Biotechnology: Pros and Cons
Throughout this past semester many important ecological dilemmas have come to my attention. The most striking environmental issue that I have noted this semester has been agricultural Biotechnology. A reputable definition of Biotechnology would be ?the means or way of manipulating life forms (organisms) to provide desirable products for man’s use?(www.biotechknowledge). Scientists are pleased due to the arrival of biotechnology, believing that it will replace original, conventional breeding methods. After all, it seems like it is a smarter, less expensive way to grow our world?s food supply. But let?s note that this scientific practice is really not that new. The word biotechnology was introduced in 1919 by a scientist by the name of Karl Ereky in showing mans interaction with biology using modern technology. But, Biotechnology in its agricultural aspects is only one of the many fields of this study. Some other areas in this study are: recombinant DNA, rDNA or gene splicing, enzyme systems, meristem culture, mammalian cell culture, immunology, molecular biology, fermentation, and others. But, humans are beginning to see the not so perfect traits of biotechnology, and even recognizing it as a type of ?biological pollution?(Nill, 03).
? Biological pollution?, as viewed by Michael Pollan, can even be seen as a ?disease?(Pollan, 186). There are many reasons why we should stick to our conventional ways of growing food, these reasons are because biotechnology is producing effects that are unfavorable to the health of humans and of our ecosystems. Using the biotech way, we could be putting ourselves at risk of numerous health problems. With conventional breeding methods, pesticides were sprayed on the outside of the fruit, where they can be easily washed off. But, biotech foods are not that easily rid of chemicals. When the pesticide is placed inside a fruit?s DNA makeup, it literally becomes part of the fruit. You cannot wash this away. Potato grower Pollan reported that ??in the Grower Guide also brought news that my potato plants were themselves a pesticide, registered with the Environmental Protection Agency?(Pollan, 184). Would you honestly eat a piece of fruit or a vegetable that can kill all insects on contact? We are not talking about something with just a waxy film on the outside; it is actually containing a chemical that itself can kill life. Conventional breeding methods would allow washing the fruit four times to be safe, but this is not an option for Biotechnology.
Biotechnology is not only bad for our health, but it is also capable of really messing up our ecosystems. We are ready to plant fields of vegetables that can wipe out an entire species of insect in a designated area. Insect-fighting capabilities of Biotechnology are even seen to be futile in the future. The insects will have built a resistance in time and this is only money out of farmers? pockets. It cannot completely wipe out all the bugs anyway, because bugs are really responsible for the process of pollination. No pollination would mean no flowers, no flowers would lead to fruit, that would bear seeds to start off a whole new generation of plants. It also brings up another issue. Just what if some bugs managed to make it, and then started spreading around pollen from plants that are resistant to bugs. We will end up crossing the wrong bugs together, and they could soon develop a resistance to the Bt chemical. ? The theory is that when a Bt-resistant bug does show up, it can be induced to mate with a susceptible bug from the refuge, thus diluting the new gene for resistance,? (Pollan, 187). This means that if we have a bunch of ?super bugs? flying around, they will be immune to even crops that don?t use biotechnology, they will be immune to the organic ones that just use Bt sprays.
Besides all the immediate, obvious threats, let us not forget the fact that the government is and has been trying to hide the fact that Bt products are already being sold. You would figure that in the ?land of the free? we would have the freedom of choice. How do we know if this Bt stuff is safe, and if it is so safe, then why aren?t we told which are Bt products and which ones aren?t?
But one should not be biased in their convictions, so let us consider the views of Biotechnology. Many people in the world today hold this optimistic view of Biotechnology. With our world growing rapidly and the populations rising to unimaginable heights, new ideas of ways to accommodate our needs should be thought of. However, we should, at the same time, not use up all of our earth?s resources. ?With the advent of biotechnology, agriculture is entering the information age?? (Pollan, 183). So, we have started recycling programs, ways of preserving energy, and now we have pretty much tackled this endeavor called Biotechnology. It allows us to grow foods that are able to protect themselves from pesky bugs, while at the same time producing more and better-qualified food. With biotechnology, the possibilities and its benefits over rule anything that is considered negative about it. It may be the method of farming that can save our world from starvation in future.
Instead of using this costly and inefficient way of farming involving the saturation of plants, daily, with loads of pesticides and herbicides, these Bt plants are designed to be a lot smarter than that. These plants have the actual pesticide genetically inserted into their DNA makeup. This way, plants can defend themselves from beetles and other destructive bugs that have wiped out complete crops in the past. Biotechnology has been described by professionals as ?part of a ?new agricultural paradigm? that will make farming more sustainable, feed the world and improve health and nutrition?? (Pollan, 183). Most farmers know how expensive continual sprayings of chemicals become, and also how bad they can be for our environment. Pesticides eventually leach into our soils and contaminate water supplies with nitrates and other chemicals that are harmful to any living thing?s health. Insects have been ruining crops for hundreds of years, and continue to in our century as being a really big problem in crop production. Bt fruits and vegetables are able to fight off these insects, and stay healthy right down to the day that they are served on your dinner table.
I know what you must be thinking, if Bt pesticides are so detrimental to health when sprayed, then how are pesticides any better when they are inside the vegetable or fruit? The answer is that these biologically engineered foods are in fact, very safe. ?EPA designates Messenger [a type of biologically engineered chemical] as a Toxicity Category IV product, a designation reserved for materials with the lowest hazard potential,? (www.edenbio). The EPA declared them safe to eat, so Bt products are not labeled as products using a Bt pesticide in them. Anyway, this toxin made in the genetically engineered potatoes, and many other biotech plants, is the same insecticide farmers have relied on for years, only externally. Tests have been prepared and this research has shown that on humans, Bt products have no evidence of any sort of allergy or hypersensitivity.
Another reason why we should continue using biotechnology is because we have actually been consuming these products all along. Food utilizing this method of farming has been on our grocery shelves for quite some time now. The EPA doesn?t consider these products as actual pesticides, but simply as ?additives? to the original food. Additives are not harmful, so why should we worry? If the agency that is designed to find inconsistencies in food is supporting biotechnology, then it should definitely be considered safe.
As you can see, we have a lot of thinking to do when it considers our future environment. We simply cannot use up all the nutrients in our soil until it all goes sour, and we certainly cannot pollute our earth?s resources with pesticides and other chemicals that we use to grow our food. After all, the earth is the one place that provides us with food, so we really cannot harm it for the sake of growing food. We might wake up one day with an earth that is too polluted to grow food in. So I really believe that biotechnology is good for many reasons. We will no longer be polluting our soil and water, and in the end, we will have stronger and healthier plants. We will also have a much more abundant supply of food that we can share with many third world countries that cannot even yield as much food as we do now already. So, when planning the future, we should consider the benefits of biotechnology!
1. Nill, Kimball. (2000). Glossary of Biotechnology Terms. New York: Technomic Publishing, Inc.
2. Online. Biotechnology. Http//www.biotechknowledge
3. Online. Eden?s Harpin Technology. Http//www.edenbio
4. Pollan, Michael. (2000). ?Fried, Mashed or Zapped with DNA.? Perspectives on Agriculture and the Environment, 183-196.
Другие работы по теме:
Genetic Engenering Essay Research Paper Genetic EngineeringA
Genetic Engenering Essay, Research Paper Genetic Engineering A new technology is dawning on our era, a technology that could change the lives of our children and their children to come. Will this medical advancement be pursued or will it be outlawed? The medical advancement is genetic engineering, the duplicating of human cells, and people have strong feelings both for and against it.
Legalize Gambling Essay Research Paper Whether or
Legalize Gambling Essay, Research Paper Whether or not to legalize gambling is a tough decision. The pros and cons of the question are almost equal, and while some say it will boost economy others say it can destroy it. No one argues that gambling is a big, profitable business, they only question whether it is a business doing good, or the opposite.
Capital Punishment 6 Essay Research Paper CAPITAL
Capital Punishment 6 Essay, Research Paper CAPITAL PUNISHMENTCapital Punishment or Life Imprisonment? I think that capital punishment should be use more often than just life imprisonment. Life imprisonment is just not working. The death penalty does have some cons but it has its share of pros too. Lets start with the pros.
BioTechnology Essay Research Paper The shortterm future
Bio-Technology Essay, Research Paper The short-term future of biotechnology in production agriculture looks bleak. The unattractive truth is that economics, not science can play a larger role in the future of biotechnology.
Selling Of Arms Essay Research Paper The
Selling Of Arms Essay, Research Paper The Selling of Armaments to Foreign Countries: Pros and Cons The wealthy nations sell or give armaments to the poorer nations. If you are not aware of what an armament is, it is a utensil or military set/sets of equipment. Since the end of the civil war, the United States has sold over $100 billion worth of weapons abroad.
Sibling Rivalry Essay Research Paper Sibling RivalryEvery
Sibling Rivalry Essay, Research Paper Sibling Rivalry Every now and then, someone wishes for something without weighing out all of the pros and cons. We don?t usually hear someone say, ? I wish I had to fight for a hot shower, hide brushes, hunt for clothes, and struggle to use the phone.? But, we do hear them say, ? I wish I had some brothers and sisters.? Believe it or not, each of these statements means the exact same thing.
Euthanasia Essay Research Paper In today
Euthanasia Essay, Research Paper In today’s society, if you ask five people who Jack Kevorkian is then three or more would know who he is. The issue of euthanasia has been on the media’s forefront for several years. There are several pros and cons to this issue. Some of these pros are as follows: it would help to end pain and suffering, it allows a person to die with dignity, and it also helps the grieving process because the person knows when they are gonna die.
Border Patrol Essay Research Paper US Border
Border Patrol Essay, Research Paper US Border Patrol: Pros & Cons The U.S. Border Patrol is the organization that polices the entry of illegal immigrants into our country. The official mission of the United States
Technology Essay Research Paper People very often
Technology Essay, Research Paper People very often debate whether technology is good or bad. Many people believe that technology can only cause harm to their lives and society, while many others strongly defend the technologies which have made their lives much more leisurely and enriching than it could have been several hundred years ago.
Fetal Tissue Implants Essay Research Paper Fetal
Fetal Tissue Implants Essay, Research Paper Fetal Tissue Implants Fetal tissue implants are a very touchy subject for a lot of different people. Many people believe in them, while other people are totally against them. When you think about it, there are many different pros and cons to it, and it would be a very difficult choice if you were actually the person who needed the implant.
Indian Mascots Essay Research Paper In these
Indian Mascots Essay, Research Paper In these types of cases where there is a dispute over Native American mascots, there are pros and cons on both sides. On the one hand, there is much pride in a schools mascot. It symbolizes the pride in the school and promotes the spirit of the crowd. Fans and students of the school look at those mascots and feel a rush of school spirit that only the mascot can bring out.
Chivalry Essay Research Paper Chivalry
Chivalry Essay, Research Paper Chivalry??. . . . . . . . . Today?? Chivalry is usually known as a moral system or an honor code. It originated in the 12th century when kings ruled the country, as a code to make peace. Now there is no king or queen monarchy, now there’s that wonderful thing that we call the Government.
Running On Ritalin Essay Research Paper Running
Running On Ritalin Essay, Research Paper Running on Ritalin was written by a psychologist, who finds himself torn over the treatment of difficult children. Dr. Lawrence H. Diller has had the opportunity to work with an array of unique children. He also has witnessed his form of profession evolve into something he is not sure he wants to be a part of.
Genetic Engineering Essay Research Paper Genetic EngineeringGenetic
Genetic Engineering Essay, Research Paper Genetic Engineering Genetic engineering is the process of manipulating and collecting a known quantity of genes from a known source, opening the recipient DNA at the desired point in the linkage. Then combining the strand of a known sequence of DNA with the recipient DNA of living organisms.
What Is Biotechnology Essay Research Paper Biotechnology
What Is Biotechnology? Essay, Research Paper Biotechnology as defined by the Merriam-Webster dictionary is the manipulation of biological organisms to make products that benefit human beings. This in essence is biotechnology but one might still be confused by this topic.
Abstract Of Bill Joy
’s The Dark Side Of Technology Essay, Research Paper In his speech, The Dark Side of Technology, Bill Joy addresses the pros and cons of three new technologies: genetic engineering, nanotechnology, and robotics. Though optimistic about the benefits of these quickly developing and promising technologies, referred to as GNR for short, Joy expresses his concerns about them.
Euthanasia Essay Research Paper EuthanasiaEuthanasia is just
Euthanasia Essay, Research Paper Euthanasia Euthanasia is just another word for ?mercy killing? as some people put it but it also means good death. I look at it as more of a good death if it is performed with the right procedures and if a person has a legitimate reason to be put to death but many people would not agree with me that it should be legal.
Pros
& Cons Of Cohabitation Essay, Research Paper Pros & Cons of Cohabitation Society and its attitudes are changing. Today’s divorce rate is now around 50% and marriage isn’t what it once was. With today’s rates of cohabitating couples rising rapidly, there are many reasons couples live together before marriage, but is it a good idea?
Pros And Cons Of Death Penalty Essay
, Research Paper Texas is known for many things, both socially and politically. The death penalty is a very serious issue that we as Texans need to concentrate on in the upcoming election. The Death Penalty has been around forever even back into the dark ages. It is the way that we punish people for crimes they have been convicted of or have confessed.
Tech Essay Research Paper Imagine thirty or
Tech Essay, Research Paper Imagine thirty or forty years form now. Biotechnology has really advanced. Scientist can now clone people and also change their DNA strands making them better or perfect all around. Do you think that it is safe to tinker with Mother Nature? Is it wise to try and control Mother Nature? Better yet can she ever be controlled? Whether or not she can be controlled is a big of deal.
Mendin Wall Essay Research Paper Walls Have
Mendin Wall Essay, Research Paper Walls Have Two In Robert Frost s Mending Wall, he shows a man views about a wall. The man names both pros and cons of having the wall. He also hints at how a wall might affect a particular society. The poem is a conversation between two neighbors on either side of a wall. The main speaker s conversation shows his views about the purpose of the wall, and it s effectiveness to either bring people together, or it s tendency to separate them.
Long Term Affects Of Weight Training Essay
, Research Paper Long term affects of weight trainingWeight training has become a very popular sport among people of all ages and sex. Whether a person is young or old, male or female, the in thing to do these days is stay in shape. Though, From working out, a person does indeed achieve noteworthy results, at the same time also receiving long term affects.
Animal Experimentation Essay Research Paper Abstract
Animal Experimentation Essay, Research Paper Abstract Animal experimentation has been going on for a while now and people have been protesting against it since it has begun. It seems now days there are more cons for animal experiments because of how it has become a popular topic to this day. The pros seem to think that animal experiments are necessary for living a healthy life.
JUDICIAL REVIEW Essay Research Paper uncategorized
JUDICIAL REVIEW Essay, Research Paper : uncategorized : Pros and Cons of Judicial Review Pros and Cons of Judicial Review Judicial Review is the power given to Supreme court justices in which a judge has the power to reason whether a law is unconstitutional or not. Chief Justice John Ma
Bilingual Essay Research Paper Richard Rodriguez wrote
Bilingual Essay, Research Paper Richard Rodriguez wrote in his essay, Aria: A Memoir of a Bilingual Childhood, about the struggles he faced growing up as a bilingual Hispanic in American society. Throughout his essay, Rodriguez discussed such topics as assimilation and heritage. He goes into depth about the pros and the cons of being forced to assimilate to the American culture.
The Pros And Cons Of Patents Law
Towards Computer-Related Industries Essay, Research Paper The following sites are discussing the pros and cons of the issue of software patents. The U.S. intellectual-property law is now being criticized by the new coming industry, software industry. As nowadays most of the companies are moving with the technological business trend, more and more IP problems between companies comes up.
Pros And Cons Of The Death Penalty
Essay, Research Paper The Pros & Cons of the Death Penalty by Dusty Craine Due to the rapid increase in crime the past ten years and prison overcrowding, more attention has been drawn to the opinion that something has to be done to the United States Criminal System. We need to reevaluate the way we treat people we are convicted of unspeakable acts of merciless slaughter or even rape.
Pros And Cons Of Spartan Culture Essay
, Research Paper Pros and Cons of the Spartans PROS 1st- A positive aspect of the Spartan Code was the idea to train their young beginning at a young age, by giving power to the state to control the youth. This allowed many of the children to have an equal opportunity in the situation given although they did not have many options.
Pros And Cons Of McDonalds Essay Research
Paper McDonalds: Welcome sign in the high street or a place to avoid?In this essay I will be discussing the pros and cons of fast foods. Now a day every body will recognize the golden arches of McDonalds, it is hard not to. McDonalds has restaurants everywhere, beside major roads and in almost every high street.
Drug Testing In The Workplace 2 Essay
, Research Paper Drug Testing in the Workplace When the question of drug testing in the workplace arises, many problems tend to come along with it. For employers, the solution is simple; drug tests are mandatory for employment. When it comes to employees, however the response might be more along the lines of It s none of your business or That s a violation of my rights .
Pros And Cons Essay Research Paper Humanities
Pros And Cons Essay, Research Paper Humanities 410 Extra Credit The Pros & Cons of Using the Atomic Bomb. During wartime, horrible atrocities against all of humanity must be dealt with. Crimes against humanity, as never witnessed before, and hopefully to never be seen again, occurred during the course of World War II.
Gambling 2 Essay Research Paper GamblingGambling is
Gambling 2 Essay, Research Paper Gambling Gambling is a subject that is heavily debated. Just as many people oppose it as there are for legalized gambling. There are many pros and cons of gambling. Casinos have been known to do many good things for the community that they are based in, but there are a lot of moral and social issues at hand.