Adventures In Evolution Essay, Research Paper
Adventures in evolution The Structure of Evolutionary Theory Stephen Jay Gould 1,464 pages, Harvard I Have Landed: Splashes and Reflections in Natural History Stephen Jay Gould 401pp, Cape There are many reasons to regret the death of Stephen Jay Gould; one of the weightiest is that he never had time to finish his last book at its proper length. Even close to death, he had twice the energy, range, and ambition of most writers; and the result is a last testament which is about twice as long as it should have been. At 1,400 pages, and weighing rather more than twice as much as the laptop on which I’m writing this, The Structure of Evolutionary Theory is obviously a book that has too many words. But you have to dig into it to discover the real disadvantage, which is that most of the words have far too many syllables. This isn’t because they are technical. Some of the passages here deal with issues of real technical complexity and philosophical difficulty, and those are admirably clear. It is in the more general sections that the Latinate orotundities settle in great snowdrifts around the argument, so that the struggling reader is overwhelmed by a warm longing to lie down and rest and never rise again. Yet struggle through the snowdrifts, fortify yourself with brandy if you must, and you will be rewarded. For the grand design of the book is impressive, and its ambitions worthwhile and close to achievement. What Gould has set out to write is an account of the evolution of evolutionary theory; to look at all the really interesting questions that have arisen since the Origin of Species and to settle the question of how much of the modern science that bears his name Darwin would recognise today. So there are chapters on the early alternatives to Darwinism: sections on the emergence of modern (anti-Gouldian) orthodoxy within evolutionary theory; one book within a book on the limits of adaptation; and another on Gould’s first large theory, punctuated equilibrium. It is all a vast apologia, without, of course, any hint of apology. For the last 20 or 30 years, Gould has stood for “pluralism”, which, to his opponents, means woolly-mindedness. In The Structure of Evolutionary Theory , he explains what he really means. There is no chance, in a review of this length, of covering all his subjects, but it is possible to give a flavour of his argument. For a start, and non-controversially, there is the idea that a great deal of the raw material of evolutionary change is supplied by accident. Natural selection can design the bat’s system of echolocation, but it hasn’t yet produced a device for warding off mass extinctions. There is no doubt that natural selection makes a great designer, but there is reasonable argument about how much of the world we see is the product of design. Gould has always argued that his ene mies, and most of his colleagues, see too much design and too many adaptations in the world, and coopted from architecture the term “spandrel” to describe an undesigned feature which is a necessary consequence of one that is designed, but is then used as a base for further design. The dispute is perhaps one between historians and engineers: Gould is a paleontologist as well as a historian of ideas. In both contexts, he is interested in evolution as an account of what actually happened. His opponents, one of whom, John Maynard Smith, actually trained as an engineer, are much more interested in Darwinism as a timeless mechanism or set of mechanisms. Most of the biologists I know spent their childhoods building things – it hardly mattered what, so long as the bits fitted together in a satisfyingly logical way. One professor of biology, when asked to be more precise, replied “bombs, rockets, radios”. But Gould spent his childhood reading books and dreaming of dinosaurs. No wonder he became the scientist for the rest of us. Gould’s essays from Natural History magazine – of which the handsomely produced I Have Landed is the 10th and final volume – are matchless examples of the strengths of a historical imagination roaming across a scientific subject. They are also better trimmed than the long book, with far less fat around the meat of the argument, partly because most of the serious arguments in his essays are ventriloquised through other people. Gould resembled Isaiah Berlin, in that he could most successfully expound his own ideas when they were presented as coming from others. The historical sections of The Structure of Evolutionary Theory are packed full of evolutionary theory presented in the clearest and most comprehensible way. The avowedly theoretical sections are much more tangly, though the ideas he is presenting are not in themselves more difficult. Nonetheless, he did manage to knot together in the final sections several of his lifelong themes in a very comprehensible way, among them his objection to “gene-centric” ideas of evolution. To the engineering mind, the wonderful thing about genes, ever since their chemical nature was unravelled by Watson and Crick, is that this nature turned out to be digital. DNA, like light and matter, comes in chunks that are precise and measurable. Just as the physicists were getting all woolly and mystical, the biologists got themselves a really hard science. The differences of style harden into greater substance when you ask what the entities are on which natural selection can operate. Are they genes, or bodies, or even whole species? For Darwin, working 50 years before the word “gene” was even coined, they were organisms – individual bodies. Individual giraffes had more descendants because they had longer necks. Once genetic inheritance was discovered, it seemed obvious that genes were the only thing that natural selection could act on. But this, while fascinating, has to be partly wrong. The meanings of a gene are the things about it that make some versions better than others in the eyes of natural selection, and this meaning, these advantages, must almost always appear in bodies. These might not be the body that the gene itself is found in – the plant genes that control the colours of flowers, and make them attractive to bees, are really selected because of the way that bees’ eyes work. That was the argument of Richard Dawkins’s second, technical book, The Extended Phenotype. This seems to prove that you can reduce almost everything about evolution to genes. However, as Gould points out, gene-centrism reached a kind of reductio ad absurdum with the the discovery of “selfish” or “junk” DNA. This is the name given to bits of chromosomes, possibly proper genes, which are copied by the exuberance of the cell’s own copying mechanisms for no reason at all so far as the organism is concerned. These are genes which really are directly selected for their own physical qualities, not for their effects on the physical qualities of the cells that surround them. Their existence shows that normal DNA is selected in a more complicated way. The point at issue is really a confusion between copying and winnowing: selection is a two-stage process, endlessly repeated. Things are copied, then their copies are winnowed to select ones with certain qualities, and the survivors are copied again. But in genetic systems, copying and winnowing are separate process (except in the specialised case of junk or selfish DNA): the things that are copied – the genes – are not the things that are winnowed – the bodies. Neither the copying nor the winnowing can sensibly be called “selection” on its own. Nonetheless, it makes sense to ask what sorts of things are winnowed, and here Gould does go out on a limb. He argues that not merely individual bodies, but populations, whole species, and even clades – related groups of species – can compete with each other in a Darwinian sense, and so become the objects of selection. This idea brings together two of his constant themes, for he argues that adaptation at one level of the hierarchy is what produces the spandrels at the next level that provide the raw material for further adaptation in their turn. That would explain, for example, how the duplication of genes when they are copied into junk DNA, which is a product of purely molecular selection, nonetheless supplies the raw material or spandrels for natural selection to work on the organism. It is not at all clear how much this would revolutionise biology, nor how Gould might reconcile this kind of multi-level selectionism with his other belief that much evolutionary change is essentially random. It was a consistent complaint of Gould’s opponents that he oversold his own ideas. But he did have an enormous amount to oversell, and it is saddening to reflect that he will never now write more, or less.
Другие работы по теме:
Dr Dolittle Essay Research Paper The Adventures
Dr. Dolittle Essay, Research Paper The Adventures of Doctor Dolittle The book I read was The Adventures of Dr. Dolittle. The author has an excellent writing style and the book is laid out in an easy to read format.
Robinson Crusoe Essay Research Paper Daniel Defoes
Robinson Crusoe Essay, Research Paper Daniel Defoe?s most famous novel was published in 1719 with the full title, The Life and strange and surprising Adventures of Robinson Crusoe. It is based, in fact, upon the experiences of Alexander Selkirk who had run away to sea in 1704 and requested to be left on an uninhabited island to be rescued five years later.
Huck Says Essay Research Paper Huck SaysHuckleberry
Huck Says Essay, Research Paper Huck Says Huckleberry Finn, an adventurous young boy, tells the tale of his own adventures. What was Mark Twain thinking? When Twain used Huck as the narrator of his book The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn it was a first. This first was ingenious he grabbed America and made them think what life was like to a young boy back in the day.
Huck Finn Essay Research Paper Michael DearingThe
Huck Finn Essay, Research Paper Michael Dearing The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn English III Mr. Baker The Foil Between Huck and Tom The foil between Huck and Tom is shown continuously in The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn. Huckleberry Finn led a troubled life, he had no real farther figure plus his pap was abusive mentally and physically.
Adventures Of Huck Finn And Town Life
Essay, Research Paper In Mark Twain?s novel ?The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn? he talks about small town life in Southern Mississippi. He portrays it as gossipy, a place
House Of Baskervilles Essay Research Paper THE
House Of Baskervilles Essay, Research Paper THE HOUND OF THE BASKERVILLES is by far the most popular of all of the adventures of Sherlock Holmes. Filmed over twenty times, serialized, illustrated, and endlessly reread, this short novel is an account of the spookiest case ever solved by the world’s best-known detective.
Huck Finn Essay Research Paper Two people
Huck Finn Essay, Research Paper Two people taking a trip down a river, is rarely thought of as anything more than just an adventure. Mark Twain, however, uses his novel, The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn, to explore and makes fun of many problems facing American society. Huck, the main character, is considered a boy who is under pressure to conform to the aspects of society.
Adventures Of Huckleberry Finn Racist Or
Not? Essay, Research Paper Adventures Of Huckleberry Finn ? Racist or Not? The book Adventures Of Huckleberry Finn is not a racist book. The main arguments against it are the characters? personalities and the dialect they used. This novel is criticized by Twain critics and on the top ten ban list for school reading material.
The Adventures Of Huckelberry Finn Essay Research
Paper Adventures of Huckleberry Finn 1.Period: The period that is most evident in this novel is that of realism. Realism is a style of writing, developed in the nineteenth century, that attempts to depict life accurately without idealizing or romanticizing it. Mark Twain depicts the adventures and life of Huck Finn in a realistic, straight-forward way.
The Adventures Of Huckelberry Finn
– Critique Essay, Research Paper Critical Biography Mark Twain, the pseudonym of Samuel Clemens, was, as a literary writer, a genius. His use of numerous literary devices throughout the novel are quite unique. Examples of them would be, irony;
Tom Sawyer Vs Huck Finn Essay Research
Paper Tom Sawyer vs. Huck Finn Tom Sawyer and Huck Finn were both characters created by Mark Twain. Tom Sawyer is the main character in the book The Adventures of Tom Sawyer and Huck Finn is the main character in the book The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn. Huck Finn and Tom Sawyer were alike in many ways but they were also very different.
Huck Finn Essay Research Paper Why Huckleberry
Huck Finn Essay, Research Paper Why Huckleberry Finn Rejects Civilization Why does Huckleberry Finn reject civilization? In Mark Twain?s novel The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn, Mark Twain describes Huck Finn as a normal down to earth kid from the 1800?s. Huck Finn rejects civilization because he has no reason for it.
The Glass Managerie Essay Research Paper Tennessee
The Glass Managerie Essay, Research Paper Tennessee Williams is well known for the use of symbols in her plays. Symbol or symbolism is when an object, a thing, a person, an animal or anything tangible represents an abstract idea. In the play The Glass Managerie, Tennessee successfully uses a variety
Robinson Crusoe By Daniel Defoe c 16591731
) Essay, Research Paper An adventurous tale, The Life and Strange Surprising Adventures of Robinson Crusoe, as Defoe titled his novel, is especially loved by children, although there is certainly enough to keep
Huck Finn Essay Research Paper The concept
Huck Finn Essay, Research Paper The concept of what truth is, is a prevailing theme in both The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn, and the essay excerpt by Andrew Lang. Lang writes about truth as being found in lack of distortion from the actual world. Lang’s idea of truth is certainly found in The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn.
European Colonization In Africa Essay Research Paper
Africa, a place of pottery colors and lots of wildlife, went through modifications in the 1900s. Settlers from Europe took lands and built colonies on African soil. They changed traditional tribal life and developed laws for the Natives. The Europeans brought about security to the Africans but took away the adventures of lurking in the outside.
The Adventures Of Huck Finn 2 Essay
, Research Paper The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn By; Mark Twain I have read the book The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn up to chapter fourteen. I have found one thing I don’t like, the language which is used is straight out of the 1800’s. An example of this can be found on every page in the book. Twain shows one of these examples when he writes, “I took to it again because pap hadn’t no objections.” This language is not acceptable in modern English, it should really be, “I took to it again because pap had no objections.”
Banning Of Huckleberry Finn Essay Research Paper
Thesis: The banning of Mark Twain’s The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn from public schools and libraries is unjustified. Mark Twain wrote The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn long after the Civil War during a time when slavery was no longer instituted in the United States. However, the story itself takes place before the War, and the attitudes and actions of Southerners during that period are boldly reflected throughout the novel#.
Symbolism In The Adventures Of Huckleberry Finn
Essay, Research Paper The Symbolism in The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn Freedom is a wonderful thing; it is a quality of life that many people cannot describe. According to the Webster’s Dictionary the word freedom is defined as “…the state of being at liberty rather than in confinement or under physical restraint…” Unfortunately almost everybody today takes his or her freedom for granted.
The Epic Hero Beowulf Thesis Essay Research
Paper The Epic Hero Beowulf An epic is a long narriative peom about the adventures of a legendary or historic hero. The hero is a figure is high social status, one with great strenght or ability, and historical importance. There are many characteristics one must demonstrate ti be considered an epic hero. An epic hero is a brave and courageous warrior, admired for his achievements and courageous qualities.
Theseus Or Hercules Essay Research Paper Theseus
Theseus Or Hercules Essay, Research Paper Theseus or Hercules? Theseus is most worthy of emulation. He was a great hero in Athens. “Theseus was, of course bravest of the brave as all heroes are, but unlike the other heroes he was as
Huckleberry Finn Essay Research Paper When the
Huckleberry Finn Essay, Research Paper When the Adventures of Huckleberry Finn begins, the main character, Huck Finn, possessed a large amount of money.This causes his delinquent lifestyle to change drastically.Huck gets an education, and a home to live in with a caring elderly woman.One would think that Huck would be satisfied.He wasn’t-he wanted his own lifestyle back.Huck’s drunkard father, who had previously left him, was also not pleased with Huck’s lifestyle.He didn’t feel that his son should have it better then he.He tries to get a hold of the money for his own uses, but fails.He precedes to lock Huck up in his cabin on the outskirts of town.Huck then stages his kidnapping and subsequent killing, and takes a canoe across to Jackson’s Island in the Mississippi river.There he comes across a runaway slave,Jim,and the two decide to leave the area-Huck to avoid his father, and Jim
Loyalty
& The Adventures Of Huckleberry Finn Essay, Research Paper Loyalty & The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn In The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn by Mark Twain, the main character, Huckleberry Finn is an early teenager living along the banks of the Mississippi River. He spends his time getting into mischief along with his friend Tom Sawyer.
The Real Arthur Essay Research Paper The
The Real Arthur Essay, Research Paper The Real King Arthur Arthur had been identified as the son of British king Uther Pendragon, who was the son of Constantine. Whatever else Arthur is, he is a composite figure of many different legends and beliefs. Some have even related his adventures to Greek mythology.
Odysseus The Great Essay Research Paper Odysseus
Odysseus The Great Essay, Research Paper Odysseus the Great Of all the mythological heroes, Odysseus would have to be the greatest. His adventures strengthened him and made him wiser. Although his men assisted him in his warfare, Odysseus was always at the heart of the battle. Odysseus was a true epic hero.
Alice In Wonderland Essay Research Paper As
Alice In Wonderland Essay, Research Paper As we read Alice?s Adventures in Wonderland and The Island of Dr. Moreau, we enter into two unique worlds of imagination. Both Lewis Carroll and H.G. Wells describe lands of intrigue and mystery. We follow Alice and Prendick into two different worlds where animals speak, evolution is tested, and reality is bent until it nearly breaks.
Alice Essay Research Paper As we read
Alice Essay, Research Paper As we read Alice?s Adventures in Wonderland and The Island of Dr. Moreau, we enter into two unique worlds of imagination. Both Lewis Carroll and H.G. Wells describe lands of intrigue and mystery. We follow Alice and Pren*censored* into two different worlds where animals speak, evolution is tested, and reality is bent until it nearly breaks.
On The Road Essay Research Paper On
On The Road Essay, Research Paper On The Road The novel On The Road is based on one mans true stories about his craziest adventures through the United States and Mexico. This is one of the greatest novels of all time and nothing I have read so far seems so realistic. Jack Kerovac, who is the author of the book, places himself as the narrator.