Affected Our Political Sovereignty? Essay, Research Paper
?Inside Europe we are part of what will be a world power. The national sovereignty
we lose is more than made good by a share of the much larger sovereignty which
we get from participation in Europe.? (Michael Heseltine)
?The 1986 Single European Act and the Maastricht Treaty can be seen as further
reducing Britain?s sovereignty.? (Nugent)
Britain has been a full member of the EEC, and later the EU, since 1972. By
joining such an organisation it enjoys the benefits of a Common Market across
Europe, but surrenders some of its political sovereignty to the precedence of
European Law over Domestic Law. Indeed Britain?s political sovereignty has unquestionably
suffered a great deal due to its membership of Europe. In 1975 Tony Benn wrote
a letter to his constituents underlying the major worries of EEC membership.
Firstly he said that the Community subjects us to laws and taxes which British
government is powerless to amend or repeal, and they are passed by people not
elected by the British electorate. Furthermore he described how the EEC requires
British courts to enforce laws that have not necessarily been supported by the
British Parliament, and that Parliament does not have the power to change these
laws, even if they conflict with existing common or statute law. To add to this,
British membership imposes duties and constraints upon British governments.
This means that ministers have to discharge many of their duties, and those
that take them over are not accountable to British Parliament or public. Basically,
the EEC can use the British parliament as a layer of insulation separating them
from the British people. They therefore have no duty to remedy the grievances
of the British people, as they are not accountable to them.
Whilst Tony Benn presents an extreme example of Euro-scepticism, it is indisputable
that membership of Europe detracts from our parliamentary sovereignty. EU law
is binding on all member states and, therefore, takes precedence over British
domestic law. However, the British Parliament does have the power to at least
try to prevent the enforcement of EU law in the case of amendments to the Treaty
of Rome, but otherwise EU legislation automatically becomes law within the UK,
irrespective of the British Parliament?s opinion on it.
Unlike the other member states of the EU, the United Kingdom has a distinctive
constitution based not on a codified document but on the principle of parliamentary
sovereignty. The issue of national sovereignty is an intensively sensitive one
in British politics because of the country?s history, which has been very different
from that of continental states, and because of the different role which the
British Parliament plays from that of European Parliaments. Membership of the
European Union inevitably entails a loss ? or transfer ? of national sovereignty
in return for a share in a greater and more powerful European sovereignty. The
main institutions of the EU operate partly on a supranational level and partly
on an intergovernmental level, and it is this idea of supranational control
which seems to threaten the sovereignty of the British Parliament, and make
its policy less important and meaningful.
Sovereignty is an idea decked with tradition and prestige. Indeed, in 1885
A.V. Dicey defined parliamentary sovereignty as the right of Parliament ?to
make any law whatever; and, further, no person or body is recognised by the
law as having a right to override the legislation of Parliament.? The supremacy
of Parliament, established by the Glorious Revolution of 1688, effectively ended
when Parliament surrendered it in passing the European Communities Act in 1972.
When Britain became a member of the EEC in 1973 certain areas of policy making
were transferred to the EEC Commission and to the Council of Ministers. This
meant that if the Council approved the commission has the right to enforce its
recommendations irrespective of domestic legislation that might contradict it,
and the only way to reclaim this loss of sovereignty would be to repeal the
act of 1972 and withdraw from EC membership.
Entry into the EEC caused enormous controversy, leading to the first ever
national referendum in 1975 and the formation of the Social Democratic Party
by pro-European ex-Labour MPs in 1981. Under Maggie Thatcher, the EC was supported
as a free trade economic union but not as a ?federalist? concept moving towards
a United States of Europe. The difficulty of having greater economic integration
without greater political integration was highlighted by the Single European
Act of 1986. This act was the first comprehensive revision of the original Treaty
of Rome (1958) and while this speeded up economic integration it also strengthened
the supranational organisations such as the Council of Ministers so as to include
decision making, and it also made qualified majority voting replace unanimous
voting in the accepting or rejecting of proposals. This signifies a further
mark in the removal of British sovereignty ? no longer did it have the power
to block bills it personally didn?t agree with and became subject to legislation
irrespective of whether it agreed with it or not. Therefore it is possible for
laws to be made without the support of the British Parliament, and this therefore,
can be seen as a major intrusion on parliamentary sovereignty.
More recently, loss of British sovereignty can be seen in the Maastricht Treaty
of 1992. To add to the increased momentum for economic and monetary union in
the Single European Act, the Maastricht Treaty laid down a timetable for this.
The prime goal for EMU was to achieve a single European currency and Central
Bank, in 1999, and this was successful. However, it also extended the role of
the Community to include health, education and the environment, and the infamous
Social Chapter laid down a range of employment conditions and gave increased
powers to the European Parliament.
Surprisingly, Maastricht has had less impact on our national sovereignty than
the Single European Act, as the Conservative government at the time, opted out
of the single currency and the social chapter. National sovereignty was preserved
here by only opting in in areas such as Justice and Home Affairs which are based
on intergovernmental co-operation and unanimous voting.
In spite of the opt-outs at Maastricht, the fact remains that so long as Britain
is a member of the EU its legal and political sovereignty is over. This can
be seen in the Factortame case of 1990. This ruling by the European Court of
Justice on a case brought against the government?s Merchant Shipping Act by
a Spanish fishing company, confirmed the supremacy of Community law over domestic
law. The government was forced to suspend the offending parts of the 1988 Merchant
Chipping Act, and thus it is proved that membership of the European Union gives
the British courts the power to suspend an Act of Parliament, a dramatic constitutional
milestone, and a complete and total contradiction to the words of A.V. Dicey,
and the principles of British parliamentary sovereignty.
In conclusion, Factortame demonstrates just how much membership of the EU
distracts from national sovereignty. Indeed some commentators have speculated
on the end of the nation state, with the Europe of the future developing into
a possible superstate. Historically Parliament has symbolised Britain?s national
sovereignty, and as the European project advances, encompassing more people
and centralising more power it is perhaps fair to say that British parliamentary
sovereignty becomes less about contemporary politics and more about history.
Другие работы по теме:
My Life As A Poet Essay Research
Paper Are the philosophical, educational, and sociological theories of childhood reflected in literature for children? If so, how? To what extent does Aesop contribute to our understanding of many early children’s books?
Northern Virginia Alumnae Club Essay Research Paper
The Northern Virginia Alumnae Club has been selected as the Ideal Club among all of the Pi Beta Phi alumnae clubs for the past two years. Our group is comprised of women of all ages and interests. We have a diverse membership that includes recent graduates, professional women, full time mothers, homemakers, and retirees.
Koljiol Essay Research Paper AUSTRIAN AVALANCHESRecently deadly
Koljiol Essay, Research Paper AUSTRIAN AVALANCHES Recently deadly avalanches have occurred and are still occuring in austria and Central Europe. Who’s to blame, the antithesis of El Nino or La Nina? Snow storms that usually occur in Scandinavia, have moved further south to Central Europe.
Juniper Flower Essay Research Paper Term Paper
Juniper F;lower Essay, Research Paper Term Paper Sites – Only the Highest Quality Sites on the Net We are currently charging an application Fee of only $50 for the first 10 sites to join. Your payment and participation guarantees that within seven business days a member of Term Paper Sites’s editorial staff will look at your site and consider it for a membership.
Europe Essay Research Paper EuropeFrom June 31
Europe Essay, Research Paper Europe From June 31 to July 31 1997, my family went to Europe. We went on 4 airplanes the whole trip. We went to 7 countries. Now I will tell you about my trip.
Europe Population Density Essay Research Paper Europe
Europe Population Density Essay, Research Paper Europe is one of the most densely populated regions in the world, but there is great variation within the region. The densest areas seem to center around major capitol cities and major tourist sites in Europe. London, Paris, and Rome are examples of this. The most densely populated areas where there are over 250 people per square mile seem to also fit into the economic core of Europe, especially in the “banana” region where there are lots of industries.
European Union Essay Research Paper Turkey and
European Union Essay, Research Paper Turkey and the European union Let us begin this by looking at what the EU wants from Turkey. The criteria for EU membership adopted by the Copenhagen European Council in June 1993 require that a candidate country has achieved stability of institutions guaranteeing democracy, the rule of law, human rights, and respect for and protection of minorities; has a functioning market economy as well as the capacity to cope with competitive pressure and market forces within the Union; and has the ability to take on the obligations of membership, including adherence to the aims of political, economic and monetary union.
Effiecent Freeway Driving Essay Research Paper Hate
Effiecent Freeway Driving Essay, Research Paper Hate Crimes To what extent is a crime a hate crime? Aren t all crimes to some extent hate crimes? Should the consequences for a crime committed against a minority be more than that for one against a white person? The purpose for classifying a crime as a hate crime might be to raise awareness in the public to the intolerance against minorities but I believe the punishment should fit the crime and not the reason for the crime.
Go To The Gym Essay Research Paper
There are many health conscience people today. Many of these people also enjoy working out in the gym. There are three groups of people that go to the gym. These groups are ?The one timers?, ?The
Leonardo Da Vinci Essay Research Paper The
Leonardo Da Vinci Essay, Research Paper The Ingenious Work of Leonardo da Vinci “Renaissance,” French for “rebirth,” perfectly describes the intellectual and economic changes that occurred in Europe from the fourteenth through the sixteenth centuries. During this era, Europe emerged from the economic decline of the middle ages.
Underlying Causes Of Wwi Essay Research Paper
There were many underlying causes for World War I in Europe, but many believe that there were a few main causes. These causes where national pride among various European people, an increase in European armed forces, Imperialism and the formation of military alliances. Nationalism- The French revolution and the Napoleonic era spread throughout Europe the belief that people of the same ethnic origin, language and political ideals had the right to independent states.
People Who Go To The Gym Essay
, Research Paper There are many health conscience people today. Many of thesepeople also enjoy working out in the gym. There are three groupsof people that go to the gym. These groups are The one timers,The buddies only, and The dedicated.There is the group of people who are considered ?The onetimers. This is the group of people who are trying to be healthconscience.
Going To The Gym Essay Research Paper
People who go to the Gym There are many health conscience people today. Many of these people also enjoy working out in the gym. There are three groups of people that go to the gym. These groups are +The one timers+, +The
How Did Asia Europe And America Affect
Europe During The 18th Century? Essay, Research Paper Impact of Africa, Asia, and America Modern European history can be compared to the fashion and entertainment business; in that many lesser celebrities may mimic the style or motif of a more recognized one. Europe, being the ?less famous? celebrity, borrowed ideas from other continents in order to strengthen their development.
History Essay Research Paper The film Europe
History Essay, Research Paper The film Europe, The Mighty Continent was an attempt entertaining film that was made from an entirely different angle than other history films. Although Peter Ustinov
Ndustrial Revolutions Effects On Europe Essay Research
Paper name = Justin Katz email = TRipLeZeR0@juno publish = yes subject = Europe History title = Industrial Revolutions effects on Europe papers = The Industrial Revolution had an overall positive effect on Europe. This
European Union Essay Research Paper EUROPE ESSAYThe
European Union Essay, Research Paper EUROPE ESSAY The European Union is a movement that will let Europe trade easier. Europeans are removing the borders to let it be easier to enter into a different country. They figured that the U.S. had few problems with it, they are going to try.
British Sovereignty
&Europe Essay, Research Paper How has British Sovereignty been compromised by membership of the European Union? The word sovereignty itself means the legitimate location of power of last resort over any community. It may be defined purely in legal terms as the power to make binding laws which no other body can break.
Bubonic Plague Essay Research Paper THE SPREAD
Bubonic Plague Essay, Research Paper THE SPREAD OF THE BUBONIC PLAGUE Many have been affected by the plague that has traveled from China – Europe. The plague was said to be carried by rats and fleas, say reasearchers. This plague is known in other places as The Black Death.
The Importance Of Balance Of Power In
Europe Essay, Research Paper B.O.P. essay Without losers, there would be no winners. Moreover, if there were no evil in the world, then kindness would not exist. This is exactly the way the principle of balance of power in Europe operates. It prevented empires, and helped to aid lesser states in their times of need.
Alcoholics Anonymous Essay Research Paper Alcoholics Anonymous
Alcoholics Anonymous Essay, Research Paper Alcoholics Anonymous (AA) is perhaps the best known and most successful alcoholism recovery program. Founded in the United States in 1935 by Dr. Robert Smith and Bill Wilson, by the 1990s the organization had grown to more than 93,000 groups in 131 countries, with an estimated membership of over 2 million.
To What Extent Should Nationalism Be Encouraged
? Essay, Research Paper Nationalism is very important towards a person’s self pride towards the country they live in. Nationalism is the base on what a country stand for and how strong the country is as a whole. With this in mind do people go over board and express this sense of pride to an extent to which it can be dangerous.
Changes In Anal Essay Research Paper A
Changes In Anal Essay, Research Paper A 35 page research paper closely examining the prospects for US-based businesses in Europe. All around the world, nations are forming geographic alliances to help build their share of the world market, but Western Europe is taking one extra “giant step” in their plans for a barrier-free Europe with a common currency in use by the year 2002.
In The Wake Of Columbus Essay Research
Paper Europe and Unintended Consequences Present-day historians have shed the light of modern understanding to issues that plagued peoples of the past. One example of this can easily be seen in the ideals popularized in Europe from the late fifteenth to the mid seventeenth centuries regarding the Americas and its inhabitants.
Euro
– Currency For Europe Essay, Research Paper This is the European Commission’s internet site dedicated exclusively to the euro – one currency for Europe. Whether you are a citizen interested in your future currency, a specialist working on technical preparations for the changeover, or a surfer passing by; this site has useful and interesting information in all eleven official languages of the European Union.
Europe 16001900 Essay Research Paper Europe 1600s1900sFrom
Europe 1600-1900 Essay, Research Paper Europe 1600s-1900s From the Romanov Dynasty of Russia in 1617 to the Second Socialist International in 1914 Europe underwent Scientific, , Industial, and political revolutons, which all contributed to a new europe being formed. Over the span these four centuries Eroupes changes were dramatical.
Britain And The European Union Essay Research
Paper ?We have our own dream and our own task. We are with Europe, but not of it. We are linked, but not combined. We are interested and associated, but not absorbed.?1 Winston Churchill?s famous quote aptly
Romanticsm Essay Research Paper Romanticism in the
Romanticsm Essay, Research Paper Romanticism in the aspect of Nature Romanticism began in the mid-18th century and reached its height in the 19th century. It was limited to Europe and America although different compatriots donated to its birth and popularity. Romanticism as a movement declined in the late 19th century and early 20th century with the growing dominance of Realism in the arts and the rapid advancement of science and technology.
Constantinople The Gateway City Essay Research
Paper Constantinople: The Gateway City Constantinople was built in 330 CE, by the first Christian emperor, Constantine. Constantinople ruled much of the deserted Roman Empire many years after Constantine’s death. Constantinople can be described as a Gateway City by its geographic features, the cultural influences, and the historical influences upon the rest of the world.
Boy Scouts V Dale Essay Research Paper
James dale first joined cub scouts in 1978 at age 8, following in his families scouting tradition. He then became a boy scout in June of 1981. He was the model of a perfect scout. He was delegated to the National jamboree, a summer camp staff member, and a dedicated fund-raiser for the BSA. During High School he was even a member of naval junior ROTC, where he served as a company commander.
To What Extent Can The Second World
War In Europe Be Described As Hitler?s War Essay, Research Paper To what extent can the Second World War in Europe be described as Hitler?s war? There has been much debate over