Timothy S. Palko
World History II
Dr. Skaff
MWF 2:00-2:50
World power can be seen today in two very different but extremely vast empires. They are the Ming Empire and the Ottoman Empire. To contrast these empires in order to predict their futures, it is necessary that I observe and analyze key factors such as leadership, military strengths and weaknesses, and morals among the people. The two empires have different types of leadership, and from this it is possible to find the core of any disadvantage. From the leadership, it is possible to continue into the military and values that these empires embody. The Ming Empire is led by brilliant philosophical scholars, ?The man who is promoted to the higher degrees in this field prides himself on the fact that he has in truth attained to the pinnacle of Chinese happiness? (Andrea/Overfield 116). The Ottoman Empire has dedicated and knowledgeable leaders as well, but they are of a more warlike and brutish character. ?These leaders rise in service by merit alone? (Andrea/Overfield p.88). Indulging in the writings of Matteo Ricci, who observed first hand the workings of the Ming government, and the writings of Ogier Ghiselin de Busbecq, who observed the government under Suleiman I of the Ottoman Empire, the prediction of success will be able to be made knowledgably.
The Ottoman Empire began around 1300 as a ?tiny state built on the strength of an army of Turkish nomad warriors and a few Christian converts to Islam in northwestern Anatolia? (Bulliet 601). It quickly proved to be a military strength and threat to the surrounding civilizations. The Turks expanded their empire through brilliant military tactics, including using Janissaries on foot, who used the new weapon called a gun in battle, and the same horseback archery that made them so successful in their previous military accomplishments. The selection of Turkish leaders has greatly influenced the success of the Ottoman Empire. ?A Turks grandeur is not defined by his birth, however; the respect to be paid to a man is measured by the position he holds in the public service? (Andrea/Overfield 88). The men who attain office are not the products of hereditary luck, but ?partly the gift of God, and partly the result of good training, great industry, and unwearied zeal? (Andrea/Overfield p.88). De Busbecq was greatly impressed by the way that these Turks found their leadership; he made it a point to describe their feelings towards it in detail.
De Busbecq also wrote extensively about the military strengths of the Ottoman. The soldiers of the Ottoman army are well trained and experienced in the arts of warfare and survival. The distances they must travel are so great, that the soldiers often have to carry a pack horse ?on which they carry many of the necessaries of life? (Andrea/Overfield 89). The weapon that was affluent and extremely effective among the soldiers is the Turkish bow. ?From the eighth, or even the seventh year of age they begin to shoot at a mark, and practice archery ten or twelve years. This constant exercise strengthens the muscles of their arms, and gives them such skill that they can hit the smallest marks with their arrows? (Andrea/Overfield p.89). The great riches and skilled military forces have served this Empire well to this day. The Turks also showed very little ignorance towards new advancements in technology originated in other parts of the world. ?There is no nation that has shown greater readiness than the Turks to avail themselves of the useful inventions of foreigners, as is proved by their employment of cannons and mortars, and many other things invented by Christians? (Andrea/Overfield p.89). These open-minded and innovative new ways of becoming a powerful country greatly impressed De Busbecq. It is true that no empire is without flaw, and the Ottoman is no exception.
The role of Sultan in the Ottoman Empire was a hereditary role, the exception to their other laws about leadership. ?The sons of a Turkish Sultans are in the most wretched position in the world, for, as soon as one of them succeeds his father, the rest are doomed to certain death? Andrea/Overfield p.90). The successor will certainly kill all the other sons in order to secure his rule. Towards the end of Suleiman I?s reign as Sultan among the Turks, jealousy and betrayal brought great criticism against the Sultan. He had a son by a Crimean concubine; the son?s name was Mustafa. He had other children as well, but their mother was a Russian woman by the name of Roxelana. Mustafa had proved himself a great soldier and a favorite of the Ottoman people to take over the throne. Through lies, selfishness, and trickery, Roxelana had her way and Mustafa was murdered by a group of mutes by the orders of his own father. This would ensure the thrown for one of her own children. Mustafa?s son was popular also, although he was a young boy. As the people hoped for the son of Mustafa to eventually take the thrown and avenge his father?s death, Suleiman ?commissioned Ibrahim Pasha to go to the Ghemlik with all speed, and put the innocent child to death? (Andrea/Overfield 91). Other problems with the Ottoman that may affect their future success, besides a light moral contingency, is that they may not be able to keep up with all of the technology that other countries are adopting. ?The Turks are much afraid of carbines and pistols? (Andrea/Overfield 89). These weapons are often used advantageously by other countries on horseback during war. These guns were difficult to repair once damaged, and because they are fairly new not many Turks have put forth the effort to figure out how to repair them. ?Prejudice was increased by the dirt which its use entailed, the Turks being a very cleanly people; for the dragoons had their hands and clothes begrimed with gunpowder, and more over presented such a sorry appearance, with their ugly boxes and pouches hanging about them, that their comrades laughed at them and called them apothecaries? (Andrea/Overfield 89). It is perceived that these weapons called guns are going to be a very widely used, and if only a small percentage of soldiers like the Janissaries will be using them, a weakness may be found in the Turkish military.
The Ming Empire also entrust only the brightest to lead and counsel. Philosophy is the major road to success in the Ming Empire; therefore other aspects of knowledge may disinterest them. ?In China it is obvious that no one will labor to obtain proficiency in mathematics or in medicine who has any hope of becoming prominent in the field of philosophy? (Andrea/Overfield 116). Heredity is not what makes a leader in China. All leaders, be it a philosopher, or a mayor of a city, gain respect by being educated and knowledgeable, ?even if they may have arisen from the lowest state in life before attaining their literary degrees and admittance to the magistracy? (Andrea/Overfield 119). The Chinese base almost all thought from a man named Confucius, a philosophical scholar whose ideas are studied and followed still today, though he lived hundreds of years ago. Confucius is ?great and learned man?spurred on his people to the pursuit of virtue not less by his own example than by his writings? (Andrea/Overfield 116). No Chinese ever argues against what he taught. Confucius ?is held in such high esteem by the learned Chinese that they do not dare to call into question any pronouncement of his and are ready to give full recognition to an oath sworn in his name?? (Andrea/Overfield 116). Matteo Ricci has studied the system of studies and testing that the Chinese practice in close detail. It is evident in his writings that he felt the Ming people had such a strict and rigorous testing to become a philosopher, only the best are allowed to counsel. The Philosophers, more formally known as the Order of the Learned, administers over the entire Kingdom (Andrea/Overfield 118).
The trust given to these select men is great; they are wholly in charge of the empire. From the government to the military, they receive great respect. ?Policies of war are formulated and military questions are decided by the Philosophers only, and their advice and counsel has more weight with the emperor than that of the military leaders?. (Andrea/Overfield 118). The men of the Order of the Learned have such a great responsibility, and their guidance has proven strong to this point, but weaknesses are very apparent throughout the government of the Ming
The flaws of the Ming are more apparent than that of the Ottoman. Not all of the men were given opportunity to become philosophers; only the rich could afford the tutoring that one needs to study the books of Confucius. The way that the philosophical men looked down upon war may make them more peaceful, but it might give them a disadvantage when war is upon them. ?Those who aspire to be cultured frown upon war and would prefer the lowest rank in the philosophical order to the highest in the military? (Andrea/Bulliet 118). Not as much time or effort may be put into strategic planning or organization. Though the Order of the Learned may be the best and brightest, they are still human, and can be influenced by new ideas that would draw away from their true purpose. It is difficult to see an entire counsel to continue to be so strictly bound to the writings of one man and that they would not form their own thoughts and opinions.
The Ming Empire is a more peaceful and organized society than the Ottoman, but after studying the two empires, it is a prediction that they will fall before the Turks. However less moral and warlike, the Ottoman Empire?s openness to new ideas and inventions could be the difference in their future, come the next century. More advanced in mathematics and sciences, as well as their advancements in war overshadow their weaknesses, such as the refusal to turn to guns, and the lawless way their leaders are able to operate. The Ming have not shown to be as savvy in war, and their polite but closed-minded empire is one that gives a critic ease in thinking that this type of empire will eventually demise.
Другие работы по теме:
Cyrano De Bergerac Essay Research Paper Cyrano
Cyrano De Bergerac Essay, Research Paper Cyrano de Bergerac Edmond Rostand was born in Marseilles, France in 1868 and he died in 1918. He was an author who mainly wrote romantic plays, mostly in verse, that provided strong roles for generations of actors. Rostand’s first drama was Les Romanesques, and it was produced in Paris in 1894.
Attila Essay Research Paper
Attila was buried in a tomb lined with lead, which represented his conquests, as well as gold and silver, which represented the tribute he received from both Roman Empires. His tomb was laid to
Mongouls Essay Research Paper MongolsMongols have a
Mongouls Essay, Research Paper Mongols Mongols have a long history of being animal herders that roamed the lands. The reason for this is because the land they lived on was because water was a hard source to come upon. Many plants that grew on their land were not enough for the tribes to live on. This would not be the case for too long though.
African Empires4 Essay Research Paper The Ancient
African Empires4 Essay, Research Paper The Ancient African Empires were very advanced for there times, they were advanced before any European contacts. Each Empire had its similarities and its differences but none of the empires were exactly the same, but they were all advanced Empires for their time. Even though many people believe that Africa was nothing until the Europeans stumbled upon the land they are very mistaken.
Earth Essay Research Paper I
Earth Essay, Research Paper I’ve watched all of history, watched great empires fall becuase of endless quarrels. I’m not a god yet I’m above humans and time itself. I’ve observered great minds prosecuted by others for something they have yet to understand, ideas turned into belief, trying to destroy one another over that one simple idea.
Roman Republic Essay Research Paper The author
Roman Republic Essay, Research Paper The author Michael Crawford wrote the book The Roman Republic to offer an interpretation about the Roman Empire. This was done to educate the reader about how Rome gained its greatness and became the military and cultural center of the world at that time. He wanted to inform the readers about how the Roman Empire grew from one city tribe, to dominate the Italian peninsula, and finally to conquer the Mediterranean coast.
Early Cultures Essay Research Paper Michael C
Early Cultures Essay, Research Paper Michael C. Morfenski ASB 222 Early Peruvian cultures evolved from the prehistoric hunter and gathering tribes. Around 9000 BC the large, hunted, animals were extinct, so supplementation of their diet was needed, and so started the trend toward domestication of plants and wildlife.
Ethnic Cleansing Essay Research Paper The first
Ethnic Cleansing Essay, Research Paper The first and most important human right is the right to live, but sometimes others bend the rules, and this is when genocide begins. Crimes against humanity have been around for many generations, including ours. The genocide against the Armenians by the Ottoman Turks in 1915 was because the Turkish authorities wanted to eliminate the Armenian presence in the country.
The Causes Of World War I Essay
, Research Paper The first world war had many causes, the historians probably have not yet discovered and discussed all of them so there might be more causes than what we know now. In
The Empires Of Athens Persia And The
Chou In China Essay, Research Paper Throughout time, the term Empire has been one to describe great power and wealth. It describes a bringing together of people from one race, culture, or area of the world. It also deploys people under a power so overcoming that millions become part of an idealistic society.
European Challenges To The Muslim World Essay
, Research Paper ?European Challenges to the Muslim World? Religion has always played an important role in European society; Islam has usually been the major religion. It was no different in the 1700?s and 1800?s. During this time, reforms were formed to revolt against the government. These reforms most often stressed religious piety and obedience to strict rules of behavior.
Dracula Essay Research Paper The creation of
Dracula Essay, Research Paper The creation of this monster was actually based upon a Romanian myth,(derived from the word draclu-devil) which implied the existence of vampires or the undead, as Stoker says. But, let?s look at this novel in a different way. Who was Dracula?
The Fall Of The West African Empires
Essay, Research Paper The Fall of the West African Empires Between 300 and 1600 AD three west African empires Ghana, Mali, and Sanghai came into power. The wealth of these empires came from the trading of gold and salt. These
Ming Tombs Essay Research Paper A
Ming Tombs Essay, Research Paper A “hideous screech and noise” poured from the open windows of the meetinghouse. Inside, the young accusers who said they had been bewitched by their neighbors twisted their bodies and cried in pain. Frail and weak, Rebecca Nurse, the most unlikely to be in league with the devil, stood to be questioned.
Coporate Empires Essay Research Paper Corporate EmpiresCorporate
Coporate Empires Essay, Research Paper Corporate Empires. Corporate empires are the downfall of civilization. If society continues to allow the corporate giants to monopolize our economy we will lose our rights as individuals. Corporate empires use people as puppet subjects for their schemes and plans.
African Empires 2001600 Essay Research Paper There
African Empires 200-1600 Essay, Research Paper There were many empires and kingdoms in West Africa. The empires of Ghana, Mali, and Songhai were three of them. These empires set the way for new ones to come. The way these people lived is very unique. The most important thing that all of these people did was trading.
Byzantine Islamic Empires Comparison Essay Research Paper
Byzantine and Islamic Empires q Introduction Both the Islamic and in the Byzantine Empires had very important social structures. There are differences between the two Empires in all aspects, however both were successful. The Byzantine was part of the great Roman Empire and the Islamic Empire was built on religious belief.
The Importance Of Balance Of Power In
Europe Essay, Research Paper B.O.P. essay Without losers, there would be no winners. Moreover, if there were no evil in the world, then kindness would not exist. This is exactly the way the principle of balance of power in Europe operates. It prevented empires, and helped to aid lesser states in their times of need.
Malclom X Essay Research Paper Ming Sen
Malclom X Essay, Research Paper Ming Sen Zhang ENG 2100 0328 9/28/99 Essay Comparison The essays ?Learning to See? by Samuel Scudder and ?Learning to Read? by Malcolm X, both described transformational experiences. There are several similarities and differences between Malcolm X and Scudder?s transformational experiences.
Persian Empire Essay Research Paper The Persian
Persian Empire Essay, Research Paper The Persian EmpireThe Persian Empire, started in 539 B.C., stretched from the Indus River all the way to Egypt. They are considered a model for the future empires because of their justice, simple religion, and roads. Unlike some of the pharaohs in Egypt, who collected any amount of tax, anytime they wanted to, the Persian rulers collected the taxes fairly.
Constitution Essay Research Paper Constitutional Movements During
Constitution Essay, Research Paper Constitutional Movements During the Ottoman Period Constitutional movements during the Ottoman period commenced towards the end of the 18th century. During the period of the 1789-1808, Sultan Selim the Third envisaged the formation of an advisory assembly, called the Meclis-i Meshveret, within the context of the New System (called the Nizam-i Cedid) that he wanted to have set up, which is seen as a major step towards a constitutional government system.
America Essay Research Paper The Ming TombsThe
America Essay, Research Paper The Ming Tombs The Ming Tombs are the mausoleums of 13 Ming Dynasty emperors after the Ming capital was reallocated to Beijing. Located at the southern foot of Tianshou Mountain in Changping County, Beijing, the Ming tombs cover an area of about 120 km^2. With a plain belt in the middle, the Tombs area is enclosed with mountains and right in front of the Tombs is a twisting river.
Austria Ottoman Report Essay Research Paper The
Austria Ottoman Report Essay, Research Paper The Austrian Empire had long been declining. This was due to a number of reasons. Most important were the different nationalities within the Empire. The Germans were the minority however they were in control of the government and all other important political positions.
Ottoman Empire
– Focus On Society Essay, Research Paper By the 16th century, the vast and mighty empire of the Ottomans had reached the zenith of its power. The lands under Ottoman rule stretched from the heart of Central Europe to the deserts of Arabia. In nearly every respect, the Ottoman Empire was strong and well-organized.
Fall Of Rome Essay Research Paper One
Fall Of Rome Essay, Research Paper One of the most famous empires of all time is the Roman Empire. The Roman Empire stretched as far north as Great Britain, as farwest as Spain, south to North Africa and east to Mesopotamia. It hadmany strengths such as their law, which became international, theirlanguage of Latin, and their advanced engineering such as roads,aqueducts and bridges.
T E Lawrence Essay Research Paper Colonel
T E Lawrence Essay, Research Paper Colonel T. E. Lawrence, known as Lawrence of Arabia, was a guerrilla leader in the Arab Revolt of 1916-18, which expelled the Turks from western Arabia and
End Of WW I Essay Research Paper
The End of World War I When World War I ended on November 11, 1918, peace talks went on for months due to the Allied leaders wanting to punish the enemy and ?dividing the spoils of war.? A formal agreement to end the war was made and called the Treaty of Versailles. The issue that took the most time were the territorial issues because the empires of Russia, Austria-Hungary, the Ottoman, and Germany had collapsed.
Asian Theatre Essay Research Paper Asian theatre
Asian Theatre Essay, Research Paper Asian theatre is comprised of more than one geographic area. It consists of India, China and Japan. Each brought their own uniqueness to Asian theatre. Asian theatre as it pertains to China will be discussed in this chapter. Ancient Chinese chronicles mention other theatrical activities such as skits, pantomimes, juggling, singing and dancing.
Ottoman Empire Essay Research Paper The Ottoman
Ottoman Empire Essay, Research Paper The Ottoman Empire The Ottoman Empire was founded in the late thirteenth century and last until the early twentieth century. This empire was one of history s greatest military empires (564 McKay, Hill, Buckler) that was centered around the present day country of Turkey.
Peter Thegreat Essay Research Paper Peter I
Peter Thegreat Essay, Research Paper Peter I the Great 1672 – 1725 Russian Czar Peter was born in Moscow. He was joint czar with his mentally retarded half-brother, Ivan, under the regency of their sister, Sophia (1682-9). On Ivan’s death (1696) Peter became sole czar.