Sonnet 130 Essay, Research Paper
“Comparison of Daniel’s Sonnet 6 and Shakespeare’s Sonnet 130″
Daniel wrote a conventional love sonnet using the traditional Petrarchan style of putting the idea of love, or the mistress, on a pedestal. Shakespeare turned these ideas on their heads by portraying a mistress who was by no means special and most certainly unappealing.
During Daniel’s time there was a traditional way of writing love poems. Many of these poems talked of an unattainable woman whose love and perfection was so great she could only be considered to be divine. This is exactly what Daniel did. He wrote of an idea of what the perfect love would be using metaphors.
Daniel uses metaphors that related to something of great power or energy, such as the sun, writing “although her eyes are sunny.” Daniel uses the sun to compliment the mystical sense of his mistress. When Daniel talks of the eyes, he is explaining the power that can be seen in her eyes. This of course is not a realistic portrayal of a woman, but rather an idea of the kind of love that is so powerful, so heavenly that it is unattainable. Daniel tries to prove that his mistress has a love so powerful and deep that it can only be an idea. When many people think of an idea of love that is perfect, many would say that women of purity and beauty would be the perfect woman. Daniel states this thought when he says “Chastity and Beauty, which were deadly foes.” Here Daniel says that his mistress is pure, innocent, and beautiful. He is asking the reader to find a woman that perfect. There also seems to be reference to the divine in this line. Daniel is possibly comparing his mistress to the Virgin Mary. This would be the ultimate example of divinity. He is speaking of someone that is worthy enough and pure enough to have God’s only child and being pure. To Daniel this is what kind of love and qualities his mistress has and this can only truly be an idea. In contrast, Shakespeare has his own way of writing this image.
Shakespeare chooses an unconventional form of love poetry. The form he uses almost mocks the traditional form of love poetry that Daniel writes about. Shakespeare believes that true love is not an idea. He believes it is a real woman with all of her flaws. This woman is not considered unattainable or divine, but rather she is mortal. To him this is the idea of true love.
Shakespeare tried a much different approach to explaining what his idea of the perfect love would be.
Shakespear uses the sun to describe his mistress as being mortal. Shakespeare states this at the beginning of his poem when he says, ” My mistress’ eyes are nothing like the sun.” From the beginning Shakespeare speaks of a woman that does not seem to have unearthly power and an unattainable love, but rather he is saying she is simple and true. There is nothing special about this woman. This is vastly different from the way Daniel portrays his mistress as having divine qualities.
Throughout his poem, Daniel works on establishing a heavenly image of his mistress. Daniel refers to perfection many times n his poem. He writes that his mistress and perfection are one in the same.
Daniel’s visual image of his lady, like many poets of the time, is trying to install a vision of a woman that is divine and perfect. Daniel expresses this when he says, “Sacred on Earth, designated a Saint above.” Daniel is saying that although she is on earth she has heavenly qualities, much like that of a saint. If his mistress were anywhere other than on Earth she would undoubtedly be considered a goddess or a saint. Throughout his poem in explaining his mistress, Daniel speaks of his mistress’s perfection. She is worthy of the title “Saint” and anyone who comes into contact with her will undoubtably think the same. Shakespeare himself also establishes a visual image of his women.
Shakespeare description of a woman is the opposite of Daniel. Shakespeare’s uses metaphors that conjure images of a very unappealing woman. Shakespeare uses the fact that she is unappealing to express his love for her. This is ironic because Shakespeare is saying that his love is as true as all the other conventional poems that fail in their comparisons. This is Shakespeare’s way of explaining that true love comes from inside a person.
Shakespeare says the opposite of Daniel and by no means wants to put a false identity on his mistress. Shakespeare emphasizes how simple his lady is. Shakespeare speaks of this simplicity when he says, ” I grant I never saw a goddess go.” In this line Shakespeare seems to be taking his lady off the pedestal that Daniel puts his mistress on. This vision of a mistress being a goddess almost seems to amuse Shakespeare. Shakespeare knows that a man can not truly love an idea. Though that man may want to, he is faking his love and this can not be the true love that he has for his woman. The couplets of both writers vary greatly also.
Daniel writes of a lady that he could possibly come into brief contact with. Daniel may have not even have spoke to her, but the brief contact with her was enough to inspire an image of someone so perfect that it could only be true love. Daniel also suggests that this woman he writes about is unattainable and this saddens him.
This brief contact must have impressed him so much that he saw everything he ever wanted in a woman, but he left it as an idea, or a vision. In the ending couplet he speaks of this when he says, ” Oh had she not been fair and thus unkind, My Muse had slept and none had known my mind.” Daniel is thanking this woman for giving him the inspiration to write this poem. He is saddened to not be able to attain her but he knows that if he were to have more than simply brief contact with her it will spoil his idea and vision of what the perfect love would be to him.
In the couplet of Shakespeare sonnet he seems to be saying, “here I am and this is my woman, she is ugly and imperfect by my love for here is as true as any.” Shakespeare is saying that he does not need to falsely compare his mistress to that of a goddess because he loves her for who she is. Not an idea, but a real person.
In his couplet Shakespeare is saying that a false comparison is not needed to describe a woman. He writes, “and yet, by heaven, I think my love as rare as any she belied with false compare.” This is where Shakespeare comes out and says that his woman, is not perfect but she is beautiful to him and there is no truer love than Shakespeare’s for his woman. Shakespeare is saying how rare his love is because he accepts his woman for who she is. Not a perfect woman. Daniel portrays his mistress as unattainable and immortal. Shakespeare on the other hand will challenge anyone who thinks through false compare that their love is truer than his. Shakespeare does not need to falsely compare his woman to someone divine. He expresses his lady as being simple and able to accept his true love.
With his use of traditional Petrarchan writing, Daniel paints a perfect idea of a woman, one who is immortal and unattainable. Shakespeare, on the other hand mocks this style of writing and creates a vision of a more human woman who has flaws and is anything but perfect. In conclusion, these two writers have different views on what true love is, and the kind of woman they admire. Neither way is wrong, but are simply two contrasting ways of expressing how a man looks at a woman.
Другие работы по теме:
100 Essay Research Paper Sonnet 69
100 Essay, Research Paper Sonnet 69 Can you feel it as my lips touch your skin Ready to share our everlasting love You whisper my name as we are to begin A rose lies by our side, white as a dove
Sonnet About Death Essay Research Paper Death
Sonnet About Death Essay, Research Paper Death is full of sorrow and surprise Sooner or later it comes at anytime. Even though I do not remember my demise In my hearts I still remember my greatest crime.
The Rare Love In William Shakespeare
’s Sonnet 130 Essay, Research Paper In “Sonnet 130,” William Shakespeare speaks about rare love. A love that no other feels. One does not see this as the case, when reading the first twelve lines of this poem. The persona describes all the faults of his beloved, starting at her eyes, and ending at her breath. He uses comparisons like snow, coral, and roses to describe what his beloved lacks.
Sonnet 29 Essay Research Paper Rob BenkovicMrs
Sonnet 29 Essay, Research Paper Rob Benkovic Mrs. Stahl Period 8 5/8/00 Explication of “Sonnet 29” The reader can find Shakespeare’s dilemma in the first two stanzas. His problem is quite clear: he is lonely and depressed. As an outcast of society, he feels unlucky and thinks that there is no hope for him. Not even God can help him.
Sir Phillip Sidney
’s Sonnet # 47 From Astrophil And Stella Essay, Research Paper Sir Phillip Sidney’s Sonnet # 47 from Astrophil and Stella The sonnet is a short concise form of writing and it takes a great mind to master it. By mastering it, I mean to be able to say so much in what seems like so little space. Sir Phillip Sidney comes as close to mastering it as anyone else in his time or any other does.
Sonnet Essay Research Paper The sonnets 130
Sonnet Essay, Research Paper The sonnets, 130 and 292, written by William Shakespeare and Francesco Petrarch, both shows their passionate love towards their woman and it is very interesting to compare and contrast the two. Although their passionate mind was similar, they differ in form, tone, and meaning.
Sonnet 73 Analysis Essay Research Paper Poetry
Sonnet 73 Analysis Essay, Research Paper Poetry is a common medium for people to express love. Sonnets are almost always about love. William Shakespeare’s “Sonnet 73″ is no exception. Senti-ments of love along with those of against and death are expressed through the use of figurative language. The poem is organized in such a way that, as it progresses, the reader feels the author approaching death as the use of carefully chosen meta-phors that give “Sonnet 73″ such powerful imagery.
Sonnet 73 Essay Research Paper Poetry is
Sonnet 73 Essay, Research Paper Poetry is a common medium for people to express love. Sonnets are almost always about love. William Shakespeare’s "Sonnet 73" is no exception.
John Donne And Shakespeare Essay Research Paper
A comparison of Holy Sonnet XIV by John Donne and Sonnet 130 by William Shakespeare John Donne and William Shakespeare both wrote a variety of poems that are both similar within the structure of a Sonnet but with very different content. This essay will compare two of their sonnets Sonnet 130 by William Shakespeare and the Holy Sonnet by John Donne.
SHAKESPEARES SONNET 23 Essay Research Paper The
SHAKE?SPEARE?S SONNET 23 Essay, Research Paper The strength of emotion in Sonnet XXIII effects the poet?s ability to express his love; therefore, he trusts his poetry–the written word (or possibly the silent language of the
Sonnet 43 Essay Research Paper Sonnet 43
Sonnet 43 Essay, Research Paper Sonnet 43, A Touching Love Poem If one were to ever receive a love poem, Shakespeare?s Sonnet 43 would be and excellent poem to receive. The sonnet is addressed to the beloved of the speaker. The speaker talks about how the best thing he sees is upon the closing of his eyes, when he then pictures the beloved.
Shakespearan Sonnet Essay Research Paper Shakespeare s
Shakespearan Sonnet Essay, Research Paper Shakespeare s sonnet deals with his redefinition of certain terms. Throughout this sonnet Shakespeare refers to beauty as an everlasting internal component. He is mocking this belief that many people have. In doing this he makes certain analogies that can be taken to have more than one meaning.
A Comparison Between Shakespeares Sonnet 73 And
Essay, Research Paper William Shakespeare, who lived during the second half of the 16th century and the early 17th century, wrote sonnets 73 and 12, both fourteen-line poems written to an anonymous lover. Similarly, the sonnets discuss the themes of time, love, and finally death. Both sonnets use ABAB rhyme, meaning that the first line rhymes with the third, whilst the second line rhymes with the fourth, etc.
Sonnet Definition Essay Research Paper A sonnet
Sonnet Definition Essay, Research Paper A sonnet is a fourteen-line poem in iambic pentameter with a carefully patterned rhyme scheme. Other strict, short poetic forms occur in English poetry (the
Comparison Of Sonnets 18 And 130 Essay
, Research Paper Sonnets 18 and 130 In Shakespeare’s sonnets 18 and 130 he referred to two women that he loved. These two sonnets shared similarities and yet contained many exciting
Analysis Of Sonnet 2 Essay Research Paper
Sonnet 2 In Sonnet 2, Shakespeare stresses to his lover that beauty will not last, and that it is selfish and foolish for anyone not to prepare for the loss of beauty
Shakespeares Sonnet
#73 Essay, Research Paper Shakespeare’s Sonnet #73, published in 1609, is written in the Shakespearean or English sonnet style. It consists of three quatrains and one couplet at the end, written in iambic pentameters. Each quatrain has its own rhyme scheme, rhyming in alternating lines. The couplet summarizes the preceding twelve lines.
Sonnet 20 Essay Research Paper Sonnet 20Over
Sonnet 20 Essay, Research Paper Sonnet 20 Over the centuries since the publication of Shakespeare s Sonnets, they have been subjected to a vast amount of analysis. From this seemingly endless supply of critiques, I have selected two that deal particularly with Sonnet 20 and its somewhat sexual ambiguity.
Comparison Of Shakespeare
’s Sonnet 73 And Sonnet 116 Essay, Research Paper Comparison of Shakespeare’s Sonnet 73 and Sonnet 116 William Shakespeare, in his Sonnet 73 and Sonnet 116, sets forth his
Analyzing Shakespear
’s Sonnet 55 And Fletcher’s Licia Essay, Research Paper Many factors can be used to analyze Sonnet 55 by William Shakespear and Licia by Giles Fletcher. Sonnet 55 and Licia share the subject of eternal love. In Sonnet 55, the narrator says that the memory of his love will last through wasteful wars that destroy tangible objects (Shakespear 5).
Shakespeare Sonnet 18 Essay Research Paper Shakespeare
Shakespeare Sonnet 18 Essay, Research Paper Shakespeare and His Sonnet 18 ?Shall I Compare Thee to a Summer?s Day?? William Shakespeare (1564-1616), English poet and playwright, recognized in much of the world as the greatest of all dramatists, is perhaps the most famous writer in the history of English literature.
Romeo And Juliet Persuasive Essay Essay Research
Paper ROMEO AND JULIET PERSUASIVE ESSAY Romeo and Juliet is a play about tow young adults that fall in love with each other. The only thing that is holding these tow lovers back is the feuding between the two families.
Daniel Boone Essay Research Paper Daniel Boone
Daniel Boone Essay, Research Paper Daniel Boone was responsible for the exploration and settlement of Kentucky. Daniel?s father was a weaver and blacksmith, and raised livestock in the country near
Sonnet 1 35 75 Essay Research Paper
Sonnet 1, 35, & 75 Many of Spencer s are based the subject of love. The poet Spencer has written many poems on love but his contain a different twist. His poems are about love but in the end some weird twist of fate happens were it doesn’t work out. There is always something that goes on where the girl doesn t like him it just wasn t meant to be.
Sonnet 130 Essay Research Paper Shakespeare was
Sonnet 130 Essay, Research Paper Shakespeare was obviously a very deep passionate and learned man; he was very open with how he felt and was able to express it in a way that was very exact and easy to comprehend. In his sonnets, which to me., are like a little diary, he tlaks a lot about his life involving his mistress as well as a male friend that he may or may not have been involved with.
Sonnet 130 Analysis Essay Research Paper My
Sonnet 130 Analysis Essay, Research Paper My Mistress Eyes Are Nothing Like The Sun William Shakespeare s poem, Sonnet 130 has a rhyme scheme and a rugged tone. It s three quatrains, four-line stanzas, and couplet, two-line stanza expresses that It also has a tone to it that signals some meaning to it.
PLATONIC IDEALS OF LOVE Essay Research Paper
SHAKESPEARE’S SONNET 116 AND SONNET 130 BOTH DESCRIBE LOVE IN DIFFERENT WAYS BUT BOTH SHOW THE IDEALS OF PLATONIC LOVE. THE THREE STAGES OF PLATONIC LOVE IS THE LOVE OF BODY, THE LOVE OF MIND AND THE LOVE OF SOUL.
Sonnet 130 Essay Research Paper Sonnet 130This
Sonnet 130 Essay, Research Paper Sonnet 130 This Shakespeare sonnet talks about the contrasts of the speaker?s lover and the beauties of the world. Unfortunately the lover is never on the winning side. The speaker tells us his lover?s physical appearance, or lack thereof. His lover?s eyes are ?nothing like the sun.? As for her lips, ?coral is far more red than? hers.
Sonnet 130 Essay Research Paper SONNET CXXX
Sonnet 130 Essay, Research Paper SONNET CXXX In our class we have been discussing sonnet cxxx. Many of my classmates believe that Shakespeare was saying that, although this girl is ugly, he still loves her. While others claim that he was not making any statements about her looks, but instead being realistic.
Sonnet 130 Essay Research Paper Sonnet 130William
Sonnet 130 Essay, Research Paper Sonnet 130-William Shakespeare’sShakespeare always wrote in such a way that his writing inspires its’ readers. It was not surprising how Shakespeare is considered by many scholars as, “…a magnificent play write…” or “… a superb poet whose talents cannot be matched, even to this day.” Aside from all his plays, I am infatuated with his sonnets, particularly 116.
Sonnet 130 Essay Research Paper Sonnet 130The
Sonnet 130 Essay, Research Paper Sonnet 130 The theme of the sonnet is beauty in that Shakespeare is comparing the eternal beauty of the subject to the beauty of nature. Shakespeare paints a picture using a combination of metaphors and a simile. He starts the poem with a simile comparing his mistress eyes to the sun.