Of Social Justice? Essay, Research Paper
Is Welfare in Keeping with the Norms of Social Justice?
In order to answer this question we must first begin with the starting point of all Catholic Social Teaching; the dignity of the human person. All social action, and activities, between individuals, lesser organizations, and the governing body must seek the common good of all society and of the individual person. The common good is that objective moral standard which takes into account the whole of man and woman in their material and spiritual nature. Thus by its very definition the common good upholds the dignity of the human person. The norms of social justice require that the common good be served on all social levels.
What does this have to do with welfare? Well, the question ultimately comes back to whether or not welfare serves the common good of all society and by doing so, safeguards the dignity of the human person. What follows is an attempt to prove that welfare (at least my understanding of it) is not in keeping with the norms of social justice.
Welfare in this country today does not require the recipient to labor for the goods he receives. Instead based on the amount of labor an individual does not put into the economy, the government provides housing and other basic necessities for that same individual. To labor is to make use of nature by responsible cultivation of it in order to meet our immediate needs. Labor therefore serves the common good by helping the person to grow and develop thereby upholding human dignity. Having ones basic needs met without labor then does not seem to be in keeping with norms of social justice, because it denies the personal dimension of labor which is the opportunity to grow and develop in their personhood and their role of sovereignty over creation. This personal dimension, which is denied in welfare, is an expression of the person being made in the ?image and likeness of God?.
Also within the welfare system, the government still retains ownership of the goods it supplies. It provides housing and other basic needs but provides no way for these impoverished to come into ownership of their own property. This too denies the dignity of the human person to whom it is given the fundamental right to the use of earthly goods. This right is the natural foundation of a livelihood, and to that right corresponds the right to private possession of property. Private ownership of property provides stability, security to the individual and again causes the individual to grow in his God-given role of sovereignty over creation. To allow a man or woman use of earthly goods without a real possibility of ownership denies them the dignity that is theirs through the right that is theirs of coming into possession of a small piece of the created world. This does not serve the common good because it gives the appearance of helping individuals come into a share of the economy, and of having their needs met while stripping them of the dignity that comes with doing it for themselves. The welfare system then, cannot be in line with the norms of social justice because it does not seek the common good and can therefore not safeguard the human dignity of the person.
A real welfare system in the true sense of the word would seek the common good of all society and every individual by offering means of employment at a just and living wage so that individuals and families can provide for themselves by labor and thereby come into a share of private property.
Другие работы по теме:
Welfare Reform Essay Research Paper One hotly
Welfare Reform Essay, Research Paper One hotly contested aspect of the recent welfare debate is the unsubstantiated characterization of welfare recipients as having alcohol and drug problems, according to authors of a study published in the American Journal of Public Health. In their study, the authors present the most recent national estimates of alcohol and drug use, abuse and dependence among recipients in five social service programs.
The Failure Of Welfare Reform Essay Research
Paper The Failure of Welfare Reform In August of 1996, the Personal Responsibilty and Work Opportunity Reconciliation Act was signed by our president. According to the Washington Post, since that time, there are seven million fewer people on welfare. The welfare roles have been cut in half.
Pros Of Welfare Reform Essay Research Paper
Pros of Welfare Reform In the summer of 1996, Congress finally passed and the President signed the “Personal Responsibility and Work Opportunity Reconciliation Act of 1996″, transforming the nation’s welfare system. The passage of the Personal Responsibility and Work Opportunity Act sets the stage for ongoing reconstruction of welfare systems on a state-by-state basis.
Moral Issues Behind Keeping Promises Essay Research
Paper The Moral Issues behind Keeping Promises Almost every relationship between two people involves the making of promises to each other. It involves giving each other words that must be followed given any certain circumstance. Therefore, making a promise implies that one will keep it, as in staying true to one?s word.
Theories Of Poverty Essay Research Paper Does
Theories Of Poverty Essay, Research Paper Does the government have an obligation to help the poor? What are the causes for poverty? These are questions that have been asked repeatedly over time. Some people believe that the government has no obligation to help the poor, and that the poor are in that situation because of their own choices.
Norms Essay Research Paper NORMSNorms have a
Norms Essay, Research Paper NORMS Norms have a large impact on what makes a quality group. Without them, the group would basically go to pieces. When a group gets together for the first time there really aren?t any norms relevant. After one or two group meetings norms will start to come up, whether they be explicit or implicit.
Greeks Essay Research Paper Our culture is
Greeks Essay, Research Paper Our culture is ruled by social norms. In America it is expected that we abide by these unwritten laws. Whether viewed by a small group of people or society as a whole, breaking such guidelines could have devastating effects. I choose to do my experiment with the least intimate group of people; total strangers.
Poverty In America Essay Research Paper Brandon
Poverty In America Essay, Research Paper Brandon Cristobal Mr.Orozco 9/25/00 Phil 103 ? Poverty, all day, everyday? Coming home everyday to nothing to eat is the scenario for the young children whose parents are on welfare. Those parents are stuck on welfare and can?t give there children anything they want, they take the money the state gives them just to get by, maybe not even able to get the biological needs to survive.
Ruling Ideologies Essay Research Paper Core Studies
Ruling Ideologies Essay, Research Paper Core Studies 3 Casilda Adames Take-Home Exam November 16, 1999 The ruling ideology dealing with welfare is a negative view among the majority of Americans. It states that welfare recipients are lazy people who have lots of children and collect checks for a long period of time.
The Differences Between American And Indonesian Norm
Essay, Research Paper Imagine this: You are on your way walking to school and having both your friends and strangers saying hello to you or asking you are doing. It s normal for American to do this but being a foreigner, it s a totally a new experience to have people greeting me so often. I fell so different, it s like having a lot of people care about me.
Welfare Programs Essay Research Paper Government
Welfare Programs Essay, Research Paper Government’s Welfare Programs For a long time now, since the accomplished formation of a stable government, the U.S government has had programs and passed laws that either
Welfare Essay Research Paper Is Welfare a
Welfare Essay, Research Paper Is Welfare a necessity for poor women and children, or is the government wasting its money on this program? In the article Poor Women and Children Need Welfare, Betty Mandell tries to prove her point that it is a necessity. Michael Tanner, who wrote the article Welfare Should be Eliminated, believes welfare is a waste of government spending.
Fitting The Poor Into The Econ Essay
, Research Paper In the article “Fitting the Poor into the Economy” Herbert Gans provides a number of antidotes to poverty which i fell will help sturgling familys and
Corporate Welfare Essay Research Paper Welfare is
Corporate Welfare Essay, Research Paper Welfare is a big part of tadays society and economy. The question of whether there is too much welfare or whether there is too little. For example President Clinton had pledged to end welfare as we know it while otehrs say society should only reform welfare. Welfare should be reformed greatly especially in the areas of corporate welfare, Medicaid, Food Stamps, and other funded areas which are wasting money.
The Invasion Of Privacy Essay Research Paper
The Invasion of Privacy A folkways violation Since the beginning civilization the people had been confronting changes in different aspect of life such as: in politics, sports and also in religion. But not everything have changed, their always be their values, ideas, norms, language, and beliefs, better known as culture that will characterized each society from other.
Welfare Essay Research Paper 2
Welfare Essay, Research Paper “No one likes the current welfare system.” As described in a report edited by Isabel V. Sawhill, an author of The Urban Institute, not many individuals were pleased with the welfare system preceding its reform in 1996. Governors complained that federal law was overly prescriptive, and were willing to take less federal money in return for more flexibility.
A Need For Welfare Essay Research Paper
A Need for Welfare There?s an old joke that asked,? Where do you find a welfare recipients check?? Under his work boots of course (Armitage 45). For a long time now, since the accomplished formation of a stable government, the U.S government has had the programs and passed laws that either dealt with issues of or influenced family.
Welfare Where Is It Going Essay Research
Paper Welfare: Where is it going? Millions of Americans today are signed up for a program called Welfare. Welfare is a program designed to aid poor and needy families. Every human being has essential needs that cannot always be met due to difficult or demanding situations. In most cases, these situations are long term and almost seem impossible to get out of.
Public Service Essay Research Paper Public service
Public Service Essay, Research Paper Public service is essential to protecting America and its citizens. It is responsible for ensuring that our air and water are clean, food is fresh, and material products are safe. Without public service, our society would be prone to impurity, and consequently, decay.
An Essay On Poverty And Welfare Essay
, Research Paper Essay on Poverty and Welfare Today it seems as if everyone has a theory about fighting poverty, now it is not necessary to be moving in the theoretical plane. Our country has had successful anti-poverty
Poverty Essay Research Paper Poverty in the
Poverty Essay, Research Paper Poverty in the United States is getting worse each day and not enough is getting done about it. The readings from ?Babies and Benefits? by Sheila
Welfare Essay Research Paper In brief first
Welfare Essay, Research Paper In brief, first, the global economy has brought with it high rates of unemployment and economic inactivity in much of Europe. It has also generated strong pressures to de-regulate and create flexible labour markets with sharp rises in wage dispersion, part-time, temporary and casual employment particularly in the UK and USA.
Welfare Essay Research Paper Welfare has been
Welfare Essay, Research Paper Welfare has been a social issue since 1936, which was when Welfare was introduced to the United States. Welfare soon expanded through out the 1960?s and 70?s. Welfare does not only exist in the United Sates, it also exists in many other nations as well. Our welfare program may not even be as good as other nations.
The Shrinking Welfare State Essay Research Paper
Welfare has been the topic of much controversy over the past few years. The welfare program has been important for many people. The purpose of welfare is to assist people who are jobless or can t make ends meet financially. One of the stated purposes of the Personal Responsibility Work Opportunity Reconciliation Act of 1996, popularly known as welfare reform was to end the dependence of needy parents on government benefits by promoting job preparedness, work, and marriage.
UK Welfare State Essay Research Paper Good
UK Welfare State Essay, Research Paper Good health is an important factor to an individual?s welfare. It is an essential prerequisite for the enjoyment of life. For this reason the importance
Welfare Reform Essay Research Paper Title Welfare
Welfare Reform Essay, Research Paper Title: Welfare ReformCategory: otherDescription:Body of paper: Welfare is a subject that many people can not agree on. It is one of the most debated topics in almost every political campaign because of it s great importance to the American public. Bill Clinton offered his view on the subject in his 1992 speech “Ending Welfare as We Know It”.
Welfare Reform Essay Research Paper Econ 251Welfare
Welfare Reform Essay, Research Paper Econ 251 Welfare Reform will hit economy hard A new law is going to be implemented in the near future, which requires welfare recipients to work increasing amount of time for their benefits, and places a five year limit on aid! This new policy is thought to make some people and some of their problems go away…but people don s just go away.
Mythology And Policy Essay Research Paper Mythology
Mythology And Policy Essay, Research Paper Mythology and policy has been a part of human culture for as long as there has been civilization . Day provides us with a history of the beginnings of social welfare. She speaks how social policy as well as social welfare has effected individuals, families, and the larger society of today.
Deviance Essay Research Paper Deviant Behavior Sociologists
Deviance Essay, Research Paper Deviant Behavior Sociologists use the term deviance to refer to any violation of norms- whether the infraction is a minor as jaywalking, or as serious as murder. This deceptively simple definition takes us to the heart of the sociological perspective of deviance, which sociologist Howard S.