Paper
Was Jim Jones a Prophet?
RELI 320
February 12, 2001
November 18, 1978 it all ended. Jim Jones and his
followers committed mass suicide in Guyana, South
America. The history of Jim Jones and the Peoples Temple
is still studied a great deal today. Why did all those
people follow Jones? Were they forced, were they brain
washed, or was Jones just that charismatic. In
this paper we will probe deep into Jonestown and answer
some of these questions. We will be using Max Webber’s
article “The Prophet” find out if Jones was a prophet, if
so what kind of prophet was he. We will also compare and
contrast Webber’s theories of charismatic leadership at
an attempt to understand Jim’s activities, successes, and
failures.
Jones started off in Indiana a branch of the
Methodist Church. Jones separated from the church
because the Methodist church did not want to allow
integration of blacks and whites. When Jones finally
separated from the church and started his own church
called the peoples temple. Here everyone was welcome.
Jones believed that it was his ethical duty to integrate
the church they way that God wanted it. He demanded
obedience as his ethical duty. Because of these things
Jones was an ethical prophet when he resided in Indiana.
When Jones discovered that his church had more
growth potential in California where the black population
was much larger. They packed up the church and headed to
California. Here is where Jones took more of an
aggressive approach to recruitment of people. He also
developed a stronger power fixation and would do anything
for a larger congregation. Jones had fixed healings to
make him look god-like and to have ultimate power. Jones
also convinced his wife that it was acceptable for him to
have multiple sexual partners while others were not. In
California Jones appeared to be out primarily for his own
self interest not the church. Because of this Jones
shifts from an ethical prophet to an exemplary prophet.
After the subversive tactics of the Peoples Temple,
they started to feel the pressure from the society around
them. So again Jones moved the Church and anyone able to
the perfect utopian society, Guyana South America. Here
they named their society Jonestown. The Church made
everything they needed and were essentially isolated from
the rest of the world. In Guyana, Jim was becoming less
and less important every day. Everyone built the society
so everyone had somewhat of stock invested, making Jim
less important. When Jim saw his importance fading, he
faked numerous injuries to gain attention. Jim claimed to
have cancer although an autopsy showed no cancer was
present in his body. Even though Jones forbid the use of
drugs, he became dependent on barbiturates and
painkillers. His excuse was that he needed them for the
pain of his non-existent injuries. Then as quickly as it
grew it ended. The People Temple killed a congressman
coming to observe their life style. Knowing the
repercussions of this Jones organized a revolutionary
suicide that proved to everyone that they would not
loose. In Guyana, Jones became a selfish nut where all
he wanted was more power that he could no longer obtain
as he did in California. You cannot classify Jim as any
type of prophet in Guyana. Jones was way too selfish,
lazy, and unimportant to be considered anything but a
crybaby.
Max Webber has many theories about prophets and
their classification. Some of which describe Jones and
some that do not. First, Jones had an incredible amount
of charisma. He convinced his wife it was OK for him to
have mistresses. He told everyone that they could not
take drugs yet he was an addict himself. Finally, He
convinced everyone in Jonestown to commit suicide. Any
man that can do these things is a charismatic
masterpiece. Having this charisma really helped Jones
persuade others to do his bidding. Second, a typical
prophet propagates ideas for his own sake not fees or any
regulated form. Jones really never demanded any money.
He was out for the power and the glory. This I think
also helped Jones. People trusted him and never asked
for much in return only to follow him. Third, a
prophet’s core should be commandment or doctrine, not
magic. This is where Jones does not fit in. Jones in
Indiana may have had a core of commandment and doctrine,
but when he moved to California it turned to power and
deceit. I mentioned earlier that he set up faked
healings to make him look powerful when he was not. Even
though Jones did not Fit into this category performing
fake healings really gained him a lot of power and new
recruits for the Peoples Temple.
Do I believe that Max Webber’s theories and
categories explain Jones and his actions? Not really,
even though Jones met most of the criteria to be a
prophet, he was all of them and none of them. His
behavior was completely erratic most of the time and I
believe he was corrupted by his own power. Because of
this it is very difficult for the theories to work.
Jim Jones was a man that started something good but
was eventually corrupted by his power and control. In
this paper I talked about Jones and how he transformed
from an ethical prophet in Indiana to an exemplary
prophet in California to Neither in Guyana. I described
how some of Webber’s theories fit Jones and how others
did not fit Jones. I discussed the activities, successes
and failures because of Jim’s Charisma. I don’t know if
we will ever really know all the details of Jonestown,
but nevertheless they should be a strong reminder and
teaching tool on how there is a thin line between right
and wrong when it comes to using power and abusing it.
Max Webber “The Prophet” In Class Reading
M.M Maaga “Hearing the Voices of Jonestown” In Class Reading
Другие работы по теме:
Leprechauns Don
’t Play Basketball Essay, Research Paper January 6, 2000 Leprechauns Don’t Play Basketball Debbie Dadey & Marcia Thornton Jones Letter #4 Dear Mrs. Schafer:
Animal Farm Essay Research Paper Animal FarmBy
Animal Farm Essay, Research Paper Animal Farm By George Orwell In this story, the major problem being faced is the dictatorship of Mr. Jones, a farmer. Most of the animals on his farm didn?t have a problem with his
Untitled Essay Research Paper Animal FarmMr Jones
Untitled Essay, Research Paper Animal FarmMr. Jones owned and managed Manor Farm. He was a bad man who liked to drink. Things on the farm got so bad one night that he fell asleep so drunk that he forgot to lock in the animals. The beasts took advantage of the situation and held a secret meeting. Led by the pigs, they ran the Joneses from their home.The animals of the renamed “Animal Farm” formed a system they called “Animalism.
The Giver Essay Research Paper 0 1ST
The Giver Essay, Research Paper :0{ 1ST LOIS LOWRY RECEIVED THE NEWBERY MEDAL FOR NUMBER THE STARS AND THE GIVER. SHE IS ALSO THE AUTHER OF MANY OTHER POPULAR BOOKS FOR YOUNG AUTHOR
Moses And Exodus Religion Essay Research Paper
Were Moses and Samuel Prophet Material? To get a good idea of being a Prophet or what a Prophet is we must look at many sources. This means we must look at the events that happened in the Bible and make conclusions about each event or section. Were Samuel and Moses Prophets? Did they receive messages from God, or was it their imagination? We will hope to discover this in looking closer at all of their lives.
Dianne Day Essay Research Paper Dianne Day
Dianne Day Essay, Research Paper Dianne Day isn t as famous as Mary Higgins Clark but she had a childhood similar to her. When she was a baby in Mississippi her father died. Dianne went on to live with her grandparents and they also were not a well-financed family. When Dianne was seven she rejoined her mother was now remarried.
Oedipus Rex 4 Essay Research Paper Essay
Oedipus Rex 4 Essay, Research Paper Essay- Oedipus the King by Sophocles According to Aristotle, the protagonist in a tragedy must have a tragic flaw that ultimately becomes the cause of his ruin. Oedipus in Oedipus the King by Sophocles tragic flaw that caused his downfall was his pride. Three examples of when Oedipus pride got the better of him were: when he left his adopted parents in Cornith, the second is when he goes against Creon, and the third is when Oedipus is demanding that the messenger tell him all he knows about who his real parents are.
Animal Farm Chapter Summaies Essay Research Paper
Chapter 4,5&6 Summary Chapter 4 talks about how the pigs ran the farm. Jones sat and sat drunk every day. Jones and the rest of the humans invaded the farm. They were chased back out of it. Jones shot Snowball and a sheep.
Roy Jones Jr Essay Research Paper Roy
Roy Jones Jr. Essay, Research Paper Roy Jones Jr. was born on January 16, 1969 in Pensacola Florida. Unlike other black boxers Roy developed his boxing skills on a hog farm in a hamlet
Modern Day Prophets Essay Research Paper What
Modern Day Prophets Essay, Research Paper What is a Prophet? The most common definition of this word is spokesman, or one who speaks for or on behalf of someone. Prophets were sent out on a well defined and specified mission entrusted to them, by God, to guide mankind along the path of righteousness. They were charged with the responsibility of conveying to the believers the commandments.
Phil CollinS In The Air Tonight Essay
, Research Paper Dec 2000 In The Air Tonight Phil Collins “In The Air Tonight” is a strophic composition produced by Phil Collins. The aria consists of an electronic drum set an electric guitar and a prophet to add an additional fullness to the song. The exposition of the monody is at an adagio tempo. The electronic drum kit repeats a drum pattern with 12 drum hits in each loop, while accenting on every third beat {eg.1-2-1-2-1-2-1-22-1-2 | 11-2-1-2-1-2-1-22-1-2}.
The Emperor Jones Essay Research Paper The
The Emperor Jones Essay, Research Paper The Emperor JonesIn Eugene O’Neil’s play, The Emperor Jones, he presents a crucial lesson to mankind: one should not pretend to be someone who he is not. Multiple repercussions may occur to someone who denies their background and race. For example, in The Emperor Jones, the character, Brutus Jones, dissembles as a free white man (Jones was really black and was supposed to be in slavery during that time).
Religions 2 Essay Research Paper Global History
Religions 2 Essay, Research Paper Global History 9 March 23rd 1999 In the world today there are three major religions, Christianity, Judaism, and Islam. Each having the same background but having different views of this religion. These religions all have originated from the same area, the Middle East, and each having branched out from there.
Oedipus Paper Essay Research Paper One of
Oedipus Paper Essay, Research Paper One of Oedipus greatest qualities as a leader was his ability to solve problems. The reason that Oedipus, not even a native of Thebes, became the king of that land was due to the great intelligence and strength shown in his defeat of the Sphinx. He was able to save the Thebans from that problem, so when the city again needs help, Oedipus is very willing to show his strength again.
Understading Robert Edmond Jones
’ Towards A New Theater Essay, Research Paper In the second chapter of his book “Towards a New Theatre”, Robert Edmond Jones explains the loss of art in American theatre. Although American theatre puts on the best show, has beautiful sets, and can do a good job “faking it”, what we [as American actors] are practicing is far from what theatre should be.
Islam Essay Research Paper The political system
Islam Essay, Research Paper The political system of Islam is based on the three principles of Tawhid (Oneness with Allah (God)), Risala ( Prophet hood), and Khilafa ( Caliphate). Tawhid means that Allah alone is the Creator, Sustainer, and Master of the universe and of all that exists in it- organic or inorganic.
Prophet Essay Research Paper The Prophet
Prophet Essay, Research Paper The Prophet Period 4 Patrick Coleman In the prophet it does not tell you how to live, but it tells you how life works. I do not agree with everything that is said, but as a whole I like the message the book sends. I have taken my five favorite chapters, and broken them down for this report.
Obadiah The Prophet Essay Research Paper Prophet
Obadiah The Prophet Essay, Research Paper Prophet – One who utters divinely inspired revelations That is how the word prophet is defined in Webster?s dictionary, but a prophet is much more. A prophet is someone who is chosen by God to convey his message to the people; a middleman between God and his people. A prophet is someone who God selects as the embodiment of himself.
Biology Exam Notes Essay Research Paper
Mother Teresa Mother Teresa was a modern prophet who gave all of herself and dedicated his life to Jesus? cause, Mother Teresa worked tirelessly for the poor believing all she needed was love to cure any disease or to aid
Shia Islam Essay Research Paper Shi
Shia Islam Essay, Research Paper Shi’a Islam Shi’a Islam is almost as old as Islam itself and has always had a minority population in Muslim populated areas of the world. According to Shi’a beliefs the prophet
Islam Essay Research Paper Islam
Islam Essay, Research Paper Islam Islam, which in Arabic means submission to God or Allah is the youngest religion of the world. It is a monotheistic religion and one of the Abrahamic
Animal Farm Essay Research Paper As I
Animal Farm Essay, Research Paper As I read the book “Animal Farm”, I have came to see that the story “Animal Farm” is a metaphor for the life in the USSR. We see how ” Animal Farm ” takes on personalities of social and political figures from the USSR. They relate to the social and political life of The USSR in how they act and live.
The Rolling Stones Essay Research Paper The
The Rolling Stones Essay, Research Paper The Rolling Stones The English rock band The Rolling Stones was formed in 1962. The five origional members of the group were lead singer Mick Jagger
The Life Of Muhammad Essay Research Paper
The prophet of Islam, Muhammad, not only was gifted religiously, but was a gifted politically as well. Muhammad was an exceptionally honest and able person who preached that there was only one true God, Allah. Muhammad’s teachings eventually developed into Islam. Though Islam was a successful religion in the end, it developed slowly in the early years.
Critique Of Bridget Jones
’s Diary Essay, Research Paper Cristin English 10HMr. LudJanuary 8, 1999Critique of Bridget Jones’s Diaryby: Helen Fielding Bridget Jones’s Diary, written by Helen Fielding, was a very interesting novel. I feel that I would have enjoyed the book more if I had read it at a later point and time in my life when I have the ability to relate to it more.
Oedipus Rex Essay Research Paper
In Oedipus Rex by Sophocles, Oedipus tried to make the world that he lived better by trying to kill people that he thought made the problems in the city.He said that he wanted to find the men who were responsible for the plague in the city. Then he would kill them and get rid of the problem. He also said that he wanted to rid the city of all the people that were causing all the pollution in the city.
Thoreau Essay Research Paper Jerry PetercuskieEnglish 20103Dr
Thoreau Essay, Research Paper Jerry Petercuskie English 201-03 Dr. E. Brinkley November 27, 1996 THOREAU AS A PROPHET Thoreau was a simple man that believed in having only the basic necessities in life. Thoreau lived a life of simplicity at Walden Pond. In Walden, Thoreau gives a background of his life and some life experiences that he has encountered.
Prophet Of Rage
– Louis Farrakhan Essay, Research Paper Prophet of Rage: Louis Farrakhan Prophet of rage? Louis Farrakhan is exactly that. He is the fearless spokesman for black America, who is unafraid to speak for his people. This is Louis Farrakhan. This book is authored by Arthur J. Magida, and speaks the controversial truth about Mr.
Corruption Of Power Essay Research Paper Corruption
Corruption Of Power Essay, Research Paper Corruption of power was a very evident theme in both Emperor Jones and Macbeth. In both plays the main character was corrupted for different reasons. However, many similarities lie within the storyline which contributed to the downfall of both Jones and Macbeth.
Joseph Jones MD Essay Research Paper Joseph
Joseph Jones, M.D. Essay, Research Paper Joseph Jones, M.D. Joseph Jones, the descendant of a prominent Southern family, was born in Liberty County, Georgia on 6 September 1833, to Charles Colcock and Mary Sharpe Jones. Since education was such a high priority of the family, Joseph began his college career at South Carolina College and then transferred to his father’s alma mater, Princeton.
Bill Clinton Vs Paula Jones Essay Research
Paper A lawsuit has been filed by Paula Jones, a clerk for the Arkansas Industrial Development Commission, for sexual harassment by then Governor Clinton. In her lawsuit, Paula Jones states that Clinton told an Arkansas State trooper to escort her to a private hotel room where she claims that she was sexually harassed.
Koran
– Book Of Islam Essay, Research Paper The Koran, the book of Islam, is not only the testimony of a false prophet, it is the testimony of Antichrist. Yet, so many hearing that testimony today are willing to believe it, to take it to heart, to stand on it, and even to die for it — as if it were written by the Spirit of Truth.