Patriot Games Essay, Research Paper
Patriot games Know Your Enemy: How the Joint Intelligence Committee Saw the World Percy Cradock
354pp, John Murray
The Secret State: Whitehall and the Cold War
Peter Hennessy
234pp, Allen Lane Twelve years ago, Sir Reginald Hibbert, a former senior Foreign Office diplomat, penned a devastating essay about the Whitehall elite responsible for assessing secret intelligence. Long-term intelligence assessments usually end up “by arguing that the future is going to be broadly like the present, only more so”, he wrote. “One knows that this can never be true because of the incidence of the unexpected. Perestroika, for example, was inherently unpredictable, at any rate in its timing.” However, Whitehall would not have been so surprised by perestroika, and the subsequent collapse of communism, had it spent less time counting weapons and more time studying human beings. Too much emphasis was placed on threats from the east revealed by secret sources, and too little on economic and political trends that were available for all to see. Hibbert pointed out the risk of ministers and their senior advisers becoming absorbed into a “a culture where secrecy comes to be confused with truth and where, after a time, contact is lost with earthly awkwardness”. Intelligence agencies were placed firmly under the spotlight after the September 11 attacks on the US. But what is their previous track record, apart from the failure to predict the fall of communism? Percy Cradock, former chairman of the Joint Intelligence Committee, one of Hibbert’s main targets, unsurprisingly takes a much less critical view. Though he acknowledges that the JIC was surprised by the speed with which the Soviet Union developed the atom bomb, and overestimated its military strength, he emphasises that it was correct in identifying Soviet “strategic caution”, which he sees as perhaps the most important single judgment of the cold war. The JIC was also correct, he observes, in seeing China as a largely independent actor, and not just a Soviet puppet, as the US believed. When things went badly and governments were caught by surprise, Cradock blames policy-makers rather than the intelligence community. On the Soviet invasion of Czechoslovakia in the summer of 1968: “It was in the field of political understanding more than hard intelligence that the west went wrong.” He skirts over the UDI crisis in Rhodesia, saying that intelligence only had a small part to play. The JIC is again praised for its scepticism about the effect of sanctions. Did this encourage sanction-busting by British oil companies? And we could have had more on the analysis – by MI6 – of whether British forces would really have backed away from mili tary action against their “kith and kin”. Ken Flower, Rhodesia’s secret-service chief, admitted later that Ian Smith and his colleagues had been deeply worried about the possible use of force by the British. There were those in MI6 who did think it would work. How far they tried to impress their view on Harold Wilson we do not know. Cradock is certainly correct in describing Suez as a “policy rather than intelligence failure”. It was, of course, more than that – the attack on Egypt involved secret collusion with France and Israel. Cradock calls it a “stark lesson to Britain on the limits of power… a dramatic wastage of government resources through secrecy, duplicity and sheer muddle”. Cradock relies largely on JIC and other official documents released at the public record office. Curiously, he ignores the intelligence failings leading up to the Falklands war, even though they were vividly described by the Franks committee set up by Thatcher after the conflict was over. “The changes in the Argentine position,” it noted, “were, we believe, more evident on the diplomatic front and in the associated press campaign than in the intelligence reports…” But, in a curiously disappointing book, Cradock does refer to discussions in Whitehall about doomsday scenarios and nuclear options in the early days of the cold war. The original decision to embark on an “independent deterrent”, he says, was not the result of any elaborate strategic thought, but ministers’ instincts. Ernest Bevin, Attlee’s foreign secretary, summed up the mood by saying: “We’ve got to have the bloody Union Jack flying on top of it.” Cradock writes: “Later he gave as his reason the need to ensure that no successor of his would be talked to as he just had been by his US counterpart, secretary of state Byrnes. His more formal comments… again turned less on threats from the Soviet Union than on independence from the United States: Britain ‘could not afford to acquiesce in an American monopoly of this new development’.” Neither could it long afford to maintain its independent ambitions. Nuclear war – or, rather, contingency planning, the procedures by which the prime minister would authorise an attack by Britain’s Trident submarine commanders, and how the government would hide from a Soviet attack in its bunkers – is the subject of Peter Hennessy’s rather misleadingly titled book, The Secret State. It has a narrow focus but, as one expects from Whitehall’s premier historian, it is well written and rich in anecdotes. How could a Trident commander be sure that the UK had suffered a catastrophic nuclear assault without an authenticated message from the prime minister? “One of the very last tests – over several days – is that BBC Radio 4’s Today programme has been silenced (a pleasing last touch of national identity, in every sense, I have always thought).”
Другие работы по теме:
History of the Olympic Games
Автор: Разное The Olympic Games are an international sports festival that began in ancient Greece. They were renewed in 1896, and since then they have been staged every fourth year. For two weeks and a half any international conflicts must be stopped and replaced with friendly competitions.
Violence In Games Essay Research Paper A
Violence In Games Essay, Research Paper A while back a senator said that violence in computer games is completely outrageous and is amazingly influential on our youth. We’ll just randomly choose
Billiards Essay Research Paper BilliardsBilliards is a
Billiards Essay, Research Paper Billiards Billiards is a game played on a rectangular table half as wide as it is long. There are several games that can be played with a variation of three to twenty-one balls. Tables may also have either no pockets or up to six pockets.
As A Child Essay Research Paper As
As A Child Essay, Research Paper As a child, I was no exception. Three games that I especially enjoyed were Freeze Tag, Hide and Seek, and Truth or Dare. When I was little I used to play all three
Video Games Experiment Essay Research Paper The
Video Games Experiment Essay, Research Paper The purpose of this experiment is to find out if video games affect your pulse rate. I predict that the more intense the game is, the higher the pulse rate will be. I believe this because in an intense game, you can get real nervous which would cause you to push the buttons very fast.
CounterStrike Essay Research Paper CounterStrikeComputer games represents
Counter-Strike Essay, Research Paper Counter-Strike Computer games represents one of the largest incomes in the worldwide video game industry and the online business. Sierra is one of the most popular and leading company in interactive entertainment over the pass 30 years. Games like King s Quest (series), Lords of the Realm, Leisure Suit Larry, K, and Counter-Strike lead the company to numerous industry awards.
The Olympics Essay Research Paper OlympicsThe modern
The Olympics Essay, Research Paper Olympics The modern Oplympic Game, first held in 1896, in Athens, Greece. The first modern Olmpic Gmaes were inspired by British schoolmaster, organized bby a Frenchman, and held in greece.
Let The Hype Begin Essay Research Paper
When sponsorship becomes too big a business. Having just read the article ?Let The Hype Begin?, on 27th. february, I would like to male a comment on that particular issue:
Patriotism 2 Essay Research Paper PatriotismI believe
Patriotism 2 Essay, Research Paper Patriotism I believe that patriotism is a belief or feeling of pride in one’s own country. That is what I believed the definition of patriotism to be before I researched anything on the topic. People can argue all day long about the subject of patriotism, since it can sometimes be such a vague subject and they probably do not quite know what the definition of patriotism to be.
Niccolo Machiavelli Essay Research Paper Machiavelli Niccol
Niccolo Machiavelli Essay, Research Paper Machiavelli, Niccol Niccol Machiavelli was born on May 3, 1469 and died on June 21, 1527 in Florence, Italy. He was an Italian historian, statesman, and a political philosopher. He was an upright man, a good citizen, a good father, and a loving patriot. He had five children with his wife, Marietta Corsini.
Patriot Games Essay Research Paper If your
Patriot Games Essay, Research Paper If your looking for a great novel full of action and suspense but much more believable than many science fiction stories, definitely
Samuel Adams
– American Patriot And Politician Essay, Research Paper Samuel Adams American Patriot & Politician ______________________________________________
Psychology Essay Research Paper Tommy is
Psychology Essay, Research Paper Tommy is an eighteen year-old male who was born with Cerebral Palsy and Mild Mental Retardation. He is diagnosed as right – hemiparetic which effects his right leg, arm and hand. Tommy is ambulatory, however, his gait is short and uneven which manifests in a noticeable limp and the dragging of his right leg.
School Violence Essay Research Paper Every day
School Violence Essay, Research Paper Every day a child is hurt purposely, or accidentally by another classmate. There are many things that cause people to take violence out on other people. It could possibly be parenting, bullies, television, and even video games.
George B Mcclellan Essay Research Paper George
George B. Mcclellan Essay, Research Paper George B. McClellan The Disposable Patriot “George B. McClellan, The Disposable Patriot” by Micheal J. McHugh recounts the struggles of the young Napoleon, George B. McClellan, as he lived out his life. George B. McClellan lived a long and fulfilling life in both the military and politics, and still had a good loving christian family.
The Easy Road To The Final Four
Essay, Research Paper The Easy Road To the Final Four… So, you’re from Indianapolis but all the tickets to the Final Four games are sold out. You still want in. You go to the game looking for scalpers but they charge over $200 a ticket. You pay him. FOOL!!!! Don’t pay him! Here’s what ya do,
The Patriot Essay Research Paper THE PATRIOTThe
The Patriot Essay, Research Paper THE PATRIOT The Patriot, directed by Roland Emmerich has to be one of the most patriotic films I have ever seen. This film focuses on merit, and how people of all backgrounds worked together for one cause: freedom.
Teenagers And Video Games Essay Research Paper
Teenagers and Video Games Video games are a major source attraction for teenagers. One of the most popular video games is called Dream Cast. Video games should be banned because they are a waste of time and money, and they damage teenagers? social skills.
Gambling Essay Research Paper Sports GamblingThere are
Gambling Essay, Research Paper Sports Gambling There are a number of different ways a person can gamble on Professional football. The only problem is here in Wisconsin it is illegal. In the following I will list several different ways a person can gamble on football.
Violent Video Games Essay Research Paper Writing
Violent Video Games Essay, Research Paper Writing the College Essay 4/4/01 Should the government restrict violence in video games? Violence in video games seems to be growing stronger with each passing day. But the main question should be, Who should be responsible for what our children play? A percentage of people will argue that violence in video games leads to violent behavior.
Video Games And Violence Essay Research Paper
The person doesn?t know the difference between reality and fantasy he or she shouldn?t be allowed to play video games, listen to radio and/or watch TV because of all the violence that occurs. If people want to do what the hero or heroine in the game is doing, let them. In every game the position you take is the good guy meaning you have to save the world, along with the humans that live on the earth.
Worst Day Of Life Essay Research Paper
The worst day of my life was when I lost my thumb it was very painful I was emotionally scared and I can?t play video games like normal people. I lost my thumb when I was only a few years old and it hurt a lot. It got taken off in a bike chain. That?s how I lost my thumb.
Sony Playstation Vs Nintendo 64 Essay Research
Paper Sony Playstation vs Nintendo 64 Essay written by Unknown In the last two years of 1995 and 1996, the video game world was taken into another gaming dimension. The releases of the Sony Playstation in September of 1995 and the Nintendo 64 in September of 1996 has given the gaming public an enormous boost of technological advances in the home entertainment system for the common man.
The Blue Hotel Essay Research Paper Leah
The Blue Hotel Essay, Research Paper Leah Miller Comparison Essay English J In the Blue Hotel, by Stephen Crane, four characters play four games of High Five. The game is played with partners. There are both similarities and differences in the
Vice President Of Personnel Fun
& Games International Essay, Research Paper 9 Warwick Rd. Stratford NJ 08084 1/24/01 Ms. Paula Hougen Vice President of Personnel Fun & Games International
Games Arn
’t Fun If You Don’t W Essay, Research Paper Why games are no fun unless you win Games arn’t any fun unless you win because your opponent gets the chance to laugh at you, If you want to win you have to play that much longer, and you lose intrest if you don’t win the game after that which makes it no fun
Welcome To Australia Essay Research Paper Welcome
Welcome To Australia Essay, Research Paper Welcome To Australia Australia is one of the most popular holiday destinations in the world. Thousands and thousands of foreign people come and visit Australia each year. This is due to our vast variety in our landscapes and animals. Also our weather is perfect in most places, especially on the coast.
Benedict Arnold Essay Research Paper SS 9
Benedict Arnold Essay, Research Paper S.S 9 L.G 10 Benedict Arnold Benedict Arnold was one of the important figures in the American Revolution. He began as a patriot, and soon later married a loyalist. Benedict
Computer Violence Essay Research Paper Violent Computer
Computer Violence Essay, Research Paper Violent Computer Games A lot of adults say violent computer games make you violent. I disagree. When you are mad you can take out your anger while playing that game. Lots of kids I know have violent computer games and none of them are violent. Pretty much everything in this world has violence in it.
Grovel Alexander Essay Research Paper professional baseball
Grovel Alexander Essay, Research Paper professional baseball player, one of the finest right-handed pitchers in the history of the game, frequently considered the greatest master of control. From 1911 to 1930 he won 373 or 374 major league games (authorities differ) and lost 208. In his first season he won 28 games.