Moral Theory Essay, Research Paper
Moral Theory
Respect for Persons:
The moral theory, Respect for Persons, or Ethics of Respect for Persons, core theme is that all human beings should be paid equal respect. Like the bible says in Matthew 7:12, “. Do to others as you would have them do to you.”[1]. This theory has been connected to the German philosopher, Immanuel Kant. Kant divided this theory in two parts, (1) universalization principle and (2) the means-ends principle. In the universalization principle, as moral standards we will use the self-defeating test to formulate the correct outcome of the moral choice involved with a moral issue. In the means-ends principle we will consider two tests the negative test and the positive test.
Let me begin with the universalizaiton principle. This principle takes the idea that all humans beings should receive equal respect and therefore give equal respect to their fellow colleagues. In simple words this principle says to do only those things involving moral choices that can be evaluated by moral rules. For example:
Let us assume that John Smith wants to sleep with his wife’s sister. This assumption poses the following rule: Everyone should sleep with their wife’s sister.
Once the universalized rule has been stated, the second step is to try to decide whether others can follow this rule, with out us felling aggravated by it. When trying to determine this we call upon the self-defeating test. This test will post a question that we can ask to ourselves and see that if in fact we are not incommoded by the rule the universalization principle has given.
The self-defeating test will post the question: “+Can I consent others acting simultaneously according to the same rule I use without undermining my own ability to act in accordance with it?” [2]. When this question is stated the self-defeating test will give the final moral judgment on an issue, if and only if the question can be certainly consider to be accepted.
For the case stated above, you ask yourself +Can I consent others to sleep with their wife’s sister without me being incommoded by their actions? This question can be answer by the following:
1. Would you like your wife’s sister’s husband to sleep with your wife?
2. Would you like your sister’s husband to sleep your other sister?
3. Would you like your mother to sleep with your uncle?
The answer to all, or at least one, of this question will most likely be no. Therefor the rule posted by the universalization principle will not be universalized. By this we conclude that John Smith will be acting immorally, therefor the self-defeating test “fails”.
The second part of this theory is known as the means-ends principle. It emphasizes in the thought of treating every human being as an end and not simply as a mean. In other words to include someone in the end of any decision, and not simply to include him just to get to that decision.
Lets suppose that in the above case Mr. Smith does in fact answers yes to all three questions. This will then become a universalized rule and therefor it would be morally acceptable. However we will have to determine if smith is merely using his wife sister as a mean and not as an end, to finally determine if in fact this rule is morally correct. We will start with the negative test for trying to justify smith’s actions.
The negative test asks, +Does my action override my own or others’ freedom or well being? [3]. This question argues that we should never violate someone’s freedom or well being. However in some cases involving criminal aspects we do override the freedom or well being of the person. With this in mind we can argue that Mr. Smith is acting in a criminal way, if we consider he is married and adultery is consider a criminal act under the law. With this argument we conclude that Mr. Smith has forfeited his rights to be treated as and end and never as a mean.
If adultery were not a criminal action then smith would had pass the first part of the mean-end principle; therefor we would have to continue with the process of determining if this is in fact a moral action. We come now to the second test in this principle the positive test; which asks +Does the action assist oneself (or others’, in certain circumstances) in achieving one’s own (or others’) freedom or well being? [4]. Applying this to the case of John Smith we formulate the following: +Is sleeping with a sister in law assisting me only or is she being assisted as well, or am I only using her to fulfill (using her as mere means) my want to sleep with my wife’s sister? By this test the rule is violated in the way that the female is pleasing the male with little cost to her. She is not obtaining anything out of it and therefor she is being used as a mere mean. John’s point of view might be very different. He might think that she is achieving satisfaction and therefor they both would be means and ends to each other. However he would be violating her freedom to act as a moral agent, to determine by her own means if she is being satisfied or not. In this case the positive test does not fail and the rule will be overthrown, making his want immoral.
Now that we have an understanding on the ethics of respect for persons we will continue with our original case and try to determine if the decision of the manager was ethically correct or not.
Другие работы по теме:
Right Theory Essay Research Paper Right Theory1
Right Theory Essay, Research Paper Right Theory: 1. Rights create obligations, type of moral discourse & involve agents, being who act & are acted upon. People are given obligations to respect your rights. There is no right to obligate other people rights. (Conventional rights: Created by group of people as law or regulation in our society.
Is It Better To Be Feared Than
Loved Essay, Research Paper Machiavelli was a man who was not worried about what was morally correct, but rather, what was politically deserved. He was in fact an honest and religious man, but he has become known for trickery and double-dealing. He thought that princes would have to start tricking his enemies, or even his people for the good of his state.
Law Essay Research Paper 1 The trial
Law Essay, Research Paper 1. The trial court is bound by the Supreme Court s decision under Stare Decisis. The Supreme Court is the highest court in the judicial system. All other courts are most likely to follow a higher courts decision. The only time a precedent would change is if it is out of date, the situation is different, or if the ruling is found invalid.
Case For Cristianity Essay Research Paper Moral
Case For Cristianity Essay, Research Paper Moral conviction is something that everyone should have, it is inherent, or at least that is the assumption. In the book, “A Case for Christianity”, by C. S. Lewis, Lewis argues that it is part of the “Moral Law”. Not the part that will make you forget about yourself and help someone else even though it might put you in danger, but rather the part that makes you feel bad when you have wronged another person or broken your own moral code.
Kant An Act Of Moral Worth
Essay, Research Paper Jill had been driving down a deserted road when her tire became flat. With no one around for miles she struggled with changing the tire when Jack happened to be driving by and stopped to give her a hand. How and why is this an act of genuine moral worth?
Death By Choice Essay Research Paper Death
Death By Choice Essay, Research Paper Death By Choice: Who Should Decide? McGuires’ references to prior cases and documents is done logically and clinically. After careful reading, and re-reading, I failed to understand his position
The Mysterious Stranger Essay Research Paper In
The Mysterious Stranger Essay, Research Paper In the Mark Twain story ?The Mysterious Stranger?, Satan teaches Theodor that the Moral Sense that humans possess is more of an impairment than a gift. The first time
Child Morality Essay Research Paper The Child
Child Morality Essay, Research Paper The Child as a Moral Philosopher In this Article ? The Child as a Moral Philosopher,? psychologist Lawrence Kolberg gives a clear description of his theory of moral development. Kolberg uses the studies of seventy-five American boys of varying ages. He also uses boys from other cultures for instance Great Britain, Canada, Taiwan, Mexico and Turkey.
Rock And Roll Essay Research Paper At
Rock And Roll Essay, Research Paper At the beginning at Enemy at the Gates, it showed the new Russian recruits being loaded onto trains to fight at Stalingrad. There was little organization, just a mob of young men
Catholic Morality Essay Research Paper Morality can
Catholic Morality Essay, Research Paper Morality can be defined as being able to be good in character or conduct; virtuous according to civilized standards of right or wrong; each person has their own ?moral standards? which they consider to be right. The Catholic Church also has a version of what being moral entails.
Economics Of Sex Essay Research Paper This
Economics Of Sex Essay, Research Paper This mini-paper is to study how people of different moral standard choose their one-night-stand partners. At a late stage of this paper, I will state the limitations of this theory.
Game Theory Essay Research Paper Game TheoryStrategic
Game Theory Essay, Research Paper Game Theory (Strategic Thinking in Everyday Life) Have you ever been faced with having to live with a decision you made knowing that had you taken the time to analyze the outcomes you may have made a more intelligible choice? Most likely the answer to that question was “yes”.
Moral Corruption Of The Great Gatsby Essay
, Research Paper Throughout the novel The Great Gatsby, written by F. Scott Fitzgerald, there is more then one theme. Culture clash, the American dream, appearance and reality, and moral corruption are all discussed and considered themes of The Great Gatsby. The idea of moral corruption found in The Great Gatsby is exemplified not only in literature but in life as well.
Moral Universalism Essay Research Paper Moral Universalism
Moral Universalism Essay, Research Paper Moral Universalism should be a worldview. I believe that it would be better for the human race to live in a world where moral universalism is the accepted worldview. I believe this because moral universalism almost offers the world a moral view that has no conflicts, no differences and has no bias.
Positivism Essay Research Paper PositivismPositivism is the
Positivism Essay, Research Paper Positivism Positivism is the belief that “scientific naturalism” is the foundation of knowledge and truth. Leszek Kolakowski wrote “Positivism is a normative attitude, regulating how we are to use such terms as knowledge , science , cognition , and information . Positivism rejects the theories of theology and metaphysics because they don t have proof that they are true.
Hungrey Essay Research Paper Global hunger is
Hungrey? Essay, Research Paper Global hunger is a major concern that effects the whole world. According to Peter Singer ?the whole way we look at moral issues-our moral conceptual scheme
Socrates Arguments Regarding Moral Conventionalism Essay Research
Paper In assessing the validity of Socrates? arguments regarding moral conventionalism, Plato presents a multitude of premises on which Socrates? argument is based. These premises both support and weaken Socrates? beliefs against Sophist teachings. Using The Crito and The Apology, it is relatively easy to understand Socrates? reasoning in opposing the sophistic position of moral relativism.
Divine Command Theory Essay Research Paper The
Divine Command Theory Essay, Research Paper The Divine Command Theory Religion and ethics are seen to be somehow inseparable in our culture. Religious leaders are usually appealed to in some capacity when
Adolescence And Moral Development Essay Research Paper
Adolescence and Moral Development Two major reasons exist for studying moral development and during adolescence. First, congnitive changes that occur during adolescence are related to moral develpment. formal operational thinking allows the adolescent to interpret the social environment in new and different ways.
To Kill A Mockingbird Courage Essay Research
Paper To Kill A Mockingbird: Courage In the novel, “To Kill A Mockingbird”, we were presented with several displays of courage. Some of the courage in the novel were displays of physical
Divine Command Theory Essay Research Paper Divine
Divine Command Theory Essay, Research Paper Divine Command Theory The divine command theory is the view that moral actions are those which conform to God’s will. Charity, for example, is morally proper because God endorses it, and murder is wrong because God condemns it. One way to test to see whether any action is right or wrong is first to determine if it conforms to God’s will, it is morally permissible, if it does not, then it is impermissible.
What Does It Mean To Be Moral
Essay, Research Paper What does it mean to be moral? Our morality is used every day in every situation and decision we make. Morality is very much a part of who you are. To be a person who is moral you know what is right and wrong on your own.
Morality Theory Essay Research Paper MoralityThrough out
Morality Theory Essay, Research Paper Morality Through out the evolutionary process of rules and regulations that we abide by, we come to a discrete conclusion that religion and its “morality” have complete power over our beings. Morality is the quality of being in accord with standards of right or good conduct.
Romance In The House Of Seven Essay
, Research Paper The House of Seven Gables: What are the effects of Romance used in the novel-as defined by Hawthorne in his Preface-on the moral of the story?
Cultural Relativism Essay Research Paper The thesis
Cultural Relativism Essay, Research Paper The thesis of meta-ethical cultural relativism is the philosophical viewpoint that there are no absolute moral truths, only truths relative to the cultural context in which they exist. From this it is therefore presumed that what one society considers to be morally right, another society may consider to be morally wrong, therefore, moral right’s and wrongs are only relative to a particular society.
On Aids And Moral Duty Discrimination
Goes On Essay, Research Paper The two essays I read were On Aids and Moral Duty by Willard Gaylin and Discrimination Goes On by Robert H. Cohen. On Aids and Moral Duty says that HIV positive individuals have a moral responsibility to let others know they are HIV positive to protect innocent people from unknowingly contracting the virus.
An Inspector Calls Has Been Described At
Different Times As A Sermon And A Lesson In Civics . How Far Can The Play Be Viewed Simply As A Vehicle For Priestley S Moral And Political Views? Essay, Research Paper
Civil Vs Moral Essay Research Paper Civil
Civil Vs Moral Essay, Research Paper ?Civil Law vs. Moral law? In Sophocles? play ?Antigone?, Antigone?s life is taken from her because of her choice to follow the moral law by burying her brother and disobeying the civil law, which forbid this.