paper Bilingualism What is Bilingualism? Bilingualism is the ability to fluently speak or write two languages. Canada is a bilingual country that has English and French, as it s two official languages. Canada has an Official Languages Act, which was passed in 1969 by Minister of Justice Pierre Elliott Trudeau.
Bilingual Education Is It Hel Essay Research
Paper Bilingual Education: Is it helping or hurting? Bilingual education seems to be a rising topic that is currently up for debate. With the growing number of immigrants entering this country, the language barrier between individuals seems to be far greater when it comes to children in the classroom. On average it is said that here alone in Tempe, schools have about 45 different languages to one classroom.
Analysis Of The Data Essay Research Paper
Descriptive research involves collecting data in order to test hypotheses or to answer questions about the opinions of people about some topic or issue. This kind of research is also called survey research. Salkind(1997) states that descriptive research is used in most of the fields, including education, political science, sociology, and economics.
Bilingual Education Essay Research Paper Bilingual Education 2
Bilingual Education Essay, Research Paper Bilingual Education = Unilingual Education Bilingual education in America is a sound idea, but it is not truly bilingual education, it is only bilingual for those who do not already speak English. America is a country with more and more cultures mixing together with different areas of America speaking different languages.
Eliminate Bilingual Education Essay Research Paper Eliminate
Eliminate Bilingual Education Essay, Research Paper Eliminate Bilingual Education One half of United States children who are not proficient in English live in California, a state who’s future depends on these three million children becoming fluent in English. In 1968, the Bilingual Education Act was passed with the theory that if you academically instructed students in their native language first, learning English would be better and faster in the long run.
Prop 63 Essay Research Paper The Official
Prop. 63 Essay, Research Paper The Official English Language Proposition 63 will make English the Official Language of the United States and I am against The official English
Bilingualism Essay Research Paper Increase in Test
Bilingualism Essay, Research Paper ?Increase in Test Scores Counters Dire Forecast for Bilingual Ban? In the August 20, 2000 New York Times, an article concerning the way the California school system has chosen to educate the large percentage of students that are categorized as having ?limited English? caught my attention.
Dual Education Programs Essay Research Paper In
Dual Education Programs Essay, Research Paper In the United States, more and more students are learning and achieving academic excellence in dual language programs. These two-way bilingual programs integrate students who were raised speaking different languages to promote and provide learning and language development in two languages (Christian).
Immigration English Immersion Essay Research Paper The
Immigration: English Immersion Essay, Research Paper The issue of immigration has been a hot topic in the United States for much of its history. Recently the point of conflict has risen over the issue of bilingual education in public schools. Many people have become opposed to this form of learning and propose a speedy immersion program.
Bilingual Education Essay Research Paper Bilingual EducationStructurally
Bilingual Education Essay, Research Paper Bilingual Education Structurally Ineffective Bilingual education for language minority students is a controversial concept that invokes heated arguments among those people in and associated with many of the nation’s educational systems. Bilingual education, in most cases, is the instruction of a student’s core classes, such as history, math, and science, in his or her native language and the instruction of supplementary English as a Second Language course.
Bilingual Education 2 Essay Research Paper Bilingual
Bilingual Education 2 Essay, Research Paper Bilingual Education in the northeastern United States and Canada serves many advantages and benefits for students of limited English skills. Since the early sixty s, it continues to serve a great advantage to foreign students. This is important because it gives these students the opportunity to achieve the American Dream .
Bilingual Essay Research Paper Richard Rodriguez wrote
Bilingual Essay, Research Paper Richard Rodriguez wrote in his essay, Aria: A Memoir of a Bilingual Childhood, about the struggles he faced growing up as a bilingual Hispanic in American society. Throughout his essay, Rodriguez discussed such topics as assimilation and heritage. He goes into depth about the pros and the cons of being forced to assimilate to the American culture.
Child Development Essay Research Paper I really
Child Development Essay, Research Paper I really enjoyed reading about cognitive and social development in infancy, I can relate to it after being around my nephew and niece when they were going
English As A Language Essay Research
Paper The original objective of bilingual education was to ensure students would not fall behind academically because of a poor command of English and to gradually teach them English as a second language. If language-minority students were taught some subjects in their native tongue, proponents insisted, they potentially could learn English without sacrificing content knowledge.
English Only Essay Research Paper ENGLISH ONLYLanguage
English Only Essay, Research Paper ENGLISH ONLY? Language has always been an important part of a country s culture and way of life. When the U.S. was founded, it was common to hear as many as 20 languages spoken along with many documents that were printed in different languages. There have been many debates over establishing a national language, and a movement arose that strives to establish English as the nation s official language.