In both The Epic of Gilgamesh and The Bhagavad-Gita, the gods play a cent0ral role. The Mesopotamians of Gilgamesh see their gods as very human-like creatures, often with faults and whims like their own. On the other hand, the Hindus see more all-powerful, heavenly beings free from faults. This discrepancy in the perception of gods effects the power of their gods and also the longevity of the religion.
The gods in The Epic of Gilgamesh behave like human beings, and therefore, limit their power. Ishtar, the goddess of love, sees Gilgamesh and falls in love with his beauty and longs for his body (35). This passion and longing for sex is a very human and earthly characteristic. Gods of the modern world would never participate in these carnal pleasures. Later, Ishtar shows even more emotion. ?The king of Uruk has insulted me (37).? She takes this feeling of dejection a step further by enacting revenge on Gilgamesh. One would think a goddess would be strong enough to do this of her own accord, but Ishtar cannot. In Mesopotamian mythology, no one god is all-powerful, Ishtar must ask Anu, her father, for permission. ?The goddess said to the god her father thus: ?Give me the Bull of Heaven that I may punish Gilgamesh the king (37).? Anu replies by saying, ??If I should give the Bull of Heaven to you, then there would follow seven years of husks. Have you prepared for this?? (37)? Ishtar says she has, and the Bull is given to her. This conversation is much like the dialog a mortal father and daughter would have. The daughter asks for permission. The father makes sure she has thought the action through and then consents. This is not god-like behavior. The fact that Ishtar has to seek permission before acting undermines her power.
More examples of the gods behaving as humans can be found. After Gilgamesh and Enkidu kill the Bull of Heaven and Huwawa, the gods meet in council and bicker about whether to kill both Enkidu and Gilgamesh or just one of them (39-40). Also, after Utnapishtim survives the flood, the gods meet in council and bicker over why Utnapishtim is still alive and what fair punishments should be (62). In both of these instances, the gods all meet together in council and discuss what is going on. This shows the sophisticated human process of discussion and possibly government. Probably, the Mesopotamians themselves would meet together to talk about the problems of the state. They personify their gods to reflect their society and way of governing. Even while reflecting their society through the gods, they are showing the gods? weaknesses as well. When the gods meet, it is not in a diplomatic format. They disagree and argue about petty matters. They are not good examples about how affairs of state should be conducted.
The gods and goddesses play favorites and come down to help the people. Shamash, god of the sun, goes with Gilgamesh and Enkidu when they venture into the forest to slay Huwawa. He even helps them defeat this nature god. ?Then Shamash heard the prayer of Gilgamesh and raised up thirteen storms against Huwawa (34).? This shows a god against a god for the sake of a human. Logically, one would think the gods would work together, but, obviously, the gods can be swayed by their human prejudices. This is further illustrated in the flood story. The gods come together in council once again and decide to flood the world and leave no survivors. Ea, the wise god of waters, goes against the decision made by the council. ?The voice of Ea telling me the secret came whispering through the reed walls of my house: ??Utnapishtim, son of Ubartutu, abandon your house, abandon what you possess, abandon your house and build a boat instead. Seek life instead of riches, save yourself (57).? Here, Ea comes down to help a human and, as a possible result, upsets the gods. It seems strange that he would place a mere mortal?s well being over the wishes of another god.
Although the gods have power and generally command respect, this is not always the case. When Ishtar wants Gilgamesh?s body, he refuses her by saying, ?You are the door through which the cold gets in. You are the fire that goes out. You are the pitch the sticks to the hands of the one who carries the bucket. You are the house that falls down. You are the shoe the pinches the foot of the wearer (36).? Gilgamesh is showing disrespect for the gods here. He obviously does not hold the goddess Ishtar in very high regard to speak about her in this way. Most cultures hold their gods in high reverence, but since the Mesopotamian gods are so human-like, they do not command consistent respect. It is hard to revere gods who argue with each other and show human faults. Gilgamesh?s attitude also shows bravery. He may not respect Ishtar, but she has more powers than he does, and, therefore, could hurt him. Ishtar did, in fact, try to kill Gilgamesh by sending the Bull of Heaven down on him, but this did not work. ??and Enkidu seized the Bull by reeking tail and Gilgamesh thrust his sword with the skill of a butcher between the shoulders and horns, and they killed the Bull (38).? Gilgamesh won. Man beat god. This shows that a mortal man can prevail against the gods in their own games. Can the gods really be that powerful if Gilgamesh and Enkidu can beat a divine creature? This once again illustrates that such human-like gods cannot be all-powerful. Also, if humans can beat the gods, they do not show them as much reverence and respect.
In The Bhagavad-Gita, the gods are viewed as divinely supreme. These gods do things in ways above human capacity. ?When they know that a day of Brahma stretches over a thousand eons, and his night ends in a thousand eons, men understand day and night (79).? This concept shows that Brahma is supernatural and above the human limitations of night and day. Brahma is obviously not a personified god as described in The Epic of Gilgamesh; he is much more powerful?he has always been here and he always will be. ?Never have I not existed (31).? Gods do not just come and go as the civilization changes. These are strong, enduring gods and ideas. This is not necessarily true with the Mesopotamians. As new cultures move in or conquer the area, new gods and goddesses are added to the pantheon and some older gods fall by the wayside. Hence, the religion is not around today. Hinduism, on the other hand, is one of the oldest religions, due, in part, to the steadfastness and longevity of the gods.
The gods are intricately connected to the humans. Krishna says to Arjuna, ?(The infinite spirit?s) inner being is perishable existence; its inner divinity is man?s spirit; I am the inner sacrifice here in your body, O Best of Mortals. A man who dies remembering me at the time of death enters my being when he is freed from his body; of this there is no doubt (77).? After the cycle of death and rebirth, man becomes one with the gods and the infinite spirit. Therefore, every man has a bit of the infinite spirit in him, and therefore, also a part of god. This gives humans a special sense of closeness and trust with the gods.
The gods are all-powerful and above humans, but they also help humans out. The entire Bhagavad-Gita is a story of how the god Krishna helps out Arjuna in his time of need and confusion. Krishna comes down in the form of a human to guide Arjuna on the right path. Krishna even says, ?Arjuna, learn from me (145).? The gods help humans, but they want some compensation in return. ?Enriched by sacrifice, the gods will give you the delights you desire; he is a thief who enjoys their gifts without giving to them in return (42).? This shows that the Hindu people do not expect to get something for nothing. They are willing to do their part to be loved and protected by the gods.
Another important theme of the gods is the cycle of rebirth. Krishna tells Arjuna not to fear death because the body is not enduring, but the soul is. There is a continuous cycle of death and rebirth. Therefore, do not grieve over this life and this body. Follow the duty prescribed for this life. Think of the bigger whole (32-33). This concept of accepting life roles and not fearing death is important to the Hindu faith. ?Look to your own duty; do not tremble before it (34).? People are born into a caste based on performance in a former life. Rebirth is inevitable. People are taught to follow their dharma and not worry about where they are in this life. Even people in the lowest class are expected to accept their lot in life without complaint and focus on how to be born again higher. ?Even more dear to me are devotees who cherish this elixir of sacred duty as I have taught it, intent on me in their faith (113).? Even the lowest people can rise in favor with Krishna if they only are steadfast in their devotion and their lives. This fosters a desire to follow the teachings of the gods. In this way, one can hope to end the cycle of rebirth and join the infinite spirit. This concept of joining the gods in spirit after death is vastly different than the view held by the Mesopotamians. They do not believe in a life after death. When they die, it is over. They have no hope of becoming one with the gods or living in peace.
Although the role of the gods is central to The Epic of Gilgamesh and The Bhagavad-Gita, they play these roles in vastly different ways. The Epic of Gilgamesh shows gods who have human-like characteristics, play favorites among the humans while helping them, and are not always highly respected. The Bhagavad-Gita?s gods are divine, all-powerful beings who hold strong connections with humans and involve humans in the complex cycle of death and rebirth before joining the infinite spirit. The contrast in these gods and the resulting religions is interesting to compare.
Другие работы по теме:
Gilgamesh Vs Ecclesiastes Essay Research Paper Ecclesiastes
Gilgamesh Vs Ecclesiastes Essay, Research Paper Ecclesiastes vs. Gilgamesh In both of these stories, there is a spiritual crisis that awaits being noticed. I think that in both of these stories, there is an underlying theme that death has the final say in our lives, and that there is not really much that we can do about it.
Dharma Essay Research Paper Dharma is the
Dharma Essay, Research Paper Dharma is the moral law that Hindus follow throughout life. Through the teachings of Gita, one can find the right way of living and the correct attitude
Epic Of Gilgamesh 2 Essay Research Paper
Heros and Their Human Traits “Who is the noblest hero? The man who conquers his senses” a quote from Bhartrihara. Heros is what is seen throughout ancient epics. Heros are, to many, seen like gods. Many heros are two parts god or have a father who is a god. Although there is god in their blood they are still human.
Epic Of Gilgamesh And The Book Of
Genesis Essay, Research Paper The Epic Of Gilgamesh is an important Middle East literary work, written in cuneiform on 12 clay tablets about 2000 BC by the oldest human author that we can name. The Epic tells the story of a great Mesopotamian king,Gilgamesh,who finds his kindered spirit and goes on a spiritual quest for understanding of death and the after life.
Classics Essay Research Paper Humans during the
Classics Essay, Research Paper Humans during the time of The Epic of Gilgamesh depended heavily on the premonitions and forecasts of the gods. The residents of the town named Uruk awaited the messages in their dreams and through various signs. Another way people foretold the future was through divination, which is not used any more.
Gilgamesh Essay Research Paper There once lived
Gilgamesh Essay, Research Paper There once lived a king, the great king of Uruk in Mesopotamia. This great leader was Gilgamesh. His preserved epic is of great significance to modern day culture. Through Gilgamesh, the fate of mankind is revealed, and the inevitable factor of change is expressed. In the Epic of Gilgamesh, it is a great love, followed by a lingering grief that cause a significant change in the character of Gilgamesh.
Gilgamesh And The Bible Essay Research Paper
Gilgamesh and the Bible In both the Epic of Gilgamesh and the Bible a common event takes place, a flood. The flood in both stories destroys all mankind. I feel that each flood serves as a symbol. Each one is a representive of rebirth and of a new beginning for all mankind. In the epic, Gilgamesh the gods decided to destroy mankind by flooding earth for six days and nights Gilgamesh and the other gods decided to destroy mankind by flooding earth for six days and nights.
Gilgamesh 3 Essay Research Paper In Gilgamesh
Gilgamesh 3 Essay, Research Paper In Gilgamesh, the tale of two companions and their epic journeys together, symbolism plays an important role in developing the story and theme. One such symbol is the so-called “How-the-Old-Man-Once-Again-Becomes-a-Young-Man” plant. As the name dictates, “new life may be obtained by means of it ” (Gilgamesh 80) Symbolically the plant is imperative to a complete understanding of the work.
Gilgamesh Essay Research Paper Sublett 1Susan Sublett031400Classics
Gilgamesh Essay, Research Paper Sublett 1 Susan Sublett 03/14/00 Classics of World Lit. Honors Dr.Haavisto Gilgamesh: A Glance at Friendship Throughout history the stories, poems, and songs have all held common themes. They help to explain the importance of certain aspects of life, and one of these is friendship.
Essay On The Epic Of Gilgamesh Essay
, Research Paper The epic of Gilgamesh is story about death and friendship, these are two main themes in the book. Gilgamesh is the one who has to come to grips with the reality that death is inevitable, and that friendship is a necessity. When Enkidu dies Gilgamesh cant deal with it, he starts to think that if his friend can die that he too is only mortal, the first thing he does is go into denial about his mortality.
Gilgamesh Essay Research Paper Gilgamesh The story
Gilgamesh Essay, Research Paper Gilgamesh The story of Gilamesh seems to relate to stories of the bible in some instances, but in others it seems like some great writers were at work when they created this story. For instance when I read the book The line “Gilgamesh, two-thirds god and one-third human, is the great-est king on earth and the strongest super-human that ever existed”, sound similar to Jesus Christ.
The Epic Of Gilgamesh And The Bible
: Comparing The Flood Stories Essay, Research Paper In both The Epic of Gilgamesh and the Bible, a flood takes place. The flood in both stories destroys most of mankind. These floods are a symbol. They represent rebirth and a new beginning for mankind, as well as the gods or God’s wrath. In the epic of Gilgamesh the gods decided to destroy mankind by flooding earth for six days and nights.
Gilgamesh Essay Research Paper Reading Response Epic
Gilgamesh Essay, Research Paper Reading Response: Epic of Gilgamesh There are questions of what tomorrow may bring. How will we handle the things life has to offer us? We don’t always know how we will react. These questions can be triggered by physical aging or a change in the lifestyle. With age come the questions of morality.
Gilgamesh Essay Research Paper Gilgamesh Essay over
Gilgamesh Essay, Research Paper Gilgamesh Essay over The Epic of Gilgamesh The main character in the book The Epic of Gilgamesh is Gilgamesh himself. Throughout the book, many things cause Gilgamesh to change. First, the quest for immortality after the death of Enkidu shows that Gilgamesh has changed. Gilgamesh has gone from arrogant to scared.
Epic Essay Essay Research Paper What an
Epic Essay Essay, Research Paper What an epic says about its culture is that that was the way they lived like in the Epic of Gilgamesh, Faerie Qveene, and Iliad (Comical Version). The three are epics from their own time and culture they are the same in some ways and different in other ways.
Comparison Of Noah And The Epic Of
Gilgamesh Essay, Research Paper In The Epic of Gilgamesh there is a being called Gilgamesh who is almost perfect. He is two-thirds god and one-third man. He is mortal, but walks equal with the gods of Mesopotamia. Gilgamesh had unintentionally won the heart of Ishtar, the goddess of love, but he rejected her love and in turn Ishtar wanted revenge.
Agamemnon Essay Research Paper Odyssey
Agamemnon Essay, Research Paper Odyssey The relationship between the gods and humanity in The Epic of Gilgamesh and The Odyssey are the same. In each saga, the gods seem to live nearby and are always present. Both epic poems portray humans as simply at the mercy of the gods. The gods feel that it is their duty to intervene if they feel that man is traveling off course from his destiny.
Epic Of Gilgamesh Essay Research Paper Gilgamesh
Epic Of Gilgamesh Essay, Research Paper Gilgamesh is an epic that has been passed down for thousands of years. The epic narrates the legendary deeds of the main character Gilgamesh. Gilgamesh is two-thirds immortal and one-third mortal; however, he cannot accept his fate that one day he too will die. The entire epic tells the story of Gilgamesh’s life and searche for immortality.
Gilga 2 Essay Research Paper The epic
Gilga 2 Essay, Research Paper The epic of Gilgamesh was found in the mid nineteenth century, written on over twenty five thousand clay tablets. After much studying and deciphering, this ancient Sumerian epic has finally been translated, though many of the tablets have not been found. it appears that all the most important elements of the story probably existed as separate poems when they were first written.
Gilgamesh
’s Downfall Essay, Research Paper In “The Epic of Gilgamesh” the main character, Gilgamesh, is searching for immortality. This want is brought about by deep feelings held by Gilgamesh for his dead friend Enkidu. From this, Gilgamesh finds himself being scared of dying. This fear pushes Gilgamesh to search for the power of immortal life, which is believed to be held only by women because of the fact that they can reproduce.
Comparison Between Gita Govinda And The Song
Of Solomon Essay, Research Paper Analysis and Comparison of Gita Govinda and Song of Solomon Gita Govinda is a religious love poem in the Indian religion. The poem consists of
The Epic Of Gilgamesh Vs Noah And
The Flood Essay, Research Paper In both ?The Epic of Gilgamesh? and ?Noah and the flood?, a flood takes place. The flood in both stories destroys most of mankind. These floods are a symbol. They represent rebirth and a new beginning for mankind, as well as the gods or God’s wrath.
Gilgamesh Essay Research Paper The story of
Gilgamesh Essay, Research Paper The story of the flood in bothe the Epic of Gilgamesh and in Gensis follows a common outline of narratives, however, each of these similarities are addressed and cxarried out in
The Story Of The Flood How Utnapishtim
Tells His Story To Gilgamesh Essay, Research Paper In the Epic of Gilgamesh, Gilgamesh’s best friend Enkidu is killed and therefore causes him to be afraid of death. Gilgamesh now that he is afraid of death wants to achieve immortal life so he will not have to face death (34). Gilgamesh travels far and longs to find the man who was granted everlasting life, and ask him how he did indeed receive everlasting life.
Enkidu Friendship Essay Research Paper Friendship with
Enkidu Friendship Essay, Research Paper ?Friendship with Enkidu? In the beginning Enkidu was created out of nature (clay). The Gods created him so that Gilgamesh would not be so powerful. The Goddess created Enkidu to be exactly like Gilgamesh. This made it easy for them to become friends. Enkidu used to live with the animals and he also ate grass, but because of the woman Enkidu becomes civilized.
Gilgamesh Essay Research Paper Gilgamesh was not
Gilgamesh Essay, Research Paper Gilgamesh was not a brave leader. Enkidu helped Gilgamesh through his journey and without him, Gilgamesh would not have survived. I would not like to be the partner of Gilgamesh because he was a coward and he is more human and vulnerable than a god and powerful.
Gilgamesh And Enkidu Essay Research Paper Throughout
Gilgamesh And Enkidu Essay, Research Paper Throughout the Epic of Gilgamesh, Gilgamesh is described as being a hero, “who knew the most of all men” (Gilgamesh, pg. 3). He is described as “two-thirds a god” (Gilgamesh, pg. 4) and “the strongest one of all, the perfect, the terror” (Gilgamesh, pg. 4). Due to Gilgamesh’s great recognition, he lacks a peer, someone who is able to challenge him.
Epic Of Gilgamesh Enkidu Vs.
. Gilgamesh Essay, Research Paper Gilgamesh and Enkidu are both similar and different in many ways. Some of their traits affect each other throughout the course of the plot, whether it be their actions or their character. Gilgamesh, a king who is two-thirds god and one-third human, begins in the story as a very arrogant and tyrannic man.
The BhagavadGita Subdued Essay Research Paper The
The Bhagavad-Gita Subdued Essay, Research Paper The Bhagavad-Gita most likely begins with philosophy instead of ending with it because it gives people the major message of the whole text. If you keep reading and find out the details of how you are supposed to be a good Hindu is up to you. If it were at the end, it would probably not be a holy book, but just a story with a couple morals attached to the ending.
Bhagavad Gita Essay Research Paper Nonexistence can
Bhagavad Gita Essay, Research Paper Non-existence can be considered a state of not being. In this sense, the faithful followers of the Bhagavad Gita find ways to reach this state within its chapters. Through advice of the ‘lord’ Krishna, followers use yoga and meditation to obtain a pure karma and self-realization for a better life after reincarnation.
Gilgamesh Essay Research Paper The search for
Gilgamesh Essay, Research Paper The search for Everlasting Life Gilgamesh wept over the death of his friend Enkidu. He thought that he was also going to die like his brother. So he went to see Utnapishtim who has everlasting life. So he went
Epic Of Gilgamesh Essay Research Paper We
Epic Of Gilgamesh Essay, Research Paper We learn about ancient civilizations through literature, artifacts, and stories passed down from generation to generation. The Mesopotamian civilization is one of earth’s earliest civilizations, and it’s also one we know very little about. We can gather information about these people’s way life, beliefs, and geographical location.
Immortality Essay Research Paper Immortality
Immortality Essay, Research Paper Immortality – (a) the quality or state of being immortal. (b) never ending existence. Although that is the Webster definition of immortality, what is never-ending existence?