Schools And Tests Essay, Research Paper
SCHOOLS AND TESTING
In the article provided, the author, Dick Williams, presents two ideas on the state of schools and education in the United States. The points of view he attempts to argue are the conditions of the nation s schools and the quality of the educational system. During his efforts to present his points, it appears as though his article is more opinionated than objective. This presents a problem because an opinion is not an argument. By presenting his thoughts he fails to do so tactfully through arguments, and those that are arguments are fallacies.
One of the first arguments presented deals with the conditions of the schools. Specifically the renewal and renovations of schools comes into question.
Should the harried taxpayers of Cobb and Dekalb counties, for instance, bail out incompetent or corrupt school boards in other states? Should New York City be rewarded for failing to build new schools in a timely manner?
This is the fallacy known as the circular argument. A circular argument is where the premise and the conclusion repeat each other using different wording. The premise in this fallacy would be the first question, while the second question is the conclusion. The idea in this statement is that cities with rundown schools are being paid for by taxpayers in other cities. In these cities the problems with schools are quite minimum.
Another argument made early on focuses on the office of the president. In the middle of the second paragraph, Williams writes:
President Clinton has become the master of exploiting the divide. Insiders call it the micropresidency: Identify a problem and propose a small solution.
In this statement, the phrase Insiders call it the micro-presidency is the conclusion. The rest of the statement forms the premise. Williams tries to convey the trickery of the president and his lack of handling problems effectively. Basically he attacks the presidency and commits the Ad hominem fallacy. The Ad Hominem is an attack against someone based on some aspect of his or her character, which has no relevance on the argument being made. This statement has no relevance on the point of the schools in America.
The second point Williams focuses on is the education of the school system in the country. More specifically he turns his attention to the testing of America s youth through the end of high school. High school graduates can take the SAT or the ACT. Well, this sentence is a clear case of the false extremes fallacy. Dick Williams assumes that high school graduates have only the choice of the SAT or ACT exams. Not all high school graduates take the SAT or the ACT. Some take entrance exams give by a college or whatever entrance exam or assignment a college will require for admission. So there are other alternatives to the SAT and ACT exams.
The last point the author makes in concluding his article is directed towards the future of testing of the countries struggling students.
The cry for national testing is a simplistic way of moving toward a national curriculum contemptuous of state and local tradition. It strengthens bureaucrats and diminishes local elected officials.
For this statement, the first sentence is the premise while the second is the conclusion. However, this is an appeal to pity. It is a fallacy because the premise provides no real or justifiable reason for the conclusion. The cry for national testing does not strengthen bureaucrats now does it diminish local tradition .
The author of this article, Dick Williams, commits at least four fallacies; the Ad Hominem, the appeal to pity, the circular argument, and false extremes. He clings to a conservative, republican view of the school situation in general and of the president. He believes in getting the job done, but he scolds the president for trying to do so. Thus, his political alliance makes a large part of this article an opinion instead of an objective editorial. In the few arguments Williams presents, he has good foresight but bad tact therefore creating the bad arguments that appear in his writing.
Другие работы по теме:
High Schools Should Not Rely On Standard
Achievement Scores Essay, Research Paper High Schools Should not use Standardized Achievement Scores to Determine Whether Students Should be Promoted, Without Regard to Course Grades
Cellphones At School Essay Research Paper Cell
Cellphones? At School? Essay, Research Paper Cell phones should be banned from rural schools. There is no reason for them in rural schools, they are a distraction, and finally they could aid in violent
Education Essay Research Paper One of the
Education Essay, Research Paper One of the greatest problems in American society today is a variation in the quality of education, dependent upon the wealth, or lack thereof, in particular areas. This problem is especially notorious in areas of destitution. Lower standards for the schools in these poorer neighborhoods are another step in the cycle of poverty.
Changes In Education Essay Research Paper There
Changes In Education Essay, Research Paper There are many significant events in the world of education. Each one changed the way that teachers taught; the way schools were run and what they learned. To this day, something new and exciting happens all the time.
School Prayer Essay Research Paper The United
School Prayer Essay, Research Paper The United States Supreme court will once again address the issues of prayer in public schools. In the constitution, it guarantees freedom of religion, and separation between church and state. Should the government be allowed to base an opinion on social values versus social values? Just like any other controversy, there are two opposing sides.
Morals Essay Research Paper Everybody has grown
Morals Essay, Research Paper Everybody has grown up around some extant morals, whether it is within their own household or it is taught to them at some other place, like school for instance. For decades now, there has been a gargantuan controversy over whether or not teachers should teach morals to students.
Commercials Essay Research Paper In every young
Commercials Essay, Research Paper In every young person life there are certain critical decisions that must be made. One of the more important of the many is the choice to resume education after high school. After that decision is made the choice of which college to go to comes into play. In making this decision you must first do research on schools that interest you, you must visit these campuses, and last you must apply to the schools of your choice.
Prayer In Schools Essay Research Paper We
Prayer In Schools Essay, Research Paper We are guaranteed by the first amendment the right for freedom of religion. By this right, we as American citizens should be allowed to have prayer in the public schools and teachers should be allowed to teach religion courses trough the high school years. We should also be able to talk about religion in and out of our classes.
Assimilation In Schools Essay Research Paper I
Assimilation In Schools Essay, Research Paper I believe that the most common of these three is assimilation. Assimilation occurs in many different ways in our schools, and it is unfortunately a part of life that we all have to learn to accept, no matter the consequences. America is more commonly known as the melting pot, one would assume automatically that the schools would consists of numerous cultures yet we still insist on forcing the American way of life onto many of our students.
Dress Codes Essay Research Paper During the
Dress Codes Essay, Research Paper During the 1980’s, some schools began to impose “dress codes” in order to obtain a proper school environment. The “dress codes” stated that students should be dressed decently and clothing or hair fashions should not distract other students. I believe that “dress codes” should be imposed in order to eliminate problems in a public schools.
Violent Kid Profile Essay Research Paper THE
Violent Kid Profile Essay, Research Paper ?THE VIOLENT-KID PROFILE? Are students being judged by the way they act, by what they say, or even by the way they dress? Sadly, the answer is yes. Not by their peers, but
10 Commandments In Schools Essay Research Paper
P.S. 233-03 Ed Mashek Dr. Hicks 02/08/01 Assignment #1 The 1st Amendment in Schools Right now in Kentucky, there is a somewhat heated debate going on about whether or not the 10 Commandments should be posted in public schools. The people, schools, and our state and federal governments all seem to have their own opinion, but which one is the right one? That is, which one follows the guidelines set in the Bill of Rights? Legally speaking, schools in Kentucky were required to display the Ten Commandments, until the Supreme Court declared that law unconstitutional.
Prayer In Schools Essay Research Paper Prayer
Prayer In Schools Essay, Research Paper Prayer in Schools I feel prayer should be re-established in America’s schools. There is a strong belief in God by the government, so our schools should also support that idea. Many use prayer as a guidance tool. It gives a lot of students something to believe in and a sense of hope.
Public Vs Private Essay Research Paper In
Public Vs Private Essay, Research Paper In the world today many parents ponder the thought whether private schools are better than public schools. They decide what would be better for their children. When they do this they ponder many different things like what would be academically better for my son or daughter or which would be safest and some people even would send their son or daughter to a school just for athletics.
School Violence Essay Research Paper Eng 105GordonProblem
School Violence Essay, Research Paper Eng. 105-Gordon Problem: Violence in schools around the nation is a serious problem. It includes gang activity, theft, bullying and intimidation, and the use of guns and other weapons. The total number of crimes committed in public schools has risen to close three million each year.
Dress Codes In Schools Essay Research Paper
Dress Codes in Schools All public schools in America should have a relaxed dress code. Schools have many rules and guidelines. How students dress should not have to be included within those rules.
Dress Code Essay Research Paper At the
Dress Code Essay, Research Paper At the beginning of the 20th century there wasn’t much discussion about the dress code in schools. During that time kids weren’t dressing so provocative. Now that we are so close to the 21st century. There is a big controversy between the students and the schools about the dress code especially in public schools.
American Education Essay Research Paper As far
American Education Essay, Research Paper As far as the world standard goes, American public education is near the top of the ladder. But, when you compare the education here to other first world countries, we fall way short. This is not to say that all public schooling institutions are of poor quality, though, because there are many public schools in America that do provide quality education.
Commercialism In Schools Essay Research Paper Commercialism
Commercialism In Schools Essay, Research Paper Commercialism affects children everyday. Children are targeted by companies to become life-long buyers of their products. When commercialism is brought into schools it is harder for children to learn to make educated decisions about their purchases. Kids need to be educated and given proper instructions about how to be objective towards advertisements.
What Makes A Good School Essay Research
Paper What Makes A Good School? According to Morrison, author of Teaching in America, schools are organized and linked to society. In chapter 3, Morrison explains the role of schooling in society, how public schools are organized, what it is like to teach in different kinds of schools, what makes a good school, and how schools are changing.
Sex Education Essay Research Paper Despite sex
Sex Education Essay, Research Paper Despite sex education at schools, teens are still lacking information on this topic. Even as more and more discussions about sex increase on TV, movies, and even at school,
Education In England Essay Research Paper England
Education In England Essay, Research Paper England has one of the finest educational system in the world. All English children between ages 5-16 must attend school. About 90 percent of the students go to schools supported entirely or partly by public funds. The rest of the students attend private schools.
Public School Vs Private School Essay Research
Paper Which is better Public or Private schools? This is a common question that parents ask themselves today. Hopes for the best possible education drives schools, teachers, and parents to create better fields and means in which to thrive, and keep up in today?s society. As the major differences between these two is organization and funding; private schools are funded by student tuition costs, which can add up to substantially, more than public schools.
Schools 2 Essay Research Paper SCHOOLSThere are
Schools 2 Essay, Research Paper SCHOOLS There are hundreds, if not thousand of schools in this world. In Malaysia, we have seven types of schools. They are Malay schools, Tamil schools, Chinese schools, international schools, private schools, and religious schools.
Private Schools VS Public Schools Essay Research
Paper Private Schools VS. Public Schools Parents often wonder how to start off their children?s education. Depending on ones religion or beliefs a private or public school is a choose most parents face. Of course, each school offers it?s own pros and con?s the choice is simple. Public schools offer the best well rounding of a student.
Money In Schools Essay Research Paper I
Money In Schools Essay, Research Paper I think that money is a key factor today in American schools. For instance, if you take a kid who has been going to a wealthy school, and a kid who has been going to a deprived school, test show that the student from the wealthy school is more likely to succeed, on top of graduating high school.
Bush Essay Research Paper Governor Bush will
Bush Essay, Research Paper Governor Bush will reform the nation?s public schools, as he has in Texas, which is one of two states that have made the greatest recent progress in education. He will close the achievement gap, set high standards, promote character education, and ensure school safety. States will be offered freedom from federal regulation, but will be held accountable for results.
American and British Schools
In America, all children from six to sixteen go to school. They spend six years in "elementary" school, and four or six years in "secondary" or "high" school. School education is free.
Integration Essay Research Paper The dictionary defines
Integration Essay, Research Paper The dictionary defines integration as a way to make schools, parks, and other facilities available to people of all races on an equal basis. Before 1960, both black and white americans alone have basically lived seperately, in society itself, but kind of in their own way.
Schools Of Psychology Essay Research Paper Schools
Schools Of Psychology Essay, Research Paper Schools of Psychology There are seven major schools of psychology Behavioral, Psychoanalytic, Humanistic, Cognitive, Neurobiological, Sociological, and Industrial. First off behavioral psychology emphasizes the scientific study of behavior and its environmental determinants.
Private Education Essay Research Paper Nelson JL
Private Education Essay, Research Paper Nelson, J.L., Carlson, K., & Palonsky, S.B. (1993). Private schools: Essential or undemocratic. In Critical issues in education (pp. 63-78). New York: McGraw-Hill,