Paper
Music is one of the most unique performing arts due to the way it has evolved. Styles and melodies considered unfit in one era are displayed prominently in another. The two concerts previewed in this report have two different and distinct techniques. The first performance that I attended was a symphonic concert playing a mix of contemporary and early 20th century works at Carnegie Hall. The second performance was an organ recital highlighted by the by the live performance of Bach’s most well known pieces. Hopefully this term paper will objectively and subjectively critique and compare the two performances.
An orchestra is a collection of a variety of instruments usually consisting of brass, woodwinds, strings and percussion sections. In the concert at Carnegie Hall, the music was abundant in tone color and a variety of pitches and moods. While the Bach music played by the organist could only demonstrate one type of sound, the multitude of instruments at the conductor’s disposal can flood the listener with a variety of sound. The key pieces of music performed were “Music for Violin and Orchestra” by Maazal and “Symphony No. 1 in D major” by Mahler. Maazal?s piece pits the virtuoso, Maazal, against the entire orchestra. It seems to be a sophisticated concerto with the violinist and the orchestra dueling with each other. Unlike Baroque music, the mood changes constantly, at one moments the violin conveys a tranquil image only to be shattered by the dissonance created by the orchestra. While Toccata and Fugue in D minor is a piece of absolute music, Maazal’s music is program music. The main theme is sort of a violinist’s journey and struggle with the much more powerful monster-like orchestra.
Objectively, the odd notes from the percussion coupled with the frequent use of
low tone color instruments (e.g. bassoon, bass) created tension. The trills provided by the virtuoso and the strings section displayed a tension reserved only for the shower scene in Hitchcock’s “Psycho”. The dynamics of the piece are deliberately arranged to convey images of peace and fright. When the virtuoso plays his violin for a requiem of the world it knew, it plays in a soft, whimpering manner. On the opposite is the tension created by the orchestra as it goes through a crescendo. Not only does this increase the tension, but conveys the image of a monster running after the “hero” as it drowns out the violin due to its increase in volume. In both cases, the music would not be Baroque. The dynamics of the music (e.g. crescendo) would not be allowed in Baroque while the changes in mood from soothing to homicidal would be a violation of the Baroque spirit. Maazal?s music is clearly 20th century music.
Mahler?s music, on the other hand, is much more difficult to understand than any other piece heard in class, concert or home. The long melodies and abrupt shifts in meter and melody are jarring. Moreover, while the symphony elicits feelings of a funeral, the only requiem it plays is the one for the listener?s interest in his music. In short, the symphony is overly long and tedious. It is not as entertaining as the struggle of Maazal?s violin versus the orchestra. While the symphony tends to be boring it shares many of the same characteristics of Maazal?s music, 20th century music.
The key characteristics of 20th century music differ from those of the Baroque period. First, there is a variety of tone color provided in the music. In Maazal?s ?Music for the Violin and Orchestra? violins, flutes, basses and even bongos are used to create images such as a ferocious monster. Moreover, the music played in this piece had dissonance and consonance, another important feature of 20th century music. While Baroque and Renaissance music does not use dissonance extensively, Maazal and Mahler use dissonance as a major tool in developing the music. In the final part of ?Symphony No. 1 in D major?, the music shifts abruptly from C minor to D major. The monstrous orchestra in Maazal?s music uses unstable chords to convey a horrific beast. In addition to this changing melodies and rhythms are another characteristic of 20th century music. The rhythm and melody of Maazal?s sad violin solo at the end of ?Music for Violin and Orchestra? are different from the calming tones that he plays to soothe the orchestral beast.
Both of these pieces are similar in some ways to Baroque music. First, the melodies are extremely difficult to memorize. The melodies used in Mahler?s music and those provided by Bach are not show tunes. This music takes more skill than, for example, classical music, which emphasized more simplicity in melody. The polyphonic sections of both styles of music give the listener variety to sustain his interest (except for Mahler where it is swiftly dispatched). The multiple melodies are evident in Bach?s fugues and in the duel between Maazal and the orchestra. Unity is achieved by repetition of the main themes. Mahler?s symphony repeats the main theme before it ends while Bach?s ?Little Fugue in D minor? continuously repeats the main subject.
Chamber music is different from the orchestral music. It is music employing a small group of musicians with each player to a part. While an organ recital is not technically a chamber music performance, the fact that there is only one player fits the definition of a small grouping this case one musician. Still, the sounds and tones coming from the organ differ greatly from those coming the plethora of instruments of an orchestra. Some of the key works of Bach were arranged exclusively for the organ. The pieces heard were characteristic of the Baroque period: constant mood, difficult melodies, constant repetitions and terraced dynamics. This is in contrast to the music played at Carnegie Hall, where there were, for examples, many changes in the mood of the music and tempo of the music.
The Baroque works have several characteristics that distinguish them from other styles of music such as the classical. First, these musical pieces have a continuity of rhythm, melody and mood. In “Now thank We all our God”, the meter, mood and melody remains constant throughout the performance. This is accomplished through repetition, which unifies the entire Baroque piece. Another important characteristic of Baroque music is that the music can never have crescendos or decrescendos. In “Toccata and Fugue in D minor”, the music does not become gradually louder or softer. The changes in music are in changes in the pitch at which the tones are played, not a change in volume. As such all of Bach’s pieces due the limitations of the organ can only be loud or soft. While word painting is used in Baroque pieces, I could not perceive it, as I do not speak German. The final characteristic of Baroque music is the polyphonic texture of the music. In Bach fugues, when one pitch (e.g. alto) is playing the main theme, another pitch (e.g. soprano) is playing a different melody entirely.
Subjectively, the music played was a change from the dissonant music of Wagner’s “Die Walkure? and Debussey’s “Omens of Spring”. There was less tension overall and a sense of completion when one of the works was over. Even in “Toccata and Fugue in D minor”, which had a very ominous theme, the music was definitively ended without any lingering expectations. Still in the recital of Bach’s music, the organist played pieces that were either menacing such as “Piece d’Orgue” or jubilant “Wir danken dir”. The tone color was somewhat limited. In the last piece, “Now Thank We all Our God”, which was arranged for both the organ and the choir working in unison, an organ horn was substituted for the choir. The music, which resulted from this, was a mockery from the choir-assisted version. The horn was a poor substitute when trying to replace the choir.
Overall the Bach music played by the organist was somewhat easy to follow. The repetitions of the chorale preludes stanzas and of the main subject in the fugue provided the cohesion needed to create unity. Moreover, the music maintains it pace and mood so that you can actually expect how the piece should end. While a unified piece can be desirable, it can become boring if there is no element of variation. Unfortunately, a singular organ does not display much tambre. As such, the variety was provided by variations in pitch of the main fugue themes and also the countersubjects of those fugues. Also the polyphonic texture lends itself to variation quite easily as a person’s ear cannot concentrate on all the melodies at once. The result is that a listener will find something new in Baroque piece with each hearing. Therefore, Bach’s music from “Wachet Auf” to the “Piece d’Orgue” has both the unity and variety to keep the listener’s interest.
The feeling of closeness to musicians in chamber music is different from the feeling one receives while listening to orchestral music. While many times, the non-virtuoso players are not displayed prominently in the orchestra (with the exception of Bartok?s ?Concerto for Orchestra?), the few musicians, (or in the organist?s case, one) provided more intimacy with the musician. Not that chamber music is superior to that of orchestral music, it only sounds more personal. Still, orchestral music provides the listener with a variety of sounds and melodies that are just not possible with only a small number of musicians. As such, orchestral music can display a depth and breadth of music unattainable by chamber music.
In summary, the two styles of music heard at the concerts are different and similar in many respects. While the musical styles of the 20th century and the Baroque period can differ greatly in terms of melody and rhythm, they also have many similarities (e.g. polyphony). Also, while orchestral music and chamber have great differences, neither is superior to the other. Rather by hearing both forms of music, the listener can broaden his perspective of music and become more understanding of this art form.
References:
Kamien, Roger, Music: An Appreciation. New York: McGraw Hill, 1998
Другие работы по теме:
Concert Report Essay Research Paper This past
Concert Report Essay, Research Paper This past Sunday I attended one of many classical concerts that the Lake San Marcos Chamber Music Society (L.S.M.C.M.S.) hosts. The one I sat in on was their season opener at the San Dieguito United Methodist Church. It featured Michele Zukovsky (clarinet), Daniel Rothmuller (?cello), and Joanne Pearce Martin (piano) as they performed an all-Brahms program.
A Rock Concert Essay Research Paper A
A Rock Concert Essay, Research Paper A Rock Concert Have you ever experienced an overload of every sense at once? Well, rock concerts can almost take you there. I went to see AC/DC in the spring of 1991, and it was truly a festival of sensory overloads. My body felt as if they stimulated it in every area to its complete capacity.
The Argument Culture Essay Research Paper In
The Argument Culture Essay, Research Paper In The Argument Culture, Deborah Tannen describes our adversarial society in debates and dialogues. Tannen discusses our culture?s style of seeing issues, questions, and conflicts as having two sides that battle each other for one goal, victory. She says that not only does this argument culture or culture of critique we live in make life more challenging and alienating, it also reduces the amount of information made available to viewers or information seekers.
Critique Of Recitatif Essay Research Paper Critique
Critique Of Recitatif Essay, Research Paper Critique of Recitatif Sometimes, the mere fact of being from a different race can influence people’s way of thinking or attitude toward other people with different color skin. That is the theme of Toni Morrison’s short story Recitatif. In the story, two eight year old girls, Roberta and Twyla, from different races (black and white) meet in an orphanage called St.
Leap Of Faith Essay Research Paper Critique
Leap Of Faith Essay, Research Paper Critique on Inherit the Wind and Leap of Faith (The Impact on Society) The world is filled with all sorts of people, with different ideas and views of living life. Different people have different methods of influencing other people, either indirectly or directly. People in today s present age have different perceptions of society than in the past.
Art Critique Essay Research Paper The first
Art Critique Essay, Research Paper The first artwork that I had had looked at was Radio Tori, a ceramic arch built by Peter King. It was my first time inside the WUWF radio station building. I found the building to be quite beautiful. The architecture was well done outside the building. Inside, there were various artworks inside the hallway.
Movie Arsenic And Old Lace Essay Research
Paper Movie: Arsenic and Old Lace The movie Arsenic & Old Lace is based on the play about a movie critique who’s two aunts , choose to put lonely men out of there reason by
Rimbaud Essay Research Paper Part II
Rimbaud Essay, Research Paper Part II A man so confused and confusing as Arthur Rimbaud, it is a wonder that he can even be analyzed, critiqued, and judged by his literary works. Never the less it has been done, however how accurate can they be, when even Rimbaud said in his Lettre Du Voyant that for the I is someone else.
Marilyn Manson Essay Research Paper Hey Mr
Marilyn Manson Essay, Research Paper Hey Mr. Superstar This band is a twist of Iggy Pop, KISS, and Alice Coopper. Starting in south Florida as a small industrial Goth band, Marilyn Manson has changed the main stream music of today. They have come to be a leader and paved the way for other shock-rock bands. Just coming out with his fifth album this week, he will continue reaching out to rebellious teenagers that need some sort of support.
Casino Critique Essay Research Paper Casino one
Casino Critique Essay, Research Paper Casino, one of the most prolific movies of the mid nineties. This is a movie of betrayal, money, sex, lies, videotape, and yada yada yada. No, seriously, this is an excellent movie. This is why I picked this movie for my major critique.
What Is Modern Music Essay Research Paper
The most important thing that was expressed about the definition of modern music is that the degree of modernism depends on the experience and taste of those whom are listening. This means that each person can have vastly different views on which musicians and what styles are considered modern, because the critique of all arts is merely opinion.
Roman Mythology Essay Research Paper Magazine CritiqueSingle
Roman Mythology Essay, Research Paper Magazine Critique Single is an independent word that means freedom, in social terms. Freedom is basically another word for having the time of your life with as little responsibility and as much fun as possible. Socializing with whomever you desire gives you that lack of restrictions, and almost unlimited options in the societal game.
Wuthering HeightsBronte Essay Research Paper Critique Wuthering
Wuthering Heights-Bronte Essay, Research Paper Critique- Wuthering Hieghts Wuthering Hieghts is the prototype of all the gothic novels. It contains all the literary elements such as, symbolism, supernatural, and the dark solemn mood classic to all gothic novels. Although the book was well written and rich with literary devices, it did not retain my attention.
Christian Reformation Essay Research Paper The Protestant
Christian Reformation Essay, Research Paper The Protestant Reformation Many ideas of the Renaissance like humanism, individualism and secularism stimulated a strong critique of the church+s policy and the clergy+s behaviour. Many people regarded it as a scandal that the catholic church sold indulgences.
Hunchback Essay Research Paper Film CritiqueThe Hunchback
Hunchback Essay, Research Paper Film Critique The Hunchback of Notre Dame Hugo was trying to say about the main character, Quazi Motto, that looks have nothing to do with personality and how well they should be liked. Quazi Motto was quite
La Madeleine Church Essay Research Paper La
La Madeleine Church Essay, Research Paper La Madeleine is a church in Paris that started during the reign XV, and designed by Constant d’Ivry using plans based on the St-Louis-des-Invalide church.
The Adventures Of Huckelberry Finn
– Critique Essay, Research Paper Critical Biography Mark Twain, the pseudonym of Samuel Clemens, was, as a literary writer, a genius. His use of numerous literary devices throughout the novel are quite unique. Examples of them would be, irony;
Hamlet Essay Research Paper Hamlet 2000 CritiqueWhen
Hamlet Essay, Research Paper ?Hamlet? (2000) Critique When we watch movies, we look for entertainment. That is the only reason why theatrical movies are created. Movies create entertainment which creates money.
Gloria Estefan
’s Successful Life Essay, Research Paper “There’s no growth with out a lot of hard work and little risk.” (members.xcom./_xmcm/troycities/gebio.htm) This statement is a reflection of what Gloria stands for. However there is more to Gloria, than concerts and videos, her personal life. Which would consist of family and marriage.
Critique Of Nevins Thesis Essay Research Paper
Tejas Dalal 10/25/95 Critique of Nevins Thesis Nevins thesis about the portrayal of the glorious and terrible sides of the Civil War is excellent. Nevins does an excellent job in proving that war is terrible, rather than the glorious way it is often looked at. Nevins accomplishes his goal by writing a thesis that emphasizes the terrible side of war, but does not ignore the glorious side of war.
Sydney Opera House Essay Research Paper There
Sydney Opera House Essay, Research Paper There was no true place for performing arts in Australia and this angered many residents. So Joseph Cahill set up a committee to raise money for an arts
Marx Essay Research Paper After reading through
Marx Essay, Research Paper After reading through Marx?s German Ideology, I came to realize that it was not actually a critique on the faults of German thinkers or philosophers. It was more a critique on the nature of history, as we know it. For the most part, people see history reflected through ideologies that distorts reality.
Indonesian Gamelan Essay Research Paper Gamelan concerts
Indonesian Gamelan Essay, Research Paper Gamelan concerts are mysterious and enticing. The sound, which come from the multi-performed, hitting of the copper instruments, makes any listener become aware of a story line of some sort. This music is exotic and that is what it has going for it in the western world.
Heart Of Darkenss Essay Research Paper Heart
Heart Of Darkenss Essay, Research Paper Heart of Darkness Critique CritiquePeriod 2 One said once, of Heart of Darkness, that ?this amazing tale that was not so much told as suggested to me in desolate exclamations, completed in shrugs, in interrupted phrases, in hints ending in deep sighs.? This effect was created by the illusions Conrad made through use of diction, style, and narrative structure.
Stephen KingS Why We Crave Horror Movies
? Essay, Research Paper A Critique of Stephen King?s ?Why We Crave Horror Movies? Elliot Potter In Stephen King?s essay ?Why We Crave Horror Movies? he suggested that
SummaryCritique Essay Research Paper
fde__________COURSEfde______SECTION/TIME______ SUMMARY/CRITIQUE FORM REFERENCE: Darley, J. M., & Latane?, B. (1968). Bystander intervention in emergencies: Diffusion of responsibility in R. Hock (Ed.), Forty Studies That Changed Psychology (295-303). Upper Saddle, N. J.: Prentice Hall.
Op Essay Research Paper Article Critique
Op Essay, Research Paper Article Critique ? New Hotel Project The article talks about the possibilities of making ?One card, For Many Doors?. They are trying to make a room key with an internal credit card. Using a new system guests will be able to check in and issue a room key (double encoded) using their own credit card.
Aaron Copeland Essay Research Paper Born in
Aaron Copeland Essay, Research Paper Born in Brooklyn on November 14, 1900, Aaron Copland was the youngest of five children. American music had no internationally recognized voice of its own when Copland was growing up. His destiny was to supply one. He was the son of Jewish immigrants. Early music training came from an older sister Laurine.
The Graduate Essay Research Paper Veronica CombsThis
The Graduate Essay, Research Paper Veronica Combs This paper will be both a critique as well as an analysis of the relationships between both my generation and the time period in which the movie took place. In the critique, I which to look at the movie score and the dependency that I felt Ben and Katherine had for each other.
Advertising Critique Essay Research Paper The first
Advertising Critique Essay, Research Paper The first of the three ads that I have selected is from The New Yorker magazine. It is an ad for Russell Athletic. This is a company that makes sports wear. In the ad, you see a man wearing their product. The man is vigorously working out and is in good shape. The outfit from Russell Athletic is supposed to perform, according to the caption on the left.
Critique Of Essay Research Paper Critique of
Critique Of Essay, Research Paper Critique of “Clara Barton s Finest Hour By Stephen B. Oates” Clara Barton is best known for establishing the American Red Cross. However, as Stephen Oates points out, her greatest achievement came during the Civil War, as an independent wartime nurse. He tells of her struggle to be accepted in a field that was exclusively male.
Demonstration Critique Essay Research Paper Demonstration Critique
Demonstration Critique Essay, Research Paper Demonstration Critique During my demonstration speech, I was affected by my speech anxiety. Some of the viewable symptoms were the shaking of my hands and also the stuttering of speech. I was able to control myself and relax after I started getting into my information.
Critique Essay Research Paper This critique is
Critique Essay, Research Paper This critique is divided into three sections: structure, content, and positive attributes. On the basis of structure the essay is not of high caliber. This is primarily because the thoughts within each paragraph did not correlate to the topic sentence. Within each subtopic the paragraphs supports were also separated and organized poorly.
Robert Frost Critique Essay Research Paper Choices
Robert Frost Critique Essay, Research Paper Choices are never easy- men face multitudes of them in their lifetime. Some decisions to these choices are clear while others are sometimes more difficult to effectuate. The poem “The Road Not Taken” by Robert Frost is a first person narrative tale of a monumental moment in the speaker s life- Frost can be considered the speaker.
The New Deal Essay Research Paper FDR
The New Deal Essay, Research Paper FDR and the Great Depression Critique the efficiency of FDR’s administration at alleviating the suffering of the great Depression