Paper
The Two Sides of Hamlet In Franco Zeffirelli’s 1990 and Kenneth Branagh’s 1996 film versions of Shakespeare’s Hamlet, Mel Gibson and Kenneth Branagh, respectively, portray the title character very differently. Gibson emphasizes the Oedipeidal complexity of Hamlet’s character, thereby injecting a childlike manner into his acting. Branagh ignores that aspect, opting to stress the revenge element. This approach makes Hamlet more of a very angry man rather than a petulant boy. These two contrasting portrayals demonstrate the two main positions concerning the source of Hamlet’s madness held by Shakespeare experts. In Gibson’s first speaking scene, he sits in the dark sulking about the recent turn of events. His lost expression turns into bewilderment and confusion when his mother and uncle come in. He cannot comprehend why thing have changed in the manner they had. The whims of his parents affect him as deeply as it would a child despite being a full grown man. He stubbornly refuses to stop his behavior in spite of his mother and uncle’s entreaties. These actions reflect those of a child who has been denied something he or she wants. Children, especially those who are cosseted their entire lives, often engage in such behavior so as to promote guilt in the parent and to hopefully get what it was they originally wanted.In the same scene, Branagh looks at his mother and uncle in disdain and allows his disapproval to color his words. These actions speak of an extremely angry man. Branagh’s Hamlet knows that his uncle’s ascent to the throne and hasty marriage to his mother constitutes as a violation of some trust. He does not sit idly by, waiting for fate to make things happen. Branagh’s military clothing also lends him a more commanding, masculine bearing which carries throughout the movie.In a later scene, Gibson’s Hamlet hopes to exploit the play, “Murder of Gonzago,” in order to get a confession of murder from his uncle. However throughout the scene, Gibson acts very energetic, bouncing from place to place, unable to stay focused for very long like a young child. He also bites his nails, a nervous habit often seen as immature. Gibson’s childish behavior indicate his unpreparedness for the full implications of his conduct.Branagh, on the other hand, demonstrates that the set up between the play and his uncle is exactly that: a set up. Branagh carefully orchestrates every facet. He enlists Horatio’s aid, asking him to carefully watch the king’s face for any betraying expression. He also takes the time to coach the players on how to play their roles so as to achieve the desired reaction from his uncle. During the play, he purposefully peppers the players lines with his own additions so as to ensure that his uncle make the correct connection between the Player King’s murder and that of his father’s. At all times, Branagh maintains control of his well-constructed plan, unlike Gibson who sets the ball rolling yet does nothing to tilt it in his favor.
During the famous closet scene, Gibson works himself into vicious display of emotion as he torments himself and his mother with thoughts of the events surrounding her recent marriage and all that it implies. In his anger and confusion, he throws himself and his mother upon her bed and starts making rape-like motions in her while yelling at her for her fickleness. These raping motions suggest that his attachment to her is so strong that he resents the intrusion that his uncle presents. He cannot relinquish his obsession of her despite her likely innocence in his father’s marriage.Branagh plays this scene slightly cooler in that he does not attack his mother in the same manner as did Gibson. Instead, he controls his anger and uses it to his advantage against his mother in order to convince her of all that had transpired and her part in it all. While he forces her to acknowledge the truth, he does not allow his anger to become more than it is and cloud his judgment. His only goal is to expose his father’s murder and exact his revenge.In the final scene where Hamlet fences with Laertes, Gibson plays it lightheartedly. He laughs and jokes with the surrounding spectators, eliciting laughs by acting the fool. Hamlet fails to realize the severity of the situation. Completely unaware of the undercurrents of the court, Laertes surprises him when he fatally wounds him with a poisoned sword tip. His unawareness signals his downfall in the end.Branagh, however, shows that Hamlet realizes that danger and accepts it in the preceding conversation he has with Horatio. He knows he has enemies, but Hamlet is determined to fulfill his promise to his father. His decision indicate him to be very focused and adult. Mel Gibson’s Hamlet further explores the argument that Hamlet’s obsessive love for his mother drove him to madness. Yet, in his efforts to do so, Gibson loses sight of the fact that Hamlet is a fully grown man. His childlike behavior throughout the movie serves only to portray Hamlet as a weak character deeply affected by the actions of others. Only at the end when Hamlet kills his uncle does he do something for himself instead of leaving it in the hands of fate. Kenneth Branagh’s portrayal of Hamlet demonstrates the character’s strength and maturity. Hamlet understandable anger of the recent events manifests into a calculated madness so as to sniff out his father’s murderer. His deliberateness contrasts sharply with Gibson’s laissez-faire attitude. These two actors portray two very different, unique sides of Hamlet. One childish, one mature, but both still enjoyable to watch.
Другие работы по теме:
Horatio From Hamlet Essay Research Paper Horatios
Horatio From Hamlet Essay, Research Paper Horatio?s role in the play Hamlet, which was written by William Shakespeare, is extremely important. In the first place, Horatio was the person who told Hamlet about the ghost. He also had the job of watching Claudius while the play was going on in order to see if he showed his guilt.
Main Thought Of Hamlet Essay Research Paper
What I believe to be the main and most important theme of Hamlet is that power corrupts and kills. This is evident in many parts of this play. In the first half of this tale, Shakespeare shows us that the power King Hamlet gave to his brother (free run of the castle, ability to get where the king slept) let to the king’s death.
Bla Essay Research Paper IIIi5690Hamlet condemns himself
Bla Essay, Research Paper III.i.56-90 Hamlet condemns himself to life in this soliloquy. He realizes that by escaping his earthly body through death he will still remain in the prison of painful thoughts. Hamlet, the thinker, cannot escape his conscious self and in that realization decides, “to be.” The foundation of his choice is solipsistic in nature.
Hamlet Analysis Essay Research Paper Pleading with
Hamlet Analysis Essay, Research Paper Pleading with Hamlet not to follow the Ghost, Horatio asks him to think about what might happen if the Ghost “assume some other horrible form, / Which might deprive your sovereignty of reason / And draw you into madness. Horatio believes that the Ghost is not Hamlet’s father in the form of a ghost, but a spirit in the form of Hamlet’s father.
Hamlet Character Essay Research Paper In the
Hamlet Character Essay, Research Paper In the pay "Hamlet", the main character is a man who wants revenge. He wants it so bad that he becomes obsessed with the idea until it ultimately kills
Hamlet Essay Research Paper Act IV Scene
Hamlet Essay, Research Paper Act IV, Scene vii: Claudius convinces Laertes that he is innocent in Laertes’ father’s death and that Hamlet is to blame. A messenger enters with Hamlet’s letter and Claudius is amazed to find that
Hamlets Sanity Essay Research Paper Hamlet s
Hamlets Sanity Essay, Research Paper Hamlet s Sanity In the second act of Hamlet , it is evedent that Hamlet is not the norm . It comes down to the question of either Hamlet is faking his insanity or he has truly lost his mind. Polonius made the ussumption that Hamlet has gone mad with love, a theory inwich holds it s own from a outside point of view.Through further investigation in which Claudius and Polonius spy on Hamlet by using Ophelia as bate .
Hamlet Essay Research Paper ally funny man
Hamlet Essay, Research Paper ally funny man. Hamlet: why are you throwing up another skull. It could be a skull of a lawyer. So who grave is this man. Clown: It?s all mine.
Love In Hamlet Essay Research Paper Hamlet
Love In Hamlet Essay, Research Paper Hamlet is, without any doubt, one of William Shakespeare’s most puzzling plays. Often times, the reader becomes engulfed in the mystery, trickery and deceit in this tragedy. People become perplexed while reading Hamlet when they ask themselves the question, “Does Hamlet truly love Ophelia?”.
Hamlet And His Revenge Essay Research Paper
Hamlet was bound by honor and a code or righteousness. He could not merely kill Claudius as Claudius had killed his father, Hamlet was obligated by personal, honorable, Biblical, and righteous standards to hesitate until the right time. When Polonius said to Hamlet, “Readiness is all”, it sparked the fact the Hamlet must wait until the perfect time to take his revenge.
Hamlet Essay Research Paper The true nature
Hamlet Essay, Research Paper The true nature of Hamlet”s madness has been an issue of debate for scholars over the centuries. One theory is that Hamlet”s madness was for his own protection. In the time period in which Hamlet would have lived, governments functioned through the usage of intricate spying networks.
Hamlet And His Maddness Essay Research Paper
Hamlet and his Madness Since the play Hamlet was first written and performed, critics have analyzed the question “Was Hamlet really mad?” I personally do not believe that he was, but all of the characters in this play have a different opinion.
Hamlet Essay Research Paper Justifying Hamlets Insanity
Hamlet Essay, Research Paper Justifying Hamlet?s Insanity Hamlet?s insanity is caused by the internal conflict within himself. His obligation as a son is to avenge his father?s death but at the same time also ensure stability in the kingdom. To fulfill his duty Hamlet must kill a king in order to avenge his father?s death.
Hamlet Kings Essay Research Paper There are
Hamlet Kings Essay, Research Paper There are many differences between the Kings Hamlet and Claudius with very few similarities. Perhaps the similarities stop at being the product of the same
Hamlet Criticism Essay Research Paper In
Hamlet Criticism Essay, Research Paper In Hamlet ; Literary Remains, Samuel Taylor Coleridge describes Hamlet as an intricate planner who s thought process is slow and methodical. He describes Hamlet as someone having Supercilious activities of the mind, which, unseated from its healthy relation, is constantly occupied with the world within, and abstracted from the world without throwing a mist over all common-place actualities.
Hamlet Foreshadowing Essay Research Paper An example
Hamlet Foreshadowing Essay, Research Paper An example of foreshadowing is when Hamlet’s father came to him as a ghost to inform him of his murder, this caused a rage within Hamlet that foreshadows his revenge. This revenge led to the death of his uncle, mother, and himself. It also created Hamlet’s wild behavior, and caused him possibly to become insane..
Hamlet And Ophelia Essay Research Paper An
Hamlet And Ophelia Essay, Research Paper An example of foreshadowing is when Hamlet?s father came to him as a ghost to inform him of his murder, this caused a rage within Hamlet that foreshadows his
Hamlet Essay Research Paper Hamlet In Lesson
Hamlet Essay, Research Paper Hamlet In Lesson 19 of the videotape ?Literary Visions?, the actor performs two interpretations of the monologue, ?To be or not to be?. As said in the video, there are many ways that an actor can choose to interpret that particular speech in Hamlet. Many actors relish the opportunity to perform Hamlet, because of that particular speech.
Hamlet Vs Laertes Essay Research Paper Hamlet
Hamlet Vs Laertes Essay, Research Paper Hamlet vs Laertes Both Laertes and Hamlet both have similar and unique personality traits. These two characters are essential parts to the structure and theme of this play. Laertes tends to be possibly, in my opinion, an earlier version of Hamlet. Laertes has a positive outlook on life and seems to make the best of his life.
Compare And Contrast Macbeth
’s And Hamlet’s Madness Essay, Research Paper Madness can be described as an internal flaw that both characters, Hamlet and Macbeth, possess. Although their madness is different in some aspects, it can be said that
Hamlet Essay Research Paper Hamlet Hamlet is
Hamlet Essay, Research Paper Hamlet Hamlet is the inner person of all mankind” as stated by actor Alan Bates. What did Mr. Bates mean by this? Could he be referring to the love, the corruption, the revenge, or the insanity displayed by Hamlet; or was he
Hamlet 3 Essay Research Paper HamletThe work
Hamlet 3 Essay, Research Paper Hamlet The work that I wish to discuss is Tom Stoppard’s play “Rosencrantz and Guildenstern are Dead” as a scholarly work in regards to William Shakespeare’s Hamlet, which is included in Sven Birket’s Literature: The Evolving Canon.
Crazy Hamlet Essay Research Paper Crazy Hamlet
Crazy Hamlet Essay, Research Paper Crazy Hamlet Shakespeare The real question is Hamlet crazy or is he just acting it. In my opinion there are many things throughout the play that make me tend to believe that he is crazy. When Hamlet enters Opheliu”s room and she has the question if he is truly mad or if he is just acting.
Hamlet Essay Research Paper There are many
Hamlet Essay, Research Paper There are many reasons why one would think that Queen Gertrude is clueless about the murder of King Hamlet, yet others think she was involved in the murder. People have their own opinions on this but I believe that Queen Gertrude had an idea about the murder. There are many reasons and facts contributing to my opinion on this.
Hamlet Movie Essay Research Paper The movie
Hamlet Movie Essay, Research Paper The movie of Hamlet was an excellent, as far as book-movies go. I believe it was produced with focus, reason, and logic. The characters were also portrayed with
Hamlet Essay Essay Research Paper Hamlet by
Hamlet Essay Essay, Research Paper Hamlet by Shakespeare Hamlet’s Sanity Hamlet appears to be insane, after Polonius’s death, in act IV scene II. There are indications, though, that
Hamlet Act I Essay Research Paper In
Hamlet Act I Essay, Research Paper In Act I of Hamlet, the ghost of the king hamlet comes to the battlement, outside a castle in Denmark. Marcellus and Horatio ask the ghost to speak, but
Hamlet Essay Research Paper In modern times
Hamlet Essay, Research Paper In modern times many crimes are exacted out of revenge. In the Elizabethan times, things were no different. Often times our feelings of unfairness and anger cloud our reasoning. The play Hamlet is an excellent illustration of this. In the play Hamlet revenge is the driving force behind the conflicts.
Claudius In Hamlet Essay Research Paper ClaudiusA
Claudius In Hamlet Essay, Research Paper Claudius A Man Masked in Betrayal and Murder What could be worse than killing your brother? Marrying his wife right after! Claudius is the shadiest character in Act I of Hamlet. Claudius had poured the juice of a hebenon (henbane; a very poisonous plant) into his brother?s, Hamlet Sr.?s ear.
Structure Of Hamlet Essay Research Paper Structure
Structure Of Hamlet Essay, Research Paper Structure of hamletThe structure of Shakespeare s “Hamlet”, lays on the little information received by Hamlet from the mysterious ghost. Among all the characters, Marcellus seems to have the deepest understanding of the personality of this ghost. He is the one who fears a relation with this ghost.
Hamlet The Movie Vs Hamlet Th Essay
, Research Paper Hamlet the Movie Hamlet the Play After reading Shakespeare s play Hamlet and viewing the video, Hamlet , many differences and similarities can be found. The video had many good qualities to it. Unfortunately it had many negative aspects also. The same applies for the book. Something s about it were great while other things could have been better.
Hamlet 12 Essay Research Paper Hamlet
Hamlet 12 Essay, Research Paper Hamlet’s “Tragic Flaw” Hamlet’s famous soliloquy (Hamlet, act III, scene 1) shows his depth and ability in thinking, and shows Shakespeare’s ability to manipulate language. Throughout the play, Hamlet stops to think before acting on anything. The more he thinks, the less he does.