The Offertory?In Perspective Essay, Research Paper
The Offertory?In Perspective
The offertory procession, as described in the rubrics of the LBW, and in detail in the Manual on the Liturgy is criticized in Making Sense: An Exploration of Word and Sacrament. Our customary format of brief response papers does not allow sufficient space to enter dialogue regarding this practice. This paper is an exploration of the issues raised by this ritual practice and the criticism and suggestions noted in Making Sense, to the purpose of entering the dialog about this issue.
The position taken in Making Sense is:
?The offertory is primarily a practical action, preparing the bread and wine for the meal.
?The procession of the bread and wine to the altar was not a uniform practice of the ancient church.
?The procession detracts from the centrality of the Eucharistic Prayer and the Distribution.
?The procession shifts the focus ?from God?s gifts to our own.?
The suggestion is to receive monetary gifts while the table is set; music may be used during the collection. The offertory prayer is omitted and the service proceeds with the Great Thanksgiving.
I suggest that this position results from a confusion of two distinct ?offertories? which are ritually combined: the monetary collection, and the preparation of the table.
The reception of monetary gifts during the Eucharistic service is uncommon in the history of the church. Although some ancient authorities speak of collections in kind and of money for the purpose of the care of the poor (and possibly of the clergy as is implied in the pastorals), this collection does not seem to have been linked with the Eucharistic action. The synagogue service does not contain such a collection, nor, apparently, did the mystery religions. Regardless, by the Middle Ages there was no monetary collection during the Mass. Money for relief of the poor was collected in receptacles in the building and by mendicants. After the Reformation the situation is not materially altered (one of the Orthodox reforms included forbidding begging and enhancing the use of the poorbox). The primary support of the parishes was from the government?a situation still prevailing in the established churches in Europe.
The collection of money during worship is primarily an American phenomenon arising from the need to finance the congregation?s activities. The need to collect money for this purpose was resisted by many Lutheran emigrants. In particular, some resisted collecting money during worship. This battle, however, is long over. It is highly unlikely that any move to an alternative means of collecting contributions would be successful. Collecting money is not one of the purposes of worship; it is not a necessary activity in the Eucharistic service; but no parish in the USA can survive long if it consistently omits this custom.
The practice of ?passing the plate,? then, would seem to be a ?given? feature of worship, whether or not it makes any ritual sense. In terms of our categories, it is a practical action rather than a rhetorical one. Theologically (at least in stewardship sermons) and in terms of folk piety, however, the donation of money to the congregation and the church is seen as a response of the people to the Gospel. Commonly the money is thought of as given to God rather than to the church. It is not a trivial response in a society that values money as much as does ours. It is, for many, a challenge to ?put your money where your mouth is.?
There is no place in the ordo where the collection fits neatly. If it is placed prior to the readings or the sermon it lacks any response character and looks like a payment for worship. When placed immediately after the sermon, as in CW and SBH, it has a character of response, but with the prominence of the sermon as a climax to the liturgy of the word this position can make the offering appear to be an evaluation of the preacher or a payment for the preacher?s work. The LBW placement, in which the creed and the prayers follow the sermon, followed by the collection underlines the response character and corporate nature of the offering. A final alternative, placing the collection after the communion, has not been common. Such a placement would seem to detract from the climax character of the distribution and, coming at the end of the service might seem, again, like a payment for services rendered.
In the non-Eucharistic service, the money collection is clearly positioned as a response to the proclamation. I submit that it is appropriate to recognize ritually the response of the people in their self-giving. This action precisely fits the proclamation-response form of the ordo. It provides a chance to theologically interpret the action of the people in giving. Given that members have often thought that only their monetary contribution was an offering, it is appropriate to include in this interpretation an expression of the other forms of giving and response which the members will make in living out their Christian vocations in the world.
The majority of congregations during the 1960?s ritually expressed this response as a gift to God by either elevating the money before the altar or by placing the money on the altar. ?Offertory? came to exclusively mean the collection and presentation to God of the money contributions of the congregation. For some members, these gifts were ?sacrificial,? an understanding reinforced by the use of the phrase ?sacrificial giving? in some stewardship campaigns.
It is against this background that the two offertory prayers of the LBW must be viewed. The prayers comment and enlarge on the meaning of the monetary collection and tie it to the Eucharistic action. These prayers can, and often do, interpret the collection in non-Eucharistic services. In contrast, the RC mass ritually ignores the collection, concentrating only on the bread and wine in this portion of the rite.
This understanding suggests that in a non-Eucharistic service, the offertory procession and offertory prayer can be valid ritual actions that fit the proclamation/response pattern of the liturgy.
What then of the Eucharistic service? There seem to be four options:
1.Receive the contributions of the people prior to the Eucharistic liturgy and underline the reception with a liturgical action such as a prayer of offering, then begin the Great Thanksgiving and set the table for the Eucharist during the Sanctus.
2.Receive the contributions while the table is set and ignore the contributions, proceeding directly to the Great Thanksgiving.
3.Receive the contributions while the table is set, pray a prayer of offering, and proceed to the Great Thanksgiving.
4.Combine the reception of contributions with the Eucharist. The reception of the bread and wine simultaneous with the reception of money then ties the people?s response to the Word by giving of money and other gifts with an act of the people offering themselves to God and being given back to each other (a la Kirkegard Fear and Trembling).
Method 1 clearly separates the collection of money from the Eucharistic action. There is no corporate giving to God connected ritually with God?s gift in the Eucharist. This is similar to the position adopted in the BCP. One disadvantage is an emphasis on the monetary contribution. It may even communicate that the Eucharist has been paid for with the contributions.
Method 2 ritually devalues the gifts from the congregation. If one of the offertory songs is used during the collection then method 2 is essentially the same as method 3. If no offertory song is used, this would seem to communicate that the congregation?s giving is so unimportant as not to deserve any ritual comment or interpretation. This is essentially the position in the Roman rite.
Method 3 confuses the situation still further as the contributions appear to be an ?offertory? intimately connected with the Eucharist. Since the bread and wine are not being offered in the same way as the money (one is coming from the congregation while the other is from the church (at best) or from the minister (at worst)) the strong emphasis is that what is offered is money and is only money.
Method 4 has the advantage of underscoring the self-giving of the people in more than merely monetary terms and links the Eucharist with their self-giving in response to the Word. It is true that there is an emphasis on the action of the people in this ritual act, but is there not also an emphasis on the action of the people in the Great Thanksgiving? ?Lift up your hearts.? ?We lift them to the Lord.? ?Let us give thanks?? These are all acts of the people. Moreover, if humans did not cooperate with God, there would be no Eucharist; it is unlikely to materialize on the table without human action. The RC prayers over the bread and the wine emphasize a partnership with God in the material substance of the Eucharist: ?which earth has given and human hands have made,? ?fruit of the vine and the work of human hands.? This position emphasizes the mission of the people in cooperation with God?s transforming action.
A counter-position to Making Sense is:
?The offertory is both a pair of practical actions, collecting money and preparing the bread and wine for the meal, and a ritual action, interpreting the meaning of these acts. It is simultaneously a part of the synaxis and part of the Eucharist. It is a response in the proclamation-response paradigm.
?The procession of the bread and wine to the altar was not a uniform practice of the ancient church. The collection of money during worship was neither a uniform nor a common practice in the ancient, mediaeval, or modern church outside of the USA.
?The procession and offertory prayer are commentaries on the monetary collection, expanding its meaning and reducing the mercenary messages which that collection may convey. It no more detracts from the centrality of the Eucharistic Prayer and the Distribution than does the invitation to the congregation to lift up their hearts. It emphasizes the Eucharist as an act of the whole community rather than of a ?Celebrant?.
Другие работы по теме:
Enlightenment Essay Essay Research Paper Life s
Enlightenment Essay Essay, Research Paper Life s experiences have the tendency to shape and mold us, influencing us to change our perspective. Certain events in life have prepared me to cope with such experiences and all the thoughts and feelings associated with them. Through this agonizing realization, I have gained personal wisdom, understanding, and ultimately been enlightened.
Jesus In John Essay Research Paper Jesus
Jesus In John Essay, Research Paper Jesus in John When reading the gospels of the New Testament, it becomes evident that the personality of each of the authors affected their understanding, interpretation, and impression of Jesus and his works. In John, the gospel that I chose to read for this paper, Jesus is portrayed in a more godlike, omnipotent manner.
Time Management Essay Research Paper Time management
Time Management Essay, Research Paper Time management. It can help you put events in perspective, avoid double or overlapped appointments, prioritize your schedule, and keep you on track. It works for school as well as other parts of your life like work and friends/family.
What Sports Mean To Me Essay Research
Paper Being a cheerleader in the summer of my sophomore year gave me a new perspective about people and the stereotypes we put on them. Before I started cheering, I always categorized
Leadership Essay Research Paper The most meaningful
Leadership Essay, Research Paper The most meaningful and challenging experiences in my life have been through sports and the 4-H club. They have instilled the values of perseverance, confidence, and teamwork within me. I feel that my peers and others could learn valuable life lessons through participating in these organizations.
Marketing Essay Research Paper FOREWORDThe first time
Marketing Essay, Research Paper FOREWORD The first time I visited an IKEA-store was in Elisabeth, New Yersey, The U.S. The year was 1995 and I still rember the joy and excitement when I entered the building. It was huge and it
Comparison Of Massacio
’s Holy Trinity And Campin’s Merod Altarpiece Essay, Research Paper Masaccio’s Holy Trinity and Campin’s Merode Altarpiece were both created during the same period, however their paintings show the influences of the Italian and northern styles, respectively, to bring forth new and different tools and methods of art.
Domestic Violence Essay Research Paper Theoretical Underpinnings
Domestic Violence Essay, Research Paper Theoretical Underpinnings of Domestic Violence In class as well as in the Levin and Weinberg readings we have covered seven theoretical perspectives on social problems. The first perspective that we covered is Social Pathology. With this perspective the individual is viewed as someone who cannot stop the domestic violence and continues these actions time and time again.
Morality Does Need Religion Essay Research Paper
Morality Does Need Religion In his essay, C. Stephen Layman clashes two views of morality: that of the secular point of view and the religious point of view. Layman starts out by defining the two different stances. The secular point of view states that there is no after life and that morality was an emergent phenomenon.
Anthem 2 Essay Research Paper The first
Anthem 2 Essay, Research Paper The first book I read this year was Anthem, written by the highly respected author, Ayn Rand. This book has two main themes which expressed in the style of her writing. In this piece I noticed Ayn Rand used her book to portray how man can overcome and achieve any objective he has been faced with and can see past any influence society has used to control his mind.
Teenage Love Essay Research Paper TEENAGE LOVEIn
Teenage Love Essay, Research Paper TEENAGE LOVE In the following paragraphs below I will be discussing three reasons on why teenage love is very controversial. Adults can misunderstand teenagers when teens say that they are in love. I also think that teenagers can mistake love for physical attraction or, as many people know it as lust.
The Age Of Streamlining Essay Research Paper
The Age of Streamlining The Age of Streamlining is an interesting art movement, occurring after World War I and before the start of World War II, mainly during the 1930 s. This was a time of economic prosperity and wealth, especially in such countries as the United States, where the streamlining effect could be seen in graphic design examples such as posters.
The First Reactor Essay Research Paper The
The First Reactor Essay, Research Paper The First Reactor The First Reactor chronicles the conception and implementation of the first self-sustaining nuclear pile. The booklet has three main sections to it. The first one tells of the history and background of the organizations and research that were used for the momentous experiment, as well as the actual proceedings that occurred on December 2, 1942.
Indians Essay Research Paper In her argumentative
Indians Essay, Research Paper In her argumentative essay, Jane Tompkins, an avid reader and researcher of the European-Indian relationships, delves into one of the most perplexing aspects of studying history in our world. Because we are such a diverse society–continuously prioritizing the fight for our own causes, there is much room left for the entrance of cultural subjectivity and perspective.
Archeo Essay Research Paper A Cross Cultural
Archeo Essay, Research Paper A Cross Cultural Perspective of Polygyny As an institution, polygyny, the social arrangement that permits a man to have more than one wife at the same
Broken Chain Essay Research Paper In the
Broken Chain Essay, Research Paper In the movie, Broken Chain , we can easily define the two sides, which are opposing each other; one is the six nations and the second is the British Empire. But actually, there is the third perspective in the scene, which I will go over later. There are two main characters in the six nations, one is Joseph Brant and another is Mohahehu.
Perspective On The Healthcare Industry Essay Research
Paper Perspective on the Healthcare Industry Healthcare systems, whether in a well-developed nation or an economically poor society, should be viewed upon as a system which can improve or replace humanity?s biological misfortunes. In other words, the system is always existent and should be open to all members of a community, regardless of financial or socioeconomic status.
Abortion Essay Research Paper wwwpottersschoolcomabortionIs it right
Abortion Essay, Research Paper www.pottersschool/abortion/ Is it right or is it wrong? Is it murder or is it a woman’s choice. There are so many conflicting views, but who is right? The debate over abortion will probably never be settled in my life time. As with many computer literate people, the author of this site gives us an objective view on abortion.
David Hume Essay Research Paper In reading
David Hume Essay, Research Paper In reading the ideas of David Hume, I have came to believe that he was telling us the miracles don?t exist. They are sort of a ?Mission impossible.? We
What Is Wrong With Killing Essay Research
Paper What is wrong with Killing? Apparently, the killing of human beings whether people accept it or not, exists within our ever growing society. Obviously it’s against the law, however does this make it wrong? The answer to this question is no. From a religious perspective killing another individual is wrong.
Frankenstein NovelVideo Assignment Essay Research Paper FRANKENSTEINFrankenstein
Frankenstein Novel/Video Assignment Essay, Research Paper FRANKENSTEIN Frankenstein is a book about how mans’ attempt to become perfect/create perfection. In a religious perspective this is what will happen if you try to create life without GOD but in my perspective this is what will happen when you try to understand the unknown with an uneducated mind.
Ceremony Essay Research Paper The novel Ceremony
Ceremony Essay, Research Paper The novel Ceremony, written by Leslie Silko deals with the actions of a Native American youth after fighting, and being held captive during World War II. The young mans name is Tayo and upon returning to the U.S., and eventually reservation life he has many feelings of estrangement and apathy towards society.
Your Biggest Mistake Essay Research Paper Your
Your Biggest Mistake Essay, Research Paper Your Biggest Mistake In response to the question “what has been your biggest mistake?” My biggest mistake is everyone’s biggest mistake, that no one can help. We all take on assumptions throughout our lives, and when we finally come to understand this, we spend our lives undoing all of them in order to approach the truth with assumptionless intelligence.
Jealousy In Gender Essay Research Paper The
Jealousy In Gender Essay, Research Paper The Influence of Jealousy in Men and Women in response to Infidelity Jealousy can be defined as ‘ a fear and rage reaction fitted to protect, maintain, and
Modernization Vs Dependency Essay Research Paper MODERNIZATION
Modernization Vs. Dependency Essay, Research Paper MODERNIZATION VS. DEPENDENCY The modernization perspective is behavioral or microsociological the primary focus is on individuals or aggregates of individuals, their values, attitudes, and beliefs. The dependency perspective, by contrast, is structural or macrosociological its focus is on the mode of production, patterns of international trade, political and economic linkages between elites in peripheral and central countries, group and class alliances and conflicts, and so on. (Valenzuela & Valenzuela, 1978)
Motivation Essay Research Paper Currently Essays
Motivation Essay, Research Paper Currently Essays All SubjectsEnglishHistoryScienceMathReligionGeography Your search found 6 essays. Iago’s Motivation and Malicious Revenge Against Othello – This essay is about the reasons for Iago’s hate for Othello with sited support from the text and other sources.
Scientific Perspective Essay Research Paper PerspectiveUse of
Scientific Perspective Essay, Research Paper Perspective Use of perspective in art finds its root in one man, Filippo Brunelleschi. Although we don?t know for sure, it is likely that Brunelleschi also invented linear, or scientific perspective. Donatello?s ?The Feast of Herod? is the earliest surviving example of scientific perspective, which is established through the use of a ?vanishing point?, an imaginary single point on the page in which all the parallel lines meet.
Madness Essay Research Paper Before the module
Madness Essay, Research Paper Before the module began I had a fixed idea of what madness was. I had underestimated the complexity of the portrayal of madness and as a result of this, I was surprised by the range of texts that we explored from that particular perspective.
Interracial Relationships Today Essay Research Paper Please
Interracial Relationships Today Essay, Research Paper Please cut and pastIn today?s society interracial relationships are more prevalent than ever before. When we view interracial relationships more closely we are able to create an individual opinion based on our own cultural upbringing. We will look at interracial relationships from a cultural relativists perspective, as well as, an ethno centrist?s point of view.
Ap Classes Essay Research Paper Your 200
Ap Classes Essay, Research Paper Your 200 word typed essay explaining why you wish to be enrolled in an A.P course(s). I wish to be enrolled in AP courses to better prepared to manage the workload of college. AP courses will prepare me for the type of classes I will take in college. They will give a feel of the college environment.
Retail Trade Essay Research Paper Write a
Retail Trade Essay, Research Paper Write a structure-performance study of the retail trade industry Paper should include the ff structure 1 Introduction. In this section you give an overview of the industry, its size, growth over the past 10-20 yrs, its important to the economy and other significant factors. 1-2 pages
Psychology Perspectives Essay Research Paper In psychology
Psychology Perspectives Essay, Research Paper In psychology there are six modern psychological perspectives. These perspectives are behavioral, psychodynamic, humanistic, cognitive, sociocultural, and biological. Each perspective has its own unique way of explaining the human behavior. I believe to truly explain the complex mental processes and behavior, each perspective must be examined and not limited to just one.