, Research Paper
Aaron McBrideSociology 10811/15/1998 Explaining Teen Prostitution Using Sociological Theories of DevianceDeviance is defined as the behavior or acts that defy the norms of a society. For many years, scientists have researched on the various forms of deviance in the hope of developing theories that explain why some people act the way they do.The two case studies presented here both involve prostitution among the young people of society. One is entitled Enjo Kosai . It involves Japanese high school and middle school girls escorting middle-aged men as dates in exchange for money. In addition to providing the men with company, they also offer sex. The girls consider this service normal because it is as common as any other part time job. From this, they are able to get money to buy clothes and accessories (Sumiko, 1997). The second case involves some Americans boys in Nashville, Tennessee, studied by a sociologist named Albert J. Reiss. The youths studied range from 12 to 17 years of age and are identified as low class status. They are involved in providing mouth genital fellatio, otherwise referred by them as blow-jobs . The services have the frame of a typical normal business transaction. The customer asks for service, it is given to him, and he pays. The deal is known as the peer-queer transaction. However, the transaction contains rules that must be followed by both parties, thus making it a kind of a social organization (Reiss summary).The boys regard this deviance as a way of making quick and easy money. Most of them come from low class societies and are career-oriented. However, they have to find other ways of making extra money. Since legitimate means of making money are limited, and the consequences of using an illegitimate means are great, they find the peer-queer transaction a perfect way of earning money. In contrast to accepting this kind of job, they do not, whatsoever, consider themselves as homosexuals. Outside the transactions, they are heterosexuals who have great pride in their masculinity. They can resort to violence if their customers see them otherwise, especially if they violate the rules of the transactions (Reiss summery). Both cases are in no doubt a problem in society. Why is it happening? Looking at the theories of deviance presented to us by Robert Stark, it is difficult to pinpoint the best explanation for both cases. I could only agree that both case studies have element of one theory or another. Even with that in mind, the theories present some flaw to the situations. I have picked on the structural-strain theory and the control theory as the possible explanations.Presented by Robert K. Merton in 1938, it states that a person s position in the social-structure or stratification system is a factor to one s deviance. He suggests that those who commit crime or acts of deviance are usual people of the lower class. They do so to alleviate themselves of their poverty. (Stark, 1997, 183)Although it has been refuted for its lack of middle-class crime and the fact that of those poorly placed in the stratification system, the great majority do not commit acts of significant deviance , Merton s idea could explain the problem among American boys. The article states that they do this to earn easy money (Reiss summary). Being in a low class status level of society suggests that they lack adequate resources. They will therefore resort to finding other means of attaining money. In this case, they have opted for prostitution as a method. They have dreams for their career and only want some extra money to elevate themselves from their social positions.
On the contrary, this aspect of the structural-strain theory does not apply to the Japanese girls. According to the article, the girls involved are very, often seemingly, normal girls coming from upstanding homes. Some are enrolled exclusive secondary schools (Sumiko, 1997, p.45). They are an example of middle-class people who commit acts of deviance. Definitely, they cannot be poor and therefore the theory cannot be applied. For the Japanese situation, the control theory seems to explain it fairly well. The theory states that people with weak ties with others are more likely to deviate than the ones who have close and tight-knit relations. The theory has sub-theories of attachment, involvement, investment, and beliefs a person holds (Stark, 1998, pp. 187-191).Looking at these sub-theories, attachment and beliefs apply to the Japanese situation despite that the evidence given in the article is not clear-cut. The attachment sub-theory refers to the degree or level an individual is close to a group or another person (Stark, 1998, pp. 188-189). The girls are weak because they have weak social bonds with their parents. The article points out that, for the most part, the girls have grown up with parents who are more engaged in attaining economic wealth than family togetherness and values (Sumiko, 1997, p. 46). This statement implies that they do not have strong relations with their children and do not watch them carefully. This neglect creates freedom for the girls to engage in Enjo Kosai .The belief theory refers to the fact that what an individual perceives to be right or wrong for them will govern his moral credibility (Stark, 1998, p.). These girls believe that it is their right to sell their bodies: it is their choice (Sumiko, 1997, p.46). These beliefs have therefore resulted in them being seen as prostitutes. On the other hand, the control theory does not apply to the American boys issue. The article does not give any evidence that they have weak bonds with others, or are not involved with other productive activities. However, they do believe that it is okay to engage in the peer-queer transaction as long as they do not deviate from their rules (Reiss summary). This belief has encouraged them to be prostitutes. Once again, we have a theory that partially explains both of the case studies. In conclusion, I do agree that both cases are acts of deviance. They are similar circumstances, but defining a theory to explain both studies is not easy because each has an aspect of one theory or another. Nevertheless, they are both social problems that need to be addressed carefully, for the participants are in danger of physical and mental problems.
36b
Другие работы по теме:
Whore Essay Research Paper DonRay WHORE December
Whore Essay, Research Paper Don-Ray WHORE December 7, 2000 Prostitution, a practice in which a person, typically a woman, becomes sexually available to another for a price is the premise of the movie Whore, in which a single mother of one turns to prostitution in order to earn some extra money (McCaghy, p.391).
The One Thing In Society That Makes
Me Angry Essay, Research Paper There are many reasons why teens are sad. When a teen recieves a “D” on the report card, he or she can get depressed. When a shcool football team loses a game, this makes the teen sad also. The thing that bothers me most about society is school bullying.
Teen Suicide Essay Research Paper Adolescence is
Teen Suicide Essay, Research Paper Adolescence is the time in which people discover their coping mechanisms and which way is most beneficial for them to deal with stress and new situations. These learning experiences can often be difficult as adolescents have very little knowledge and experience in how to deal with these new situations and stress.
Teen Curfews Essay Research Paper William Plemons
Teen Curfews Essay, Research Paper William Plemons III New curfew for teens It was a very tragic moment last week when two teens died in driving accidents. One of the events happened to a student of a fellow G.I.S.A school. Now the main focus is on the future of teen driving. It is a very serious issue, which needs very serious reform.
Thailand Prostitution Essay Research Paper Prostitution PaperThe
Thailand Prostitution Essay, Research Paper Prostitution Paper The society in Thailand has an up and rising problem that they better look into very quickly, or else the well being of every citizen could be in great danger. This problem is prostitution and it poses almost equally as great of a threat to the nation as would a major war.
Prostitution Essay Research Paper I Introduction Prostitution
Prostitution Essay, Research Paper I. Introduction Prostitution, performance of sexual acts solely for the purpose of material gain. Persons prostitute themselves when they grant sexual favors to others in exchange for money, gifts, or other payment and in so doing use their bodies as commodities. In legal terms, the word prostitute refers only to those who engage overtly in such sexual-economic transactions, usually for a specified sum of money.
Teenagers Problems Essay Research Paper Teenagers problemsToday
Teenagers Problems Essay, Research Paper Teenagers problems Today in the modern society, there a lot of problems, especially problems related with teenagers. A lot of factors influenced in this situation. For example some teenagers felt lack of love from their parents. Another factor is the lack of education because of poverty.
Teen Sex Stats Essay Research Paper Alarming
Teen Sex Stats Essay, Research Paper Alarming Statistics: - 1 of 10 women b/w 15-19 years of age get pregnant every year, 83% are unwanted or unplanned - 50% of unmarried teens who get pregnant do so within six months of their first sexual experience
Credit Cards Essay Research Paper Should teens
Credit Cards Essay, Research Paper Should teens have a credit card? Some people feel that it is a good thing for a teen to have. Others see it as a bad thing. I feel that it is a good thing to have if you are teen. There are a couple of reasons for this. For instance, if you need some extra cash because you have run out of money when you were at the gas station a credit card would be helpful.
Prostitution 2 Essay Research Paper Solicited SexTwo
Prostitution 2 Essay, Research Paper Solicited Sex Two consenting adults can have sex, so why is it illegal for two consenting adults to have sex but to have one pay the other. Prostitution should be legal because it would save money and make the live of partakers more safe.
Curfews Essay Research Paper Teen CurfewWhen
Curfews Essay, Research Paper Teen Curfew When it was learned that Louisville had input a curfew a few people got worried. Had teen violence gotten so out of control? I don t think so. As stated above, teen
Teens And Problems Essay Research Paper Teens
Teens And Problems Essay, Research Paper Teens and Problems Teens must deal with a wide variety of problems which can be difficult and stressful. These problems can range from peer pressure to dealing with
Legalizing Prostitution Essay Research Paper A comedian
Legalizing Prostitution Essay, Research Paper A comedian asked why is it illegal to sell sex but its okay to gibe it away. A beautician performs a service when she cuts your hair. The service is taxed, and the beautician makes money on the service she provided. The beautician, in performing this service, is doing nothing illegal, and is well within her constitutional rights.
Prostitution Essay Research Paper Specific Purpose To
Prostitution Essay, Research Paper Specific Purpose: To persuade the audience that prostitution should be legal. Introduction I. Open with Impact: If Ann Landers is for prostitution, then how far out can the notion be?
Legal Prostitution Essay Research Paper Prostitution has
Legal Prostitution Essay, Research Paper Prostitution has long been considered as illegal. But is it necessary to do so? It is said that prostitution causes inconvenience and troubles to general public. However, the act that considers prostitution as illegal causes inconvenience and troubles to prostitutes either.
Teen Smoking Essay Research Paper Teen smoking
Teen Smoking Essay, Research Paper Teen smoking has always been a factor in America, especially during High School. That is when teens are most likely to pick up the habit (Teen Smokers PG 13). We are constantly around people that smoke and usually offered cigarettes when they do smoke. If smoking is so bad for you then why do so many teens smoke? Because they don’t know how bad it is for them.
Teen Parenting Essay Research Paper Teen PregnancyCurrently
Teen Parenting Essay, Research Paper Teen Pregnancy Currently teen pregnancy is a major problem facing our nation. It causes social and a vast amount of personal problems. Social problems include a higher rate of high school dropouts, government spending is increased for social programs for parenting teens such as Medicaid, welfare, and food stamps.
Teenagers Rebelious Years Essay Research Paper Teenagers
Teenagers Rebelious Years Essay, Research Paper Teenagers Rebellious Years People say that life begins at thirteen. The time of their life that kids love, and parents hate. The days gone when Little Johnny sat in Mom s lap. The day s found where testing their limits are newfound rules. The days of money and clothes have been produced; and the days of telling the Mom s where they are going are no longer found.
Perspectives On Prostitution Essay Research Paper Perspectives
Perspectives On Prostitution Essay, Research Paper Perspectives on Prostitution Beginning around 1910, many religious and civic organizations in the United States started to develop a nationwide campaign against the immorality of prostitution. Although the government and other organizations may view prostitution as an immoral act, depending on a person s social perspective, he or she may view prostitution as being acceptable in today s society.
Teen Pregnancy Essay Research Paper Teen PregnancyThere
Teen Pregnancy Essay, Research Paper Teen Pregnancy There are a lot of teen mothers growing up in this world wondering, what if I would have stayed in school? What could I have become? Would it have made my life easier if I had thought first?
Teen Sex Essay Research Paper In the
Teen Sex Essay, Research Paper In the article, “Society Should Encourage Teens to Postpone Sex Until Marriage,” Joseph Perkins argues that in order to avoid unwanted pregnancies and sexually transmitted diseases, teen should be taught to abstain from sex, rather than be taught about condoms and other forms of birth control.
Teen Smoking Essay Research Paper There are
Teen Smoking Essay, Research Paper There are many factors that author use in each of their stories to help the reader imagine what the setting look likes. In Pat Conroy, the author describes how the air smells and what the land looks like at different times of the year. This is some of the things that he gives you to help image the setting of the story.
Sex Prostitution And The Penal Law Essay
, Research Paper Sex, Prostitution, and the Penal Law As the Bill and Monica drama has shown, sex addiction is not neccessarily what you would think it is. It is often not about the pervert, the exhibitionist, or the pornographer, although it can be. It is about your friendly neighbor down the street who turns out ot be, as everyone learns during the divorce, a hopeless womanizer.
The Hardships Of A Teen Christian Essay
, Research Paper Teen Christians have to deal with a lot of pressures like when at school, because when a Christian teen does talk about what they believe in they are mock or criticized. And when the fact that when a teen does believe in Jesus it causes them to lose friends so that causes teens to not want to be with god, or talk about it because of what there friends will think and do to them.
Teen Curfew Essay Research Paper Teen CurfewIn
Teen Curfew Essay, Research Paper Teen CurfewIn San Diego County, and in many other counties across the country,teenagers are forced to be indoors after ten p.m. Should there be a teencurfew? This idea is ridiculous. There is no legitimate reason for there to bea curfew.The proponents of a teen curfew say that a curfew would bring thecrime rate down during those hours that teenagers are not allowed to beon the street.
Teen Suicide Essay Research Paper As if
Teen Suicide Essay, Research Paper As if parents did not have enough reasons to worry about their teenage children, what with drugs, drinking, and driving. Now a new concern has appeared within the last several years. I am talking about teenage suicide.
Suicide Essay Research Paper Social Problem Teen
Suicide Essay, Research Paper -Social Problem: Teen Suicide -Social Problem- Any problem that may cause pain and may affect a person?s life. ? Teen Suicide- Intentional and self-inflicted death.
Teen Fashion Essay Research Paper Teen FashionTeen
Teen Fashion Essay, Research Paper Teen Fashion Teen fashion is a big part of the fashion world today. Every week stores come out with many new clothes and accessories knowing that teens or the younger generation will
Teenagers problems
Everybody was a teenager, that’s why everybody can say that it’s very difficult to be a teenager. Everyone has different problems, but teenage problems are special. One of the worst teenage problems is schooling.