Paper
The play Amadeus by Peter Shaffer was not written in order to be a biography of the great composer Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart, much more than this, Peter Shaffer wrote it as a story, rather than a history. In his story he was free to insert fiction to make the play more interesting to a wide audience, as well as to fulfill his purposes. However, musicologists and historians have written several articles claiming that Peter Shaffer trashed this immortal . What none of them can see is that in Amadeus there are situations that are plausible while others are fictional ornament . In this paper I will make an attempt to point what is fiction or untruth.
The center of the play lies on the character of Antonio Salieri and his obsessive jealously of Mozart. To convey this plot, it was necessary that Salieri had motives enough dislike Mozart. So it was necessary to build a character that was extremely competent but with no talent at all to contrast with a genius who behaved badly. With this, Salieri would have reasons to be jealous.
As his first attempt to convey his plot, Salieri is shown as a musical hack as we can see in this extract:
Bewildered, MOZART does so (halts and listens), becoming aware of SALIERI playing his March of Welcome. It is an extremely banal piece, vaguely but only vaguely – reminiscent of another march to become very famous later one.
The truth is that Salieri was recognized as a great composer and that is the reason he was appointed as the court composer and imperial Kappelmeister. He had several students, including Beethoven, Liszt and Schubert. His operas were performed and acclaimed in Italy and France during 1778 to 1790. Unfortunately, his style lost worth and his works were no longer popular at the end of the XVIII century. However, showing Salieri as only a competent musician was intentional in order to convey the plot, which is the rivalry against Mozart s artistic creativity and Salieri s intellectual capacity.
Salieri held his posts in the court from 1774 until 1824. He died one year later in 1825 and in his last years he suffered from senility. During 1824 there was indeed the rumor in Vienna that someone had heard Salieri saying that he had poisoned Mozart. However, many biographies of Mozart don t even mention the probability of poisoning and in 1825 the attendants of Salieri said that they had never heard Salieri saying that he had killed Mozart.
Furthermore, if Salieri had indeed said those things, it wouldn t have meant that he indeed poisoned him, it could be related to his weak mind. On the other hand, Constanze supported the idea that Salieri killed Mozart and she believed that Salieri planned against Mozart during his life. But the medical observations of Mozart can nowadays be diagnosed as several causes, from typhus to rheumatic fever, streptococcal infection to cyclothymic disorder, but none related to poisoning.
Shaffer probably decided to write this play because of this rumor of a murder between two great composers. This idea, which at that time was indeed plausible, fed Shaffer with inspirations to write Amadeus . Even not being true, Salieri poisoning Mozart was a demand for Shaffer s play. Again, a play here is a piece of art, not a biography.
What seems to be the most important topic of the play is the relation between Salieri and Mozart. As it is seen throughout the play, Salieri s envy is not demonstrated to others, he treated Mozart with respect and had friendly manners. However, he boycotted Mozart inside the court. Mozart could have had the post to teach Princess Elizabeth:
JOSEPH: Herr Sommer. A dull man, surely? What of Mozart?
SALIERI: Majesty, I cannot with a clear conscience recommend Mozart to teach royalty. One hears too many stories.
JOSEPH: They may be just gossip.
SALIERI: One of them, I regret, relates to a prot g e of my own. A very young singer.
JOSEPH: Charmant!
SALIERI: Not pleasant, Majesty, but true.
JOSEPH: I see Let it be Herr Sommer, then.
And later, the emperor was willing to offer Mozart a post and a salary, to which Salieri objected.
JOSEPH: We must find him a post. ( ) There s Chamber Composer, now that Gluck is dead.
SALIERI: Mozart to follow Gluck?
JOSEPH: I won t have him say I drove him away. You know what a tongue he has.
SALIERI: Then grant him Gluck s post, Majesty, but not his salary. That would be wrong.
JOSEPH: Gluck got two thousand florins a year. What should Mozart get?
SALIERI: Two hundred. Light payment, yes, but for light duties.
JOSEPH: Perfect fair. I m obliged to you, Court Composer.
Here we see that Salieri betrayed Mozart when he was not around, while held courtly manners in front of him. In real life, nothing can prove us that Salieri was or was not a jealous character. However, we can say that Salieri s jealously might have been true, as he had high posts and Mozart could seem to him as a threat.
On the other hand, as Salieri had such honorable career inside the court, he could have done something to prevent operas like The Abduction from the seraglio , The Marriage of Figaro , and Cosi fan Tutte from being presented in the court theaters.
He had influence enough to prohibit these operas and he did not. Besides, if his jealousy were obsessive as it is shown, others would have noticed. And all that is reported about Salieri is that he was a small-town, earnest young man, filled with a
Single desperate desire to serve God. Again, in the play Salieri must be exactly how he is portrayed because his personality is the plot itself. His jealousy is the main plot of Amadeus . In any other way Shaffer could convey his intentions.
Another element that was controversial in the release of the play is how Mozart s character is portrayed. In Amadeus there are examples of Mozart using inappropriate language, lacking respect for the emperor and behaving like a child. However, it is said that at that time, if he behaved the way he does in the play towards the emperor, it would result in banishment from the court. At that time, it was impossible to imagine someone addressing an emperor the way he did. Mozart is portrayed as a spiteful, sniggering, conceited, infantine man. However, Shaffer himself tells that this portrait of Mozart was indeed excessive: The theatrical portrait of Mozart in Amadeus is clearly excessive and one-sided, at least in the expositional first act. It has been made so deliberately by crowding together into an hour s time instances of Wolfgang s most unattractive behavior, so as to provide ever-increasing fuel for Salieri s equally mounting sense of outrage. This is dramatically essential, because at the end of the act, Salieri has to explode in a furious, pain-racked, violently aggrieved address to his God, upbraiding him for choosing a patently unworthy man to be his divine instrument.
But what is documented is that Mozart was extremely irritable. A sort of child. All his sentiments had more violence than depths. 1804. So Mozart personality was exaggerated in order to convey the plot. Being like this, we would give a minimal reason for Salieri being jealous. It was intentional to make Mozart as a silly person so that Salieri s rage would have a motif.
With these discussed elements of the play, it seems noticeable that a playwright or any writer is free to use any ornament needed to convey what he wants to transmit to the readers. Shaffer, although being a Mozart scholar, used some fictional elements to write his story about the relation between the two composers.
Другие работы по теме:
As A Child Essay Research Paper As
As A Child Essay, Research Paper As a child, I was no exception. Three games that I especially enjoyed were Freeze Tag, Hide and Seek, and Truth or Dare. When I was little I used to play all three
Historical Fiction Essay Research Paper Textbooks can
Historical Fiction Essay, Research Paper Textbooks can often prove to offer only a limited amount of information. Space and time constraints place the author(s) of these textbooks in a sticky situation. They must get the general concept through without taking up to much space. However, this can sometimes push out relevant material that van help to support the general concept.
God And Gifts Essay Research Paper Amadeus
God And Gifts Essay, Research Paper Amadeus: God and Gifts Amadeus was a great film. The overall theme of the movie is a man vs. God. Antonio Salieri s started his life in music after his father died. He found that music was his passion. He devoted his life to writing music and to God. He was content with his music, and was considered a great Italian composer.
Truth Or Lie Essay Research Paper January
Truth Or Lie? Essay, Research Paper January 31, 2000 Truth or Lie ….??? The truth should be told most of the time. I do not think however that lying should be put out of our mind because sometimes lying is the only option we have. Lying can be a good thing and a bad thing. Depending on the situation we should analyze it and find out if telling the truth would inflict more harm or lying would.
A Dramatic Monologue Essay Research Paper They
A Dramatic Monologue Essay, Research Paper They will be back in twenty-five minutes, But I’ll show them. I’ll show them that I can do this. Climb these steps like everyone else. They think I’m decrepit, a burden, old.
Truth Essay Research Paper Is there any
Truth Essay, Research Paper Is there any objective truth? Or must we finally accept that at bottom, in the end, philosophically speaking, there is no “real” or “objective” or “absolute” or “foundational” or “fact of the matter” or “right answer” truth about anything, that even our most confident convictions about what happened in the past or what the universe is made of or who we are or what is beautiful or who is wicked are just our convictions, just conventions, just ideology, just badges of power, just the rules of the language games we choose to play, just the product of our irrepressible disposition to deceive ourselves that we have discovered out there in some external, objective, timeless, mind-independent, world what we have actually invented ourselves, out of instinct, imagination and culture?
THoughts On Pocahontas Essay Research Paper After
THoughts On Pocahontas Essay, Research Paper After watching the disney movie, Pocahontas, many people have found a large amount of historical inaccuracies in both the setting, and the characters portrayed. An example is: the topographic features of Virginia aren?t at all like the waterfalls and mountains shown in the movie.
Mozart Essay Research Paper The Life of
Mozart Essay, Research Paper The Life of Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart (1756-91) is regarded as the greatest composer who ever lived. He began writing minuets
Family Essay Research Paper Scholarship EssaySince the
Family Essay, Research Paper Scholarship Essay Since the day I was born, I have enjoyed story-telling. My first memories are of my father spinning me tales, as I nodded off. Every night I traveled back in time through his stories. I learned of Nero’s sadistic burning of Rome, Adolph Hitler’s maniacal reign, and Sojourner Truth’s brilliant speech.
Hot Lez Sex Essay Research Paper What
Hot Lez Sex Essay, Research Paper What is Truth and the best way to obtain it according to Ancient Scientists? In general, truth is anything that is correct of nature. The truth is in existence yet is not understood/known until it is uncovered. (Bruce Foltz WHGC lecture “What is truth?”)
Philosophy Truth Essay Research Paper Truth That
Philosophy: Truth Essay, Research Paper Truth! That is a word that philosophers have been arguing about for a good while! Truth is a state of mind free of error, a state of mind, which is an accurate reflection of things in existence, of the things about you. Truth is unchangeable; it is ageless and constant.
Peter Shaffer
’s Amadeus Essay, Research Paper I believe that there are two ways to critique Peter Shaffer’s Amadeus. The first, and the easiest for me, is as an artistic work only.
The Theban Plays Essay Research Paper Throughout
The Theban Plays Essay, Research Paper Throughout, The Theban Plays Creon remained an important character. From the first play King Oedipus through the second play Oedipus at Colonus Creon displayed a dramatic change in his character. A change in Creon?s personality was noticeable when the truth about Oedipus was revealed.
Ali Essay Research Paper Much of the
Ali Essay, Research Paper Much of the footage, particularly shots of Ali ingratiating himself with the natives and Foreman stepping off a plane accompanied by German shepherds, helps fill in the historical background of the fight. “Ali was loved by the Zaireans,” Gast says, “because they felt he was fighting for them.
The Folly Of Logic The Freedom Of
Truth Essay, Research Paper Logic can very often restrain us from recognising the truth when it is presented to us. Allow me to begin by asking a question.
1984 Essay Research Paper 1984 by George 2
1984 Essay, Research Paper 1984 by George Orwel is a dramatic novel portraying a restricted society.Winston Smith is a thin, 39 year-old man who wears blue Party coveralls. Winston is sick of the Party’s rigid control over his life and world, and begins trying to rebel against the Party–writing defiant thoughts in a secret diary and starting an illegal affair with Julia.
Amadeus Patron Saint Of All Mediocrities
Essay, Research Paper Patron Saint of All Mediocrities10/21/98AP English Patron Saint of All Mediocrities 1) IntroductionA) Broad summary of themeB) Thesis Statement2) Salieri s help from GodA) Reasons for Salieri s initial faithB) God s Betrayal3) Mozart is God s toolA) Musical tortureB) Romantic torture4) Salieri declares war with God5) Plans to use Mozart to defeat God6) God defeats Mozart Patron Saint of All Mediocrities The movie Amadeus is a dramatic depiction of the competition between Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart and his Italian rival Antonio Salieri.
Oedipus Rex Essay Research Paper Oedipus RexQuestion
Oedipus Rex Essay, Research Paper Oedipus Rex*Question 1*Dramatic irony plays a large part in the artistry of Sophocles’ Oedipus, creating a special dramatic tension. For example, when Oedipus says:And for the man that slew him [Laius].. I lay this curse upon him, that the wretchIn wretchedness and misery may live.(1) Since we, the audience, know that Oedipus is the killer, we see him setting himself up for the fall.
Oedipus 3 Essay Research Paper The Greek
Oedipus 3 Essay, Research Paper The Greek tragedy of Oedipus illustrates dramatic irony through Oedipus’ noble birth which is unknown to him and his fall from the throne due to his fate and excessive pride.
Huck Finn Essay Research Paper The concept
Huck Finn Essay, Research Paper The concept of what truth is, is a prevailing theme in both The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn, and the essay excerpt by Andrew Lang. Lang writes about truth as being found in lack of distortion from the actual world. Lang’s idea of truth is certainly found in The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn.
Sir Walter Scott Essay Research Paper Sir
Sir Walter Scott Essay, Research Paper Sir Walter Scott Scottish Novelist 1771 – 1832 Sir Walter Scott was born on August 15, 1771 in Edinburgh, Scotland. Scott created and popularized historical novels in a series called the Waverley Novels. In his novels Scott arranged the plots and characters so the reader enters into the lives of both great and ordinary people caught up in violent, dramatic changes in history.
The Allegory Of The
Cave Essay, Research Paper The Allegory of the Cave Plato gives rise to an interesting thought in The Allegory of the Cave . He suggest that people are to trusting in an unreliable society. Though he wrote this many years ago, it still applies today. It is ironic that people are willing to believe what the are told to be true, rather than search for the actual truth.
Mythology Essay Research Paper What is mythology
Mythology Essay, Research Paper What is mythology? Mythology is like a fib that started many years ago in the olden days. It is still around due to people still continuing to use a myth as the truth. They seem to not know the difference between a myth and a legend. People these days are so naive it is ashame to know the rate of people that actually believe those myths.
Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart Essay Research Paper Wolfgang
Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart Essay, Research Paper Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart The remarkable musician and composer by the name of Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart was born in Salzburg, Austria in 1756. At the early ages of three and four, Wolfgang exhibited extraordinary powers of music memory and ear-sophistication.
Lao Tzu
’S Response Essay, Research Paper I am Lao Tzu. In response to Mr. Martin’s observation: “The mind cannot find truth by itself, but it sure as hell can find falsehood. The idea of stumbling through life with my heart open and my bull*censored* detector turned off doesn’t appeal to me.”
Discovery Essay Research Paper Discoveries reveal things
Discovery Essay, Research Paper Discoveries reveal things that we often would prefer to keep hidden. Discuss the concept of Discovery and the effects it has on those who are involved. You must refer to your set text and supplementary material which you have studied in relation to this topic.
Appleby Book Review Essay Research Paper October
Appleby Book Review Essay, Research Paper October 20, 2000 Telling The Truth About History I am writing a book review of Telling The Truth About History by Joyce Appleby, Lynn Hunt and Margaret Jacob. In this book, the authors’ talk about the increased skepticism and the position that relativism has lessen our ability to actually know and to write about the past.
The Blindness In Oedipus Rex Essay Research
Paper The Blindness in Oedipus Rex In the play Oedipus Rex by Sophocles, the minor character of Tiresias is responsible for foreshadowing Oedipus fate, developing the theme of blindness, and also illustrating dramatic irony. Tiresias is responsible for further developing the theme of blindness, by using his own physical blindness to reveal to Oedipus his mental blindness.
Mozart Essay Research Paper I
Mozart Essay, Research Paper I’m writing my paper on Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart. I will be talking about his life and his music. I will tell you a little bit about his father, wife, and
Art And Photography Essay Research Paper
- To what extent has photography been used as an instrument of social control? Use historical examples to illustrate this essay. Photography was once prized for its ability to objectively capture what sat in front of the lens. The content of a photo was to be believed without question. Because photos seemed to be able to portray objects exactly as the human eye seemed to, they were taken at face value.
Truth And Belief Essay Research Paper Truth
Truth And Belief Essay, Research Paper Truth and Belief James is a believer in the pragmatic theory of truth. He draws a relationship between the good and the true. The true is not an separate entity from good, but is one of the species of good.
The Daughter Of Time By Josephine Tey
Essay, Research Paper Josephine Tey?s The Daughter of Time is a historical novel that looks at the belief that Richard III, King of England, murdered his two nephews in order to maintain his power. This novel also