’ “Love And Role Playing In A Farewell To Arms” Essay, Research Paper
John Stubbs’ “Love and Role Playing in A Farewell to Arms”
John Stubbs’ essay is an examination of the defense which he believes Henry and
Catherine use to protect themselves from the discovery of their insignificance
and “powerlessness…in a world indifferent to their well being…” He asserts
that “role-playing” by the two main characters, and several others in the book,
is a way to escape the realization of human mortality which is unveiled by war.
Stubbs thinks that Hemingway utilized role-playing as a way to “explore the
strengths and weaknesses of his two characters.” Stubbs says that by placing
Henry’s ordered life in opposition to Catherine’s topsy-turvy one, and then
letting each one assume a role which will bring them closer together, Hemingway
shows the pair’s inability to accept “the hard, gratuitous quality of life.”
Stubbs begins by showing other examples, notably in In Our Time and The Sun Also
Rises, in which Hemingway’s characters revert to role-playing in order to escape
or retreat from their lives. The ability to create characters who play roles, he
says, either to “maintain self-esteem” or to escape, is one Hemingway exploits
extraordinarily well in A Farewell to Arms and therefore it “is his richest and
most successful handling of human beings trying to come to terms with their
vulnerability.”
As far as Stubbs is concerned, Hemingway is quite blatant in letting us know
that role-playing is what is occurring. He tells that the role-playing begins
during Henry and Catherine’s third encounter, when Catherine directly dictates
what is spoken by Henry. After this meeting the two become increasingly
comfortable with their roles and easily adopt them whenever the other is nearby.
This is apparent also in that they can only successfully play their roles when
they are in private and any disturbance causes the “game” to be disrupted. The
intrusion of the outside world in any form makes their role-playing impossible,
as evidenced at the race track in Milan, where they must be alone. The people
surrounding them make Catherine feel uncomfortable and Henry has to take her
away from the crowd. He goes on to describe how it is impossible for them to
play the roles when they are apart and how they therefore become more dependent
upon each other’s company.
Stubbs goes on to explain how, “neither mistakes role-playing for a truly
intimate relationship, but both recognize that it can be a useful device for
satisfying certain emotional needs.” He says that originally Henry and Catherine
are playing the “game” for different reasons but eventually move to play it as a
team. Henry is role-playing to regain the sense of order he has lost when he
realizes the futility of the war and his lack of place in it. Catherine is role-
playing to deal with the loss of her fiance and to try to find order in the
arena of the war. When they are able to role-play together, “the promise of
mutual support” is what becomes so important to them as they try to cope with
their individual human vulnerability.
He also analyzes the idyllic world introduced early in the story by the priest
at the mess and later realized by Henry and Catherine in Switzerland. They fall
fully into their roles when they row across the lake on their way to their
idealized world. The fact that they actually are able to enter this make-believe
world strengthens their “game” and allows it to continue longer than it would
have otherwise. And once they are in this new world they adopt new roles which
allow them to continue their ruse. They also need to work harder to maintain the
“game” because far from the front they are both still aware the war is
proceeding and they are no longer a part of it. The world in which they exist in
reality (!) is not conducive to role-playing because it tries repeatedly to end
their “game”.
Stubbs manages to uncover numerous instances in which the two are role-playing
and he makes a very interesting case that this is exactly what they are doing
and not just his imagination reading into the story. He does make certain
assumptions, that their love is not “real”, that the characters are searching
for order, which are not completely justified or even necessary to prove his
point. He also forces an intentionality upon Hemingway which could have been
avoided without harming his theory. Towards the end of the essay Stubbs infers
that their role-playing is “inferior to true intimacy,” which is a point that,
although he defends well, is not central to his theory and seems to detract from
his objectivity.
The essay is a valuable tool to help the reader understand this view of what is
happening through Henry and Catherine’s relationship and how they use each other
to maintain their self-images, provide themselves with psychological support,
and in a way escape the war. Hemingway may not have been trying to purposely
create a role-playing scenario, but Stubbs’ essay will benefit someone wishing
to explore this aspect of the relationship of the two main characters in greater
depth.
Bibliography
Bruccoli, Matthew J. and Clark, C.E. Frazer (ed.), Fitzgerald / Hemingway Annual
1973, pp. 271-284, Microcard Editions Books, Washington, D.C., 1974
Другие работы по теме:
The Pigman
– Analysis Of John Conlan Essay, Research Paper John Conlan is a main character in the book The Pigman. He doesn’t act, think and have a social reputation as many people might
The Birth Narrative Through The Gospels Of
Matthew Luke And John (Comparison) Essay, Research Paper The birth narratives of the gospels of Matthew, Luke and John are versions of the stories of the Messiah’s birth. They are not exactly the same. John’s gospel doesn’t even give word of the virgin birth. In Biblical Theology class, we remembered each birth narrative as “the one with the shepherds,” or “the one with the wise men.” Matthew’s gospel starts with the Messiah’s genealogy.
The Pigman Essay Research Paper In the
The Pigman Essay, Research Paper In the novel, The Pigman, writing by Paul Zindel the main characters are Mr.Pignati, John and Lorraine. They all meet by chance and each becomes a trespasser on another’s life. However, John and Lorraine each gain something from their experience with the Mr.Pignati. Mr.Pignati, John and Lorraine all have their own individual reasons and desires for wanting to be with each character.
Jesus In John Essay Research Paper Jesus
Jesus In John Essay, Research Paper Jesus in John When reading the gospels of the New Testament, it becomes evident that the personality of each of the authors affected their understanding, interpretation, and impression of Jesus and his works. In John, the gospel that I chose to read for this paper, Jesus is portrayed in a more godlike, omnipotent manner.
Pig Man Essay Research Paper Three individuals
Pig Man Essay, Research Paper Three individuals with varying personalities and backgrounds come together in a strange and magical way to help each other strengthen in their weak points. Lorraine who is self-conscious has John to make her happy and forget about her worries. John does not have many weak points except that he smokes and drinks.
The Crucible Insight Of Hale Elizabeth And
John Essay, Research Paper The Crucible, a container that resists hear or the hollow at the bottom of an ore furnace. However its connotations include melting pot, in the symbolic sense, and the bearing of a cross. Elizabeth, John Proctor?s wife; a cold, childless woman who is an upright character who cannot forgive her husband?s adultery until just before he died: she is accused of being a witch.
Blind Ambition Essay Research Paper Blind AmbitionJohn
Blind Ambition Essay, Research Paper Blind Ambition John Dean was counsel to the President. He wanted power and superiority. To advance up the ladder, John Dean got involved in certain activities. Some of which were not legal. One example would be the extortion of money. John Dean didn?t really think of the consequences but of the rewards.
John Gotti Essay Research Paper email PPMafUnBosaolcomtitle
John Gotti Essay, Research Paper email: PPMafUnBos@aoltitle: “The King of New York:” The Life and Times of the “Dapper Don,” John GottiJohn Gotti was born John Joseph Gotti, Jr. on October27, 1940 to Fannie nd John Joseph Gotti Sr. He is ofNeapolitan background, not Sicilian like most people think.His grandparents immigrated from a small village in thevicinity of Naples which was inhabited by Teutonic maraudersin the sixth century, the Goths.
Owen Meany Essay Research Paper Owen Meany
Owen Meany Essay, Research Paper Owen Meany lived his life to the fullest and lived to make the people that he loved happy. John gets accepted to attend University of New Hampshire and Owen follows John. Owen follows him for the reason that he feels John cannot cope with University and he feels he needs to be there to assist him.
The Crucible Essay Research Paper Abigail Williams
The Crucible Essay, Research Paper Abigail Williams portrays Miller’s affair with the inner voice and guilt. Arthur Miller saw guilt as a habit of mind capable of being over come. It is seen in Abigail who exhausts her conscience to get herself out of trouble by accusing Tituba, and then to seek revenge on the adults who make her life miserable.
Jfk Jr Essay Research Paper John F
Jfk Jr Essay, Research Paper John F. Kennedy Jr. John Fitzgerald Kennedy Jr. was born on November 25, 1960, two and a half weeks after his father was elected president of the United States and less than two months before his father was inaugurated. Three years later, that father, murdered by an assassin’s bullet, was buried on John’s third birthday.
Crucible By Miller Essay Research Paper John
Crucible By Miller Essay, Research Paper John Proctor was the main character in the play The Crucible, written by Arthur Miller. Will the truth set you free? In Proctor?s case of choosing truth over
John Brown Essay Research Paper John Brown
John Brown Essay, Research Paper John Brown’s raid on the federal armory at Harpers Ferry, Virginia, In October 1859, involved only a handful of abolitionists, freed no slaves, and was over in two days. Although many
John Locke Summary Essay Research Paper John
John Locke: Summary Essay, Research Paper John Locke: The Empiricist Theory of Knowledge: Summary Understanding and knowledge is what makes man superior to all other beings according to John Locke. However, the bounds of this understanding and knowledge are questionable. Is some knowledge innate? How certain can we be about beliefs and the knowledge we have? John Locke attempts to give some insight as to the answers of these questions in his work, The Empiricist Theory of Knowledge.
The Crucible Essay Research Paper God in
The Crucible Essay, Research Paper ?God in Heaven, what is John Proctor, what is John Proctor? (Act IV, pg 138) The Crucible is a story of love, pity, revenge, and forgiveness. It details the lives
Event That Changed My Life Essay Research
Paper An Event That Changed My Life When I was very young an incident occurred that changed my relationship with my older brother John forever. John and I were in the tree fort behind our house playing with a piece of piping. John was on the upper level of our fort holding the large pipe when suddenly he dropped it on my head.
John Vincent Atanasoff Essay Research Paper John
John Vincent Atanasoff Essay, Research Paper John Vincent Atanasoff inventor of the electronic computer In any scienctific field, there needs to be a person with the vision to define the future. John Vincent Atanasoff was a genius with such a vision. He developed the first electronic digital computer that has dramatically changed our lives.
John Bardeen Essay Research Paper Bardeen John
John Bardeen Essay, Research Paper Bardeen, John 1908-91, American physicist; b. Madison, Wis. He was known for his studies of semiconductivity and other aspects of SOLID-STATE PHYSICS. The first
Brave New World Summary Essay Research Paper
SUMMARY::: We start with Bernard, who was created in the Bokanovsky Process, but was unusually smart. Smart in the way that he had his own, natural way of thinking, unlike all other humans in the Brave New World. Bernard was indeed intelligent, but because of an error during one of the processes of creation, he grew small and weak.
The Outcasts Of Poker Flat 2
The Outcasts Of Poker Flat – John Oakhurst Analysis Essay, Research Paper John Oakhurst is the main character in ?The Outcasts of Poker Flat?. John is an outstanding person and has some phenomenal traits. Such as that he is unusually calm, courageous, and modest.John has shown numerous times in ?The Outcasts of Poker Flat?, that he is an extraordinarily calm person.
Crucible Essay Research Paper Tragic Hero EssayThe
Crucible Essay, Research Paper Tragic Hero Essay The historic happenings of the Salem Witch Trials are told in the story of the Crucible. In the Crucible, the main character is John Proctor. John Proctor is a tragic hero who is a great man but has one single flaw, pride, which will lead to his destruction.
Basics On Keats Essay Research Paper John
Basics On Keats Essay, Research Paper -John Keats was born in 1795 and died in 1821 -John Keats was born in Moorfield, England -John Keats had two brothers, George and Tom, and a sister Fanny
A Famous Person John Lennon Essay
, Research Paper A famous Person : John Lennon I like music. Whenever I listen to my favorite music, I feel good. My favorite musician is John Lennon. I have reasons why I like him and why I choose John Lennon as famous person.
Green Mile Essay Research Paper The Green
Green Mile Essay, Research Paper The Green Mile was about a murder of two girls. When the father is told by the mother that the 2 little girls are missing, he gets a whole crowwd together to look for the little girls. They
Character Sketch Of Mr Pignatti Essay Research
Paper Character Sketch of Mr. Pignatti Mr. Pignatti is just a big kid at heart. He was very lonely until John and Lorriane came along. He is a closed man and tries to hide his feelings
John Kennedy Essay Research Paper JOHN F
John Kennedy Essay, Research Paper JOHN F. KENNEDY John Fitzgerald was born in Brookline, Massachusetts on May 29, 1917. He graduated from Harvard University in 1940. Which
John The Baptist Essay Research Paper John
John The Baptist Essay, Research Paper John The Baptist By John the Griffin The story of John the Baptist begins with his father Zachary, a priest of the Temple in Jerusalem. He was in the church praying when Gabriel, an angel appeared to him. The angel said to him, ?Do not be frightened Zechariah; your prayers have been heard.
John Hale Vs John Proctor Essay Research
Paper Rev. John Hale vs. John Proctor The characters of John Hale and John Proctor in ?The Crucible? can be compared and contrasted according to their key traits, goals, and
The Crucible 2 Essay Research Paper In
The Crucible 2 Essay, Research Paper In the book, The Crucible, Abigail Williams and her childish friends take advantage of the situation in their hometown of Salem, Massachusetts. At the time, there was a lot of tension about the discussion of witches and virtually anyone who was accused of being a witch was proven a witch.