, Research Paper
In the January/February issue of Archaeology magazine, the article “Early Homo erectus Tools in
China” holds additional, yet questionable information about the foundations of the genus Homo. After
recent findings of stone tools and animal bones at Renzidong (Renzi Cave) in Anhui Province, eastern
China, Chinese scientists have concluded that Homo erectus may have been established there 400,000 years
earlier than formerly believed, almost 2.25 million years ago. Besides this site being one of the oldest for
findings of early hominins, it has fueled, “[…] a debate on the origins of our genus Homo, with some
Chinese scientists proposing an evolution of H. erectus in China parallel to that […] in Africa”(14). A
limestone cave at Longgupo (”Dragon Hill”) in Sichuan Province is also in the spotlight for the “[…]
East-West debate […]“, over Homo origins (14). This cave has produced a 2 million year old mandible
fragments with features supporting both ideas of origins from the Chinese and West, not yielding to a
single, simple explanation. As to where these apes made their signature development onto the open, flat
land is debated indefinitely.
Approximately 1.7 million years ago, Homo erectus arose in Africa and shortly thereafter spread to
other continents, as most scientists believe. As they expanded their range and increased in population, H.
erectus may have exterminated H. habilis. Then transition from H. erectus to H. sapiens occurred about
400,000 years ago, and the dispute is over the place of origin of modern humans. “There is considerable
controversy among scientists as to whether the transition to H. sapiens took place only in Africa, or the
evolution of modern humans occurred simultaneously on three continents” (Purves 515). With little
information that we have now, a strong, clear hypothesis with support is lacking. But these newly
recovered fosiils and tools in Renzidong may change things around.
The “out of Africa” hypothesis suggests a single origin in Africa followed by several dispersal’s.
The “multiregional” hypothesis, in contrast, proposes parallel origins of Homo in different regions of
Europe, Africa, and Asia. But the Chinese believe in the “Asian Hypothesis”, or Asian origins of the genus.
Both sides agree that plate tectonic movements caused climatic changes from East Africa to East Asia. The
weather tended to be more “[…] seasonal and arid”, instigating arboreal apes to move onto the savannah
and evolve into upright hominins (Ciochon 15).
A large fissure in Anhui Province has yielded 3,000 bones of animals of 60 species. Some animals
included a tapir and a mastodon. Another one of the species included is the monkey Procynocephalus,
determining that that area was open to the environment about 2.5 million years ago. Also found were 50
stones and bones cut to be used as choppers, similar to those found in Africa. Most East Asian tools
found tend to be flakes with one side removed, called choppers. The only problem is that sometimes these
tools can be confused with rocks formed asymmetrically from wear and tear, including rain, snow ,and years
of movement and erosion. These tools were used for digging, cutting wood, capturing animals, cleaning
and cutting meat, and scraping hides. Early hominins could have gone into the fissure and butchered the
animals for food after they had fallen into the hole. Evidence for this is provided by the findings of the tapir
seemingly to be laid out for butchering and the mastodon skeletons piled on one of the side walls.
Procynocephalus skeletons as well as similar monkeys and H. erectus fossils have been found
together both in East Africa and Asia. In Longgupo, a mandible fragment found had two worn out molars
from the Procynocephalus monkey. Western scientists believe these “[...] teeth share features with earliest
Homo in East Africa-leading us to suggest a direct link, a “dispersal” of African hominins to East Asia about
2 million years ago”(14-15). But the Chinese disagree, seeing similar features in Asian apes, and proposing
an Asian Homo origin.
Fossil remains from this genus have been found in Africa, Indonesia, China, the Middle East, and
Europe. The Pliocene record of hominins in Africa preceding H. erectus is extensive, “[...] whereas the
Asian record holds little information to date” (15). But more recent findings in new areas and techniques
have sprouted with hidden information yet to be known.
A newly introduced potassium/argon dating technique was used to redate the Sangiran erectus
fossils, found in Java. These fossils were found to be from 1.6 to 1.9 million years ago, twice as old as
previously thought and at least as old as the oldest African erectus fossil. This opens up the possibility
that H. erectus may have evolved somewhere other than Africa, evidently East Asia. For Westerners,
plausible explanations for this include that they first appeared in Africa earlier than any of the fossils that
have been found, or that their expansion began shortly after they first evolved. Or maybe erectus evolved
in between Asia and Africa and migrated. “{…} [T]hen why haven’t any earlier fossil hominids been found
outside Africa?”, asks Matt Cartmill author of the article “The Third Man”(185). If the dates are accurate,
then these explanations are legitimate. But the Chinese scientists see it in a different light.
According to many scientists, (both Chinese and Western amongst others) Homo erectus left the
savannah’s to which they were so well adapted because of reproductive success. Their big brains allowed
them to exploit their environment and make better and more varied tools. They could learn more and reason
out problems that their habitat posed. They also had a more complex social organization. With the
population increase, there may have been pressure put on resources and social harmony. Different groups
migrated out to find less competition over food, water, and space.
Overall this article has an East vs. West theme, Chinese vs. the Westerners. Who’s to say who’s
right or wrong? Here are fossils of great geological age and importance that have been used to back up two
different theories on the beginnings of the genus Homo. Both are plausible, but one is more widely
accepted and a more evidence supported than the other. The authors could be racist and want the Chinese
to look ridiculous in front of the world, leaning for a Western explanation to be the correct one. The article
portrays a theme of right versus wrong, white versus Asian. Or is it just circumstantial that all the Chinese
anthropologists agree with the “Asian Hypothesis” and unlike the Westerners who are divided among the
“multiregional” and “out of Africa” hypotheses? This article has made gross generalizations that are not
entirely supported with evidence. Ciochon and Larick demean the Chinese because they have found
evidence that could support what some of them believe to be their roots, or beginnings. I applaud the
Chinese scientists for challenging theories, the way truth is found in science. They have fossils from a very
early date that are not corresponding to past records and the lineage of movement of H. erectus. East Asia
holds hidden information in its untouched land about our ancestral past and the West should not shun
ideas that could one day be supported indefinitely by these new fossil findings.
Park, Michael A. Biological Anthropology/An Introductory Reader. Mayfield Pub. Co.: Toronto,
1999/2000.
Purves, William K, et al. Life: The Science of Biology. Sinauer Assoc.: Sunderland, 1998.
Bibliography
at end of paper
my knowledge, jen
Другие работы по теме:
Hominid Species Essay Research Paper Hominid SpeciesThe
Hominid Species Essay, Research Paper Hominid Species The time of the split between humans and living apes used to be thought to have occurred 15 to 20 million years ago, or even up to 30 or 40 million years ago. Some apes occurring within that time period, such as Ramapithecus, used to be considered as hominids, and possible ancestors of humans.
China Essay Research Paper It seems strange
China Essay, Research Paper It seems strange to me that I have underestimated China’s economic power for all this time. After reading and doing the site work, I have concluded that China is in fact a very powerful nation with a vast supply of natural resources and material goods. The amount the country exports to others astonishes me.
O Henry Essay Research Paper As Ralph
O. Henry Essay, Research Paper As Ralph D. Spencer strolled down the sidewalk, he knew of a few things he had to do. For he liked being Ralph Spencer and did not want to
Theme In A Pair Of Tickets Essay
, Research Paper Amy Tan s A Pair of Tickets is the account of Jing-mei, an American woman on a pilgrimage to China to meet her half-sisters, abandoned by her mother in China during World War II. Jing-mei s mother always hoped of reuniting with her daughters she left behind long ago, but she died of an aneurysm before the opportunity arose.
How Man Evolved Essay Research Paper How
How Man Evolved Essay, Research Paper How Man evolved How did the early man evolve and change into the way we are today?Human Evolution, the natural development of the species Homo Sapiens, or humanbeings. The initial man, called the Hominid was short, not intelligent, and very ape like. The next man lived in the stone age; his name was Homo Habilis.
Mao Zedong Vs Deng Xioping Essay Research
Paper Mao Zedong was one of if not the most famous communist leaders in the history of China. His views of modernizing his country won him millions of followers. After his death in 1976, a man by the name of Deng Xioping attempted to win over Mao’s former followers and rule China. These two men were probably the most influencial people in China inthe 1900’s.
Kate Chopin Essay Research Paper ChinaHerrlee Glessner
Kate Chopin Essay, Research Paper China Herrlee Glessner Creel wrote The Birth of China. The book was published in 1937 at Frederick Lungar Publishing in New York City. Creel was born in Chicago, Illinois on January 15 1905. Both Creel’s mother and father were writers. Creel attended the University of Oklahoma, Creighton University, and finally the University of Chicago where he received his Ph.D. in 1929.
Shangeid To China Essay Research Paper The
Shangeid To China Essay, Research Paper The book is about a boy named Neil who came down to Liverpool to stay with his grandparents . While Neil was there, he snuck out of the house and went to the waterfront.There he stopped to
The Great Wall Of China Essay Research
Paper The Great Wall of China By: Leonard Everett Fisher King Cheng became Ch in Shih Huang Ti and was the first emperor. China at this time was hard to manage. Since there were many different old kingdoms, each had it s own system of weights, measures, money, and writing. Shih Huang Ti decided to make these systems of weights, measures, money, and writing the same for everywhere in China.
Iron And Silk Essay Research Paper In
Iron And Silk Essay, Research Paper In the book Iron and Silk, written by Mark Salzman as his point of view, is all about China. Throughout the book, Mark experiences many differences between the Chinese culture and his own American culture. Chinese people want to save face by doing some weird things. First example, kissing in China over the age of two is embarrassing for both children and parents.
Modernizing China Essay Research Paper Modernizing ChinaThe
Modernizing China Essay, Research Paper Modernizing China The belief systems that have been given rise to in China are religions thought out for thousands of years. All of them are different from each other, but also interlaced. Many scholars and thinkers spent a whole life devoted to further developing a way of thinking.
China Foreign Policy Essay Research Paper Paul
China Foreign Policy Essay, Research Paper Paul Kanitra Public Policy Paper-Draft #1 9-28-99 Since the initial warming of U.S.-China relations in the early 1970’s, policymakers have had difficulty balancing conflicting U.S. policy concerns in the People’s Republic of China. In the strange world of diplomacy between the two, nothing is predictable.
Ideas Are Tools
” Essay, Research Paper I have found that the power process #1 “Ideas are Tools” is the most important learning process that a person can use to reach the level of a master student. This idea suggest that you treat ideas as tools and that each new idea that the text has to offer should be used and evaluated as to it’s effectiveness.
Chinese Kites Essay Research Paper The Kite
Chinese Kites Essay, Research Paper The Kite: China, Fifth/Fourth Century BC. Two kitemakers, Kungshu P’an who made kites shaped like birds which could fly for up to three days, and Mo Ti (who is said to have spent three years building a special kite) were famous in Chinese traditional stories from as early as the fifth century BC.
Silk
– Research Method Essay, Research Paper Do you know the process that goes into making silk? Many people over look this fine, luxurious garment. When I first heard that we had to do an I-search, I was overwhelmed by the choices. I made many changes before finally settling on this topic. When I first though of how to make silk, I didn’t think that it would be that hard with the right tools.
Taiwan Perspective Essay Research Paper Comment critically
Taiwan Perspective Essay, Research Paper Comment critically on at least two Taiwan futures. As United States policy states we support the “one China” idea but we will defend Taiwan if mainland China begins to attack. Thereby putting us at war with China. Taiwan would then be a free state, assuming we control and win the war, but at what cost to America? And for how long?
ChinaTaiwan Essay Research Paper After the fall
China-Taiwan Essay, Research Paper After the fall of the Qing Empire, nationalists, known as the KMT established the Republic of China. However the KMT was rife with corruption, and a new faction inspired by Russian communist ideology soon emerged to struggle for power. After World War II, the clash between the KMT and the communists continued.
The Stone Age Tool Essay Research Paper
The Stone Age Tool The Neanderthals lived form 70,000 to 40,000 B.C. By that time man knew how to make tools, not just find and object and use it, but craft it with their own hands.
Untitled Essay Research Paper Sand Pebbles essay
Untitled Essay, Research Paper Sand Pebbles essay The movie Sand Pebbles focus was on the flag. The flag was not only a symbol of a nation, but of nationalism, militarism and imperialism. During the 1800’s and early 1900’s there was a severe foreign influence in China. During this time period the European nations wanted to trade with the Chinese, but the Chinese had no interest in the European products for at the time China was self sufficient.
Joy Luck Essay Research Paper The Joy
Joy Luck Essay, Research Paper The Joy Luck Club, by Amy Tan, is a powerful portrayalThe Joy Luck Club, by Amy Tan, is a powerful portrayal of four Chinese women and the lives of their children in America. The book discusses the conflicting cultures between the United States and China, and how men treat women throughout their lives.
Marijuana 3 Essay Research Paper Marijuana has
Marijuana 3 Essay, Research Paper Marijuana has been used as a drug since the beginning of time, yet there are still many mysteries about its health effects on humans. Marijuana, or cannabis sativa, is a preparation of the crushed flower or buds of the female hemp plant. The existence of the plant has been reported as early as 1500-2000 BC in China, and cannabis has been described as an analgesic as early as 200 AD.
Facts About China Essay Research Paper Facts
Facts About China Essay, Research Paper Facts About China 1.)21% of China’s population live in urban areas and 79% live in rural areas. 2.)China’s national anthem is the “The East is Red.” 3.)The capital of China is
Sun YatSen Essay Research Paper Sun YatSen
Sun Yat-Sen Essay, Research Paper Sun Yat-Sen helped the growth of Nationalism during the early 20th century. After experiencing and studying in Hawaii, he got a taste of what the western world was like. Sun wanted to help westernize China to keep up with the world s technology and economy. His goal was to nationalize China.
Homo Erectus Essay Research Paper About one
Homo Erectus Essay, Research Paper About one million years ago, Homo erectus populations began migrating out of East Africa. They soon spread into South and West Africa, Asia and Europe. This adaptive radiation was the result of several biological and cultural factors.
Homo Erectus Essay Research Paper Animalia Chordata
Homo Erectus Essay, Research Paper Animalia, Chordata, Mammalia, Primates, Hominidae, Homo erectus The appearance and body structure of the Homo erectus is very similar to present humans. The skull of the Homo erectus, however, is noticeably smaller. Brain capacity ranges from 800-1000 cc corresponding with a retreating forehead and thicker skull bones.
Politics In China In 1900
′S Essay, Research Paper POLITICS IN CHINA IN EARLY 1900′S The politics in China varies to republic and nationalism and communism. First of all, there is Republican China which evolved very
What I Know About China Essay Research
Paper What I know about China China is located around Mongolia, Russia, Nepal, Laos, East China Sea, South China Sea, and Myanmar. A better described location
Fire And Early Man Essay Research Paper
The definition of fire is the active principle of burning, characterized by the heat and light of combustion; And cultivating it was perhaps one of the biggest technological leaps humans ever surpassed. Fire affected the ancient man in many ways through cause and effect, and every effect created a cause, which resulted in another effect.
Homo Erectus Essay Research Paper Homo erectusMichael
Homo Erectus Essay, Research Paper Homo erectus Michael F. Chapman Jr. Homo erectus was a well-adapted species capable of much more complicated day-to-day tasks. Much of this ability was due to their morphological changes. These changes occurred in the skeletal system and the soft tissues and were tied to environmental factors, tool use, increased meat consumption as well as the more nomadic lifestyle.
Human Ancestory Essay Research Paper Human AncestoryThe
Human Ancestory Essay, Research Paper Human AncestoryThe evolutionary relationships of Australopithecus and Homo are still argued today among top anthropologists. The direct human phylogeny is not certain, and many links to modern man from four million years ago are possible. What is not argued, however, is that the evolution of man was an evolution from the neck up, rather than from the neck down.
Democracy In China Essay Research Paper During
Democracy In China Essay, Research Paper During the 1980?s, China came under the rule of a new man. His name was Deng Xiaoping. China?s culture and views on trade were greatly influenced by Deng, yet he failed in establishing a democratic China. Contrary to many people?s beliefs, Deng did not create any democracy in China.