Alice in Wonderland – Critical Review
Philosophy – a subject that had driven people insane for as long as humans know their history. All the time people try to find a meaning, and later controvert it. For example, critics view a novel by Lewis Carroll Alice’s Adventures in Wonderland, as a quest for maturity story, Carroll’s view on Victorian Society and even existential meaning on life. All of those interpretations come from philosophical “drive” of the critics. The truth is that anyone can point a finger at the book and come up with their own “deep” meaning of the story, but if one looks at facts, well known, and obvious things – it is clear that the story is simply a children tale intended for entertainment and nothing more.
Of course there is no sure way to prove that Carroll did not intend any deeper meaning into the story, after all, he was a mathematician and a man of great knowledge of children (19th Century Literature Criticism 105), but lets take a look at the most obvious fact – the time, place and audience of the original story of Alice in Wonderland. Here are the words of Lewis Carroll as he recalls that day:
Full many a year has slipped away, since that “golden afternoon” that gave thee birth, but I can call it up almost as clearly as if it were yesterday – the cloudless blue above, the watery mirror below, the boat drifting idly on its way, the tinkle of the drops that fell from the oars, as they waved so sleepily to and fro, and (the one bright gleam of life in all the slumberous scene) the three eager faces, hungry for news of fairyland, and who would not he say ‘nay’ to: from whose lips ‘Tell us a story, please,’ had all the stern immutability of Fate (Hudson 128)!
The “three eager faces” Carroll is talking about are the three Liddell girls – Edith, Alice and Ina. Carroll, the girls and their butler Duckworth were on a boat ride picnic one afternoon when one of the girls, Alice, asked Carroll to tell her the story. And that’s how the story originated. A little girl asked a man to tell her a story during an afternoon boat ride. It is amazing how someone can even attempt to prove this as an existential theory. Duckworth was a person who was there who simply heard the story at the time it was told says, “ it was actually composed and spoken over my shoulder for the benefit of Alice Liddell…”(Hudson 128). As you see, the story was told simply to entertain a child.
Critics may argue saying that although it was written for a child, Carroll still had deeper meaning intended when he told it. Now the question that comes to mind is ‘Why?’. Why would Carroll, make up a deep-meaning story over which people are still breaking their minds, while he himself was enjoying a lovely boat ride? The answer is: he would not! And he did not! This answer lies in the first pages of the book…
All in the golden afternoon
Full leisurely we glide;
For both our oars, with little skill,
By little arms are piled,
…
Thus grew the tale of Wonderland:
Thus slowly, one by one,
Its quaint events were hammered out –
And now the tale is done,
And home we steer, a merry crew,
Beneath the setting sun.
Alice! A childish story take,
And with a gentle hand
Lay it where Childhood’s dreams are twined
In memory’s mystic band,
Like pilgrim’s withered wreath of flowers
Plucked an a far off land (Carroll 13)
With this poem by the author, the book is started. It clearly tells in Carroll’s own words how, for whom and why was this story told. In the sixth stanza “Thus grew the tale…” it is told that the story was made up as the trip with the girls went on, and it ended when their trip ended – just like that. No one can argue with the author. If he himself says that the story is for a child – its for a child!
The third argument that contradicts the critics who claim to the deeper meaning of the tale is the fact that the story itself does not make much sense. “Alice’s adventure is a work of nonsense and as such lacks the coherent structure of a conventional literary work” (Kelly 79). Indeed, the content of the story is so crazy, that it even seems sometimes that the author is crazy himself. But he is not crazy, he just had to make up a story in a short period of time. The boat ride only lasted couple of hours, and he was put on a spot to tell it. He had no preparation and as Richard Kelly notices the character of Alice is not developed or changed (79). There is no possibility of deeper meaning without a developed character.
There is another fact that proves that Carroll did not put much thought into his story and that is the fact that Carroll would tell stories like the one he told on the day of the boat ride, very often to the girls. “We used to go to his rooms… escorted by our nurse. When we got there, we used to sit on his big sofa while he told us stories”(Gattegno 15). Its been Carroll’s habit to tell these stories to the girls. The only thing that makes this story of Alice in Wonderland different is that it was the girls’ favorite, and Carroll thought that it would be interesting to other kids and so he published it (Hudson 133).
So here we have it – the story of Alice. So deeply explored by critics each one trying to prove his point, but it seems that they all have went too far into the wonderland and missed the obvious facts on the surface. When you go too far, it is easy to forget where you started. A famous literary critic Richard Kelly points out that:
Critics fall into several categories: bibliographical, psychoanalytical, logical-linguistic, esthetic, Jungian, mythic, existential, sociological, philosophical, theological and literary comparatist. At this juncture in Carroll’s criticism and scholarship, one would do well to be eclectic and to reread the story in the light of the various schools of criticism in so far as they clarify or enrich the story – while recognizing that there is no single meaning to the adventure (79).
Philosophers might disagree with this, but the only way to show truth is through a fact. And the facts show that Alice’s Adventures in Wonderland were a short story made up by a man for a child to entertain that child. The setting, people involved and the story itself all lean toward that idea. But as was said earlier, it is impossible to stop a person from searching deeper and deeper for an idea.
Bibliography
Carroll, Lewis. Alice’s Adventures In Wonderland & Through The Looking-Glass Signet Classic New York, NY 1960.
Cohen, Morton. Lewis Carroll: A Biography Alfred A. Knopf New York, NY 1996.
England in Literature: MacBeth Edition: Teacher’s Supplement Chapter 8, “Alice in Wonderland” 144-146. Scott Foresman & Co. 1973.
Gattegno, Jean. Lewis Carroll: Fragments of a Looking-Glass “Alice” and “A Carroll Chronology” 4-27. Thomas Y. Crowell Co. 1973 New York, NY.
Hudson, Derek. Lewis Carroll “Alice” 124-149. Folcroft Library Editions 1976.
Kelly, Richard. Lewis Carroll “Alice” 78-97. U of Tenn. Twayne Publishers, G. K. Hall & Co. Boston, Mass 1977.
Nineteenth-Century Literature Criticism, Vol. 2 “Lewis Carroll (1832-1898)” 105-121.
Rackin, Donald. Alice’s Journey to the End of Night 132-143 MLA 1966.
Другие работы по теме:
A Long Hard Road Of Adolescenc Essay
, Research Paper A Long Hard Road of Adolescence Reading through the novel, Go Ask Alice, finding out all of the unbelievable, yet true, experiences and feelings of Alice is quite shocking. No matter how shocking they may seem, you can very easily relate those experiences and feelings to those of a typical day-in and day-out teenager.
Moby Dick Essay Essay Research Paper Moby
Moby Dick Essay Essay, Research Paper Moby Dick Essay Throughout time, people have associated their problems with with something bad that happened to them. That thing became the center of their problems by causing a lot of suffering to that person. In Moby Dick, Melville has many interpretations of what the white whale symbolizes.
Myth Dis Essay Research Paper The Wife
Myth Dis Essay, Research Paper The Wife of Bath, Dame Alice is quite a spiteful woman even though she desires only a few simple things in life; power and control. Through her prologue and tale, she makes mirror images of herself , which reflects the person who she really is.
A Strange Man Of Many Talents Essay
, Research Paper Cadyn Allen April 1, 1999 CP English IV Ms. Wade A Strange Man of Many Talents Lewis Carroll by today’s standards would be considered a weirdo. Alice’s Adventures in Wonderland was written by Charles Lutwidge Dodgson, also known as Lewis Carroll, who was a separated man who delighted in the consortship of little girls.
Flowers For Algernon Essay Research Paper Charlie
Flowers For Algernon Essay, Research Paper Charlie s world changes in relationships, how he feels about himself, and the way he views others. His relationship with people change as he gets more intelligent. He begins to understand himself in the way he feels. He starts to look at the world in different ways.
Alice GerstenbergS Overtones Essay Research Paper In
Alice Gerstenberg?S ?Overtones? Essay, Research Paper In Alice Gerstenberg?s ?Overtones?, she presents two deceitful women, both insanely envious of the other, who meet one day over coffee. Two other actors living out their true feelings and being honest show the jealous, rude, but truthful, side of each of the women.
Go Ask Essay Research Paper Go ask
Go Ask Essay, Research Paper Go ask Alice is a book about a teenager who tried drugs once and was hooked. After the first time she tried drugs she thought she would never use them again. One thing led to another, and soon enough she was selling drugs to eleven and twelve year olds. Alice tried to get off drugs numerous times, but she always-ended up right back on them.
Dream Interpatation Essay Research Paper DREAM INTERPRETATIONThere
Dream Interpatation Essay, Research Paper DREAM INTERPRETATION There are many different interpretations of dreams and dreaming. These interpretations tend to fall into two main categories. There is the physiological approach or the psychological approach. The physiological approach deals with the brain’s interpretations of nerve actions.
Alice In Wonderland Essay Research Paper Lost
Alice In Wonderland Essay, Research Paper Lost in this land that?s so clearly make believe, my mind is playing tricks on me, and my eyes they do deceive. I feel through the looking glass and I hit the grassy floor,
Book Classification Essay Research Paper When I
Book Classification Essay, Research Paper When I was a very small child, I fell in love with books of all types. I could lose myself for hours in Alice and Wonderland, Black Beauty, and Tom Sawyer. As
The Importance Of The Bibles Many Interpretations
Essay, Research Paper Having several different translations of the Bible is very important. Each translation highlights different aspects of the book. Providing familiar language to special groups, some interpretations make it easier to understand. Having one translation of the Bible would not make sense , but, several different versions make the Bible able to be read by almost everyone.
Charles Lutwidge Dodgson
– Lewis Carroll Essay, Research Paper English 265 – Modern Poetry Poet: Lewis Carroll Term Paper Charles Lutwidge Dodgson was born on the 27th of January in the year of 1832 and died on the 14th of that same month in 1898. His pseudonym, Lewis Carroll, was born on March 1st, 1856 and was destined to live forever.
Louis Carroll Essay Research Paper The writings
Louis Carroll Essay, Research Paper The writings of Louis Carroll have been described as “inspired wordplay set within the frame of an idiosyncratic view of the humansituation.” Does this really sound right? If, not here is another lookat this enigmatic storyteller: “Carroll s art is so well concealed, hisprose so limpid that we may fail to realize how carefully the stories areorganized.
Go Ask Alice Essay Research Paper Summary
Go Ask Alice Essay, Research Paper Summary of the Plot: The novel, Go Ask Alice, is basically about a 15-year old girl who subjects herself to drugs. At first she is in love with Roger and comes from a loving home, but is also very curious about drugs. She ends up running away, which didn’t last, comes home just in time for Christmas, clean of drugs, starts up again and runs away.
Naylor Phyllis R Essay Research Paper Monday
Naylor, Phyllis R. Essay, Research Paper Monday November 23, 1998 Phyllis Renolds Naylor: Her Life Reflected in Her Alice Books Phyllis Renolds Naylor was born in Anderson, Indiana on January 4, 1933. She has written over eighty books for children, teenagers, and adults, but her Alice books are most famous.
Alice Essay Research Paper In Lewis Carroll
Alice Essay, Research Paper In Lewis Carroll’s novel Alice in Wonderland, Alice is curious, well-mannered, and confused while she tries to find her way out of Wonderland. Alice meets many unique and weird creatures which eventually help her escape wonderland. Alice shows that she is curious through her actions.
Differences Between Alice
’s Adventures In Wonderland And Through The Looking Glass Essay, Research Paper At the mention of the name Alice, one tends to usually think of the children?s stories by Lewis Carroll. Namely, Alice?s Adventures in Wonderland and Through the Looking Glass are two classic works of children?s literature that for over a century have been read by children and adults alike.
Alice In Wonderland Essay Research Paper In
Alice In Wonderland Essay, Research Paper In Alice’s Adventures in Wonderland, Lewis Carroll tells an entertaining story about a young girl’s adventures in a strange “Wonderland.”
Alice
’s Adventures In Wonderland Essay, Research Paper An analysis of Alice’s Adventures in Wonderland The following text is a small part of a project from: Jerry Maatta, HII, Katedralskolan, Uppsala, Sweden
Alice Walker 2 Essay Research Paper What
Alice Walker 2 Essay, Research Paper What is Beauty? In her autobiographical story Alice Walker tells about how after the accident of losing sight in one eye she was never the same. At the young age of eight she was above all others in wit, looks, and talents. I think that the loss of her sight is not what blinded her most, but her unwillingness to except what had happened.
Sir Thomas More Essay Research Paper Man
Sir Thomas More Essay, Research Paper Man For All Seasons Essay In the play, A Man For All Seasons, Sir Thomas More is faced with a number of difficult choices, namely whether to support the King’s decision to divorce Catherine of Aragon and marry Anne Boleyn and the consequences of that decision. More makes his decision to oppose the marriage early on, but even though it is something he does not waver from, he still has trouble with it, especially when he see the pain it causes to his wife and family.
Color Purple Essay Research Paper In Alice
Color Purple Essay, Research Paper In Alice Walker?s The Color Purple Celie faces love obstacles in the beginning of the novel. eventually, she overpowers these obstructions and truimphs. One
Alice Walker Essay Research Paper Alice WalkerBlinded
Alice Walker Essay, Research Paper Alice Walker Blinded in one eye from an accidental gunshot wound at the young age of eight, Alice Walker realized that the rest of her life probably held many hardships and rough times ahead. Racism, oppression, discrimination, and bigotry all played great roles in all of the Alice Walker s works throughout her life.
Analysis Of Go Ask Alice Essay Research
Paper September 21, 1998 Go Ask Alice The character “Alice” is a strong person. Throughout the book, she had a sense of maturity, that later enabled her to take back control of her life. She dealt with her problems and got herself cleaned from the influence of drugs. She also had to be strong to call her parents when she had run away.
Different Views Essay Research Paper Different Views
Different Views Essay, Research Paper Different Views in Everyday Use In the story of ?Everyday Use? by Alice Walker the narrator told the story in a wonderful way. She was simple and I feel she gave a fair and just description of each character in the story. Her words put picture perfect description of the character in the reader?s head.
Alice In Wonderland Essay Research Paper Finding
Alice In Wonderland Essay, Research Paper Finding the Child in Us All Lewis Carroll’s classic Alice’s Adventures in Wonderland has entertained not only children but adults for over one hundred years. The tale has become a treasure of philosophers, literary critics, psychoanalysts, and linguists. It also has attracted Carroll’s fellow mathematicians and logicians.
Carrol And Influences Of Alice In Wonderland
Essay, Research Paper Events or people in their lives inspire many authors. It is reflected in their writing. Lewis Carroll was inspired to write Alice in Wonderland by the real-life relationship with an Alice and his other child-friends.
Alice In Wonderland Essay Research Paper Alice
Alice In Wonderland Essay, Research Paper Alice in Wonderland by Lewis Carroll, a story about a little girl and her adventures in a dream-like place called wonderland, has been a beloved children’s story for over one hundred years. Though viewed by many as a simple children’s tale, if it is taken into a little more depth one will find that is a brilliant satire on the English system of government.
Alice In Wonderland Essay Research Paper As
Alice In Wonderland Essay, Research Paper As we read Alice?s Adventures in Wonderland and The Island of Dr. Moreau, we enter into two unique worlds of imagination. Both Lewis Carroll and H.G. Wells describe lands of intrigue and mystery. We follow Alice and Prendick into two different worlds where animals speak, evolution is tested, and reality is bent until it nearly breaks.
Alice Essay Research Paper As we read
Alice Essay, Research Paper As we read Alice?s Adventures in Wonderland and The Island of Dr. Moreau, we enter into two unique worlds of imagination. Both Lewis Carroll and H.G. Wells describe lands of intrigue and mystery. We follow Alice and Pren*censored* into two different worlds where animals speak, evolution is tested, and reality is bent until it nearly breaks.