Partial Birth Abortion Essay, Research Paper
Partial-Birth Abortion
There are hardly many topics that can raise such debate, and invoke such passionate discussion, as does abortion. Whether one is pro-life or pro-choice , the clear and definitive line between the pros and cons of abortion predictably leads to a standstill of opinion. Each side is sure that their view is the right view, and the nature of the abortion issue does not allow for a middle ground. Abortion arguments, however, are even further broadened and complicated by the sub-issues they include. One such sub-issue is partial-birth abortion.
Partial-birth abortions are those that are performed in the late second or third trimester of pregnancy. The procedure usually calls for the abortionist to turn the unborn baby into the breech (or feet first ) position, then pulling the child from the mother until all but the head is exposed. Scissors are then jabbed into the base of the baby s skull where a catheter is inserted to suction out the baby s brain, effectively collapsing the skull and allowing for the easy removal of the dead baby from the mother.
To date, about forty states have deemed partial-birth abortions illegal, though, on the federal level, attempts by Congress to ban this practice had been repeatedly vetoed by Bill Clinton. Current president George W. Bush indicated during the election campaign that he would fight for the abolition of these abortions, though no action has been taken as of yet. Furthermore, the Federal Supreme Court struck down a ban on partial-birth abortions in July of 2000, deeming it unconstitutional, perhaps feeling a need to protect Roe v. Wade.
The Catholic Church, of course, is strongly opposed to partial-birth abortions, and has consistently presented a strong lobbying presence in Washington D.C., pledging to continue their efforts until the procedure is banned. In his homily at St. Patrick s Cathedral on Sunday, January 18, 1998, the late John Cardinal O Connor reiterated the Church s rejection of partial-birth abortion, calling it infanticide. Responding to charges by pro-choice advocates that pro-lifers are only using the partial-birth abortion platform as an inroads to the beginning of the end of all abortion, Cardinal O Connor said, Even if you accept other abortions, you still (must be) appalled by infanticide. He then added, A broader issue lies behind the partial-birth dispute. It isn t the fate of Roe v. Wade, it s the future of infanticide. (Catholic New York, Oct. 1998)
On October 4, 1998, Cardinal O Connor delivered a homily in which he read a graphic account of a late-term abortion as described by Brenda Pratt Shafer, a registered nurse who was assigned by her nursing agency to assist in the abortion procedure. Up until that time, Nurse Shafer had considered herself very pro-choice, and did not give the assignment a second thought. The Cardinal read from Nurse Shafer s account, The baby s little fingers were clasping and unclasping, his feet kicking. Then the doctor stuck scissors in the back of the head, and the baby s arms jerked out startled, like a baby does when he thinks he s going to fall. Then the doctor opened up the incision, stuck the high-powered suction into the head and sucked the baby s brains out. (Catholic New York, Feb. 1998)
It is very difficult to comprehend the defense of partial-birth abortion after becoming privy to such a graphic and emotional description. Later in the same homily, Cardinal O Connor added, Do we dare to use the word pro-choice for a woman who burns her child with cigarettes, beats her child, throws the child out the window? Is it fair to say that is a woman s choice? (Catholic New York, Feb. 1998)
The Cardinal s point is well taken. The argument that the unborn baby is not truly a child becomes difficult to fathom when we are presented with a picture of a fully-formed baby, arms flailing, fingers wiggling, whose life is ended by means of a sharp object being jabbed into its head. Even the Congress of the United States, who continuously refuses to overturn Roe v. Wade, voted to ban partial-birth abortion after being presented with the facts, only to have the bill vetoed by Bill Clinton.
One of the arguments against the ban is that government should have no say in medical issues. According to a brochure entitled Reproductive Rights, published by the American Civil Liberties Union, legislators should not get in the way of doctors developing new surgical procedures because they will impede medical progress. Additionally, the ACLU argues that women who carry pregnancies into their seventh and eighth months do not abort on a whim, but do so because the pregnancy endangers their lives or health. (Reproductive Rights, ACLU, 2000) If we are to accept this argument as fact, however, then the ACLU should not be opposed to the federal ban because there are provisions included that would allow a partial-birth abortion to take place if it were deemed necessary to save the life of the mother. Furthermore, there is strong doubt present within some factions of the medical community as to whether or not the procedure is ever necessary. In a letter to the editor of the New York Times, dated September 26, 1996, former Surgeon General C. Everett Koop wrote, With all that modern medicine has to offer, partial-birth abortions are not needed to save the life of the mother, and the procedure s impact on a woman s cervix can put future pregnancies at risk. In reality, it appears that pro-choice groups like the ACLU are using the issue of the mother s health to mask the fact that they favor elective legalization of the procedure, no matter the reason.
I must say, I have tried, though have found it quite difficult, to present both sides of the partial-birth abortion issue. I had heard of the procedure before, but knew it only as an abortion that was performed somewhat late in a pregnancy. When I discovered the details of the act, as a result of researching for this paper, I was completely horrified. As a Roman Catholic, I was always taught that abortion was wrong, though I must admit that I was not really sold on one side of the issue or the other. I realize that my ambivalence is a result of a lack of knowledge on the subject, and, perhaps, even a fear of commitment as a result of the intense passion exhibited on both sides of the fence. Writing this paper, however, was an awakening for me, and it served to reinforce the notion that one must educate oneself in order to be able to formulate a valid opinion.
How can anyone look at the facts that make up the partial-birth abortion argument, and, with good conscience, decide that it is ok to remove most of a living being from its mother, and then kill it? How can proponents of pro-choice values condone and advocate the elective murder of a living being? Why do politicians find it necessary to concede to these groups, even when the facts scream of injustice? Some may argue that we must maintain a separation of church and state, but religion need not even play a role in this issue. Surely, none of these groups would justify the killing of a five-year-old child by its mother because she felt like doing it, or because she just didn t want to be a mother anymore.
Perhaps valid arguments can be made supporting the legalization of earlier term, or more common abortions. The question of when a fetus actually becomes a child will probably never be answered to the satisfaction of all people. It is quite clear, however, that when entering the seventh and eighth months of a pregnancy, the baby is a formed, viable, and sensitive human creation, able, in most cases, to exist and thrive outside of the mother s womb. Surely, the majority of us know someone who has given birth prematurely to a healthy and beautiful baby. Would anyone dare say that he or she is not yet a child?
Bibliography:
Alcorn, Randy. 2000. Pro-Life Answers to Pro-Choice Arguments. Sisters, OR: Multnomah Publishers Inc.
American Civil Liberties Union. 2000. Reproductive Rights: Partial-Birth Abortion Bans. The American Civil Liberties Union, Copyright 2000.
Letter to the Editor. New York Times. Sep. 26, 1996.
McDonnell, Claudia. Oct. 1998. Infanticide, Catholic New York.
O Connor, John Cardinal. Feb. 1998. The Issue, Homily of Jan. 18, 1998, Catholic New York.
Poust, Mary Ann. Nov. 1998. Ultimate Child Abuse, Catholic New York.
Другие работы по теме:
Abortion Essay Research Paper Abortion Ever since
Abortion Essay, Research Paper Abortion Ever since the Roe v. Wade Supreme Court decision in 1973, Abortion has changed its course in society. With the new decision made by the United States, abortion
Abortion Is It Murder Essay Research Paper
Abortion: Is it Murder? A mother kills her baby because it is unwanted, yet she is not charged with murder. Is this right? Believe it or not, this has happened more than
Abortion 11 Essay Research Paper In the
Abortion 11 Essay, Research Paper In the United States, one out of every four women decide to abort their baby during their pregnancy. Although, abortions are a greater problem in other countries such as the Soviet Union and Romania. In these countries over one-half of the pregnancies end in abortion. The amount of abortions in the United States is far less then in these countries.
Abortion Essay Research Paper Page 6 of
Abortion Essay, Research Paper Page 6 of 7 I recently interviewed a woman who had an abortion. She was twenty years of age when she had the abortion She did so because she felt she had no choice. She was away at college and she did not want to tell her parents and the guy was a jerk (Interview). I do not think I would be able to tell my parents I am pregnant if I was away at college.
Anti Abortion Pill Essay Research Paper I
Anti Abortion Pill Essay, Research Paper I wish I would have said something about abortion and the new pill that came out. I wish that that pill would have never came out and I wish that none of the abortion methods ever came about. I believe no one in this world has the right to take the life of another human being no matter how old they are.
Abortion Essay Research Paper Hello Today
Abortion Essay, Research Paper Hello. Today, I feel we need to talk about a woman?s right to choose. To be pro-choice means believing that women can decide on their own, based on their personal beliefs, health, and life circumstances, without government interference. Let me repeat myself: I am pro-choice, which does not mean that I am pro-abortion.
Abortion 26 Essay Research Paper ABORTIONThis topic
Abortion 26 Essay, Research Paper ABORTION This topic has always been a concern between the people and the government. There are approximately 1.6 million abortions. Abortion means Induced termination of pregnancy and expulsion of an embryo or fetus that is incapable of survival. I think that basically, people can do whatever they want to do, as long as they know what they are doing.
What Is Abortion Essay Research Paper What
What Is Abortion? Essay, Research Paper What Is Abortion? What is abortion? Is it the killing of a defense less child or is it the freedom of a woman. In the case of the latter, it is easy to see how
Abortion Is Murder Essay Research Paper This
Abortion Is Murder Essay, Research Paper This is a very big moral issue. I wonder is people realize that they are killing an innocent baby? Yes it is a fetus, but it is in the process of becoming a whole innocent, beautiful baby. God is just in the process of creating. Every baby deserves a chance at life. You did.
The Mother Essay Research Paper Abortion is
The Mother Essay, Research Paper Abortion is defined as a premature birth occurring before the fetus can survive; an induced expulsion of a fetus. “The Mother,” a poem written by Gwendolyn Brooks looks at abortion from a different point of view. This is a poem that deals with the sequence of emotions that a woman may go through after she has had an abortion.
Abortion Pill Essay Research Paper The Abortion
Abortion Pill Essay, Research Paper The Abortion Pill There have always been strong disagreements as to whether abortion should be legal or not. A new medical breakthrough, the abortion pill, will only make these arguments stronger. Whether you are a pro-choice person or a pro-life person, there are still benefits to this recent discovery.
My Thought On Abortion Essay Research Paper
My thoughts on abortion Abortion is one of the toughest controversial issues. On the side of feminist and pro-abortionists, abortion is women’s right to choose and best healing for raped woman.For the religious group and pro-lifers, abortion is a kind of murder because unborn babies and even fetus are life.
Abortion In America Essay Research Paper Abortion
Abortion In America Essay, Research Paper Abortion in America One of the most debated issues in America is abortion: Pro-life or pro-choice. This is a decision that each person has to make for him or herself. Many people say that abortion is the woman’s choice. I firmly believe, however, that if the woman is willing to have sex, she should be willing to suffer the consequences.
PartialBirth Abortion
& Its Affect On The American People Essay, Research Paper “Partial-Birth Abortion and its Affect on the American People” We sat and watched our televisions and rejoiced as Jeffrey Dahmer was sentenced
The History Of Abortion Essay Research Paper
History of Abortion In the United States, abortion laws began to appear in the 1820?s, which forbid abortion after the fourth month of pregnancy. Through the efforts of mostly physicians and doctors, the American Medical Association, and legislators, most abortions were outlawed by 1900. Illegal abortions still frequently occurred, though they became less frequent while the Comstock Law came into effect, which essentially banned all birth control information and devices.
Abortion Essay Research Paper AbortionI feel that
Abortion Essay, Research Paper Abortion I feel that abortion is wrong. God says that he is the way, the truth, and the life. I am a Christian and I believe that God has a plan for everyone and everything. He has the whole world planned and He sees ahead. What happens is his will, no matter how harsh it may be or difficult to deal with.
Abortion Essay Research Paper There are many
Abortion Essay, Research Paper There are many women who have choices to make in life that can be difficult or easy. One very difficult decision is whether or not to terminate a pregnancy. Most people should think before they act. If a woman has to terminate a pregnancy, it is because she wasn’t planning to get pregnant or because she did not use birth control.
Abortion Essay Research Paper Abortion I think
Abortion Essay, Research Paper Abortion I think is very bad. Abortion is the killing of an unborn child. The abortion clinics use many cruel and discusting techniques to kill the unborn baby. On way is they take a vaccuum and suck the child out break it into pieces. Another way is they take a sharp knife or something and they scrape the baby out while cutting it into pieces.
Freedom Of Choice Essay Research Paper Freedom
Freedom Of Choice Essay, Research Paper Freedom Of Choice Since 1973 abortion has been an important controversial issue to the United States. The problem begins should it be a womans choice whether or not to terminate her pregnancyor should it be the goverments choice. This is where a woman looses her rights as a person.
Abortion Essay Research Paper Abortion is the
Abortion Essay, Research Paper Abortion is the termination of an unborn fetus. In today’s society there is a lot of controversy over this issie. Many people have views that say abortion is both right and wrong, while others are primarily focused on it either being right, or wrong. I for one am completely against the whole abortion issue.
Partial Birth Abortion Essay Research Paper 05
Partial Birth Abortion Essay, Research Paper 05 July 2000 Partial Birth Abortion When is it not a baby? In my opinion, partial birth abortion is not ethical, it is wrong. Lets first look at the process of aborting a child while in the mother. Depending on the phase or the trimester the baby is in, will determine how the child is to be killed.
Parental Consent Essay Research Paper Does Parental
Parental Consent Essay, Research Paper Does Parental Consent Work? Abortion is a controversial issue that can cause uproar for many families. When a young girl is thinking about having an abortion, she is making the choice on whether or not to go through with a pregnancy. One of the biggest controversies right now, about abortion is parental consent.
Abortion Essay Research Paper My personal opinion
Abortion Essay, Research Paper My personal opinion about abortion is that it should stay legal. I believe that it is the woman’s choice because it’s her body, and no one else should be allowed to tell her what she can, and can’t do with it.
Abortion Essay Research Paper Page 1 of
Abortion Essay, Research Paper Page 1 of 7 Many have argued over the legality of abortion. Pro-life activists believe that every child conceived should be born. They also believe
Abortion Essay Research Paper Page 1ABORTIONIn some
Abortion Essay, Research Paper Page 1 ABORTION In some cases people think that abortion is wrong. They think that killing an innocent a baby is like committing murder. In this paper I will be talking a little bit about partial birth abortion. And a little about the Roe V. Wade court case.
Partial Birth Abortions Essay Research Paper PartialBirth
Partial Birth Abortions Essay, Research Paper Partial-Birth Abortion I. Intro- In 1973, the Supreme Court handed down its Roe vs. Wade decision legalizing abortion in all fifty states during all nine months of pregnancy, for any reason, medical, social, or otherwise. Of the approximately 1.5 million abortions performed each year, 93% are done electively.
ProChoice Essay Research Paper ProChoiceI personally support
Pro-Choice Essay, Research Paper Pro-Choice I personally support a woman?s right to terminate an unwanted pregnancy for any reason. I don?t agree with abortion being used as a form of birth control, but since I don?t believe in ?straddling the fence? on such issues, I support abortion fully. There are too many negative consequences possible with the prohibition of abortion.
Abortion And A Womens Right To Choose
Essay, Research Paper When abortion was illegal in America, many women died or suffered serious medical problems from either self-induced or illegal,
Abortion Essay Research Paper Page 7 of
Abortion Essay, Research Paper Page 7 of 7 The last question was asking the females if abortions should be banned. 24% said they think abortion should be banned in Pennsylvania
Abortion Essay Research Paper The most important
Abortion Essay, Research Paper The most important issue in balancing individual human rights with social responsibility in my point of view is abortion. The law that was passed so that abortions would be legal was a good decision. The anti-abortions have very sound points, but it should be up to the women to make her choice.
Abortion Essay Research Paper My view on
Abortion Essay, Research Paper My view on the abortion is pro-choice so I will debate the issue from the pro-life point of view. Abortion is in a word: murder. There is no way around it , people that have abortions are committing a crime. If one was killing a person who could defend themselves they would go to jail but the people who have abortions just get continue on with their sinful lives.