, Based On John Stuart Mills’ “Revised
Harm Principle” Essay, Research Paper
An Argument for the Legalization of Drugs, Based on John Stuart Mills’ “Revised
Harm Principle”
The question of whether or not to legalize certain drugs has been
debated for decades. Although opponents have thus far been successful in
preventing this, there are nonetheless a substantial number of people who
believe that legalization should be given a chance. Their arguments range from
the seeming ineffectiveness of current drug laws to the simple premise that the
government has no right to prohibit its citizens from using drugs if they
choose to do so. This essay will address the issue from the standpoint of John
Stuart Mills’ “Revised Harm Principle?,” which asserts that people should be
free to do what they want unless they threaten the vital interests (i.e.,
security or autonomy) of others.
Using Mills’ principle as a litmus test for this issue leads one to come
down on the side of legalization. Since Mills is concerned not with individual
rights, but with the consequences of one’s actions on other people, the question
becomes: Is drug use an action that, although performed by an individual,
threatens the vital interests of others? Using the example of a casual,
responsible drug user who is a contributing (or non-detracting) member of
society, it is clear that more harm is done to others if the user must resort to
illegal methods to obtain his drugs. The very act of buying drugs is
intrinsically illegal and carries the threat of establishing a criminal record
for the buyer. This can have a devastating effect on his family, his lifestyle,
and his career. The effects on society as a whole include more crowded jail
cells (prompting politicians to demand more jails be built), higher taxes to
support these jails, and the loss, or at least diminution, of a productive
citizen. In order to buy drugs illegally, the user may be forced to expose
himself to the fringes of the criminal world–something he would never do under
any other circumstances. If drugs were legalized, the criminal stigma would be
removed from their purchase, possession, and use. The government would collect
taxes on drug sales and, conversely, would not be spending millions of dollars
to stem the flow of illegal drugs. This increase in tax dollars could be put to
use in drug education and treatment programs for those individuals who are
unable to moderate their intake and subsequently become addicts. Then the
government would be intervening with its citizens’ lives in a benevolent manner
(and only when asked) rather than in a forceful, punitive way.
Many opponents to legalization point out that drug use leads to spousal
and child abuse, random criminal acts precipitated by the effects of drugs on a
user’s inhibitions, and crimes committed to support drug habits. This argument
is fundamentally defective because it addresses the abuse of drugs, which is not
the issue here. When an individual’s use of drugs leads him to harm others, it
becomes a behavioral problem. That is, the issue is no longer drugs, but the
behavior of the individual. If that behavior breaks a law, the individual
should be punished for that specific conduct–not for drug use. In its pure
form, drug use affects only the user, and the government is therefore acting
paternally when it regulates this behavior. This government regulation violates
Mills’ “Revised Harm Principle?” as blatantly as would regulations against
sunbathing or overeating or masturbation.
A Rebuttal
When using John Stuart Mills’ “Revised Harm Principle” to argue for the
legalization of drugs, it is necessary to examine that principle (that people
should be free to do what they want unless they threaten the vital interests,
i.e., security or autonomy, of others) and define its terms. Proponents of
legalization argue that drug use is a self-regarding act and has no effect on
anyone other than the user. But drug use affects every aspect of society: it
affects the security of nonusers, and it affects the autonomy of the user.
If drugs were made legal and easily obtainable in this country, the
government would be relinquishing its role as protector of those citizens who
are unable to control their excesses. These people surrender their autonomy to
drug addiction, thus “selling” themselves into a type of slavery. It is true
that the decriminalization of drugs would remove much of the stigma associated
with them, but this would not be a positive change. It is that stigma that
keeps many law-abiding citizens from using illegal drugs, and thus keeps the
number of addicts at a minimum. Also, if drugs were legalized, the government
would not be legally able to force addicts into treatment programs, and the
number of addicts would grow exponentially.
This scenario leads to the problem of security, both economic and
personal, for the vast number of Americans who probably would not become
addicted to drugs if they were legalized. Drug use would become as prolific as
alcohol consumption, and the number of societal and health-related problems
would be as numerous as those associated with alcohol. More working days would
be lost by people unable to control their drug habits, and insurance costs would
soar in order to cover expensive treatment required to rehabilitate addicts and
to deal with the health problems caused by addiction. These consequences would
have a direct effect on people other than the drug users, thus negating the
concept that drug use is a self-regarding act.
Regarding personal security, legalization advocates try to draw a line
between drug use and drug abuse. As it is impossible to predict who would use
drugs “responsibly” and who would succumb to addiction, the government has a
right and a duty to do everything in its powers to limit the availability of
harmful substances, even though the majority of its citizens might never make
the transition from use to abuse.
Proponents of legalization maintain that legalizing drugs would remove
government control from a private area of our lives. This is a faulty
assumption because the government’s role would only shift, not disappear. There
would be taxes, quality control, and distribution issues to deal with, and the
government would be at the helm. Therefore, Mills’ Principle would still be
“violated,” and the country would have a slew of new problems to deal with due
to the availability of legal drugs and lack of recourse with which to address
them.
Другие работы по теме:
Legalizing Marijuana Both Sides Essay Research Paper
The idea of controlled legalization of narcotics is an issue that many people in the United States have been thinking about recently. A great deal of important people in this country have been formulating their opinions about this topic. One might wonder why important figures are occupying their time with such a proposal.
Drug Legalization Essay Research Paper Legality Although
Drug Legalization Essay, Research Paper Legality, Although it is clear that society is unhappy with current efforts to stop illegal drug smuggling, illegal drug use and distribution, no one seems to know what should be done. With drug use and drug related crime on the rise, some Americans argue that current drug law is too easy on drug offenders.
Drug Essay Essay Research Paper Andrew Mattus121000English
Drug Essay Essay, Research Paper Andrew Mattus 12/10/00 English Mrs. Mantle Drug Essay There is no question that drugs are prevalent in the United States today and that something should be done about it. Drugs hurt society in so many ways; people die, loose their jobs, and lose their families all because of addiction.
Drugs Essay Research Paper For several decades
Drugs Essay, Research Paper For several decades drugs have been one of the major problems of society. Not only has the drug problem increased but also drug related problems are on the rise. Some people are born addicts, while others become users. The result of drug abuse is thousands of addicts in denial. One controversial solution to the drug problem is the proposal of legalizing drugs.
Our Right To Drugs Essay Research Paper
“Please, sir. . . may I have some more?” The Analysis of a Paternalistic Government A Report on Our Right to Drugs by Thomas Szasz You might be tempted to label Thomas Szasz, author of Our Right to Drugs, The Case for a Free Market, a counter-culture hippie. However, this analysis couldn?t be further from the truth.
Legalize It Essay Research Paper Legalize It
Legalize It Essay, Research Paper Legalize It! Many feel today we are loosing the war on drugs. When a battle goes to the point where there is no winner there needs to be a re-evaluation of how to solve the problem. In the case of the war against drugs, years of fighting have caused increased crime, overcrowding of prisons and the wasted use of money and resources with no results.
Drugs Essay Research Paper Reasons For The
Drugs Essay, Research Paper Reasons For The Legalization Of Drugs We will never get rid of drugs and until we realize this we will still have one of the worst education systems, the largest imprisonment rate, the largest crime rate, and a depletion of money from other more important budgets. Legalizing drugs will create drug regulation, crime reduction, and increased revenue for the government.
Should Marijauna Be Legalized Essay Research Paper
Should Marijuana be legalized? United States is facing many controversial issues today. The highly controversial issue that comes up in Newspapers again and again concerns the legalization of Marijuana. Some people support and believe that legalization is the only solution left for the nation while others oppose it because it will help to increase the number of drug users and drug related crimes.
Drugs And AIDS Essay Research Paper Hopkins
Drugs And AIDS Essay, Research Paper Hopkins University. In the U.S gay men still make up the primary risk group,although 750,000 to 1 milliondrug addicts are believed to be at risk to AIDS nationally. The problem here is thesharing of needles, which is causing the spread of AIDS. IV drug abusers arekilling our nation at an amazingly fast speed.
Mistakes To Avoid In Legalitzation Of Drus
Essay, Research Paper Mistakes to Avoid in the Legalization of Drugs If in fact drug legalization does take place in the United States, it is pertinent that the government not make the same mistakes in doing so that they did decades ago with the end of prohibition (Schmoke 897). The government failed to take any preventive measures against alcohol once it was legalized, such as anti-drinking campaigns or any kind of education programs to inform the public about the dangers of alcohol (Schmoke 897).
Drug Legalization Essay Research Paper 42797EthicsEssayDrugs Should
Drug Legalization Essay, Research Paper 4/27/97 Ethics Essay Drugs Should NOT Be Legalized I remember when I was in High School over fifteen students got suspended or arrested for drug related incidents. Students were charged with possession, selling, or caught using drugs. Many students often used to show up to class high waiting to get caught.
Pros And Cons Of Legloizing Dr Essay
, Research Paper The legalizing of drugs have been an issue in the forefront since the 20 s and the 30 with the probation of alcohol. Many have argued weather narcotics should be legalized or not. There are arguments supporting each side. People who are in favor of the legalization of drugs claim that drugs would increase our economy, making drugs legal will reduce the great amounts of money spent on law enforcement, and legalization of drugs would benefit the federal budget.
Just Some Bad Logic Essay Research Paper
Just Some Bad Logic The Battle For Medical Marijuana in The War on Drugs is an article written by William E. Stempsey debating over why the dispute against the legalization of medical marijuana is just bad logic. The article is clearly for the legalization of marijuana for medicinal purposes and gives several opinions on why opponents of this issue are incorrect with their arguments.
The Fallacy Of Personal Attack Essay Research
Paper Fallacy of Personal Attack The fallacy of personal attack involves assaulting the arguer rather than the argument. This fallacy is very common. Personal attack is like not accepting a argument
Drug Legalization Essay Research Paper Mark DeOrioDecember
Drug Legalization Essay, Research Paper Mark DeOrio December 8, 1999 Dr. Bechtel Criminology Drug Legalization The question of whether to legalize drugs or not is a very controversial and important issue. Drugs affect so many areas of society. Several groups have formed and spoken out regarding their position.
Drug Lealization Essay Research Paper Drug legalization
Drug Lealization Essay, Research Paper Drug legalization is a hotly debated topic in today s society. Proponents of this plan state that it will put drug dealers out of business and take away the rebellious allure that causes many young people to take drugs. This theory could not be farther from the truth. If illegal drugs were legalized, drug dealers would be brought to the forefront of one of the fastest growing industries in history.
Drug Legalization Essay Research Paper Drug Education
Drug Legalization Essay, Research Paper Drug Education and Prevention Question #2 March 8th 2000 Will the legalization of certain drugs reduce the crime rate in the United States? This question has baffled United States lawmakers, reformists, and citizens alike for so long that many people probably consider it a rhetorical question.
Theories On Drug Legalization Essay Research Paper
Theories of Drug Legalization If Drugs were legal they would be easily accessable and legal, Goverment would receive revenue, It deters crime of people obtaining drugs, and gives better emotional state of americans. The other side of this is the highly possible death by overdose, psychological problems because of drug abuse, anarchy over the alleged govermental control over drugs increase the number of drug addicts, lead to more children using drugs,increase the number of hard-core addicts, increase drug-related problems and costs, and increase crime There is another argument of Prohibition, and the war on drugs in theory isn’t valid, because like in 1919 , when alcohol was outlawed, all that prove to do was defeat the purpose of prohibition by glamorizing Drugs and Alcohol through the black market because people need Drugs and Alcohol, and that’s reality.
Drug Legalization In America Essay Research Paper
The issues surrounding drug legalization are complicated and sensitive. Each year drug use kills about 14,000 Americans and costs taxpayers approximately $70 billion. Drug-related illnesses and crime costs an estimated $67 billion per year. Drug use also influences worker productivity as seventy-one percent of all illicit drug users are eighteen and older and employed.
Drug Should Not Be Legalized Essay Research
Paper Drugs Should Not be Legalized The question of whether to legalize drugs or not is A Very controversial and important issue. Drugs affect so many areas of society. Several groups have formed and spoken out regarding their position.
Should Drugs Be Legalized My View Essay
, Research Paper Should Drugs Be Legalized; My View It seems as if the cry of “legalize drugs!” is heard everywhere. Some argue that legalizing drugs is the way to “win” the drug war. Drug enforcement does place a burden on us. Economic resources are used up that could be used elsewhere. But the consequences of legalizing drugs would make an already large problem out of control.
Issues On Legalization Of Marijuana Essay Research
Paper Issues in Legalization of Marijuana The legalization of marijuana has long been a strongly debated social issue in the United States. Both sides have gathered their thoughts and research to provide a persuasive view of their position. Other than the issue of the medicinal benefits that can be provided through the prescribed use of marijuana, here in the United States there is a war raging regarding the personal opinions of many and the politics regarding the same.
Legal Marijuana Essay Research Paper Legalization of
Legal Marijuana Essay, Research Paper Legalization of Marijuana By: Michelle Jarka E-mail: shellgal8@aol Legalization of Marijuana Should marijuana be legalized? This has been an enormous controversial issue for the last couple of decades. It?s a drug that can be good for you, yet cause many great dangers.
The Legalization Of Drugs A Risk Not
Worth Taking Essay, Research Paper The legalization of drugs; a risk not worth taking. Arguments concerning the repeal of the 18th amendment, drug prohibition, have not changed much over the last seventy years; the questions are the same, the concerns are the same, and the policy is the same; the way it should be.
Legalizing Hard Drugs Essay Research Paper Legalizing
Legalizing Hard Drugs Essay, Research Paper Legalizing Hard Drugs I believe that the State and Federal governments should legalize hard drugs. The legalization of hard drugs will benefit many people for many reasons. First of all, there will no longer be a black market for illegal drugs, which will minimize the nation s crime scene significantly.
The Question Of Legalizing Drugs Essay Research
Paper The Question of Legalizing Drugs? Drug legalization is an enduring question that presently faces our scholars. This issue embraces two positions: drugs should not be legalized and drugs should be legalized. These two positions contain an array of angles that supports each issue. This brief of the issues enables one to consider the strengths and weakness of each argument, become aware of the grounds of disagreement and agreement and ultimately form an opinion based upon the positions stated within the articles.
Legalization Of Drugs Essay Research Paper The
Legalization Of Drugs Essay, Research Paper The legalization of drugs has always been a problem in the United States. Some people agree with the Idea of legalizing drugs such as marijuana, cocaine, heroin, and many others. These people argue that with the legalization of these drugs the crime rate and other social problems would reduce.
The Legalization Of Drugs Essay Research Paper
The legalization of drugs; a risk not worth taking Arguments concerning the repeal of the 18th amendment, drug prohibition, have not changed much over the last seventy years; the questions are the same, the concerns are the same, and the policy is the same; the way it should be. Both sides are in a constant battle over the legality of drugs: Proponents of drug prohibition insist that the effects on society would be disastrous- wide-spread addiction, increased crime – Opponents of drug prohibition insist that drug legalization would allow society to prosper – potency control, crime reduction, tax revenues.
That Drugs Should Be Legalized Essay Research
Paper Explanation of Views That drugs should be legalized. There are great numbers of people in Australia who believe that legalizing hard-drugs, such as heroin, speed, cocaine etc, would improve the drug problem. This may be a true statement, however such legalization is yet to be proven, and can cause some severe consequences, which outweigh the possible benefits.
Legalization Of Marijuana Essay Research Paper Legalization
Legalization Of Marijuana Essay, Research Paper Legalization of medical marijuana This act may be cited as the ? legalization of marijuana? Sec. 1 This bill will be for the well being of the pain stricken patients in our nation’s hospitals, a doctor that will decide if a patient is illegible to receive marijuana.