One? Essay, Research Paper
Biosafety Protocol: Is There A Need For One?
By John M. Seguin
Outline
Thesis statement: An international biosafety protocol should be created to
establish and maintain control over the products designed with biotechnology.
I. The existing laws and regulations that govern the release of
transgenic
organisms are inadequate or nonexistent.
A. The developed nations of the world are using regulations
that were designed to control and monitor crops created with
traditional technologies.
B. Biotechnology is regulated by three different agencies.
C. The undeveloped nations have virtually no regulations
governing transgenic organisms.
1. This indicates that biotechnological research can and is
being conducted in these countries without regulation.
2. There are many biotech companies based in developed
countries that have branches or joint ventures around
the world.
II. The potential risks of transgenic organisms to the environment
is still being determined.
A. Some experts warn that there is a danger that biotechnology
can create mutant hybrids.
B. Biotechnology has the potential to harm the economies of some
developing nations.
C. The last and possible the most important argument for an
international biosafety protocol is in the name of ignorance
and caution
III. The United States, Germany, Japan, and Australia are the only
countries opposed to the biosafety protocol.
IV. The need for a change in the world of agriculture is undeniable.
As the world moves closer to the 21st century, research and development
in the area of biotechnology has increased dramatically. According to Bette
Hileman of Chemical and Engineering News, the world population will increase by
3 billion people in the next thirty years while the amount of land available for
agriculture cannot be greatly expanded. “Biotechnology – specifically that
aspect involved in transferring genes from one species into the [DNA] of another
- has the potential to alleviate . . .” (8) this and many other problems facing
the world in the near future. Even though biotechnology has already shown
dramatic results in the creation of beneficial transgenic (genetically
engineered) species, many countries and researchers are “. . . quite leery about
the uses of biotechnology” (8). Therefore, an international biosafety protocol
should be created to establish and maintain control over the products designed
with biotechnology.
The existing laws and regulations that govern the release of transgenic
organisms are inadequate or nonexistent. In general, the developed nations of
the world are using regulations that were designed to control and monitor crops
created with traditional technologies like hybridization and cross-breeding
(Hileman 8). Pamela Weintraub, of the National Audubon Society, states that
many expected problems with biotechnology can be kept under control with proper
regulations, but the regulations (where there are any) governing biotechnology
today are “tangled and obscure” (164).
In the United States for example, biotechnology is regulated by three
different agencies: the United States Department of Agriculture (USDA), the Food
and Drug Administration (FDA), and the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA).
These three agencies regulate product research and commercialization of
transgenic organisms depending upon their nature and intended use. The USDA
regulates transgenic plants grown on a large scale. If a product of transgenic
origin is to be used as a food, then it falls under FDA regulations. The EPA
has jurisdiction over all transgenic organisms that express or function as a
pesticide, and all genetically engineered microorganisms. Because Congress has
elected not to instate a law specifically regulating transgenic organisms, all
three of these agencies are using existing regulations designed for crops
created by traditional methods. According to Bette Hileman of Chemical and
Engineering News, “Under the existing legal framework, environmental releases of
most gene tically engineered animals are essentially unregulated” (9).
The undeveloped nations on the other hand have virtually no regulations
governing transgenic organisms. This means that research can and is being
conducted in these countries without regulation to protect the ecology. A
resolution passed by the European Parliament confirmed this when they stated,
“Deliberate releases of genetically modified organisms are being carried out in
many developing countries, which have no legislation or infrastructure to ensure
their safe use. . . “(Hileman 8). Further proof that this is taking place is
the speed with which transgenic crops are being commercially produced in these
nations. China, for example, has transgenic vegetables engineered for
resistance to viruses that have been on the market for about 18 months. Similar
transgenic crops in the United States are still in the testing and approval
stages at the USDA (Moffat186).
There are many biotech companies based in developed countries that have
branches or joint ventures around the world, especially in undeveloped countries.
One of the biggest, Pioneer Hi-Bred International based in Des Moines, Iowa,
has branches in over thirty countries (Hileman 16). Many of these companies
conduct enough research to adequately ensure that there are minimal
environmental and ecological risks, but Rebecca Goldburg, chairman of the
biotechnology program at the Environmental Defense Fund, “. . . warns that other
companies may follow through only if adequate regulations are in place” (qtd. in
Weintraub 163).
The potential risks of transgenic organisms to the environment is still
being determined. Some experts warn that there is a danger that biotechnology
can create mutant hybrids that can seriously endanger the ecosystem (Dalglish
41). As stated by Heike Dornenburg, quoted in The Reference Shelf: Genetics and
Society, “The number of genetically engineered products at the brink of
commercialization is growing. A number of environmental and ecological risks
remain unanswered” (152). One concern is that transgenic plants could either
become weeds that could raise the cost of weed control, or could transfer genes
into wild relatives that could then develop into weeds. Other risks include the
inadvertent spread of new virus strains which could gain resistance to virus
resistant plants, as well as possible detrimental effects on insects, birds, and
other animals that feed on transgenic plants (Dornenburg 152-53).
Biotechnology also has the potential to harm the economies of some
developing nations. According to Lawrence Busch, a Michigan State University
sociologist, if it becomes feasible “. . . to use plant cell culture techniques
to make high-value materials, such as vanilla and cocoa butter . . . ” (qtd in
Moffat 187) then these products can be made in the laboratory, instead of having
to extract them from tropical plants. The economies of the nations that have
traditionally produced these materials rely heavily on them for income. If
these materials can now be produced cheaper and easier in a laboratory, then the
developing country will lose one of its major exports (Moffat 187).
The last and possibly the most important argument for an international
biosafety protocol is in the name of ignorance and caution. Burke K. Zimmerman,
author of the book Biofuture: Confronting the Genetic Era, expounds on the
uncertainties of biotechnology:
Perhaps we all have a need for certainty in our lives, or the assurance
of knowing the limits to our lives or the fates that could befall us. Here,
however, we cannot allow ourselves that comfort. The knowledge we have gained
about living cells in recent years has been vast, but it has also showed us how
much more we have yet to learn. We will simply have to accept the fact that
there are uncertainties in our lives with which we will have to contend for some
time to come. One of those uncertainties is the absolute assurance that there
can never be a biological disaster (150)
Many researchers argue that there hasn’t been enough testing and
virtually no working experience in this field. Referring to the detrimental
effects modern agriculture has already had on the environment, Jack Brown, a
plant breeder geneticist at the University of Idaho, states, “Modern agriculture
has happened at a price. We should learn from our experiences what disasters
could befall us before we jump into large-scale production of gene-modified
plants” (qtd in Hileman 15). Jeremy Rifkin, president of the Washington-based
Foundation on Economic Trends, sums up the sentiment on the release of
transgenic organisms by stating, “Every introduction is a hit-or-miss ecological
roulette” (qtd. in Weintraub 160).
The United States, Germany, Japan, and Australia are the only countries
opposed to the biosafety protocol. They maintain that voluntary guidelines are
all that is needed to regulate international biotechnology. The opponents of a
biosafety protocol also argue that it will harm international trade and
corporate profits ( Hileman 8). A few researchers, typically in the private
sector, maintain that “Biotechnology is simply an extension of traditional
agricultural practices like hybridization and cross-breeding” (Mather 18).
According to John C. Sorenson, general manager of Asgrow, “. . . bioengineering
does not threaten plant or animal diversity, any more than conventional seed and
animal breeding programs do” (qtd. in Mather 162).
The need for a change in the world of agriculture is undeniable. The
world population is expected to approximately double in the next thirty years.
To feed this many new mouths with the same agricultural practices, the amount of
land available for agriculture must approximately double in size. The only
available land that is not being used for agriculture already is the endangered
and protected natural areas (Hileman 8). When the amount of land used for food
production increases, then so does the amount of chemicals used in today’s
agricultural processes increase. These chemicals are vital because they offset
or prevent the losses from weeds, pests, and diseases. Hopefully with new
technologies, biotechnology being one of them, plants will be created that can
grow and survive without the use of these environmentally harmful chemicals
(Hileman 14). While many people agree that biotechnology will be at least part
of the solution, they are also concerned about the safety of transgenic
organisms
that are released into the environment (Barker 126).
Works Cited
Barker, Penelope, ed. The Reference Shelf: Genetics and Society. New York: H.W.
Wilson Company, 1995.
Dalglish, Brenda. “Changing the face of the farm.” Macleans 06 March 1995:
41-42.
Dornenburg, Heike, and Christine Lang-Hinrichs. “Genetic Engineering in Food
Biotechnology.” The Reference Shelf: Genetics and Society. Ed. Penelope Barker.
New York: H.W. Wilson Company, 1995. 145-153.
Hileman, Bette. “Views differ sharply over benefits, risks of agricultural
biotechnology.” Chemical and Engineering News 73 (1995): 8-17.
Mather, Robin. A Garden of Unearthly Delights: Bioengineering and the Future of
Food. New York: Penguin Group, 1995.
Moffat, Ann S. “Developing Nations Adapt Biotech for own needs.” Science 08
July 1994: 186-187.
Weintraub, Pamela. “The Coming of the High-Tech Harvest.” The Reference Shelf:
Genetics and Society. Ed. Penelope Barker, New York: H.W. Wilson Company, 1995.
155-167
Zimmerman, Burke K. Biofuture: Confronting the Genetic Era. New York: Plenum
Press, 1984.
Другие работы по теме:
Wap Essay Research Paper What is WAPWAP
Wap Essay, Research Paper What is WAP? WAP stands for Wireless Application Protocol. The idea has been developed by some of the wireless telecommunications giants such as Nokia and Ericsson.
Telnet Essay Research Paper TelnetPURPOSE OF THIS
Telnet Essay, Research Paper Telnet PURPOSE OF THIS REPORT Before gophers, hypertext, and sophisticated web browsers, telnet was the primary means by which computer users connected their machines with other
Arpanet Essay Research Paper The USSR launches
Arpanet Essay, Research Paper The USSR launches Sputnik, the first artificial earth satellite. In the late 1960’s the U.S. military was desperately afraid of a nuclear attack from the Soviet Union. The United States formed the Advanced Research Projects Agency (ARPA) within the Department of Defense to establish a bombproof network to connect military bases.
Lassa Virus Essay Research Paper The Lassa
Lassa Virus Essay, Research Paper The Lassa virus is a vulgar virus with a high mortality rate and an expensive cure. Lassa was strange to me because I have never heard of the virus before. As I was reading in my research, I began to realize the risk the virus has on people.
The Life In A Greenhouse Essay Research
Paper The life in a greenhouse may be a deadly one in the future. Every single day people pollute the environment and the ozone layer cannot withstand all the pollution that takes place. Much of the pollution comes from cars, trucks, factories, and everyday house hold items, such as refrigerators and air conditioners.
Ebola Essay Research Paper Your have sudden
Ebola Essay, Research Paper Your have sudden fever, weakness, muscle pains, headache, and a sore throat, and that is just what?s happening to you before the really bad symptoms of this virus kicks in. These are followed by vomiting, diarrhea, and rash, and that are just some of the bad symptoms of this horrible virus know as the Ebola virus.
Internet Structure Essay Research Paper The Internet
Internet Structure Essay, Research Paper The Internet connects nearly 400 million users worldwide and is an essential part of how we work, play, communicate, and conduct commerce. We use the Internet in ways that seemed unimaginable The term “Internet” refers to the global information system that — (i) is logically linked together by a globally unique address space based on the Internet Protocol (IP) or its subsequent extensions/follow-ons. (ii) is able to support communications using the Transmission Control Protocol/Internet Protocol (TCP/IP) suite or its subsequent extensions/follow-ons, and/or other IP-compatible protocols; and (iii) provides, uses or makes accessible layered on the communications and related infrastructure described herein.”, either publicly or privately, high level services.
Logical Positism And The Vienna Circle Essay
, Research Paper Moritz Schlick and A.J. Ayer were both logical positivists, and members of the Vienna Circle. They had differing yet concentric views on the foundations of knowledge, and they both shared the quest for truth and certainty.
TcpIp Essay Research Paper Introduction I
Tcp/Ip Essay, Research Paper Introduction I will demonstrate the unique power of TCP/IP. We will explore some of the powers of this suite of protocols and understand the importance of using it. TCP/IP is actually a packet of information being sent through different servers to reach its destination. In some instances it takes only seconds and with certain programs you can actually see how many servers and seconds it actually takes to reach it’s destination.
Ip History Essay Research Paper Recent years
Ip History Essay, Research Paper Recent years saw huge increase in Internet growth there were 40,073 networks on Internet (as of 10/4/94) and it was doubling approximately every 12 months. The current version (IPv4) of Internet Protocol was sufficient for 20 years, but if Internet will continue to grow, pretty soon we will run out of addresses for all connections because IPv4 can handle only 32 bit addresses (which are millions of connections).
The Internet Essay Research Paper The InternetBy
The Internet Essay, Research Paper The Internet By Greg Lynch Once, a small and simple collection of computers operated by the Defense Department is now a massive world-wide network of computers that we call the Internet. The word Internet literally means “network of networks.” In itself, the Internet is composed of thousands of smaller local networks scattered throughout the globe.
Biotechnology Information Essay Research Paper Since its
Biotechnology Information Essay, Research Paper Since its inception, the International Centre for Genetic Engineering and Biotechnology (ICGEB) has devoted all its efforts in assisting its Member States, most of which are developing countries or countries with economies in transition, for the peaceful application of modern biotechnology.
Internet Service Providers Essay Research Paper The
Internet Service Providers Essay, Research Paper The internet is an excellent resource for information, entertainment, and communication. The term “internet” refers to the global information system that is logically linked together by a globally unique address space (ie. yahoo) based on the Internet Protocol (IP) or its subsequent extensions/follow-ons; is able to support communications using the Transmission Control Protocol/Internet Protocol (TCP/IP) suite or its subsequent extensions/follow-ons, and/or other IP-compatible protocols; and provides, uses or makes accessible layered on the communications and related infrastructure described herein.”, either publicly or privately, high level services You can do so many things on the internet, such as communicate by e-mail, instant messaging, or chat rooms with family and friends, play games, download music mp3s and videos through an FTP
Bartelby The Scrivener Essay Research Paper Bartleby
Bartelby, The Scrivener Essay, Research Paper Bartleby, the Scrivener by Herman Melville will be the story I intend to discuss in this protocol. I intend to discuss this story in terms of four literary elements: Character symbolism, descriptive passages, irony and the novellas theme.
Ozone Depletion Essay Research Paper The Ozone
Ozone Depletion Essay, Research Paper The Ozone Layer Ozone layer depletion slows There is good news about the ozone layer above us. The good news about the ozone layer is not always frequent. On International Ozone Day, the report came in that the ozone levels have decreased above Montreal and other residents of southern Canada.
History Of The Internet Essay Research Paper
History of the Internet The Internet as we know today was not a concept that was quickly enacted when it was first thought up. It was a revolutionary process that was the result of visionary people who painstakingly brought forth the World Wide Web. These individuals saw a promising potential in allowing computers to share information on research and development in scientific and military fields.
8Th Amendment To Us Constitution Essay Research
Paper In the United States Constitution, the 8th Amendment prohibits the use and practices of cruel and unusual punishment. What exactly is considered to be cruel and unusual punishment? This question is a hot topic among America’s many different current controversies. Many people are saying that the use of capital punishment (to be sentenced to death as a penalty in the eyes of the law [a capital crime].
Netiquette Essay Research Paper As we enter
Netiquette Essay, Research Paper As we enter the age of computer technology, more and more people are relying on the computer for communication. The main medium of computer communication is e-mail. When using e-mail there are some basic unwritten rules that one should follow. E-mail protocol, better known as netiquette, is the list of rules that are generally followed.
Ipv4 Vs Ipv6 Essay Research Paper Evan
Ipv4 Vs. Ipv6 Essay, Research Paper Evan Gilden 2/12/01 CIT/TCT 120 Ipv4 vs. Ipv6 Ipv4 is short Internet Protocol Version 4, the same goes for Ipv6. Most of todays internet uses Ipv4 witch is almost 20 years old. There has been one magor problem with Ipv4, it is running out of IP addresses (IP addresses are a unique identifirer for a computer on the internet).
Big Oil
’s View On Global Warming Essay, Research Paper Big Oil?s Proposals Proposal 1 Representatives of major corporations that will be affected by the Kyoto Protocol should play a major role in the procedures:
The Ebola Virus Essay Research Paper Ebola
The Ebola Virus Essay, Research Paper Ebola Hemorrhagic Fever In the world today, there are many known deadly viruses, but few present as great a threat as Ebola, the virus that causes Ebola Hemorrhagic Fever. Key factors in understanding Ebola HF include: Its history, plan of attack, and the diagnosis and treatment of the disease.
Cgi Scripts Essay Research Paper CGI Scripts
Cgi Scripts Essay, Research Paper CGI Scripts Must have Internet service provider that will allow you to run CGI scripts. You should really have telnet access to your account, too
Wireless Application Protocol Essay Research Paper Wireless
Wireless Application Protocol Essay, Research Paper Wireless Application Protocol (WAP) Background Market study has shown that the number of mobile users is exceeding the number of PC users. Some of the industry leaders have created a forum to evolve an industry standard for providing internet access to users over wireless access.
The Evolution Of Tcp Ip (And The Internet
Essay, Research Paper The Evolution of TCP/IP (and the Internet) While the TCP/IP protocols and the Internet are different, their evolution are most definitely parallel. This section will discuss some of the history.
The Seven Layers Of The Osi Network
Model Essay, Research Paper The Seven Layers of the OSI Network ModelThe OSI Reference model is comprised of seven layers. This network model is used to describe the different layers, or “parts” of a network. Ranging from software related to hardware related, they are: Application, Presentation, Session, Transport, Network, Data-link, and Physical.
The Upward Migration Essay Research Paper The
The Upward Migration Essay, Research Paper The Upward Migration Whether or not it has anything to say, the world wants to be connected. Royal Messengers, Pony Express riders, door-to-door mailmen, radio, and television all had their glory days, and now it’s the internet’s turn. At a very rapid rate, the internet’s population is increasing, and our available address base is shrinking.
Buddhism Vs Christianity Essay Research Paper Border
Buddhism Vs Christianity Essay, Research Paper Border Gateway Protocol Exodus Communications should implement Border Gateway Protocol (BGP) into its new network architecture at the Westmoor Building in Westminster, Colorado. BGP is a well-known exterior routing protocol in the computing industry, highly reliable in routing data, and provides circuit load balancing with redundancy.
Kyoto Protocol Advantages And Limitations Essay Research
Paper The Kyoto Protocol: Advantages and Limitations The advent of industrialized civilization has brought to us many remarkable feats that enhance our everyday lives. Such things as automobiles, airplanes, tractors, mainframe computers, and even relatively simple machines like lawnmowers have intertwined themselves into the everyday culture of modern day industrialized countries..
Intranet 2 Essay Research Paper These days
Intranet 2 Essay, Research Paper These days Intranets are becoming more and more popular throughout the business world and other types of organizations. Many companies and organizations are already making this change and many more are considering it. The advantages offered by Intranets when compared to other types of networks are many, at a reduced cost for the owner.
Atm Essay Research Paper Traditional local area
Atm Essay, Research Paper Traditional local area networks, such as Ethernet and Token Ring, use a connectionless or unreliable approach when sending information across the network. Each client is connected to the network by an adapter card, which has a driver, and above that driver is a protocol driver, such as TCP/IP.
Token Vs Ethernet Essay Research Paper Well
Token Vs Ethernet Essay, Research Paper Well, now I feel confused about this whole situation. I started taking classes part time at BU about five years ago. I took two networking classes, Network hardware and Network management. I didn?t transfer my credits to um because the technology had changed so fast, and I wanted to learn the newest technology.