“Sonny’s Blues” Essay, Research Paper
James Baldwin’s story of redemption and musical epiphany is filled with gritty realism and thematic uses of music and imagery. One of the strongest themes throughout the story is the use of cigarette smoking as a symbol of interpersonal barriers and depravity. The specific act of smoking not only provides substance to a number of characters within the story, but also symbolizes the dishonesty and unapproachable nature of each particular smoker. Likewise, each time a cigarette is tossed away or extinguished, the act is accompanied by brutal honesty and revelation. Cigarette smoke, then, exists as a character in the story rather than a mere byproduct of another habitual vice.
As the clich? phrase “smoke screen” suggests, the presence and creation of smoke are a character’s subconscious way of distancing him or herself from others within the story. Nearly every scene depicts a character in the act of smoking, particularly when confronted with difficult dialogue or when attempting to hide his or her feelings. When the narrator first learns of Sonny’s arrest, he immediately encounters a former associate of his brother’s. After learning through his narration how angry and contemptuous the narrator feels toward this shady character, “…now, abruptly, I hated him” (75), it becomes apparent how further irritated he is by the boy’s smug manner. His reply to the boy’s “repulsive” grin is to effectively disassociate himself from him through a wall of cigarette smoke: “I offered him a cigarette and I watched him through the smoke” (75). It is as if the unsavory drug addict and his irritating familiarity with the narrator’s brother are only tolerable through this protective veil.
The boy is aided by the smoke in a different manner. Through his “smoke screen,” he is able to deceive the narrator regarding the fate of his brother. He retains the cigarette as a means by which he can skirt the issue of what is to become of Sonny. At this point, the boy becomes openly honest only as he finishes the cigarette: “’Maybe he’ll even think he’s kicked the habit. Then they’ll let him loose’ — he gestured, throwing his cigarette into the gutter. ‘That’s all.’” (77). With that disposable gesture, it is as if the boy is either able to or can’t help telling the painful truth.
Baldwin’s narrator, feeling his mother’s burden of protector and keeper of his little brother, seems to have always utilized this strategic and subliminal defense mechanism. As the reminiscent order of the narrative shows, this is a device that has been used by Sonny and his older brother throughout their relationship. Following the death of their mother, the first time that the older brother must act out her request, the conversation between him and Sonny is punctuated by the lighting and smoking of cigarettes. Beginning openly and honestly, the brothers discuss Sonny’s future plans. When Sonny suggests that he dreams of being a musician, tension is created between the two. The narrator, feeling that his authority is being questioned and threatened, displays a tone of condescension, imploring Sonny to “Be serious”. He further preaches to his defensive little brother: “Well, you may think it’s funny now, baby, but it’s not going to be so funny when you have to make your living at it, let me tell you that” (84). His lack of understanding and parental chiding increase the unease between them, and, almost as if on cue, the cigarettes appear.
At Sonny’s mention of one of his favorite Jazz musicians, his older brother is bemused and lights a cigarette while smugly quipping, ” ‘You’ll have to be patient with me. Now. Who’s this Parker character?’ ‘He’s just one of the greatest jazz musicians alive,’ said Sonny, sullenly, his hands in his pockets, his back to [the narrator]” (85). As the narrator creates his protective screen, behind which he is able to dole out authoritarian advice, Sonny further distances himself by literally turning his back. Possibly recognizing his error, the narrator attempts to rationalize with his brother asking, “Doesn’t all this take a lot of time?” (85). The emotional damage, however, has been done.
Sonny responds: “He stopped at the kitchen table and picked up my cigarettes” (86), ironically not with just any cigarettes but the very ones which the narrator uses to create his own impenetrable veil of smoke. Testing his “courage to smoke in front of [the narrator],” he questions the very integrity of his supposed guardian (86). Sonny turns the tide of the conversation, inquiring about his older brother’s youthful activities, “Come on, now. I bet you was smoking at my age, tell the truth” (86). Grinning defensively at having his dreams of Jazz discounted, he jabs his elder where he is most sensitive. He threatens to join the army, which is his brother’s worst fear. When the narrator is able to ground him with the mention of school, the honesty returns, as Sonny relinquishes his cigarette and begins to reveal what is happening to him there.
There is a notable change in Sonny’s and the conversation’s tone at this point. Sonny’s mood becomes remarkably somber, and through his uncharacteristically serious comments, he reveals the very root of his problem. He implies that he feels trapped and helpless, accented by his discarding of the cigarette. The narrator remembers:
“I ain’t learning nothing in school,” he said. “Even when I go.”
He turned away from me and opened the window and threw his cigarette out into the narrow alley. I watched his back. “At least, I ain’t learning nothing you’d want me to learn.” He slammed the window so hard I thought the glass would fly out, and turned back to me. “And I’m sick of the stink of these garbage cans!” (86)
Sonny’s desperation and awareness of his fate surface as he flicks his cigarette symbolically into the alley below. Landing amid the “stink of [the] garbage cans”, the fading source of enveloping smoke seems to remind Sonny of the inescapable street, “black and funky and cold,” that he is resigned to (92).
Later, the narrator witnesses the depravity of the street firsthand while watching a tambourine revival meeting that takes place below the window of Sonny’s room. As the revivalists dance and sing praise, he notices the contrasting element of “street” people who are unable to be moved by the joyful noise. Again, the appearance and mannerisms of cigarette smoking are used to describe some of the more detached, unmoved spectators: “The barbecue cook, wearing a dirty white apron, … and a cigarette between his lips, stood in the doorway, watching them” (89). Baldwin’s narrator continues to observe the cold reaction from some of the street members– “Neither did they especially believe in the holiness of the three sisters and the brother”– and the seemingly small degree of enlightenment that separates the revivalists from them: “The woman with the tambourine, whose voice dominated the air, whose face was bright with joy, was divided by very little from the woman who stood watching her, a cigarette between her heavy, chapped lips…” (90). The narrator observes the changing effect that the music has on one particular bystander: “The barbecue cook half shook his head and smiled, and dropped his cigarette and disappeared into his joint” (90). Ironically, he spots Sonny among the crowd “very faintly smiling, standing very still” without the habitual cigarette (90). The remarkable air of peace that he gets from the music is even further portrayed as he appears in the house to invite his older brother to accompany him that evening. In the absence of smoke, in the soothing atmosphere of the revival’s musical redemption, there is a comfortable understanding between the two.
It is in this figuratively “smoke free” environment that the two final scenes of revelation take place. Somehow finally able to communicate, Sonny explicitly describes to his brother the need to play music, and its relevant similarity to his drug addiction. The narrator begins to realize Sonny’s plight, and arrives at a moment of understanding and forgiveness:
I wanted to say more, but I couldn’t. I wanted to talk about will power and how life could be — well, beautiful. I wanted to say that it was all within; but was it? or rather, wasn’t that exactly the trouble? And I wanted to promise that I would never fail him again. But it would all have sounded –empty words and lies. (92)
Recognizing his lack of compassion, the narrator ultimately sees Sonny’s implicit humanity.
Thus, when accompanying him to the nightclub “[squeezing] through the narrow, chattering, jam-packed bar to the entrance” with “all that atmospheric lighting,” it is interesting to note that nowhere in the description of the setting is the mention of smoke (94). With the brothers’ new understanding of one another, the smoke literally fades, and even in a barroom atmosphere it is unnoticeable to the narrator as he observes “Sonny’s world. Or, rather: his kingdom” (94).
Baldwin’s story of “Sonny’s Blues,” the story of ultimate salvation, ends in a very clear field of vision. Having finally been able to comprehend and accept one another, the smoke between the brothers dissipates, and clarity is reached. The narrator passively observes Sonny’s musical triumph. Baldwin achieves the greatest effect by first allowing the reader to view life through the cloudy film of his characters’ lives. Each of their personal withdrawals and withholdings of emotion is accented by their communication through this seemingly perpetual smoke. When Baldwin clears the air, in a literary sense, at the conclusion of the story, there is a very real, refreshing feeling of honesty and openness that might not have been achieved without the integral part that cigarette smoke plays throughout. It is this masterful device that allows the reader to almost unconsciously experience the discomfort of the murky discord and the comfort of resolution. When “the smoke is cleared,” the reader can not only observe but also experience and feel.
Bibliography
Work Cited
Baldwin, James. “Sonny’s Blues.” The Story and Its Writer: An Introduction to Short Fiction.
Comp. Ann Charters. Fourth Edition. Boston: Bedford, 1995. 74 – 97.
35e
Другие работы по теме:
Smoke Or Live Essay Research Paper Raj
Smoke Or Live Essay, Research Paper Raj Sagar Francisco Gil Yeon Sik Kim Tannenbaum Freedom to Live or Freedom to Smoke? What have cigarettes done for society?nothing but taken away millions of innocent lives. Each year thousands and thousands of people die from either smoking or second-hand smoke. Smoking has not benefited anyone but the tobacco companies.
Smoking Essay Research Paper In the seventh
Smoking Essay, Research Paper In the seventh grade I began to smoke cigarettes with my brother and a friend who introduced me to cigarettes. We smoke cigarettes in the morning before we get on the bus to go to school. I smoked cigarettes all through high school until my senior year, when I began to smoke black and milds (cigars).
Smoking Be Ban Essay Research Paper
I feel that there should be laws against smoking. Right now there are laws against buying them. You have to be 18 to buy cigarette. But my question is if you have to 18 why do people under 18 have possession of cigarette? We all already know that smoking is bad for you. On the news all the time they have something about smoking and why it is so bad for you.
Smoking Essay Research Paper According to these
Smoking Essay, Research Paper According to these 2 article many teens decide to smoke because of peer pressure and looking cool. According to this recent article that was in the Detroit News about an Edsel Ford High School student they asked him why he started smoking and he said he didn t no he just did. All most every article I came across said that Joe Camel was to blame but researchers aren t sure if that s still the case.
Summary On The Articles About Second Hand
Smoking Essay, Research Paper Secondhand Smoke, Is It a Hazard? In the 1950’s and 60’s scientists gave the people a lot of evidence on the deadly effects of smoking where the tobacco companies on the other hand tried to put the doubt in people?s minds through the campaigns to show that it is not all true. By the time people actually decided to take care of their health and finally saw how life-threatening smoking could be by real life examples, the tobacco companies already got rich from its sales.
Secondhand Smoke Is Bad For Your Health
Essay, Research Paper Reyes Freytes Phil 112 4-20-01 Secondhand Smoke I went on the Internet and started surfing around until I found this web-site called www.no-smoker. This site is About Americans for Nonsmoker’s Rights. The article I read was called “Things are changing”. The issue is secondhand smoke is bad for your health.
Effects Of Secondhand Smoke Essay Research Paper
Imagine your child wheezing, working hard for every breath he takes. You rush him to the Emergency Room. He is suffering from another severe asthma attack, which he developed when he was a baby. Why? Your child has been expose to secondhand smoke. This scenario may not be your community s worst problem, but I just want to address some concerns on the affects of secondhand smoke to children s health and their future.
Why Smoking Is Hazordous Essay Research Paper
In this report I will tell you the dangers of smoking. Smoking is one of the most preventable causes of death in our society. About one in five deaths in the US are results from using tobacco. More then half of all tobacco uses die much earlier then their normal life expectancy. Smokers could be losing an average of 20 to 25 years of their life.
The Smoking Problem In America Essay Research
Paper The smoking problem in America Smoking is a severe detriment to the heath of America. Smoking is harmful to everyone s health, even in second hand form. The main argument for being able to smoke is personal freedom. It is the smokers choice if they want to smoke. I have a variety of different feelings about this topic because I am coming from a different society, distinct from that of America.
Smoking Essay Research Paper SmokingAfter reading the
Smoking Essay, Research Paper Smoking After reading the article “Whose lungs are they, anyway?” by Janet Singleton, I was able to determine the proposal at issue. The issue in this article is about why people decide to smoke and who s responsible for making hat decision. Should we put the blame one the tobacco industry or is it just people’s own decision to smoke? The position I stand in is I feel that the tobacco industry should not be held responsible for smokers’ decision to smoke.
Smoking Us Bad Essay Research Paper The
Smoking Us Bad Essay, Research Paper The prohibition of smoking has become more and more wide spread in the Unite States today. Due to studies that smoking is related to many illnesses, people have made safe guards to prevent from acquiring them. One of those safe guard is prohibiting smoking in public places.
How Secondhand Smoking Affects Us Essay Research
Paper How Secondhand Smoking Affects Us As most of you know, smoking is bad for your health, but what some of you might not know is that you don t actually have to smoke to be harmed by smoking. Lung cancer, which is the leading cause of cancer deaths in men and women, is mainly caused by cigarette smoking. Secondhand smoking causes approximately 2 percent of lung cancer deaths each year.
Tobacco Smoking And Its Risks Essay Research
Paper I am here to talk to you about smoking its risks and its consequences. First, to understand how smoking tobacco affects your body you have got to understand how smoking works inside your body
Why Smoking Is Hazardous Essay Research Paper
Hi I?m here today to tell you the dangers of smoking. Smoking is one of the most preventable causes of death in our society. About one in five deaths in the US are results from using tobacco. About half all of smokers between of 35 and 69 die ahead of time the new smokers replace them. Smokers could be losing an average of 20 to 25 years of their life.
Disgusting Smoke Stains And Odors Essay Research
Paper November 15, 1998English Comp. I Disgusting Smoke Stains and Odors Has anyone ever walked by you with the smell of stagnant smoke on his or her clothes, or have you ever met someone that has yellow stains on their teeth from nicotine? Smoking cigarettes not only makes people smell bad, but the things around them as well.
Help Put Out The Butt In Teen
Smoking Essay, Research Paper Help Put Out the Butt in Teen Smoking You could probably walk around your neighborhood and see groups of teenagers smoking. In fact, there 6,000 teens that start smoking everyday and 3,000 of them will make the choice to continue smoking. Throughout this essay, I will give you facts on why it is smart to either stop smoking now or never start.
Teen Smoking Essay Research Paper Teen smoking
Teen Smoking Essay, Research Paper Teen smoking has always been a factor in America, especially during High School. That is when teens are most likely to pick up the habit (Teen Smokers PG 13). We are constantly around people that smoke and usually offered cigarettes when they do smoke. If smoking is so bad for you then why do so many teens smoke? Because they don’t know how bad it is for them.
Smoking In Public Essay Research Paper 11299Whinery
Smoking In Public Essay, Research Paper 11/2/99Whinery 1 Got a Light Little Boy? For years, there has been a huge debate on whether cigarette smoke affects both the people being around the smoke, or the people doing the actual act itself. There is a huge cloud of ?smoke? on this topic that needs to be cleared.
Why Not To Smoke
… Essay, Research Paper First let me start off by saying that the choice to smoke is yours and yours alone. Everyone has their own freedom of choice to start smoking or never smoke at all. I am highly against the idea
Persuasion Speech Essay Research Paper Rob BurkeCom
Persuasion Speech Essay, Research Paper Rob Burke Com 210 Mr. Hunn Persuasion speech Intro: Today I would like to inform you why cigarettes are bad, and why you shouldn?t smoke. Did you know that smoking related deaths total up to the #1 cause of death in peoples. Not only can it effect you personally but it can also harm others around you.
Smoking In Restaurants Essay Research Paper I
Smoking In Restaurants Essay, Research Paper I think smoking in public places such as indoors of a restaurant shoudn’t be allowed. There’s a few good reasons for me saying that. It has been proved that smoking kills you. Besides, would you like someone smoking next to you if you have your baby with you? Not only that, But I don’t think I would like anyone to be smelling the nasty smoke odors while they’re eating.
Smoking In Public Places Essay Research Paper
Should it be legal to smoke around others in public places where there are non-smokers? Smoker’s today think that they can just light up wherever they feel. Non-smokers feel that smoking should be band from all public places. This problem between smokers and non-smokers is an ongoing battle that seems to have no solution.
Should Smoking Be Banned In Public Places
Essay, Research Paper Smoking or Non-Smoking Should There Be A Choice? Imagine sitting in a restaurant unable to enjoy a meal due to the cloud of smoke coming from a neighbor s table. The fact that there was not a designated area for smokers has put the smoker and the non-smoker in an uncomfortable situation.
Jourrnal Essay Research Paper Journal AbstractPeople effect
Jourrnal Essay, Research Paper Journal Abstract People effect others without even knowing it when they choose to smoke. When someone lights up a cigarette and others inhale secondary smoke, you directly effect their health. Most smokers deny the fact that they are damaging others, or often don t even realize what they are doing.
Effects Of Smoking 2 Essay Research Paper
Smoking has many side effects many of these effects being serious life altering side effects and not simply cosmetic. The cosmetic effects are all well known from the smell of cigarette smoke, to yellowing teeth. But also are the effects of lung cancer to not only the smoker but to anyone who is near them or being exposed to the second hand smoke of the smoker.
Would You Please Smoke Outside Essay Research
Paper Jonathan Denney T. Huddleston English Comp. II 10-04-99 Would You Please Smoke Outside! While eating dinner at El Ranchito an acrid plume of smoke wafts over my table causing my eyes to
Tobacco Should Be Illegal Essay Research Paper
Tobacco Should Be Illegal! Why isn t tobacco considered a drug? When the facts are reviewed, tobacco produces all of the effects of a drug although isn t recognized as one. What makes tobacco different from any other drug?
Smoking Essay Research Paper Smoking
Smoking Essay, Research Paper Smoking Studies of ex-smokers show that their risk of dying from smoking-related disease decreases with each year of non smoking. Encouraged by such evidence,
Passive Smoking Essay Research Paper What is
Passive Smoking Essay, Research Paper What is secondhand smoke? ? Secondhand smoke is a mixture of the smoke given off by the burning end of a cigarette, pipe, or cigar, and the smoke exhaled from the lungs of smokers.
Passive Smoking Essay Research Paper There is
Passive Smoking Essay, Research Paper There is nothing more annoying and sickening than sitting down for a meal at the local restaurant, or any place for that matter and having the poisonous haze of cigarette smoke drift towards you. It moves in an ever-expanding mass to all corners of the room, being inhaled by all.