Internet Censorship Essay, Research Paper
Internet Censorship
Does censorship violate the first amendment? This is one of the largest questions in Congress at the moment: whether or not to require blocking software in schools and libraries that receive government funding, cutting their funds if they do not. By law, all printed materials are protected from censorship due to freedom of speech and freedom of the press, but does this include the Internet? Yes, it does and, therefore, blocking software companies, such as Solid Oak (makers of CYBERsitter) and N2H2 (makers of BESS), have been abusing their power and should not be used to control Internet access.
Keyword blocking filters incoming html documents and web sites for certain key words that these companies have decided are not acceptable for minors. This does not allow access to those documents and sites that contain these words. This method prevents access to such sites as the Breast Cancer Legislation and The Vatican. In a study of average error rates due to keyword blocking done by Peacefire, the conditions of the study were as follows:
Using “zone files” from Network Solutions (which list all domains in existence), we obtained a list of the first 1,000 active domains on the Internet as of June 14, 2000. We tested this list of 1,000 domains using five popular blocking programs: Cyber Patrol, SurfWatch, Bess, AOL Parental Controls, and SafeServer, to see how many sites each program blocked as “pornography”, and of those sites, how many were actually pornographic (Error).
In this study, Surf Watch came out with one of the highest error rates, with 42 of 51 sites tested blocked (Error). Another problem with keyword blocking is a human worker does not review the website in order to rule it obscene or not. Our Review Team carefully analyses and catalogs in accordance with the Integrity Online Filtering Philosophy (Integrity). This is obviously a lie, because sites such as the Breast Form FAQ and Breast Cancer Legislation are blocked. Programs such as MudCrawler are used to search the web for keywords and place any offending site s address on the software s blacklist. These keywords and affected sites are usually not reviewed by a human being first, resulting in errors (BESS). This kind of mistake can clearly be avoided. Automatic keyword blocking is not a good way to filter the Internet, because far too many web pages that are not obscene in any way are blocked and placed on the hard-coded list.
Software companies are intentionally blocking many sites that are not overly violent or pornographic. For example, Cyber Patrol blocked the Ontario Center for Religious Tolerance and the Envirolink Animal Rights page due to the manufacturer deeming the description of animal testing in laboratories unsuitable for young children. Another example is the fact that BESS, another censorware company, blocks the Safer Sex Page, the anti-racists Hate Watch as well as the Marijuana Policy Project, a web site that advocates the use of medical marijuana. The company X-Stop blocks the AIDS Quilt and the official page of the Quakers (FAQ). The reason for blocking some of these sites is unknown as there is no offensive material on the web page at all.
Blocking software companies are severely abusing their power of censorship and forcing their conservative view on their customers. Many filtering companies discriminate against gay, lesbian and non-mainstream religions. Brian Milburn, the CEO of Solid Oak Software Inc., has censored access to nearly all Wiccan and Pagan sites and added witch , pagan , and the like to the list of blocked words as well as words usually connected with minority religions such as Jehovah s Witnesses , Hare Krishna , and Brethren . Many non-mainstream religions are not accessible at many schools and libraries across the United States. CYBERsitter also blocks all gay and lesbian sites that center on gay rights and AIDS awareness (Anti-Wiccan). Censorware companies also block their critics or send them an emailbomb. TIME Magazine was put on the CYBERsitter blacklist due to an article, The CYBERsitter Diaper Change , which criticizes CYBERsitter s blocking philosophy (Out). A lady by the name of Sarah Salls received an emailbomb from Solid Oak and her web site, Thewitchs, and many other Wiccan and Pagan were blocked:
This blocking came about as a result of an e-mail that I had written criticizing Solid Oak Software for blocking The National Organization for Women’s website and ALL homosexual related sites including sites focused on gay rights and AIDS awareness. As a result of that letter, I was e-mail bombed by the software company and had my own two domains, thepagans and thewitches blocked. The company further made a public statement dismissing my concerns as irrelevant due to the fact that I “run a website promoting Witchcraft and Pagan activities.” Two days after blocking my domains, the above Wiccan/Pagan related keywords were added, effectively blocking or censoring ALL Wiccan/Pagan websites on the web from customers using CYBERsitter (Emailbombed).
Wired News wrote, She says her account received more than 800 emails from support@solidoak, quoting her letter with the subject line re: your crap and a message Do not send us any more e-mail! (Emailbombed). This is simply uncalled for. TIME magazine wrote about the gay and lesbian access online:
Such programs also give parents near-complete control over what their children can and can’t read. Traditionally, kids have been able to browse the stacks of a library away from parental supervision. But when the library is online, access can be completely controlled by censorware. Pity the closeted gay son of homophobic parents, prevented by CYBERsitter from accessing socpport.youth.lesbian-gay-bi (Change).
Encrypted blacklists prevent parents and librarians from seeing what sites are being blocked. TIME Magazine reporter, Declan McCullagh, wrote:
I have one major objection to all of the software filters currently on the market: Consumers have no way of knowing what’s being blocked. Without knowing what’s on the filter list, parents can’t know what Junior will or won’t be seeing. When reporters who try to reveal that information are faced with potential criminal investigations, the press’s ability to shed light on these companies is threatened (Change).
This abuse of power is unnecessary and should not be allowed.
Censorship can be like a hammer in the hand of a carpenter. It can be used to build up or tear down. Over 200 years ago, our forefathers left a country that was based on censorship. No one had the right to express his or her concerns against the English government or the church. On July 4, 1776, these same men established a government of and for the people with certain rights. It is interesting that this first right is the freedom of speech, the very same freedom that so many today are wanting to censor?
Is America going backwards to where its forefathers came from, or are the American people going to uphold the dreams of the founding fathers and the Constitution of the United States of America?
Let freedom ring!
Works Cited
Brown, Janelle. Write a Complaint, Get Emailbombed. Wired News 9 Feb. 1998 Wired News. 6 Dec. 2000.
Cockburn, Bruce. CYBERsitter is Anti-Wiccan, Anti-Pagan, Anti-Religious Freedom, Anti-Free Speech. CYBERsitter is Anti-Wiccan, Anti-Pagan, Anti-Religious Freedom, Anti-Free Speech. 6 Dec. 2000.
Haselton, Bennett. BESS, the Internet Retriever Examined Peacefire. 15 Nov. 2000
Haselton, Bennett. Blocking Software FAQ Peacefire. 15 Nov. 2000
Haselton, Bennett. Study of Average Error Rates for Censorware Programs. Peacefire. 15 Nov. 2000.
Integrity Online. Integrity Online Internet Filtering Philosophy and Methods. 7 Dec. 2000.
Lindsay, Greg. CYBERsitter Decides to Take a Time Out. TIME Digital 8 Aug. 1997, TIME Magazine. 28 Nov. 2000.
McCullagh, Declan. The CYBERsitter Diaper Change. TIME Digital 12 Jan. 1997, TIME Magazine. 28 Nov. 2000.
Другие работы по теме:
The Future Of The Internet Essay Research
Paper The Future Of The Internet In Today’s world of computers, the internet has become part of ones regular vocabulary. The internet is everywhere, in the news, the newspaper,
Censorship Freedom Or Suppression Essay Research Paper
Censorship Freedom or Suppression ? Government censorship can be looked at as a blessing or an unneeded burden. I personally feel that all censorship is completely unnecessary and should be found unconstitutional. It is the countless moral views that bring no right answer for what should and should not be censored.
Whers The Freedom Going Essay Research Paper
The Internet has developed into a vast basin of knowledge with many users contributing to its growth. With the growth of the Internet, many people have seen is as a source to express one’s ideas to the public. Some would even view the Internet as a virtual community, and say it is a democracy. People argue that with such free will, the Internet should be censored to protect children from pornography.
Censorship 2 Essay Research Paper The Internet
Censorship 2 Essay, Research Paper The Internet is one of the technologies that are widely used in the world. It is also one of the most controversial technologies. The government wants to put some regulations on the Internet. These regulations mainly consist of the censorship of it. These regulations are lead by the Communications Decency Act.
Press Censorship Essay Research Paper There are
Press Censorship Essay, Research Paper There are many kinds of censorship within our school system. Such as press Censorship, we aren’t aloud to express freely among our school?s newspaper nor
Censorship Essay Research Paper Censorship by definition
Censorship Essay, Research Paper Censorship by definition is the suppression of published or broadcast material to the public. People have fought and died for the right to hear, read, and see anything and everything that is available. But our right goes beyond that, we have the full right to publish and broadcast material, even though it is controversial.
Censoring The Net Essay Research Paper Every
Censoring The Net Essay, Research Paper Every time our technology advances and some new form of entertainment, such as television, magazines or music begins to develop or change, there are some people that would like to control what goes on by some form of censorship. The recent growth of the Internet has created the same demand.
Internet Censorship Essay Research Paper Censorship of
Internet Censorship Essay, Research Paper Censorship of inappropriate material has been an issue with every form of mass media. Now the new and upcoming Internet is becoming the focus. Software makers and service providers are choosing what the public should see. Does this seem right? How can a stranger choose what another person or their family sees on the Internet? Parents and adults should choose what they and their children are exposed to on the Internet.
The Internet Essay Research Paper Information has
The Internet Essay, Research Paper Information has long been sought out by many generations throughout time. It is a powerful tool that has often been hard to find, until the evolution of the Internet. The Internet has
Censorship Essay Research Paper Censorship making the
Censorship Essay, Research Paper Censorship, making the world a better place. Censorship affects our society in many different ways, it affects the music we listen to, the movies we watch, the books we read, and many other aspects of our everyday lives. Even though many might argue that censorship doesn t really have a place in a society that emphases freedom of speech and the freedom to express oneself, but censorship is an essential and needed part of our growing society, it s needed in the television industry, the Internet, and the music industry.
Internet Piracy Essay Research Paper In this
Internet Piracy Essay, Research Paper In this day and age where technology is rampant and advance, it is critical that we comprehend the possibilities that such technology has, no matter whether it is good or bad. From our very own households, we can now ?get connected? and experience this technology first hand.
The Internet Vs The Library Essay Research
Paper The Internet vs. the Library Overall, when one compares the Internet vs. the Library, the Library is superior. This is because, though it takes a bit longer to use, the Library has a standard information research tool; the Dewey decimal system. This organized system makes finding books simple, and with the added assistance of a librarian, finding information can be easy.
America Online Essay Research Paper America Online
America Online Essay, Research Paper America Online To Unveil Flat Fee For Internet Access The Internet is becoming more popular and more widely used, and the Market for internet access is growing rapidly. To stay
Censorship Essay Research Paper Probably the most
Censorship Essay, Research Paper Probably the most obvious example of intolerance in our society today is the existence of censorship. I have yet to encounter a valid argument for any form of censorship. Such arguments as are presented invariably take the form of concern for the well being of others , children frequently being the alleged victims quoted .
Should The Internet Be Censored Essay Research
Paper I believe that the Internet is a good source of information on a wide variety of subjects. I have personally used the Internet for a year now and have found it very useful for helping me with my school work as well as being very entertaining. However I have been deterred by some of the information that is easily accessible and that anyone could look at such as, detailed instructions on how to make harmful or fatal explosives and illegal pornographic material.
Internet Legislation Essay Research Paper subject
Internet Legislation Essay, Research Paper subject = LAW title = Internet Legislation papers = Internet Legislation With the recent popularity of the Internet many topics concerning it have hit main
Computers Essay Research Paper Why We StartedInternet
Computers! Essay, Research Paper Why We Started Internet Mental Health is a free encyclopedia of mental health information. It was designed by a Canadian psychiatrist, Dr. Phillip Long, and programmed by his colleague, Brian Chow.
Letter On Censorship Essay Research Paper Dear
Letter On Censorship Essay, Research Paper Dear Mr Smith,I am writing to you on the subject of censorship. It is my belief that the laws governing film censorship should be more versatile.Children of today are becoming mature and adult-like at an
Censorship Essay Research Paper Censorship an official
Censorship Essay, Research Paper Censorship: an official authorised to examine printed matter, films, news, etc., before public release, and to suppress any parts on the grounds of obscenity, a threat to security, etc. (Dictionary, MS Encarta)
Internet Regulation Essay Research Paper The internet
Internet Regulation Essay, Research Paper The internet was created for the cold war, in the event that the U.S. were attacked, there would be no communication among the nations leaders, because traditional communication would be disrupted by a nuclear blast. Since that time, the internet survived only though commercialization, the original form of the internet was scrapped when the cold war ended.
Net Censorship Essay Research Paper Most of
Net Censorship Essay, Research Paper Most of us have used it. Most of us find it useful, Some of us find it entertaining. Some of us find it offensive. ?It? is the Internet. The Internet has dramatically changed our society. It brings together people
Internet Censorship Essay Research Paper Speech II
Internet Censorship Essay, Research Paper Speech II Outline Intro: Censorship is when a third party makes decisions about what can be communicated between two people; even if the two agree that the censorship is okay, it is still censorship. Although the Internet was created in the 1960s as a communications tool of the U.S. military that would withstand even the most severe nuclear war and still be operable, it was not until after the government opened it up to public use in the late 1980s that the Internet became a unique communications phenomenon.
Internet Censorship Essay Research Paper Internet CensorshipThe
Internet Censorship Essay, Research Paper Internet Censorship The Internet is a wonderful place of entertainment and education, but like all places used by millions of people, it has some murky corners people would prefer children not to explore. In the physical world, society as a whole wants to protect children, but there are no social or physical constraints to Internet surfing.
Government Censorship On The Internet Essay Research
Paper Government Censorship on the Internet Thesis: Government Censorship would damage the atmosphere of the freedom to express ideas on the Internet; therefore, government should not encourage censorship. Introduction I. In the Internet
The Internet And World Wide Web Defined
Essay, Research Paper Christopher L. Isaacs 1010 ? Technical Writing Extended Definition 00 March 6th The ?Internet? and ?World Wide Web? Defined In recent years the Internet and World Wide Web (WWW) have become more and more popular as an information resource. Many people believe that the WWW is the same as the Internet.
Internet PC
’s: Next Wave Or Nonsense? Essay, Research Paper Internet PC’s: Next Wave or Nonsense? Call them what you will: Internet appliances. Network terminals. The whole
The Internet 2 Essay Research Paper The
The Internet 2 Essay, Research Paper The Internet The Internet is a place with an infinite of possibilities. It is the biggest technological breakthrough ever created. The Internet symbolizes freedom. It is uncensored and unregulated by the government. And that is hard to come by these days. With the Internet anything is possible.
Internet Marketing Essay Research Paper Internet Marketing
Internet Marketing Essay, Research Paper Internet Marketing and Associated Topics Computers and the Internet are becoming faster and capable of new and exciting things every day. Through this evolution, businesses have begun to reach out to consumers in new, unprecedented ways. With the amazing growth of users of the Internet, and the enormous growth that is expected to continue, businesses are aware that there is tremendous potential to provide and promote products and services in previously inconceivable ways.
ECommerce Essay Research Paper ECOMMERCEApril 10 2000
E-Commerce Essay, Research Paper E-COMMERCE April 10 2000 E-Commerce Electronic commerce has its ups and downs for consumers. On one hand, online shopping holds the potential for more convenience and broader selections. On the other, it has bred confusion over the legitimacy of electronic records.